Opinion: Can Alberta survive a net-zero agenda?

Calgary Herald

2 days ago

Article content
It should be evident to Albertans that the province is on a collision course with the Carney government, driven by a fundamental disagreement: will Alberta and Western Canada be allowed to fully develop its hydrocarbon endowment, or will that economic value be lost in pursuit of the climate policy known as 'net zero'?
Article content
Article content
This collision is inevitable and imminent. Net zero is difficult to reconcile with growing, or even sustaining, existing hydrocarbon production in Canada.
Article content
Article content
In April 2025, Mark Carney won a near majority government based on his perceived superior credibility in confronting the tariff threats from the Trump administration. The win was narrow in the popular vote nationally, but not in Alberta, where Carney gained only 28 per cent of the vote. The outcome was defined by tariffs and not a direct endorsement of a net-zero imperative for Canada.
Article content
Article content
Canada has endured a decade of economic stagnation, much of it attributable to the obstruction of hydrocarbon production and related infrastructure by various elements of the Canadian left. Yet, net zero remains a policy goal of the Carney government.
Article content
It's unreasonable for any Canadian prime minister to speak about becoming an 'energy superpower' while placing self-destructive limits on the development of Canada's hydrocarbon endowment.
Article content
Meanwhile, hydrocarbon demand globally is not declining, nor is it expected to in the foreseeable future. Any global market share for hydrocarbons Canada relinquishes in its pursuit of net zero will be captured by other nations, creating no real net decrease in global emissions.
Article content
Carney wasn't elected to explicitly deconstruct the hydrocarbon industry and with it, much of Alberta's economy. Yet that would be the consequence if his government materially advances its net-zero agenda.
Article content
If this is not Carney's intention, he should clarify his position to be consistent with the following:
Article content
No federal emission caps will apply to hydrocarbon production through to at least 2050.
Article content
The Impact Assessment Act (Bill C-69) should be repealed and replaced with an expedited review process that ensures irrevocable political sanction for major projects within one year of regulatory application, free of climate tests and explicit statutory guidance on stakeholder consultation and accommodation.