HMP Lowdham Grange: 'Repeated failures' at jail where three men died
Three prisoners found hanging in their cells in the space of three weeks died in an "overwhelmed" jail, a jury has found.Anthony Binfield, Rolandas Karbauskas and David Richards were inmates at HMP Lowdham Grange in Nottinghamshire in March 2023.An inquest that concluded at Nottingham Coroner's Court on Friday criticised "repeated failures" at the Category B jail, which was run by Sodexo at the time of the deaths.The jury said failures in leadership and issues surrounding the first transfer of a prison between private companies in England and Wales, the month before the deaths, had been contributing factors.
'Out of touch'
The inquest heard Lowdham Grange had been previously run by Serco before it was transferred to Sodexo on 16 February 2023.A former director described the buildings as being "dirty" when he arrived, while longstanding issues with safety and drug use were also mentioned.On the day of the handover, staff arrived to find computers leased to Serco had been taken away, and the court heard a number of experienced prison officers had left in the months beforehand.The jury cited a number of issues around staffing levels and the sharing of "risk-pertinent information", with "multiple missed opportunities" to provide support.In all three cases, it said the transfer of the prison's control "due to poor leadership and supervision" was likely to have "more than minimally contributed" to their deaths."It was apparent that senior directors were out of touch with issues being faced on the shop floor," the jury said.
Anthony Binfield
Anthony Binfield was 30 years old when he was found in his cell on 6 March 2023, just weeks after Lowdham Grange changed hands.He had first arrived at the jail in August 2021, and after a short period at a different jail returned in November 2022, but he had repeatedly requested a transfer to a different institution.The court heard he was known to have issues with drugs and had been attacked due to debts, yet in the days before his death, information about his mental health struggles was not passed on properly between staff.His aunt said he had been "let down" by the prison service, and said Lowdham Grange "couldn't cope with him, and often didn't care".The jury said Binfield had, on five different occasions, been placed under an ACCT (assessment, care in custody and teamwork), a process used in prison to help those at risk of self-harm or suicide, but it was not in place at the time of his death.He was placed under half-hourly observations after being found under the influence of Spice, but staff did not carry out the checks properly, with CCTV showing them also not present at his cell when they said they were.The jury said when the observation hatch to Binfield's cell door was covered, "there was an 11-minute delay before the prison staff entered the cell", with "no urgency" to call an emergency.Returning a conclusion of suicide, it said a note found laid bare how he "felt let down and unheard by the system and by the prison staff"."Anthony felt trapped by the system, out of depth, and felt he had no-one to turn to for help," jurors added.
David Richards
A week after Binfield's death, David Richards, 42, was also found hanging in his cell.He had arrived at the jail on 24 February, and the inquest heard he was "very unhappy" about being moved to a site without a vulnerable prisoner unit due to threats made against him at his previous prison, where he had been on four ACCTs at various times.The jury found staff at Lowdham Grange "were not aware of his previous ACCTs due to not reading his history", while his status as a vulnerable prisoner "was not taken into consideration before his transfer or upon arrival".A mental health assessment recorded Richards as being "petrified and unsafe in prison", with a prison induction officer warning he was like a "rabbit in headlights" when learning there was no dedicated unit for vulnerable prisoners.When he learned he was due to be transferred from the induction site to a wing on 13 March, Richards "raised multiple concerns to the induction officer regarding his safety"."His concerns were not taken into consideration and he was told he would be 'moved by force' if he did not co-operate with the move," the jury said."[Richards] had now been consistently lied to regarding the decisions around his move and safety."At about 11:35 GMT on 13 March, Richards was last seen alive, before he was discovered hanging in his cell by another prisoner at 13:16.The jury said his "likely intention when performing this act was a cry for help", and concluded his death was an accident, but said there was a failure to perform a welfare check when his cell was unlocked at 11:45.
Rolandas Karbauskas
Rolandas Karbauskas arrived at Lowdham Grange on 20 March, five days before he was found hanging in his cell by a fellow prisoner.The 49-year-old had a history of depression, but the jury heard no formal action was taken to address his mental health issues when he transferred from HMP Lincoln, and found that healthcare staff did not read his history on arrival.He spoke "little to no English", which was not flagged as putting him at risk of isolation, and staff used a fellow inmate who was fluent in Lithuanian to assist them, which the jury said was "not appropriate".A nurse made an urgent mental health referral and "advised multiple times" for the need for an interpreter, but an interpreter was not booked for the referral on 23 March."This was an inadequate provision of care as an interpreter was a vital part of his next appointment," the jury said.Despite Karbauskas raising a history of depression at the referral - where a prison officer who spoke Lithuanian and was "by chance" at Lowdham Grange on secondment provided assistance - but no ACCT was opened.Karbauskas's wing buddy raised concerns on 24 March, but a prison officer who saw him in his cell for three minutes "took no action", which the jury said was "a missed opportunity" to monitor him.He was found hanging in his cell by his wing buddy at about 10:30 on 25 March, and the jury found no adequate welfare check was carried out when his cell was unlocked earlier that morning.Returning a conclusion of suicide, the jury cited the "questionable" translation service that "led to distinct language barrier issues", and also highlighted problems as the prison moved from being run by Serco to Sodexo.
'Extremely concerning'
Following the jury's conclusions, area coroner Laurinda Bower thanked the jury for their diligence during an "incredibly protracted inquest", which began hearing evidence on 4 November last year.She also raised "a number of concerns" regarding conditions at Lowdham Grange, and the way the inquest was responded to by some parties."I'm concerned not only by the failures in Anthony, David and Rolandas's care, but also by the persistent failure to learn from deaths at Lowdham Grange, and by the manner in which the prison agencies have engaged with this inquest," she said."Getting to the truth has been challenging."Ms Bower also criticised a failure to act "with candour" from some witnesses, adding: "The agencies involved must stand back and consider how they engage with inquests."She issued two prevention of future death reports, one concerning the "multiple failings and missed opportunities" found by the jury in the care of all three.Another report was issued regarding the death of Binfield and the way Lowdham Grange prison staff managed the covering of observation panels on the door to his cell, which she said "is not a new issue for the prison" and led her to worry "that the prison has failed to tackle this issue over many years"."There is a dangerous culture of staff assuming the prisoner has obscured the observation panel for privacy purposes or as a form of protest against the regime," she said in her address to the current governor."This neglects the obvious and very real risk that the prisoner is seeking to harm themselves, without detection."If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this story, you can visit the BBC Action Line.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
12 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Outrage after young female prison guard working alone was sexually assaulted at knifepoint by an inmate then told to work the next day
A young female prison guard has been allegedly sexually assault while on duty before being asked to return to work the very next day. The young officer was working an early morning shift at the Adelaide Remand Centre, in the city's CBD on May 5 when an inmate allegedly threatened her with a makeshift knife. It's understood she had turned to secure a door when the prisoner allegedly sexually assaulted her from behind. The inmate allegedly showed the guard the weapon hidden in his jumper before telling her he would 'slit her throat' if she raised the alarm. In claims reported by 7NEWS, it's believed the prisoner told the guard he would hurt her family if she pressed the emergency alarm button. The officer was left traumatised by the alleged assault and suffered bruising. However, shockingly it's claimed she was asked to return to active duty the following day. A spokesperson for Adelaide Remand Centre, which is privately managed and operated by Serco, confirmed the incident and said South Australia Police were aware of the alleged assault. 'We take seriously any reported incident involving an alleged assault on one of our officers,' the spokesperson said. 'The matter has been formally referred to South Australia Police for investigation.' The spokesperson added the guard is receiving the necessary support and care she needs. 'We are committed to maintaining a safe environment for everyone and do not tolerate this type of alleged behaviour.' Daily Mail Australia has contacted Adelaide Remand Centre and South Australia Police for comment.
Channel 4
2 days ago
- Channel 4
TAGGING JACKIE
As the government gets ready to roll out a massive expansion of the offender tagging programme in England and Wales, a whistleblower from inside Serco, the private company charged with running it, has told Channel 4 News the system is in 'chaos' and could be putting the public at risk. The Serco insider works at the company's monitoring centre. We've called him Aaron to protect his identity. He told us at one point the computer system was throwing out so much data, finding genuine breaches was 'like finding a needle in a haystack'. 'It was throwing out all these alerts that sometimes didn't mean anything but there'd be thousands and thousands. We didn't know how to identify the genuine breaches from all this traffic of data that was coming into the system.' He also claimed some offenders are going unmonitored and the company only realises it after being asked for information from police or probation looking for them. 'We've had somebody who they want to arrest for rape or potential assault, a serious assault of a victim, and you'd look up the records to identify the person that they're asking about. There's been instances where we haven't been able to give them that information because something has gone wrong when it's been installed, or something's happened in the system where the person has got a tag on, but we're not actively monitoring them. There's been instances where it's been weeks and weeks of where we think we're monitoring someone but they're not actively being monitored.' Aaron described staff at the centre being asked by police for GPS location details of a tagged domestic abuse offender after his ex partner was found dead and he became a potential suspect. Aaron claims staff found he hadn't been monitored effectively 'due to an error.' Serco won the 200 million pound government contract back in 2023 and it came into operation in May the following year, but it's had a troubled history . The company has been fined for poor performance on the contract every month since it started. In April, failures in the tagging system were exposed by Channel 4's Dispatches programme, including offenders going untagged for weeks. In response, Serco said it was tagging a record number of people and its performance would continue to improve 'at pace.' But Channel 4 News has uncovered potential flaws across the entire system – not just with Serco. 'If I was a victim of domestic abuse, I would be extremely scared having been told that tagging is the solution to my safety and then to find it's not.' Twenty one year old Samuel Mattocks was found by police with a knife in his bag. He was initially told to expect prison but, for his first offence, magistrates decided instead to give him a three month community sentence, a critical part of it being a tag to make sure he observed his curfew. He was told the tag would be fitted in two or three days. For weeks, Samuel says he waited for the tagging company to arrive, initially being told they went to the wrong address. He told us he tried to contact the company to make sure they had his new details but was left on hold for hours. Eventually, he says – a fortnight to go before his three month curfew ended – the tag was fitted. When we tried to find out why it had taken so long, there were problems identified throughout the process. Samuel was put on probation on March 14, but no specific instructions for the tag were sent from Probation to Serco for another two weeks. Serco told us after that it did attempt to fit the tag three times, going 'above the requirements' of its contract, but he wasn't at the address Serco had been given. Serco said he was in breach of his conditions and this was reported to Probation. Probation says from Serco's first visit on 11 April until 6 May, Samuel was deemed to have withdrawn his consent to be tagged, because he had been at the wrong address. They say he was told at a meeting on 15 April to return to his original address which he confirmed he had done at a meeting the following week. Samuel says he had already notified the authorities about his change of address and had tried to contact both Serco and the Probation Service to ensure they had the correct one. What is accepted is that Samuel remained untagged until May 23 – the vast majority of the time he was supposed to be being monitored. We put his story and the whistleblower's claims to the National Chair of the Magistrates Association, Mark Beattie. He said: 'We tell an offender that the tag will be fitted in the next two days and the expectation is it's fitted in the next two days. We're very concerned about what we're hearing if we're now being told it's not being fitted for weeks, then you question whether tagging is an effective solution.' Mr Beattie said tagging should be a useful tool to both punish the offender but also to protect the victims of crime. He said if they can't trust the process 'that's a disaster'. 'If I was a victim of domestic abuse, I would be extremely scared having been told that tagging is the solution to my safety and then to find it's not.' This is all a problem for the government itself. In an effort to relieve the prisons crisis , there will be more community sentences and a massive expansion of the tagging programme. It's expected tens of thousands more offenders will be tagged in the coming months. Mark Beattie says if magistrates can't trust the system they will just send offenders to prison instead, defeating the government's plans to send fewer offenders to jail. He says before they expand the tagging programme there should be a complete review of how it's working. 'I think we need to understand the scale of the problem. If they can't deliver now what we have been ordering through the courts, then we have to understand what the recovery plan is. So at the point that it ramps up, we have to have confidence that they're going to be ready to deliver it.' In a statement , Antony King, the Managing Director of Citizen Services at Serco, said: 'We are proud of the challenging work our people do, working with multiple partners across the criminal justice system in delivering an essential and critical public safety service, often with complex and ever increasing requirements. Our performance continues to improve, which the MoJ recognise, and we continue to monitor record numbers of people in the community supporting our colleagues in probation and the Home Office.' The Ministry of Justice told us: 'While we cannot comment on individual cases, we dispute many of the claims being made. Tagging is an important and effective way to monitor and punish offenders and any delays are totally unacceptable.' But it did add that while the backlog of tagging visits had been significantly reduced, Serco's overall performance 'remains below acceptable levels'. Serco to repay £68m for wrongly billed electronic tagging G4S and Serco face SFO 'criminal investigation' over tagging Is electronic tagging too costly and out of date?
BBC News
2 days ago
- BBC News
Inspection finds high rates of violence at HMP Fosse Way
High rates of violence and "significant" drug use have been uncovered at a new prison in Leicestershire, inspectors at HMP Fosse Way in Glen Parva, Leicestershire, told His Majesty's Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) that they felt unsafe during an unannounced inspection in showed there had been a "steady rise" in violence at the prison which opened in 2023, over the 12 months before the inspection, with violence against staff also the inspection revealed "significant concerns" over safety, inspectors rated three other areas - respect, purposeful activity and preparation for release - as "reasonably good". The visit was the first review of the service - which is run privately by Serco - since it opened in 2023, according to the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS). Inspectors said they found "illicit drugs" were "widely available" at the prison, and added it was a "threat to the stability" of the said such items were being brought in through the gate by staff or prisoners, or being thrown over the fence, but acknowledged that steps had been taken to crackdown on the report added that tackling the issues had been identified as "a priority" by prison leadership, but said that "not enough" was being done to address demand for drugs or provide support for those who engaged with substance misuseIt added that leaders had taken "decisive action" to deal with "staff corruption" with several members of staff "arrested or dismissed". 'Maintain the momentum' Some 42% of prisoners said they had experienced "bullying or victimisation" in the prison compared to 29% in similar were also about 360 new charges brought against prisoners each month, most of which were for possession of unauthorised articles, incidents of violence and positive drug test results, according to the said staff often "failed" to reinforce the standard of behaviour needed to make prisoners feel the prison was praised for the amount of time prisoners were able to be out of their cells, and the "wide range" of education, work and training opportunities was also praise for the range of activities available to inmates, and prisoners were encouraged to stay in touch with their families, the report added. Ultimately, inspectors said that leaders and staff "should be congratulated on what they had achieved so far" and "encouraged to maintain the momentum they have created".Wyn Jones, prison director for Serco, said the company was "overall pleased" with the said: "Our focus remains on ensuring our prison is safe and we have an action plan in place to improve this."This includes an accommodation strategy for prisoners who feel unsafe to move to quieter house blocks."Our zero-tolerance approach to drugs in the prison continues and our work with the police has led to a significant reduction in the availability of drugs within Fosse Way."
