PM says he ‘particularly' listens to hostages after Palestine backlash
The Prime Minister said there is a 'need to do everything we can to alleviate the human catastrophe in Gaza' after Emily Damari accused him of 'moral failure' over the move.
Ms Damari said that Sir Keir is 'not standing on the right side of history' and that she was 'deeply saddened' by the decision.
As well as Ms Damari's criticism, Wednesday also saw a group of peers warn that the pledge could break international law.
Speaking to ITV West Country while on a visit to Swindon on Thursday, the Prime Minister said: 'I particularly listen to the hostages, Emily Damari, who I have spoken to, – I've met her mother a number of times, and they've been through the most awful, awful experience for Emily and for her mother.
'And that's why I've been absolutely clear and steadfast that we must have the remaining hostages released. That's been our position throughout and I absolutely understand the unimaginable horror that Emily went through.
'Alongside that, we do need to do everything we can to alleviate the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza, where we are seeing the children and babies starving for want of aid which could be delivered.
'That is why I've said unless things materially change on the ground, we'll have to assess this in September, we will recognise Palestine before the United Nations General Assembly in September.'
It comes as some 38 members of the House of Lords, including some of the UK's most eminent lawyers, wrote to Attorney General Lord Hermer.
As first reported by the Times newspaper, the peers warned Sir Keir Starmer's pledge to recognise Palestine may breach international law as the territory may not meet the criteria for statehood under the Montevideo Convention, a treaty signed in 1933.
Business minister Gareth Thomas described the decision as a 'political judgment' and said ministers 'believe it is' compliant with international law.
He told Times Radio 'In the end, recognition of another state is a political judgment and over 140 countries have already recognised Palestine, and we're determined to do so in September if Israel does not end the violence in Gaza, agree to a ceasefire and agree to a lasting route towards a two-state solution, and to no annexation in the West Bank.'
In their letter to Lord Hermer, the peers said Palestine 'does not meet the international law criteria for recognition of a state, namely, defined territory, a permanent population, an effective government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states'.
There is no certainty over the borders of Palestine, they said, and no single government as Hamas and Fatah are enemies.
In their letter, seen by the PA news agency, the peers added: 'You have said that a selective, 'pick and mix' approach to international law will lead to its disintegration, and that the criteria set out in international law should not be manipulated for reasons of political expedience.
'Accordingly, we expect you to demonstrate this commitment by explaining to the public and to the Government that recognition of Palestine would be contrary to the principles governing recognition of states in international law.'
Lord Hermer has previously insisted a commitment to international law 'goes absolutely to the heart' of the Government's approach to foreign policy.
Sir Keir announced earlier this week that the UK could take the step of recognising Palestine in September ahead of a gathering at the UN.
The UK will only refrain from doing so if Israel allows more aid into Gaza, stops annexing land in the West Bank, agrees to a ceasefire, and signs up to a long-term peace process over the next two months, the Prime Minister said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
a few seconds ago
- The Guardian
Labour urged to consider wealth tax as Reeves visits Scotland
Update: Date: 2025-08-01T10:17:24.000Z Title: the Treasury should consider a wealth tax to close the growing gap in the public finances, according to a', 'Labour', 'former shadow chancellor Content: Former shadow chancellor Anneliese Dodds said ministers must be frank about 'really big decisions' in autumn budget Tom Ambrose Fri 1 Aug 2025 11.17 BST First published on Fri 1 Aug 2025 09.28 BST From 9.28am BST 09:28 Good morning and welcome to the UK politics blog. My name is Tom Ambrose and I'll be bringing you all the latest news lines throughout the day. We start with news that the Treasury should consider a wealth tax to close the growing gap in the public finances, according to a Labour former shadow chancellor. Anneliese Dodds, who held the role under Keir Starmer in opposition, said ministers must have a 'full and frank discussion' with the public about the 'really big decisions' they had to take at this autumn's budget. With Rachel Reeves aiming to fill a financial hole that economists say could exceed £20bn, the senior Labour MP said there was 'no silver bullet' to funding big-ticket items such as defence, but the chancellor should consider tax rises. Dodds quit her post as international development minister in February over the government's decision to slash the aid budget to pay for increased defence spending – a move she said was a mistake that would have a big impact on global security. With Russia and China already stepping into the gap to boost their own global influence, she said now was not the time for the UK to be 'walking back' from using soft power. Read the full report here: Reeves is visit Scotland later today. She will visit RAF Lossiemouth in Moray and the St Fergus gas plant in Aberdeenshire on Friday. The chancellor is expected to meet with 200 Boeing employees at the Lossiemouth military base, where three E-7 Wedgetail aircraft are being worked on, the National reports. The UK government has previously said that its plan to increase defence spending to 2.6% of GDP could boost the economy by around 0.3% and create 26,100 jobs in Scotland. In other developments: The UK's plan to recognise a Palestinian state is compliant with international law, a minister has said, after a group of peers raised concerns that it did not meet the legal bar. Jonathan Reynolds, the business secretary, defended the fact that the government's plan for recognising Palestinian statehood does not involve firm 'conditions' being placed on Hamas, saying the government could not make the decision conditional on what Hamas does because it does not negotiate with terrorist organisations. Nine out of 10 nurses have rejected their 3.6% pay award for this year and warned that they could strike later this year unless their salaries are improved. Mary-Ann Stephenson has been confirmed as the new chair of the equalities watchdog, after the government overruled the objections of parliament's equalities committee over her suitability for the job. 11.17am BST 11:17 Private companies running special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) schools should face a cap on their profits to curb 'shameless profiteering,' the Liberal Democrats have said. The party commissioned research revealing that some firms are raking in tens of millions of pounds a year, with profit margins topping 20%, BBC News reported. Liberal Democrat education spokesperson Munira Wilson said profits should be limited to 8% to prevent funds intended for SEND children from being diverted 'into the pockets of shareholders.' In response to the findings, the government said Labour was pushing schools to prioritise 'improving children's outcomes – not excessive profit-making.' Analysis from the House of Commons Library, carried out for the Lib Dems, found that several major SEND education providers – including some backed by offshore private equity firms – have seen sharp increases in profits in recent years. One provider reportedly earned more than £44 million in profit on a turnover of £208 million, with profits rising by 60% in just two years. Another recorded £20.9 million in profit from £194.2 million in turnover – a margin of 10.8%. 10.50am BST 10:50 The Green Party's occasionally fractious leadership contest has entered its final stages as members begin voting on Friday. The party's more than 60,000 members face a choice between MPs Adrian Ramsay and Ellie Chowns, and an insurgent campaign led by London Assembly member Zack Polanski. Ramsay, a current co-leader of the party, and Chowns have said that the Greens should 'double down' on the 'proven techniques' that saw them quadruple their representation in Westminster last year. But Polanski has urged the party to be 'bold', pushing an 'eco-populist' stance and seeking to emulate Nigel Farage's success in creating headlines and catapulting his Reform UK to the top of the opinion polls. Ramsay and Chowns have accused Polanski of using 'polarising' language that only appealed to a 'narrow segment' of voters. 10.33am BST 10:33 The government will tighten eligibility criteria for Whitehall internships as part of a broader push to make the civil service more representative of the working class. According to the BBC, the main internship scheme will now be limited to students from 'lower socio-economic backgrounds' and based on which occupations their parents held when they were 14. Pat McFadden, the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and the minister responsible for civil service reform, said that Whitehall needed to reflect the broader community, PA reported. 'We need to get more working-class young people into the Civil Service so it harnesses the broadest range of talent and truly reflects the country,' he told the BBC. 'Government makes better decisions when it represents and understands the people we serve.' Changes are expected to take effect from summer 2026 and will give young people experience writing briefings, planning events, conducting policy research and shadowing civil servants, according to the broadcaster. The existing work summer placement programme, which lasts up to eight weeks and is paid, is open to undergraduates in the final two years of their degree. 10.15am BST 10:15 Richard Adams Confucius Institutes at universities across England are under threat from new free speech rules, setting off urgent talks between ministers, vice-chancellors and regulators over the fate of the China-backed language and culture centres. Universities fear that the new regulations imposed by the Office for Students (OfS) this month will cause legal headaches with their Chinese partners, including the government in Beijing, and could lead to some being closed. University leaders claim they have been left in the dark by England's regulator over whether or not they are breaking the new rules, which bar foreign governments from vetting staff employed at the institutes. The 20 Confucius Institutes operating in England – including at the universities of Manchester, Coventry and Liverpool – are partnerships between each university, a Chinese university, and an arm of the Chinese state that provides funding. They offer Mandarin classes and promote cultural events but critics allege they also act as a Trojan horse within the education system. The Department for Education (DfE) said it 'welcomed a range of international partnerships with UK higher education' but that they had to comply with UK laws and regulations. 'It is for individual higher education providers to assess whether the criteria of existing arrangements would have the effect of restricting free speech and take steps to address that,' the DfE said. 10.00am BST 10:00 Rowena Mason The government should greatly expand family centres under the Sure Start brand to help win back Reform voters in former Labour heartlands, a commission backed by Labour politicians has said. Hilary Armstrong, the Labour peer and former cabinet minister, was among those pressing for a fuller reintroduction of family centres under the Sure Start label, saying it would help to rebuild trust in neighbourhoods damaged by austerity. Armstrong is chair of the Independent Commission on Neighbourhoods, which said its polling showed 62% of people recognised the Sure Start brand, and that 76% would like to see it revived. Bridget Phillipson, the education secretary, announced last month that one-stop-shop family hubs similar to Sure Start would be introduced throughout England to give parents advice and support. The £500m project will open up to 1,000 centres from April 2026, meaning every council in England will have a family hub by 2028. It will be called Best Start and will build on the existing family hubs and the start for life programme to provide a single point of access for services in health, education and wellbeing services. The policy forms part of the government's push to replace services lost since 2010, which include the closure of more than 1,400 Sure Start centres. At their peak under Gordon Brown, there were more than 3,600 Sure Start centres, which were considered one of the previous Labour government's biggest achievements. 9.46am BST 09:46 Gwyn Topham Heathrow has submitted its 'shovel-ready' plans for a third runway as part of a £50bn investment, as the government said expanding Europe's largest airport could create 100,000 jobs and drive growth. The 2-mile (3.2km) runway expansion would cross a diverted M25 and allow more than 750 additional flights a day over London, helping bring the total annual number of passengers to 150 million. Environmental campaigners called it a 'doomed scheme' that would release millions of tonnes of CO2 while benefiting only a small minority of rich flyers. Heathrow said that with government support it could obtain planning permission by 2029 and have the runway in operation by 2035. Its proposals remain essentially the same as those submitted in 2019 and approved in principle by the government and MPs. That scheme survived a brief block on climate grounds sparked by legal challenges from campaigners, overturned on appeal in 2020. However, the plans were put on hold as passenger numbers dropped during the pandemic. The shareholders in the airport, which include the French private equity firm Ardian and Saudi Arabia and Qatar's sovereign wealth funds, are seeking legislative change, as well as long-term political support, before filing a full planning application. Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, has strongly endorsed expansion, but Heathrow is seeking firm policy guarantees after previous runway plans were overturned. 9.28am BST 09:28 Good morning and welcome to the UK politics blog. My name is Tom Ambrose and I'll be bringing you all the latest news lines throughout the day. We start with news that the Treasury should consider a wealth tax to close the growing gap in the public finances, according to a Labour former shadow chancellor. Anneliese Dodds, who held the role under Keir Starmer in opposition, said ministers must have a 'full and frank discussion' with the public about the 'really big decisions' they had to take at this autumn's budget. With Rachel Reeves aiming to fill a financial hole that economists say could exceed £20bn, the senior Labour MP said there was 'no silver bullet' to funding big-ticket items such as defence, but the chancellor should consider tax rises. Dodds quit her post as international development minister in February over the government's decision to slash the aid budget to pay for increased defence spending – a move she said was a mistake that would have a big impact on global security. With Russia and China already stepping into the gap to boost their own global influence, she said now was not the time for the UK to be 'walking back' from using soft power. Read the full report here: Reeves is visit Scotland later today. She will visit RAF Lossiemouth in Moray and the St Fergus gas plant in Aberdeenshire on Friday. The chancellor is expected to meet with 200 Boeing employees at the Lossiemouth military base, where three E-7 Wedgetail aircraft are being worked on, the National reports. The UK government has previously said that its plan to increase defence spending to 2.6% of GDP could boost the economy by around 0.3% and create 26,100 jobs in Scotland. In other developments: The UK's plan to recognise a Palestinian state is compliant with international law, a minister has said, after a group of peers raised concerns that it did not meet the legal bar. Jonathan Reynolds, the business secretary, defended the fact that the government's plan for recognising Palestinian statehood does not involve firm 'conditions' being placed on Hamas, saying the government could not make the decision conditional on what Hamas does because it does not negotiate with terrorist organisations. Nine out of 10 nurses have rejected their 3.6% pay award for this year and warned that they could strike later this year unless their salaries are improved. Mary-Ann Stephenson has been confirmed as the new chair of the equalities watchdog, after the government overruled the objections of parliament's equalities committee over her suitability for the job.
Daily Mail
a few seconds ago
- Daily Mail
Trump's top advisers arrive in Gaza to assess humanitarian crisis
Two of President Donald Trump's top lieutenants in the Middle East - special envoy Steve Witkoff and Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee - will travel to Gaza on Friday to inspect food deliveries. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt shared the updates on Thursday, detailing that Witkoff and Huckabee had a 'very productive meeting' with Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu earlier in the day. During his trip to Scotland on Monday, Trump broke with Netanyahu when he noted, alongside British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, that there was 'real starvation' in the Palestinian territory of Gaza. Netanyahu has denied that Israel is waging a starvation campaign against Palestinian civilians living in Gaza amid the current war with Hamas. Leavitt said the meeting with Netanyahu was on the topic of food and aid deliveries into Gaza. 'President Trump is a humanitarian with a big heart and that's why he sent special envoy Witkoff to the region in an effort to save lives and end this crisis,' Leavitt said. She said that Witkoff and Huckabee will survey current distribution sites and figure out ways to get more food into the wartorn territory. They will also 'meet with local Gazans to hear firsthand about this dire situation on the ground.' On Tuesday, as the president traveled back from Scotland after spending time at his two golf resorts and meeting several world leaders, Trump hinted that Melania Trump may have played a role in his evolution on Gaza. 'She thinks it's terrible,' Trump told reporters. 'She sees the same pictures that you see. And that we all see. And I think everybody - unless they're pretty cold-hearted or, worse than that, nuts.' 'There's nothing you can say other than it's terrible,' the president continued. 'When you see the kids. And those are kids - whether they talk [about] starvation or not - those are kids that are starving. They are starving.' A journalist had asked the president if the first lady had called attention to the crisis in Gaza after she previously piped up about Russian President Vladimir Putin's continued bombings of Ukraine despite having 'very pleasant' talks with Trump. During Thursday's briefing, Leavitt reiterated Trump's position against recognizing Palestinian statehood - a move France, the United Kingdom and Canada have threatened to push Israel to allow more aid into Gaza. The president had said Tuesday that such moves reward Hamas. 'You could make the case that you're rewarding people - that you're rewarding Hamas if you do that and I don't think they should be rewarded,' the president said. Netanyahu had made a similar point saying that the move 'rewards terror' as Hamas responsible for the October 7, 2023 terror attacks that started the war - hasn't been fully removed from power in Gaza. Trump showed his displeasure with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney by suggesting recognizing Palestinian statehood would prevent Canada from getting a last-minute trade deal ahead of the August 1 deadline when the president's reciprocal tariffs are expected to kick in. 'Wow! Canada has just announced that it is backing statehood for Palestine. That will make it very hard for us to make a Trade Deal with them. Oh' Canada!!!' Trump posted to Truth Social overnight Thursday. During an executive order signing on physical fitness later Thursday, Trump said Carney's move wasn't a 'dealbreaker' but suggested he was leaving the Canadians unread ahead of the crucial deadline. 'We haven't spoken to Canada today,' Trump said.
The Independent
30 minutes ago
- The Independent
Minister reopens door to wealth tax days after cabinet colleague calls it ‘daft'
A government minister has reopened the door to a wealth tax, just days after the business secretary dismissed the idea as 'daft'. Asked about a wealth tax, policing minister Dame Diana Johnson said it is 'important… that all these issues are looked at and discussed and we look at the evidence about what will work and what won't work'. But last week, business secretary Jonathan Reynolds slapped down the concept, urging his colleagues to stop calling for a 'magic wealth tax' that does not exist and dismissing it as 'daft'. It comes amid mounting questions over how the government will raise the money to fill the black hole in the public finances left by a series of major U-turns and spending commitments. Ministers have already squeezed significant savings out of their departments in cuts that were unveiled at last month's spending review, meaning there is now a mounting expectation that the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, will be forced to raise taxes instead. But Labour 's manifesto pledge not to raise taxes on 'working people' leaves the chancellor with a limited number of workable options. Dame Diana's remarks came after former Labour minister and ex-shadow chancellor Anneliese Dodds urged the government to consider a wealth tax. Asked about Ms Dodds' remarks, the policing minister told Sky News: 'I think the Labour Party and the Labour government welcome contributions from everybody. Ultimately it is down to the chancellor to make decisions about what she is going to announce in the budget later this year.' She added: 'I think whatever decision that the chancellor makes it will be based on our values as a Labour government and we have made very clear commitments around tax. 'I think it is important though that all these issues are looked at and discussed and we look at the evidence about what will work and what won't work.' Speaking to GB News just days before, Mr Reynolds had said: 'This Labour government has increased taxes on wealth as opposed to income – the taxes on private jets, private schools, changes through inheritance tax, capital gains tax. 'But the idea there's a magic wealth tax, some sort of levy ... that doesn't exist anywhere in the world. 'Switzerland has a levy, but they don't have capital gains or inheritance tax. There's no kind of magic ... We're not going to do anything daft like that. 'And I say to people: 'Be serious about this.' The idea you can just levy everyone ... What if your wealth was not in your bank account, what if it was in fine wine or art? How would we tax that? This is why this doesn't exist.' Amid growing calls for the government to introduce a wealth tax from Labour backbenchers, Ms Dodds warned that spending cuts alone would not 'deliver the kind of fiscal room that is necessary'. Speaking to Sky News's Electoral Dysfunction podcast, Ms Dodds pointed to work undertaken by the Commission on Wealth Tax. 'They looked at the operation of lots of different wealth tax. They looked at all of that evidence and set out how it would be possible to deliver something like that in a UK context', she said. 'I would hope that the Treasury is considering that kind of evidence as well as other changes that have been put forward. 'We've seen the deputy leader of the Labour Party, for example, put forward suggestions. I think it's important for all of those to be considered now.' It comes after a memo leaked earlier this year showed Angela Rayner suggesting eight wealth taxes on the super-rich and corporations in a move supporters described as the 'progressive alternative'. Ms Dodds also urged the government to take a 'longer-term approach' to the public finances, after the prime minister was bounced into a £5bn U-turn on welfare cuts by his own MPs. Downing Street has so far failed to rule out a wealth tax, but the prime minister has previously said that 'we can't just tax our way to growth' when pressed on the subject at PMQs last month. Rachael Maskell, the leader of the rebel Labour MPs who forced Sir Keir to abandon his welfare reforms, called for a wealth tax to meet the cost of the U-turn, suggesting that as much as £24bn a year could be raised by increases in capital gains tax and other measures.
