'Absolute rot': Five fact-checked claims you should know before voting
Australian federal election
is on today, and hundreds of candidates have spent the past few weeks suggesting why they should be part of the new parliament.
While many of the claims made by politicians and their supporters stack up, that's not the case for all of the information shared in the lead-up to the election.
Here are five claims made about the election that aren't quite correct.
No, voting isn't an act of fraud
A Facebook post suggests there are no lawful candidates and that it's a crime to vote.
This stems from the erroneous claim that there has been no valid head of state in Australia since 1973 due to the Royal Style and Titles Act from that year.
AAP FactCheck says it's a debunked
sovereign citizen
myth, and the Act sets out the formal title for the Queen but has no effect on any other laws.
Peter Dutton won't cut $350b from the health budget
An advert authorised by Labor appears to suggest Labor will cut $350 billion from Victorian hospitals.
Labor has told AAP FactCheck the ads did not specifically say the cuts would come from health spending.
Dutton has said he would reduce "wasteful spending", but has
ruled out reductions to frontline services
.
The
Coalition costings
have revealed savings including from ditching Labor's student debt plan, axing its housing fund, and reducing foreign aid.
READ MORE
The cuts that could leave some Australians worse off after election day
Labor's approach to migration did not cause the housing crisis
Dutton has claimed that higher migration under Labor has "really created a housing crisis".
Experts have said the
shortfall in housing
pre-dates Labor's term in office.
Michael Fotheringham, managing director of the Australian Housing and Urban Research Institute, told AAP FactCheck the idea that the crisis was created under
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's
government is "absolute rot", adding: "This is a crisis that's been 40 years in the making."
READ MORE
The housing affordability stumbling block being ignored by both major parties
Bulk-billing claims don't include context
The Coalition claims bulk-billing rates for GPs have fallen since Labor won power in 2022.
While this is true, experts say this is due to a complex mix of factors. They say elevated inflation rates (which started rising before Labor took office) and the failure of indexation of Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS) items to keep up with inflation have made the costs of running a GP clinic higher, and less attractive for doctors to bulk bill.
Bulk-billing rates also rose sharply during the COVID-19 pandemic because vaccine and telehealth appointments were funded as part of the government response.
Meanwhile, Albanese's claim that bulk-billing rates were in "free-fall" when Labor came into office has been found to be misleading because, while rates were going down, they fell more rapidly after Labor took government.
Albanese isn't 'proud' of alleged preference deal with Greens
A video circulating on social media appears to feature fake quotes from Albanese.
"We're proud to say we will preference the Greens … and we're grateful they have preferenced us," a voice says with pictures of Albanese speaking underneath.
But there's no evidence the Labor leader used those words at the Adelaide event, AAP FactCheck said.
Labor has suggested supporters give their second preference to the Greens in over two-thirds of lower house seats but this isn't the case in all 150 electorates.
Albanese has distanced himself from preference suggestions on how-to-vote cards, saying they were a matter for the organisational wing of the party.
For the latest from SBS News,
download our app
and
subscribe to our newsletter
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
6 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Australia grants asylum to HK pro-democracy activist
Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Ted Hui has been granted asylum in Australia, the former MP says, more than four years after he left Hong Kong where he faces criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. Hui said he received written notice from the Australian Department of Home Affairs on Friday approving his claim and that his wife, children and parents were also granted visas. "When people around me say 'congratulations' to me, although I politely thank them, I can't help but feel sad in my heart. How to congratulate a political refugee who misses his home town?" he said in a Facebook post on Saturday. "If it weren't for political persecution, I would never have thought of living in a foreign land. Immigrants can always return to their home towns to visit relatives at any time; exiles have no home." The Home Affairs Department did not immediately respond to emailed questions sent after business hours. The Hong Kong government and China's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to questions about the decision. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited Beijing in July as part of his administration's years-long push to improve ties with China. A former Democratic Party MP, Hui left Hong Kong in late 2020 after facing criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. In 2023 Hong Kong accused him and seven others of national security offences, including incitement to secession, and put $HK1 million ($A196,000) bounties on their heads. Australia said it was disappointed by the decision at the time and concerned about the law. Pro-democracy businessman Jimmy Lai is on trial in Hong Kong on charges related to a national security law imposed by Beijing and alleged sedition. Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Ted Hui has been granted asylum in Australia, the former MP says, more than four years after he left Hong Kong where he faces criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. Hui said he received written notice from the Australian Department of Home Affairs on Friday approving his claim and that his wife, children and parents were also granted visas. "When people around me say 'congratulations' to me, although I politely thank them, I can't help but feel sad in my heart. How to congratulate a political refugee who misses his home town?" he said in a Facebook post on Saturday. "If it weren't for political persecution, I would never have thought of living in a foreign land. Immigrants can always return to their home towns to visit relatives at any time; exiles have no home." The Home Affairs Department did not immediately respond to emailed questions sent after business hours. The Hong Kong government and China's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to questions about the decision. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited Beijing in July as part of his administration's years-long push to improve ties with China. A former Democratic Party MP, Hui left Hong Kong in late 2020 after facing criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. In 2023 Hong Kong accused him and seven others of national security offences, including incitement to secession, and put $HK1 million ($A196,000) bounties on their heads. Australia said it was disappointed by the decision at the time and concerned about the law. Pro-democracy businessman Jimmy Lai is on trial in Hong Kong on charges related to a national security law imposed by Beijing and alleged sedition. Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Ted Hui has been granted asylum in Australia, the former MP says, more than four years after he left Hong Kong where he faces criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. Hui said he received written notice from the Australian Department of Home Affairs on Friday approving his claim and that his wife, children and parents were also granted visas. "When people around me say 'congratulations' to me, although I politely thank them, I can't help but feel sad in my heart. How to congratulate a political refugee who misses his home town?" he said in a Facebook post on Saturday. "If it weren't for political persecution, I would never have thought of living in a foreign land. Immigrants can always return to their home towns to visit relatives at any time; exiles have no home." The Home Affairs Department did not immediately respond to emailed questions sent after business hours. The Hong Kong government and China's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to questions about the decision. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited Beijing in July as part of his administration's years-long push to improve ties with China. A former Democratic Party MP, Hui left Hong Kong in late 2020 after facing criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. In 2023 Hong Kong accused him and seven others of national security offences, including incitement to secession, and put $HK1 million ($A196,000) bounties on their heads. Australia said it was disappointed by the decision at the time and concerned about the law. Pro-democracy businessman Jimmy Lai is on trial in Hong Kong on charges related to a national security law imposed by Beijing and alleged sedition. Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Ted Hui has been granted asylum in Australia, the former MP says, more than four years after he left Hong Kong where he faces criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. Hui said he received written notice from the Australian Department of Home Affairs on Friday approving his claim and that his wife, children and parents were also granted visas. "When people around me say 'congratulations' to me, although I politely thank them, I can't help but feel sad in my heart. How to congratulate a political refugee who misses his home town?" he said in a Facebook post on Saturday. "If it weren't for political persecution, I would never have thought of living in a foreign land. Immigrants can always return to their home towns to visit relatives at any time; exiles have no home." The Home Affairs Department did not immediately respond to emailed questions sent after business hours. The Hong Kong government and China's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to questions about the decision. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited Beijing in July as part of his administration's years-long push to improve ties with China. A former Democratic Party MP, Hui left Hong Kong in late 2020 after facing criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. In 2023 Hong Kong accused him and seven others of national security offences, including incitement to secession, and put $HK1 million ($A196,000) bounties on their heads. Australia said it was disappointed by the decision at the time and concerned about the law. Pro-democracy businessman Jimmy Lai is on trial in Hong Kong on charges related to a national security law imposed by Beijing and alleged sedition.
The Advertiser
6 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Arrests made as women's rights rally draws opposition
Four people have been arrested as protests in Melbourne's CBD turned scrappy. Tensions began to flare mid-morning between police and masked protesters in black believed to be rallying in opposition to a nearby demonstration for "women's sex-based rights". Some members of the media were also caught in the fracas outside the state's parliament house and surrounds as cameras and other equipment were targeted by masked activists. Victorian Police said pepper spray was used and four arrests were made, including a man in his early 20s who hit an officer with an umbrella. Two protesters were charged with allegedly possessing flares and a fourth for failing to move on. Three officers were injured, Victoria Police said, though none needed to be taken to hospital. A group of about 80 gathered to counter-protest a scheduled Women Will Speak demonstration against Victoria's anti-vilification laws. Roughly 50 attended the Women Will Speak rally, cordoned off and guarded by police, where "restore women's sex-based rights" was among the slogans adorning banners. The two groups were separated with water-filled barriers and a heavy police presence, a decision made by police after "disruptive behaviour" in April when similar protests took place. Riot unit and mounted police were among the officers deployed on Saturday. At one point during the rally, photographer Luis Ascui tried to intervene to stop a colleague's camera equipment being damaged by a protester. "They have a right to protest, but they don't have the right to attack us when we're doing a job," he told AAP. A neo-Nazi group was also reportedly planning on crashing the rally but it was unclear if any individuals turned up. Four people have been arrested as protests in Melbourne's CBD turned scrappy. Tensions began to flare mid-morning between police and masked protesters in black believed to be rallying in opposition to a nearby demonstration for "women's sex-based rights". Some members of the media were also caught in the fracas outside the state's parliament house and surrounds as cameras and other equipment were targeted by masked activists. Victorian Police said pepper spray was used and four arrests were made, including a man in his early 20s who hit an officer with an umbrella. Two protesters were charged with allegedly possessing flares and a fourth for failing to move on. Three officers were injured, Victoria Police said, though none needed to be taken to hospital. A group of about 80 gathered to counter-protest a scheduled Women Will Speak demonstration against Victoria's anti-vilification laws. Roughly 50 attended the Women Will Speak rally, cordoned off and guarded by police, where "restore women's sex-based rights" was among the slogans adorning banners. The two groups were separated with water-filled barriers and a heavy police presence, a decision made by police after "disruptive behaviour" in April when similar protests took place. Riot unit and mounted police were among the officers deployed on Saturday. At one point during the rally, photographer Luis Ascui tried to intervene to stop a colleague's camera equipment being damaged by a protester. "They have a right to protest, but they don't have the right to attack us when we're doing a job," he told AAP. A neo-Nazi group was also reportedly planning on crashing the rally but it was unclear if any individuals turned up. Four people have been arrested as protests in Melbourne's CBD turned scrappy. Tensions began to flare mid-morning between police and masked protesters in black believed to be rallying in opposition to a nearby demonstration for "women's sex-based rights". Some members of the media were also caught in the fracas outside the state's parliament house and surrounds as cameras and other equipment were targeted by masked activists. Victorian Police said pepper spray was used and four arrests were made, including a man in his early 20s who hit an officer with an umbrella. Two protesters were charged with allegedly possessing flares and a fourth for failing to move on. Three officers were injured, Victoria Police said, though none needed to be taken to hospital. A group of about 80 gathered to counter-protest a scheduled Women Will Speak demonstration against Victoria's anti-vilification laws. Roughly 50 attended the Women Will Speak rally, cordoned off and guarded by police, where "restore women's sex-based rights" was among the slogans adorning banners. The two groups were separated with water-filled barriers and a heavy police presence, a decision made by police after "disruptive behaviour" in April when similar protests took place. Riot unit and mounted police were among the officers deployed on Saturday. At one point during the rally, photographer Luis Ascui tried to intervene to stop a colleague's camera equipment being damaged by a protester. "They have a right to protest, but they don't have the right to attack us when we're doing a job," he told AAP. A neo-Nazi group was also reportedly planning on crashing the rally but it was unclear if any individuals turned up. Four people have been arrested as protests in Melbourne's CBD turned scrappy. Tensions began to flare mid-morning between police and masked protesters in black believed to be rallying in opposition to a nearby demonstration for "women's sex-based rights". Some members of the media were also caught in the fracas outside the state's parliament house and surrounds as cameras and other equipment were targeted by masked activists. Victorian Police said pepper spray was used and four arrests were made, including a man in his early 20s who hit an officer with an umbrella. Two protesters were charged with allegedly possessing flares and a fourth for failing to move on. Three officers were injured, Victoria Police said, though none needed to be taken to hospital. A group of about 80 gathered to counter-protest a scheduled Women Will Speak demonstration against Victoria's anti-vilification laws. Roughly 50 attended the Women Will Speak rally, cordoned off and guarded by police, where "restore women's sex-based rights" was among the slogans adorning banners. The two groups were separated with water-filled barriers and a heavy police presence, a decision made by police after "disruptive behaviour" in April when similar protests took place. Riot unit and mounted police were among the officers deployed on Saturday. At one point during the rally, photographer Luis Ascui tried to intervene to stop a colleague's camera equipment being damaged by a protester. "They have a right to protest, but they don't have the right to attack us when we're doing a job," he told AAP. A neo-Nazi group was also reportedly planning on crashing the rally but it was unclear if any individuals turned up.
Perth Now
6 hours ago
- Perth Now
Australia grants asylum to HK pro-democracy activist
Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Ted Hui has been granted asylum in Australia, the former MP says, more than four years after he left Hong Kong where he faces criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. Hui said he received written notice from the Australian Department of Home Affairs on Friday approving his claim and that his wife, children and parents were also granted visas. "When people around me say 'congratulations' to me, although I politely thank them, I can't help but feel sad in my heart. How to congratulate a political refugee who misses his home town?" he said in a Facebook post on Saturday. "If it weren't for political persecution, I would never have thought of living in a foreign land. Immigrants can always return to their home towns to visit relatives at any time; exiles have no home." The Home Affairs Department did not immediately respond to emailed questions sent after business hours. The Hong Kong government and China's foreign ministry did not immediately respond to questions about the decision. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited Beijing in July as part of his administration's years-long push to improve ties with China. A former Democratic Party MP, Hui left Hong Kong in late 2020 after facing criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. In 2023 Hong Kong accused him and seven others of national security offences, including incitement to secession, and put $HK1 million ($A196,000) bounties on their heads. Australia said it was disappointed by the decision at the time and concerned about the law. Pro-democracy businessman Jimmy Lai is on trial in Hong Kong on charges related to a national security law imposed by Beijing and alleged sedition.
