What happens when PM gets recommended names for judges? Ex-JAC members share experiences
Published on: Sat, May 10, 2025
By: Ida Lim, MM Text Size: Holder of the Tunku Abdul Rahman Chair, Universiti Malaya Emeritus Prof Datuk Shad Saleem Faruqi address the floor during the Judicial Independence in Malaysia Forum held at Raja Aziz Addruse Auditorium, Wisma Badan Peguam Malaysia. — Picture by Sayuti Zainudin Kuala Lumpur: When the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) recommend names to be appointed as judges, does the prime minister of Malaysia accept all these recommendations? During a forum by the Malaysian Bar here, two former JAC members today confirmed that 'the answer is no', including Former Malaysian Bar president Datuk Mah Weng Kwai. 'When it goes to the PM's Office, everything is done so diplomatically, you will never get an answer from the PM's Office to say so and so not to be appointed. What we will hear is, can we have other names please,' said Mah, who is also a retired Court of Appeal judge. Emeritus Prof Datuk Shad Saleem Faruqi, holder of Universiti Malaya's Tunku Abdul Rahman chair, replied: 'Same here, the answer is no. In some cases, we rejected candidates and we found their name on the list.' The duo were panelists in the first session titled 'Safeguarding the Bench: Judicial Independence in Malaysia' at the Malaysian Bar's two-hour-plus forum 'Judicial Independence in Malaysia: Past Lessons, Current Challenges'. They were replying to the forum session's moderator and Malaysian Bar vice president Anand Raj, who had asked them for if 'all recommendations of JAC were accepted by the executive' while both of them were in the JAC. In Malaysia, the JAC vets through potential candidates to be appointed or promoted as judges by checking if they are qualified and fulfil the criteria under the law. The JAC then votes on these candidates before forwarding the names as recommendations to the prime minister, before the prime minister gives advice to the Yang di-Pertuan Agong for the judges to be appointed. But under the existing laws under the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) Act 2009, the prime minister can choose not to accept the names recommended by the JAC, and instead ask the JAC to give additional names or other candidates. Datuk Seri M Ramachelvam, fellow panellist at the same forum session and co-chair of the Bar Council's Civil Law and Law Reform Committee, said the JAC has brought about a 'much better process' and 'brought much improvement to the appointment of judges from what it was'. But Ramachelvam said Malaysia should head towards the direction of making JAC's recommendations 'binding' on the prime minister, and said this would require amending the Federal Constitution to mandate the prime minister to follow the JAC's recommendations. * Follow us on Instagram and join our Telegram and/or WhatsApp channel(s) for the latest news you don't want to miss. * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available.
Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
5 hours ago
- The Sun
Malaysia rules out single regulator for rare earth industry
KUALA LUMPUR: The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability has ruled out establishing a single entity to regulate Malaysia's rare earth elements industry. Acting Minister Datuk Seri Johari Abdul Ghani cited constitutional provisions and objections from state governments as key reasons for this decision. Several states had raised concerns during engagement sessions, viewing the proposal as an attempt to nationalise state-owned mineral resources. 'Petroleum resources outside state waters are managed differently from land matters, which fall under state jurisdiction,' he told the Dewan Rakyat when winding up the 13th Malaysia Plan debate for his ministry today. He cited the Federal Constitution's Ninth Schedule (State List), which gives states authority over mining permits, leases and licences. Johari also dismissed claims that Malaysia had offered to supply REE, raw or otherwise, exclusively to the United States as leverage in trade tariff talks. 'This was already clarified by the Investment, Trade and Industry Minister (Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz) on Aug 7. The tariff discussions did not involve any commitment to supply REE,' he said. On negotiations with China, Johari said discussions are currently focused on strengthening bilateral cooperation to develop Malaysia's REE industry across the full value chain, including the setting up of processing plants. 'It's still early and China wants to see if our REE can be converted into the downstream products they need. No formal talks are underway regarding any buyback of processed REE,' he said. – Bernama
New Straits Times
6 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Govt has no plans for single REE entity to regulate industry
KUALA LUMPUR: The government has no plans to establish a single entity akin to Petronas to regulate the rare earth elements (REE) industry for now, says Datuk Seri Johari Ghani. The acting natural resources and environmental sustainability minister said that during past discussions and stakeholder engagements, several states expressed objections to such a move. "They viewed the proposal as an attempt at the nationalisation of mineral resources that belong to the states. "As is well known, the management of petroleum resources beyond state waters is different from the management of land matters, which falls under state jurisdiction. "This is clearly stated in the Federal Constitution, Ninth Schedule, List II (State List), which provides that the states have jurisdiction over permits and licences for prospecting, mining leases, mining, and mining certificates," he said in his winding-up speech for the 13th Malaysia Plan. This comes after proposals by several members of parliament for the government to establish a regulatory agency, similar to Petronas, through the enactment of an REE Act to drive the development of the REE industry. Johari assured that the Federal Government fully respects state jurisdiction over land and mineral matters, as enshrined in the Federal Constitution. Accordingly, he said the government has formulated a clear long-term plan to develop the rare earth elements industry holistically, in line with the direction endorsed by the National Economic Action Council. "Any policies or mechanisms on REE revenue distribution will be formulated and decided inclusively through the National Mineral Council, which serves as the main platform for engagement and coordination between the federal and producing state governments. "This planning is based on the principle of close cooperation between the federal and state governments, to ensure that every initiative for the development of the REE industry takes into account state rights and jurisdiction as provided under the Constitution," he said. Malaysia, he said, is also still in discussions with China on technology transfer of REE to Malaysia. "We want to first see what they are doing. We will also conduct our own research, and only then sit down to decide what technologies we want to adopt. "We cannot depend solely on China, as Russia also has expertise, although they have not approached us. China, on the other hand, has offered, and they want to prove themselves to us. We will assess the outcomes and then discuss further," he said. When asked why the proof-of-concept phase in Kenering, Perak is taking up to five years, Johari clarified that big-scale mining usually takes more time to assess, especially on its impact towards the environment. He said he would visit the site soon to get updates from the scientists. He also clarified that Malaysia has never offered the export of raw REE as a concession or condition for tariff reduction in trade tariff negotiations with the United States. This also comes after several queries from MPs to the government about negotiations with the United States involving REE, given that the raw export ban is still in force. "NRES wishes to stress that, in trade tariff negotiations with the US government, Malaysia has never offered the export of raw REE as a concession or condition for tariff reduction.
Barnama
6 hours ago
- Barnama
Malaysia Rules Out Single Entity To Regulate Rare Earth Industry — Johari
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 19 (Bernama) -- The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability (NRES) has no plans to establish a centralised body to regulate Malaysia's rare earth elements (REE) industry, citing constitutional provisions and objections from state governments. Acting Minister Datuk Seri Johari Abdul Ghani said several states had raised concerns during engagement sessions, viewing the proposal as an attempt to nationalise state-owned mineral resources. 'Petroleum resources outside state waters are managed differently from land matters, which fall under state jurisdiction,' he told the Dewan Rakyat when winding up the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP) debate for his ministry today. He cited the Federal Constitution's Ninth Schedule (State List), which gives states authority over mining permits, leases and licences. As such, any move to centralise REE regulation would require in-depth study and close consultation with all state governments to safeguard their rights. Johari also dismissed claims that Malaysia had offered to supply REE, raw or otherwise, exclusively to the United States as leverage in trade tariff talks. 'This was already clarified by the Investment, Trade and Industry Minister (Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Abdul Aziz) on Aug 7. The tariff discussions did not involve any commitment to supply REE,' he said. On negotiations with China, Johari said discussions are currently focused on strengthening bilateral cooperation to develop Malaysia's REE industry across the full value chain, including the setting up of processing plants. 'It's still early and China wants to see if our REE can be converted into the downstream products they need. No formal talks are underway regarding any buyback of processed REE,' he said. -- BERNAMA
