
‘Not Just About Cost': Why Ruapehu Voted Against Bigger Water Model
Government water reforms are driving proposals for smaller councils to meet future costs by amalgamating water services.
Mayor Weston Kirton's bid to team up with Palmerston North, Horowhenua and Rangitīkei councils was lost 6-4 on Wednesday.
Councillors opted instead for a two-council model with Whanganui District Council, which is to decide its approach on Tuesday.
'I have no qualms or ifs or buts,' deputy mayor Viv Hoeta said. 'I heard exactly what my community wanted. It was not just about cost, it was also about local voice and relationships with a council we know and trust and share the same values with.'
Hoeta said community feedback called for a standalone water entity – 'and if we couldn't go it alone, they didn't want to go big.'
The council's acting team leader of policy, strategy and sustainability told councillors larger groupings were the most affordable options because of additional scale.
Aggregated water services with up to four neighbouring local authorities were projected to save users $38.7m through cost efficiencies in the first seven years when compared with the two-council model, Todd Livingstone said.
Councillor Lyn Neeson, who is standing against Kirton for the mayoralty in October, lives rurally. She is not connected to reticulated water and therefore does not pay council water charges.
'I've invested $50,000 to get my water systems – rural people and small communities have to do that.'
She did not believe cost savings would be as high as projected.
'I will be fighting really hard to ensure higher costs don't happen.'
Neeson said savings expected from procurement bargaining could be achieved through collective council buying power regardless of whether Ruapehu was part of a larger Council-Controlled Organisation (CCO).
'A two-council CCO fully intends to make those procurement connections. It doesn't close down any of the opportunities for cost efficiencies.'
She said being a 50% partner in a smaller CCO was more palatable for the community and she was proud of the debate and its outcome.
'This was democracy in action. It was a fundamental, directional shift from chasing potential savings to listening to our community, following the awa, following the community of interest, and following our relationships to Whanganui.'
Fiona Kahukura Hadley-Chase, who is also running for mayor, said pricing alone was not reason enough to choose a bigger entity.
More important was a strong relationship with a council that was bound by obligations to Te Waiū-o-te-Ika and Te Awa Tupua (the catchments of the Whangaehu and Whanganui rivers) as well as agreements with each other.
Her vote against the proposed four-council grouping was based on 'the weight of public opinion', including from iwi leaders.
'I would rather wager on creating and keeping good relationships with people who are interested in the Whanganui River and its tributaries and people.'
Rabbit Nottage said two-thirds of the council voted against the four-council proposal, including the three Māori ward councillors.
'I was comforted by that. They are the voice of Māori and iwi.'
Nottage said his decision took into account all submissions because there were concerns that consultation questions were skewed toward the four-council option.
'In my opinion we made the best decision for the Ruapehu community. If people think otherwise, the elections are coming up in a few months.'
Councillors Korty Wilson and Channey Iwikau also voted against a four-council entity.
In a report to the council, an analysis of submissions during consultation showed 36 supported a larger water entity if it helped reduce long-term costs, with 16 opposed and eight undecided.
Mayor Weston Kirton said he was 'pretty gutted' at losing the vote.
'I thought we'd be able to get a bigger entity over the line, based on evidence that the bigger the number of councils, the greater the efficiency gains and flow-on benefits for pricing.
'The rationale of elected members suggesting that relationships not pricing is more important is foolish if not irresponsible.'
Kirton said the district's affiliation with the awa would not be compromised by a four- or five-council model. Te Awa Tupua legislation would remain a cornerstone for council values.
'The relationship would continue regardless and probably get stronger.'
Kirton said price did matter, particularly for water users and ratepayers who were struggling, including pensioners and people on benefits.
In his report to the council, Livingstone said the difference between the two-council and four-council models in the first year was $4m, with savings of $14.5m across the first three years of a new entity, and $38.7m across the first seven years through till the end of the Long-Term Plan (LTP).
A five-council model would see costs in 2027 of $1488 per water connection.
'The four-council model is 8% more expensive ($123 increase) in the first year, while the two-council model is 67% more expensive ($996 increase), with standalone being nearly three times as expensive ($2589 increase),' Livingstone said.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NZ Herald
5 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Strategy for Whanganui: Guiding document signed off by council after two years of work
Two years of work have culminated in Whanganui District Council's new guiding document - and a goal of more than 5000 new residents by 2035. Strategy for Whanganui - Rautaki mō Whanganui, replacing 2014's Leading Edge Strategy, was signed off by councillors at a meeting this month. It has five


Scoop
a day ago
- Scoop
A Fresh Look For A Much-Loved Landmark: Whanganui Regional Museum's New Exterior Colour Scheme Unveiled
Visitors to Pukenamu Queen's Park will see an exciting and fresh new look emerging for Whanganui Regional Museum. As scaffolding comes down on sections of the building, glimpses of its attractive new colour scheme are being revealed. The repaint is part of the Whanganui District Council's Long-Term Plan 2024–2034, which includes exterior refurbishment of both the Museum's original 1928 building and its 1968 extension, home also to the Davis Lecture Theatre. The project is currently in Stage One of completion, with work being carried out by Alan Tong Ltd. Craig Dalgleish, Director of Dalgleish Architects Ltd, and design technician Catherine Macdonald designed the new look - a thoughtful blend of local identity, culture, architecture, and natural elements. Their vision brings a new sense of life and warmth to this significant civic building. 'We wanted the Museum to sit confidently on its corner and announce itself,' says Craig. 'The colours reference Whanganui's natural environment, cultural past, and architectural heritage - but they also reflect optimism and inclusivity. We deliberately moved away from the safe neutrality of 'greige' to create a sense of welcome and vitality.' Craig worked with Resene Trade Sales Representative Nick Gibbons on the technical aspects of the colour choices, and with Rāwiri Tinirau, Pou Rauhī / Māori Advisor for Whanganui Regional Museum to ensure cultural resonance. 'We made sure we had cultural sign-off before we presented the scheme. The response was very encouraging, and very supportive.' The palette is anchored by tones of Resene Merino and Triple Merino, a nod to Whanganui's strong farming heritage and the city's early growth on the back of the wool trade. These soft neutrals are contrasted by earthy Resene Scoria, a volcanic red that acknowledges both the region's geology and the architecture of marae, and by Resene Bali Hai, a blue evoking the moana, the awa, and the distant mountains. A soft blush pink - carefully chosen from Resene's colour charts of the period - adds an unexpected yet authentic 1920s touch. 'The Soft Pink is probably the most unexpected colour, but it plays a key role in pulling the scheme together,' Craig explains. 'It breaks the building free from the beige tones and connects both to the 1920s design period and to the warmth of the whenua expressed in the Scoria.' Attention to architectural details was key. The classical 1928 building is designed in three parts - base, shaft, and capital - like a column. Craig and Catherine worked to accentuate the vertical elements that link the two distinct eras of architecture. 'That vertical language softens the transition between the 1920s and 1960s sections, making the whole building feel more cohesive,' he says. The vertical segments on the 1968 building will be painted Scoria red in reference to the pou of marae. An unexpected delight emerged during the project: the discovery of a hidden architectural detail beneath old bitumen waterproofing layers. 'It's a modern detail leaning to the modernist movement and where that was going - quite forward thinking and subtly done by the architect at the time. It is abstract, asymmetrical, and does not follow a classical order at all. It's out of step with the building and is a real clue to how architecture was evolving,' says Craig. 'I think the architect slipped in a reference to the modernity that was starting to happen.' The feature is purely decorative but is linked to the design of the Whanganui War Memorial Centre directly opposite the Museum, built in 1960. 'The fact that the detail is asymmetrical and abstract, is the clue that it illustrates the transition from the classicism of the Museum to the eventual abstraction of the War Memorial Hall.' 'That gave me a real kick – that we uncovered this transition detail that was not of the classicism of the 1920s, but on its way to the modern style. Finding that was a real thrill - it's a little piece of design history brought back to light.' The Museum's new look also reflects a wider shift in Whanganui's cultural precinct. With its neighbours - the Sarjeant Gallery, Whanganui War Memorial Hall, and the Alexander Heritage and Research Library - the Museum helps define a civic destination that is forward-looking while firmly grounded in heritage. 'The new colour scheme has a degree of frivolity and 1920s optimism. It looks backwards, but it looks backwards to look forwards.' 'We wanted the building to express inclusivity,' says Craig. 'Historically, the Museum has felt quite patriarchal. It's important that it feels inclusive. This colour scheme is very deliberate – it's intended to say: You're all welcome here.' Whanganui Regional Museum Director Dr Bronwyn Labrum says, 'I could not be more delighted. We had very careful discussions throughout the development of the colour scheme and I always had great faith in Craig and Catherine with whom I have worked on our recent award-winning exhibitions. Their work is outstanding: thoughtful, appropriate, yet bold and contemporary. The meticulous work of Alan Tong Ltd was essential. We have had lots of positive visitor feedback already and the team love it.' Throughout the project, the Whanganui Regional Museum remains open as usual - continuing to welcome visitors into a space where the past, present, and future come together. Note: Founded in 1892, the Whanganui Regional Museum is internationally renowned for its Taonga Māori Collection. Located in Pukenamu Queen's Park, visitors can view the exceptional creations of tupuna (ancestors) of Whanganui tangata whenua (indigenous people) alongside a changing exhibition programme encompassing a world-class collection of natural and human history, with a regional emphasis. The ground level boutique museum store sells a range of local and Māori jewellery, books, cards, art, and other New Zealand-made gift items. The Whanganui Regional Museum Trust is an independent legal entity that owns the collection and governs the development of the Museum on behalf of the Whanganui community. Open to visitors daily from 10.00am to 4.30pm (except Christmas Day and Good Friday), entry to Whanganui Regional Museum is free. Connect with Whanganui Regional Museum or on Facebook and Instagram.

RNZ News
4 days ago
- RNZ News
Departing councillor: ‘Social media abuse has got out of hand'
Whanganui district councillor Jenny Duncan is calling time on her 12 years' service. Photo: RNZ / Leigh-Marama McLachlan Long-serving local councillor Jenny Duncan is calling it quits, after four terms on the Whanganui District Council. Duncan, who served six of her 12 years as deputy mayor, has announced she will not stand for a fifth term in October's local body elections. "It's now time to hand over the reins," she said. "When the negativity outweighs the reward, it's time to go." Duncan said each term had its own challenges, highs and lows, and rewards, but the role had become more complex over time and took up "way more hours than intended, which is fine if you still enjoy it". She lashed out at the government and "keyboard warriors". "Costly impositions and criticism from government and the contempt they direct at us is not deserved by Whanganui," Duncan said. "Social media abuse has got out of hand in the past five or so years. "Keyboard warriors who draw swords before engaging sound thought or seeking facts is truly disappointing. All you're doing is showing your own ignorance and bias." The "dreadful" period during the pandemic, when government-mandated restrictions were in place, had emphasised for her how important it was to treat each other well, all the time. "I love my community, respect my colleagues and can attest to the huge amount of work that goes into our decisions. "We're often at variance, but with robust discussion and challenge, better decisions are made. "If you don't understand the decisions, maybe you didn't read the nine reports and attend the seven workshops that we did." Jenny Duncan (far left), taking part in a Whanganui District Council meeting. Photo: Local Democracy Reporting/ Tuakana Te Tana Duncan is one of several long-serving Whanganui councillors who have announced they will not seek re-election. Deputy Mayor Helen Craig and Charlie Anderson are also standing aside, after 12 years in the council chambers. Duncan said she was pleased to end her service on a high note. "The average 2.2 percent rate increase [for 2025/2026] is a testament to how hard staff and councillors have worked over the past few years to drive up efficiency and reduce cost. "We've done it sustainably. You don't get to 2.2 percent without an outstanding chief executive and staff, and a mayor and councillors working hard to make it possible." Some high points of her council career included how it handled the 2015 flood, port redevelopment, and the North Mole and Rangiora Street projects. Reinstating the 'h' in Whanganui and stopping the food scraps collection were also highlights. She was proud that councillors had consistently refused catered lunches, new furniture and a heat-control system in the chamber. "It's either too hot or too cold. We really are here for our community and not the benefits." Duncan said she would have liked to see further action on housing before stepping aside and she put in a plug for Māori wards. "I'm sorry I'll miss the new Māori ward councillors. Please vote 'yes' to retaining them in the coming referendum. "You'll not regret it." Duncan said she would take some time out and a long trip to Scotland, after her council work. "Then we'll see what pops up. Something always does." LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.