Review: ‘Pirates! The Penzance Musical' is a delightful bit of Gilbert and Sullivan, back on Broadway
Sensibilities have changed, of course, since 1879. And since Gilbert and Sullivan helpfully reside in the public domain, they can be adapted with impunity. In this latest case, now a relatively rare outing for the pair on Broadway with the Roundabout Theatre Company, they've been given an overhaul by adapter Rupert Holmes and a new sexed-up title, being as producers these days panic whenever a title lacks a 'banger,' as we say in journalism.
Ergo, the doings of the Cornish buccaneers now goes by 'Pirates! The Penzance Musical,' as if Gilbert and Sullivan had given a damn about that particular town, beyond its alliterative properties.
At least they'd have appreciated the commercial practicalities. As they would Holmes' decision to juice up the 'Pirates' score with songs actually written for 'Iolanthe,' 'The Mikado,' and 'H.M.S. Pinafore.' Why not? That's been done with Cole Porter and George Gershwin and we won't be seeing 'The Mikado' anytime soon.
Naturally, 'Pirates' has a star in David Hyde Pierce. The good news is that said celebrity is fully equal to the formidable performative demands of one of the greatest patter songs of all time, 'I Am the Very Model of the Modern Major-General,' which he performed flawlessly, and ever more rapidly, on the night I was there. Hyde Piece is perfect for Gilbert and Sullivan: he's droll, a tad dotty, curiously understated and generous with fellow actors, and there is a perpetual twinkle in his been-there-done-that eyes. Add a handle-bar mustache, and what more do you need?
Ramin Karimloo, the dubious pirate monarch, certainly adds to the party. Half Kevin Kline and half Hugh Jackman, the bare-chested Karimloo swaggers around as the fun demands alongside Frederic
(Nicholas Barasch), the duty-bound young fellow apprenticed to the pirates and whose complications and affection for Mabel (Samantha Williams) inform most of the plot. Barasch looks and acts like the long-lost child of Conan O'Brien; he's funny too, in the straight-man kind of way that Gilbert and Sullivan demands.
Frederic has to fight off the machinations of his guardian Ruth, who is spiced up a tad by Jinkx Monsoon, a shrewd bit of casting that I suspect was intended to make that whole relationship more fun and, well, a little less creepy.
The director, Scott Ellis, is clever with those kinds of choices (Preston Truman Boyd is well cast as the police sergeant) and Ellis is joined here by choreographer Warren Carlyle, who keeps all of these wacky characters on their toes, including the show's famous Chaplinesque constables, here rendered as the New Orleans Volunteer Police, since the whole show now takes place in New Orleans in 1880 with a Creole kinda vibe and new syncopations added to the score.
My one caveat on what is a highly entertaining and most genial evening of daffy, escapist Broadway, is that some of it feels a bit much, especially movement and new orchestrations-wise. Gilbert's internal rhymes were never equalled until Stephen Sondheim came along with comparable talent and there are times when the puns and quips get a tad overwhelmed by the Monty Python walks, the jazzy stylings and what not. Occasionally, the material needed to be better trusted.
But those are minor caveats. Holmes, best known for writing 'The Mystery of Edwin Drood,' gives the show a fresh and loving applied coat of paint, even writing Gilbert and Sullivan themselves into the experience, taking a leaf from Jamie Lloyd's little homage to Andrew Lloyd Webber in the current 'Sunset Blvd.' But Ellis also has delivered an old-school analog pleasure in a Broadway season much seduced by digital temptation.
In their graves, Gilbert and Sullivan must be turning topsy-turvy with delight.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
a day ago
- New York Post
Livvy Dunne agrees with Taylor Swift's take on male sports fans
From one WAG to another. Olivia 'Livvy' Dunne was tuned into Taylor Swift's internet-breaking appearance on the 'New Heights' podcast Wednesday — and the retired NCAA gymnast specifically enjoyed the part where the singer trolled male sports fans for complaining she's given too much TV time during Chiefs games. 'As we all know, you guys have a lot of male sports fans that listen to your podcast,' said Swift, 35, who began dating Chiefs' All-pro tight end Travis Kelce in the summer of 2023. Advertisement 'I think we all know that if there's one thing that male sports fans want to see in their spaces and on their screens — it's more of me.' 4 Taylor Swift called out male sports fans for complaining she's given too much TV time during Chiefs games while on the 'New Heights' podcast on August 13, 2025. Instagram/Olivia Dunne Dunne, who's dating Pirates All-Star pitcher Paul Skenes, reposted the video, writing, 'She gets it,' adding a crying laughing emoji on her Instagram Story. Advertisement Swift, who revealed that her new album, 'The Life of a Showgirl' will drop Oct. 3, received backlash from NFL fans for taking away attention from the sport — to the point where NFL commissioner Roger Goodell defended the mega popstar, saying she's introduced the league to a whole new fanbase of women. Dunne, who retired in April after the LSU gymnastics team did not advance to the national championship finals, has spoken publicly about negative attention she's received from fans. Taking to her TikTok on Tuesday, Dunne called out fans for flooding her social media accounts with Gifs and comments about Skenes. Advertisement 4 Olivia Dunne and Paul Skenes. Instagram/Olivia Dunne 'POV: You're dating a professional athlete,' the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model wrote, including screengrabs of comments on her social media. 'Yall are obsessed,' she added with a crying emoji. Advertisement Swift's two-hour appearance on the 'New Heights' podcast garnered global attention, as she revealed her new album, 'The Life of a Showgirl' will drop on Oct. 3. The couple discussed their whirlwind relationship in depth for the first time, and explained how they've dealt with constant media attention. 4 Olivia Dunne supporting boyfriend Paul Skenes at a Pirates game. Instagram/Olivia Dunne 'I don't see a lot of things, I'm of the firm belief … if you're getting your feedback from the internet, anything you feel, your brain will internalize [and] anything you feed the internet will kill,' Swift said, adding that she's dealt with the scrutiny being in the music industry. 'It took me a while to be a pro at it,' Kelce, 35, said. 'The last thing I wanted to do was screw this up.' The three-time Super Bowl winner added that Swift was 'so real' about helping him navigate the attention that her world brings. During a joint interview with GQ in April, Skenes — the No. 1 overall pick in the 2023 MLB draft — explained that Dunne has experienced notoriety much long than him. 4 Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift during her internet-breaking appearance on the 'New Heights' podcast on August 13, 2025. YouTube/New Heights Advertisement 'But she always handles everything very well — she's very comfortable to be around for other people who come up and ask to talk, that kind of thing,' he said, with GQ describing his as being a 'little itchy in the spotlight.' Dunne — who embraced the spotlight after she became a social media sensation during the COVID-19 pandemic, when she began posting gymnastics videos on TikTok — said she helps Skenes navigate the social media world. The couple met in Baton Rouge and went public with their relationship in August 2023.
Chicago Tribune
2 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
‘Sunday Best: The Untold Story of Ed Sullivan' review: How the TV variety show boosted Black talent when segregation was the norm
The documentary 'Sunday Best: The Untold Story of Ed Sullivan' on Netflix examines the pivotal role 'The Ed Sullivan Show' played in spotlighting Black music and culture to TV audiences at a time when segregation was still the norm. In a clip discussing his Sunday night variety show, which ran on CBS from 1948 to 1971, Sullivan keeps his intentions clear and to the point: 'It seemed to me, if you're using public air(waves), the least you can do — or TV can do — in return for this high privilege was to try to do something to bring people a little closer together.' Sullivan died in 1974 and sometimes in the film his voice is drawn from television interviews he gave over the years. But sometimes it's courtesy of artificial intelligence — a synthetic recreation — that gives literal voice to the columns and articles he wrote over the years. I have an ethical problem with this choice. Plenty of documentary projects before the advent of AI handled this by simply hiring a talented actor to voice the written words of their subjects. It's the more honest choice and it doesn't detract from the end result. I wish filmmakers embraced that instead. But otherwise 'Sunday Best,' from director Sacha Jenkins (who died this past May), is a fine effort that explores Sullivan's commitment to pushing back against network forces, sponsors and other interested parties who were opposed to the presence — the celebration, really — of Black people on the show. Sullivan's influence predates all but the boomer generation, and though I've seen clips, I don't think I've ever watched an episode all the way through. My ideas around him were vague and uninformed, mostly of the stiff host tolerating the younger acts. But that impression is inaccurate and undersells his own taste; instead of the reluctant old fogie, he was keeping his finger on the pulse of pop culture and handpicked every entertainer who appeared on his show. Watching his talents more closely here, I have a real appreciation for what he was doing — and how he did it — during a period of profound social change in the U.S. The documentary also offers an opportunity to think through the impact the show had at the time, compared to our current era, where the closest equivalent — the late-night talk show — has lost so much of its cultural relevancy when it comes to showcasing performers to a broad audience. Sullivan's path to TV fame was unintentional. He began as a print journalist in sports. Years later, he would note: 'Sports writers get to be very critical and observant. They can tell you what makes a certain ballplayer click.' Maybe he used some of those same skills when it came to identifying which acts he wanted on his show. Segregation never sat well with him. Using the verbiage of the era, he recalls that when he played baseball in high school, 'there were Negros in the league and some fellows said they would actually not play against a Negro. I always resented (those classmates) very deeply because the Irish had gone through that when we first came.' His parents knew bigotry was wrong. 'They weren't broad-minded, they were just sensible,' is how he puts it. Later, as a sports writer, he covered a college football game played in New York, where the northern school benched its one Black player to appease their opponents from Georgia. Sullivan was disgusted, so he wrote about it. What a shameful state of affairs this is, of a player 'risking his neck for a school that will turn around and bench him because the University of Georgia asks that the color line be drawn.' Sullivan did not mince words: 'If a New York City university allows the Mason-Dixon line to be erected in the center of its playing field, then that New York City university should disband its football season for all time.' He was eventually reassigned from sports to Broadway — the film doesn't explore why, or if that column was the reason — and though Sullivan was unfamiliar with the new beat, it eventually led to gala hosting opportunities, which paved the way for his career in television. He got terrible reviews at first; he wasn't a natural in front of the camera. Not that it mattered. 'I never thought I was the attraction. I just keep looking for the best thing to put on the show.' And that included Black talent. The prevailing idea at the time that 'Negro performers should be barred from TV shows on which white performers appear is both stupid and vicious,' he said. Fifty years after it went off the air, 'The Ed Sullivan Show' is maybe most famous for appearances by Elvis Presley and The Beatles. But the list of Black musical acts Sullivan featured is long and notable, with 'Sunday Best' including clips of Bo Diddley, James Brown, Bill 'Bojangles' Robinson, Cab Calloway, Pearl Bailey, Nina Simone, Mahalia Jackson, Stevie Wonder, The Supremes. Jackie Wilson singing 'Lonely Teardrops' is a standout and a fascinating example of a singer taking the stage alone, without any visible musicians behind him. No dancers, set, or props either. You don't really see that kind of thing today, and it's remarkable how he establishes a presence with nothing more than his voice and charisma. 'Sunday Best: The Untold Story of Ed Sullivan' — 3 stars (out of 4) Where to watch: Netflix
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
‘Pirates of the Caribbean' Producer Spoke to Johnny Depp About Jack Sparrow's Return in ‘Pirates 6': ‘If He Likes the Way the Part's Written, I Think He Would Do It'
Johnny Depp is possibly eyeing a return as Jack Sparrow in a sixth 'Pirates of the Caribbean' movie, at least according to franchise producer Jerry Bruckheimer. In a new interview with Entertainment Weekly, Bruckheimer confirmed he has spoken to Depp about a new 'Pirates' movie. The producer feels optimistic that Jack Sparrow could be back. 'If he likes the way the part's written, I think he would do it,' Bruckheimer told EW. 'It's all about what's on the page, as we all know… We are still working on a screenplay. We want to make it. We just got to get the right screenplay. We haven't quite gotten there yet, but we're close.' More from Variety Duffer Brothers and Jerry Bruckheimer Join Program for Entertainment and Technology Summit Johnny Depp Joins 'Hyde' Graphic Novel Series From Ridley Scott and Mechanical Cake, Will Create Title Character (EXCLUSIVE) Johnny Depp Thought 'F-- You' When He Got Dropped From 'Fantastic Beasts': 'There's Far Too Many of Me to Kill' and You Can't Hurt Me 'More Than I've Already Been Hurt' Depp headlined five 'Pirates' movies from 2003 to 2017, all of which grossed more than $650 million at the worldwide box office. 2006's 'Dead Man's Chest' and 2011's 'On Stranger Tides' both topped the $1 billion mark. His future with the Disney-backed series has been a question mark following his legal troubles and his 2022 libel trial against Amber Heard. With Depp now mounting a Hollywood comeback with the Lionsgate action-thriller 'Day Drinker,' it's only put more speculation over whether Disney would welcome him back him (and vice versa). With Depp front and center, the 'Pirates' movies have collectively grossed $4.5 billion. The road to a new 'Pirates' movie has been a long one. Variety reported in summer 2020 that Disney was in early development on two 'Pirates' movies: A reboot led by Margot Robbie and a sixth film in the original franchise written by Craig Mazin and Ted Elliott, the latter of whom co-wrote the first four 'Pirates' movies. Robbie ended up telling Vanity Fair in November 2022 that Disney was not interested in her 'more of a female-led' movie, although Bruckheimer downplayed the claim by later telling EW there's still room for both 'Pirates' movies to exist and 'I think Disney agrees they really want to make the Margot one, too.' As for the other 'Pirates' movie, Bruckheimer told EW last summer that screenwriter Jeff Nathanson had boarded the project. Nathanson wrote the script for the last 'Pirates' movie, 2017's 'Dead Men Tell No Tales.' 'He's cracked it,' Bruckheimer said at the time of Nathanson's script. 'He's got an amazing third act. We just gotta clean up the first and second and then we'll get there. But he wrote a great, great third act.' Whether or not Nathanson's script is a new draft of Mazin's or an entirely original screenplay remains to be seen. Mazin told the Los Angeles Times last year that his script for 'Pirates 6″ was so weird he was surprised Disney signed off on it, adding: 'We pitched it and thought there's no way they're buying it, it's too weird. And they did! And then we wrote a fantastic script and the strike happened and everyone's waiting around.' Bruckheimer also said last summer that he would be open to bringing Depp back for the Nathanson-penned movie, explaining: 'It's a reboot, but if it was up to me, [Johnny] would be in it. I love him. He's a good friend. He's an amazing artist and he's a unique look. He created Captain Jack. That was not on the page, that was him doing a little Pepé Le Pew and Keith Richards. That was his interpretation of Jack Sparrow.' Depp's last Hollywood studio movie was 2018's 'Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald.' He had just finished his first day of filming the sequel, 'Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore,' when Warner Bros. asked him to exit the movie a day after he lost his 2020 libel trial against The Sun. The actor sued the U.K. publication for referring to him as a 'wife beater,' but the court ruled this characterization of Depp was 'substantially true.' Depp was eventually recast in the sequel with Mads Mikkelsen. A second trial centered on Depp took place in the U.S. in 2022 after Depp sued ex-wife Amber Heard for defamation over an op-ed she wrote in The Washington Post in which she referred to herself as 'a figure representing domestic abuse.' The outcome of this trial was more in Depp's favor, as the jury ultimately ruled that Heard did defame Depp in the op-ed (although the jury also ruled that Depp defamed Heard in the course of fighting back against her charges).Best of Variety New Movies Out Now in Theaters: What to See This Week What's Coming to Disney+ in August 2025 What's Coming to Netflix in August 2025
