Mainstream health system failing Māori, Waitangi Tribunal told
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
The Waitangi Tribunal has been told the health system is failing Māori with one woman detailing how her son has been let down multiple times.
Te Aka Whai Ora, the Māori Health Authority, was set up in 2022 but the government scrapped it last year and the Tribunal is scrutinising the decision as well as asking what the plan is now for improving Māori health.
The second part of the Tribunal's inquiry into the disestablishment of Te Aka Whai Ora has been running since the start of the week.
Maia Honetana from Ngāti Tu ki Tai Tokerau told the Tribunal on Monday multiple government agencies failed to help her son Akira, who suffers from Fetal Alcohol Syndrome and ADHD.
Honetana said instead of helping him they blamed her and her family for his condition, resulting in a poor education and a one-way ticket to prison.
A dedicated Māori Health Authority when her son was young have made all the difference, she said, and she was furious the young agency was scrapped.
"I find it really appalling that this government could even think about striking us out and putting us at the bottom, just because they want to.
"Just because they somehow have this power to just do that, to scrap it whenever they feel like it."
The mainstream health system had not worked for her whānau, Honetana said.
"I know that I'm not alone, I'm one of many.
"My case should be unique, it shouldn't just be one of many Māori that have suffered the consequences of not having a Māori-based health system or Māori Authority to basically look after us and take care of our needs."
Deputy Director General of Health Māori John Whaanga provided evidence on behalf of the Crown and when asked by the Tribunal what exactly will replace Te Aka Whai Ora, defended the government's ongoing approach to improving Māori health.
"Your point is that there is nothing new since the disestablishment of Te Aka Whai Ora. I'm responding by saying that I don't quite understand that question.
"We continue to work on a stratergy for government on Māori health, which we would have been doing with Te Aka Whai Ora, the Māori Health Authority if they were still in place." Whaanga said.
Whaanga and Crown lawyers could not give the exact details on what the government has planned for improving Māori Health, but evidence submitted to the Tribunal shows the role Iwi Māori Partnership Boards (IMPB) have in developing and actioning Māori health policy.
Moe Milne from Ngāti Hine told the Tribunal the short-lived health authority made progress connecting small Maori providers with the government.
"It wasn't 'happy families' with Te Aka Whau Ora but they went out of their way to not only come once for a consultation, they came several times to check, ring - we did several Zooms.
"What we lost was the discussion about what should happen next, that's the biggest loss." Milne said.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 minutes ago
- RNZ News
GP funding changes will worsen Māori health inequities, expert says
The GP funding changes are proposed to take effect from 1 July 2026. Photo: RNZ A public health expert says the government's updated funding formula for general practices will fail to address the country's biggest health inequities because it excludes ethnicity. From July 2026, GP clinics will receive funding based on factors such as age, sex, rurality, socioeconomic deprivation and morbidity. The changes are intended to replace a 20-year-old model that largely used age and sex to determine funding levels. But public health senior research fellow at Otago University Dr Gabrielle McDonald said the government had ignored expert advice to also include ethnicity, despite strong evidence it was a powerful indicator of health need. "It's illogical," she told RNZ. "Leaving ethnicity out means [funding is] not going to be allocated to those highest areas of need, which will make accessing health care more difficult for Māori and Pacific communities." McDonald said data showed Māori lived seven years less than non-Māori and had higher rates of many serious illnesses, including cancer, even when poverty and other social factors were taken into account. "There's a lot of data that shows Māori don't get as good a deal from the health system as non-Māori. We've got a system that doesn't respond to Māori and Pacific people, it's geared towards the so-called majority Pākehā," she said. The funding formula is used to allocate money to general practices based on the characteristics of their enrolled patients. A 2022 government commissioned analysis by consultancy Sapere recommended it should include age, sex, ethnicity, deprivation, morbidity and rurality. "It was very thorough and they produced a high-quality report and put ethnicity in the funding formula because there was evidence to support that. "And so the government has said, yes, that's good, we will use that formula, but they've taken the ethnicity out, which is illogical," McDonald said. McDonald said removing ethnicity would make it harder to reduce inequities in primary care, which acted as the "gatekeeper" to the rest of the health system. "We know that general practices are the backbone of any good public health service. "Measures that don't aim to reduce inequities at that spot mean you're going to be playing catch-up throughout the health system if you can't reduce inequities in accessing primary care." She said including ethnicity was "highly justified." "We know our health dollar is really scarce and it needs to be spent where it's most needed. Leaving ethnicity out means it's not going to be allocated to those highest areas of need, which will make accessing health care more difficult for Māori and Pacific communities." McDonald has been a public health physician since 2011 and is a Pākehā researcher at Kōhātū - the Centre for Hauora Māori at the University of Otago. She has worked as a doctor for about 25 years, including extensive experience reviewing child and adolescent deaths. "I've spent a large amount of time reviewing child and adolescent deaths, and the inequity is very, very obvious there," she said. "Māori and Pacific children bear the brunt of many of the negatives of living in our society and they pay for it with their lives. We've got inequity in death rates for children and adolescents in almost all areas." Minister of Health Simeon Brown says Māori and Pacific peoples, in particular, will benefit from the updated GP funding model. Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER In a statement to RNZ Minister of Health Simeon Brown said too many Kiwis were waiting too long for a GP appointment. "The current funding model is outdated and doesn't fully reflect the needs of patients," he said. "That's why we're making changes to the way GP clinics are funded to ensure money goes where it's needed most, with the revised formula going beyond age and sex to also factor in rurality, multimorbidity and socioeconomic deprivation." GP clinics serving communities with higher health needs would receive more funding to care for their patients, he said. "The reweighted formula recognises the impact that age, rurality, complexity and deprivation have on health outcomes, and will ensure resources are targeted to those with the greatest need. "Māori and Pacific peoples, in particular, will benefit from this change." The changes are proposed to take effect from 1 July 2026. Public health physician and Otago University research fellow Dr Gabriel McDonald says data shows Māori often face extra hurdles getting the right care and the same treatment as non-Māori, even when poverty is factored in. Photo: Supplied / Gabrielle McDonald However, McDonald said she expected the government to implement a "state-of-the-art, fully fit-for-purpose formula," but that the final version "ignored the ethnicity funding factor". "We know from the data that outcomes are not the same for Māori and non-Māori, even when you take into account poverty and other factors. "Māori face additional barriers to accessing care, to accessing appropriate care, and to receiving the same level of treatment once they do access care. There's a lot of data showing Māori don't get as good a deal from the health system as non-Māori." "And then there are the determinants of health, things like poverty, level of education and other factors, which we know are not equally distributed, with Māori marginalised in almost every area." She also believed the decision reflected a wider trend in government policy. "There's a lot of pushback to talking about the needs of ethnic groups, even where there's really good reason to pay attention to ethnicity." She argued the government should adopt a complete, evidence-based mechanism for funding general practices, rather than the partial formula announced, to align with its stated goal of needs-based funding. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
27 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Green party co-leader won't apologise for remarks in House
politics about 1 hour ago Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick has no plans to apologise for her remarks in the House on Tuesday. Political reporter Giles Dexter spoke to Tuwhenuaroa Natanahira. Tags: To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
33 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Funding agency Te Māngai Pāho considering creating 'national hub' for Māori news
Te Māngai Pāho Chief executive Larry Parr. Photo: Supplied/Te Māngai Pāho Māori Media is in for a shakeup with funding agency Te Māngai Pāho resurrecting the idea of a "national hub" for Māori news. The Minister in charge the last time the idea was floated in 2020 said there could still be opportunities in a centralised news service, as long as it didn't compromise the ability of Māori to tell their own stories. Former Minister for Māori Development Nanaia Mahuta told RNZ the ' Māori Media Sector Shift ' which culminated in a report released in 2020, had a number of drivers including future proofing Māori media for the digital age. The proposal generated pushback from the industry at the time and Mahuta said while there was opportunity in bringing the idea back, it was not so simple. Funding agency Te Māngai Pāho. Photo: Supplied "I don't think it's as simple as saying 'it wasn't accepted then but it should be accepted now', there are competing pressures around who's funding Māori media and therefore the system has to adjust accordingly." This time the idea is being proposed by funding agency Te Māngai Pāho, which released its latest [file:///C:/Users/ppaewai/Downloads/RFP_2025-26_-_News__Current_Affairs_final1.pdf Request for Proposals] (RFP), outlining how Māori news and current affairs producers can apply for funding. Te Māngai Pāho Chief Executive Larry Parr (Ngāti Raukawa te Au ki te Tonga) said it was time to have a look at the Māori News and Current Affairs space to make sure they got the best outcomes for te reo Māori from the money being spent. In 2022, Te Māngai Pāho was allocated $5m of funding for three years to expand Māori regional news providers - that funding expires in June 2026. The RFP outlines that "the potential reduction of funding beyond 2026 requires us to transition to a much more collaborative model to ensure the sustainability of the news and current affairs eco-system." "It is going to be transformational... Our funding is under pressure and we need to be making moves to demonstrate that we are using the money well, and I think that out of this we will get some really good results," Parr said. Te Māngai Pāho has set aside $2 million to support the establishment of a national hub for Māori news content. Its core function would be to provide centralised storage of news items from regional news providers and manage access rights to approved platforms and publishers. "This time around we're still funding Māori news content, we're still funding Māori current affairs content, but we are also funding a national hub. "Where, hopefully, all of the news and current affairs content that we fund will end up, and then publishers can access that content and publish it on their platforms as they wish," Parr said. The regional capacity of Māori news had been developed and now it was time to take that to the next level, he said. Currently regional providers like Aukaha in Waikato and Rotorua, Pūkaea in the Bay of Plenty and Tahu News in the South Island share content with Te Ao Māori News and Te Karere. Former Minister for Māori Development Nanaia Mahuta. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Mahuta said regional providers like iwi radio stations had shown they could generate news within their regions that were not only popular, but were being conveyed on many different platforms. "It's about our stories being told in our way because it's relevant to what we see as important in our society. Often mainstream news does not capture that." There were opportunities that fell off having a centralised news service, she said. "Well I hope that a centralised hub news service for Māori news doesn't mean that people have to compromise the ability to tell their own stories. The whole idea of having a Māori news service is that it is setting the tempo and the pace of the stories that are important to Māori communities." Parr said he wasn't sure the idea of a centralised news hub had been "seriously contemplated" before, including when the Māori Media Sector Shift was proposed. "There was an excess of mana motuhake in the atmosphere, the hubs were focussed on trying to acquire the best kaimahi... that's the sort of competition that I allude to when I saw there is an excess of competition and we didn't incentivise collaboration as much as might have," he said. Parr said the current model encouraged competition leading to "too much energy wasted" on trying to be the best Māori news programme. Te Māngai Pāho has $3 million on the table for Māori current affairs content. That's split between $1.8 million for fluent te reo content and $1.2 million for "receptive content" which is 30 to 70 percent in te reo. Parr said a lot would depend on the quality proposals, but Te Māngai Pāho reserved the right to spend more or less than the funding indicated. If they were faced with a challenging choice between two good proposals, they could decide to fund them both, he said. "The biggest pressure is going to come on the fact that we are going to preference a fluent te reo Māori current affairs strand, and that will take funding from other areas I suspect." Applications for the RFP close on the 27th of August, with decisions announced in September. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
