ORC opposes mine expansion
After visiting OceanaGold's Macraes gold mine, north of Dunedin, 10 times, Otago Regional Council (ORC) senior consents planner Shay McDonald recommended the consent application for its proposed expansion be rejected.
The expansion — referred to as the Macraes Phase 4 (MP4) Project — would result in actual and potential effects on surface water quality, aquatic ecology, natural inland and ephemeral wetlands, lizard habitat, and a threatened invertebrate species of moth, Ms McDonald said.
These effects would be "significantly adverse" and could not be avoided, minimised, remedied, offset or compensated for.
"The proposal will also have significant adverse cumulative effects on cultural values, and it is not yet known if these can be managed by conditions."
Section 42A reports on the application were published this week by the ORC, Dunedin City Council (DCC) and Waitaki District Council (WDC).
While Ms McDonald recommended the application be "declined in full", the DCC said it could only be granted with conditions that could not yet be finalised.
The WDC recommended only two elements of the application could be granted.
OceanaGold legal and public affairs senior vice-president Alison Paul said the company was aware of the three councils' recommendations.
"OceanaGold remains committed to engaging constructively with all stakeholders both in the leadup to and during the hearing before the independent commissioners to provide further confidence in our plans, particularly when it comes to the management of water and biodiversity."
Macraes supported over 700 direct jobs as well as hundreds of contractors and was a leading contributor to the economy, Ms Paul said.
"We are committed to our staff, our communities, and the environment in which we operate."
The application involved a total of 34 new resource consents and variations to another 20.
In her 84-page recommending report, Ms McDonald said the staged implementation of the Macraes mine had to date impacted over 2000ha of land, an unknown portion of which previously supported indigenous vegetation and habitat for lizards, birds and invertebrates.
Much of MP4 was located within Threatened Land Environments of New Zealand, which were areas with less than 20% indigenous cover remaining.
"I consider that the cumulative terrestrial ecology effects do not appear to be well understood or accounted for in the current proposal," Ms McDonald said.
Activities in four main project areas of MP4, including extensions to the mine's Coronation and Golden Bar open pits, "must be avoided" due to the effects on rock tors (lizard habitat) and ephemeral wetlands, she said.
A technical expert who audited OceanaGold's application said the company's proposal to create new lizard habitats to compensate for the loss of 12 rock tors as a result of the expansion was considered "experimental and unsupported by any evidence".
Natural rock tors provided important habitats for lizards, particularly the at-risk korero gecko, and the effectiveness of creating rock tors remained unknown.
The loss of the rock tors was "likely to be irreversible" and could not be compensated for, Ms McDonald said.
A waste rock stack extension at Golden Bar would also affect the lizard habitats as well as the threatened species of Orocrambus sophistes moth.
"Only a single specimen" of the species had been found at the proposed site to date, as part of a single survey conducted in 2022, she said.
In order for an area of tussock grassland to be cleared, the company had to be able to minimise or remedy the effect on the moth and its habitat such that any residual adverse effects were no more than minor, Ms McDonald said.
For this to be achievable, more surveys needed to be undertaken "until there is sufficient data for a qualified person to say with the required degree of certainty that the moth is or isn't there".
The proposed extension to the mine's Innes Mills site would affect natural inland wetlands.
Attached to the report were seven recommended consent conditions, but Ms McDonald said she did not consider them as being able to "adequately manage" all of the effects of the proposal.
In his report, DCC consents planner Phil Petersen recommended the application be granted but only subject to appropriate conditions which could not be finalised for recommendation until further evidence was available.
In her report, WDC resource management consultant Marian Weaver recommended only two elements of the proposed application could be granted — the creation of a tailings dam in Frasers Pit, from material only to come from existing waste rock, and the buttressing of the Golden Point open pit using material from the Northern Gully waste rock stack.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Autocar
4 days ago
- NZ Autocar
Kia Tasman launches in New Zealand
Kia's Tasman has arrived in the country, and is ready to rip into the ute segment. We recently had a brief experience of it off road, where it proved capable, showing off its rough road credentials. It was all low speed stuff, rumbling around in low range and trying out the X Trek low speed crawl control. So still no verdict on how this truck drives on road in New Zealand just yet. That will come soon however. Video review – Kia Tasman first drive: Ready for the rough stuff? We spoke with Kia NZ MD, Todd McDonald, about how hard it is to launch a new ute into a market segment the brand has no prior history in. 'I don't think it's difficult to launch Tasman here, because the market is well established already. It's more a case of how do we launch a vehicle that is uniquely Kia and create a point of differentiation from both our other products, and those of our competitors.' He sees being the new challenger as a huge opportunity. Read more – Local pricing announced for Kia Tasman ute 'Tasman is great from a brand perspective, but also for our dealer network. It provides them with more opportunities and is a welcome addition.' McDonald admits there is a bit of a learning curve for some dealers that have never sold a ute before however. 'Our pre-launch activity has been about getting them involved and understanding what the market is and how to meet the consumer requirements.' In terms of those opportunities, McDonald says Tasman hits all parts of the market. 'Our range is targeted at volume. Everything from our base model TX all the way through to X line is specific and targeted. We have double cab chassis and simple cab chassis coming, which are also targeted at specific customers within New Zealand. 'Next year our target would be to hit the top five in New Zealand for commercials in our first full year of sales.' Kia is launching with a range of New Zealand designed and built accessories for Tasman. 'I think we're up to 149 options for our New Zealand customers. Most of these are made here, which is quite important to us for New Zealand business and for our competitiveness within the market.' According to McDonald he says the response from dealers and customers alike has been one of 'overwhelming enthusiasm' towards the new ute. Asked to describe the Tasman's styling, McDonald says it's 'fresh, modern, new generational.' As to the comments online that people either love or loathe it, he says; 'Give it a year. I think this kind of styling will become quite mainstream. We've seen a lot of other manufacturers moving towards the US-style body shape. I think that's where the direction of the ute is going. I think you might see traditional brands also moving towards that same style.'
Otago Daily Times
13-08-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Community issues in focus
Community advocacy was top of mind at the West Harbour Community Board meeting, held last Wednesday at Port Chalmers Town Hall. At its public forum, the board heard a presentation from local resident Ms Wilson, who complained about excess lights used at night by Port Otago and asked for board support. The board also heard from Port Chalmers residents Mike Webb and John Innes about a local bus shelter that had been removed earlier in the year. Local musician and co-organiser of the Lines of Flight musical festival Peter Porteous spoke in support of a funding application from the Metonymic Trust for $700 towards the hire of Port Chalmers Town Hall for the event in October. The festival had been running two-yearly for the past 25 years, featured many local musicians and attracted people from around the world, he said. Later in the meeting, board members voted unanimously to grant the requested $700. Bus routes Otago Regional Council regional planning and transport general manager Anita Dawe attended the board meeting to speak about the Regional Transport Plan, which was adopted in June. Directives from the government had resulted in the team investigating a zoning model and small rises in fares — from $2 to $2.50 for adults, and from free to $1.50 for children. In response to questions from board members, Ms Dawe said there would not be a return to very high fares, but there were few "levers" for the council to pull to cover bus service costs. Planning was also well under way in advance of cruise ship season. Scholarship The board considered an application for a scholarship from emerging young Māori leader Ngāki Kiore for $500 towards attending the Ngā Manu Kōrero national speech competition in September. The board voted to grant her the $500 requested. General The board voted to continue advertising in the Rothesay News , at a cost of $1500 for the year. The column features board members' contact details. In discussing the Community Plan, board member Barbara Anderson raised concerns over lack of progress from the board on the plan. She also spoke about communication with the community during emergencies. In the subsequent discussion, it was highlighted that official information had to come from the bunker in an emergency to be shared, and there were changes under way. Following board reports, Ms McErlane congratulated Ms Goldsmith and board member Duncan Eddy on their efforts in organising the recent West Harbour Community Awards. Information panels Cr Mandy Mayhem shared progress on the creation of six panels highlighting historic sites and events for display around the Port Chalmers area, and requested an additional $78 for the cost of the sixth panel — this was granted. WEST HARBOUR COMMUNITY BOARD NOMINEES • Duncan Eddy • Jarrod Hodson • Jenny Kendrick • Ange McErlane • Matthew Newton • Barbara Olah • Marion Poole • Wayne Sefton Postal votes need to submitted by Tuesday, October 7. After this date, votes must be returned to the council's secure ballot boxes before noon on Saturday, October 11.
Otago Daily Times
07-08-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Fast-track plan loses big backers
Two major backers of Queenstown's controversial Coronet Village fast-track proposal have pulled out, and a third is not involved at present. The proposal, which is still being firmed up before final approval is sought, involves 780 houses in the Malaghan Valley, a gondola up Coronet Peak, a "world-class" mountain bike hub and two schools. Local-based tech entrepreneur Rod Drury, the gondola's likely funder, has pulled out. So has iwi-led environmental organisation Te Tapu o Tane, which had planned a base there. Another partner, NZSki, which operates the Coronet Peak skifield, was not involved at present, chief executive Paul Anderson said. Coronet Peak Station owner Bernard Cleary is the last high-profile backer of the proposal still involved. "It's very much a Cleary-led project going forward, so it's not so much a consortium approach", village planner Ben Farrell said. "We're still going through the whole engagement of talking to people and refining the project." Mr Drury, who has helped fund mountain bike tracks on Coronet Peak and elsewhere, conceived the gondola idea as part of his plan to electrify Queenstown and take cars off Coronet Peak Rd. His chief executive, Jenna Adamson, said he had pulled back to focus on delivering a mass rapid transport cable car network for Queenstown. "This project is more closely aligned with the community's immediate needs and offers a more economically viable solution that would be integrated into Queenstown's multi-modal transport system. "We may revisit our involvement down the track," Ms Adamson said. Mr Drury said the bottom of Coronet Peak was "probably not quite the right spot" for intensive housing, and concerns over it were "valid". Asked if he was disappointed Mr Drury had pulled back, Mr Farrell said: "I'm not going to comment on that". "Obviously, I mean, he had a great vision, but that's why we're rethinking. "The opportunities there for commercial recreation and a globally attractive recreation commercial hub are outstanding. "And just because Rod's out doesn't mean that still can't happen. "Look, the Cleary family, they've got the capital, so I guess Rod was a nice-to-have." Mr Farrell — who last week announced he was standing for the Otago Regional Council in this year's election — confirmed Te Tapu o Tane, which came along with Mr Drury, was also no longer involved. Chief executive Janas Davis could not be contacted this week, but last year he said he could not support "intensive housing". James Hall, chairman of the Malaghans Valley Protection Society, which fears housing will destroy the area's rural character, is not surprised Mr Drury and Mr Davis have backed out and has thanked them for doing so. "It's not saying, 'don't put development in'. [It's fine] as long as it's planned and well thought through, but just a speculative, opportunistic thing like 780 houses in the headwaters of Lake Hayes is just outrageous."
