Are school holidays too long? A mother of two and school principal debate
Ireland's children enjoy almost two months off primary school and three months off secondary school during the summer.
But how can a parent continue to work when their primary-aged child/children, who need supervision, are out of school for two months of the year?
Even for my five-year-old, this is a simple mathematical equation to solve. The answer is to provide supports such as subsidised summer camps or structured summer programmes within school settings or even paid parental leave which must be taken during the summer holiday period.
READ MORE
The present solution offered to working parents in Ireland is lacking any real sense. We have a series of messy, just-muddle-through-and-get-on-with-it-style lifelines that are often expensive, unequal or unpredictable. Show me a working parent in Ireland during the summer break who has not had to call in every favour in the book and hope they have an understanding workplace to boot?
I can't help feeling the powers that be have forgotten basic mathematics as they seem unable to solve this unbalanced equation for working families.
Taking annual leave will only get you so far. That's assuming you haven't used most of your leave for midterm breaks, Easter holidays, parent teacher meetings, school plays or random days off throughout the year. You could also take unpaid parental leave, but with many families already stretched financially this is not a solution.
Summer camps are the other go-to, even if the best ones need to be booked by February, cost a small fortune and don't come within an ass's roar of covering a full working day.
If you're lucky, you might have secured a childminder to help or have grandparents or family to step in.
That's a lot of 'ifs' and it takes just one small 'if' to be knocked out of place and the whole deck of cards will fall, generally on top of an exhausted mum.
Asked recently about consideration of any change to the length of school holidays, Minister for Education
Helen McEntee
said
schools were 'very active' throughout the year and they offered people a chance to 'take a break'
. It's definitely a break for the children and teachers, just not so much for the working parents.
I'm not a total curmudgeon either. Children need a proper break to switch off and be children again. Teachers also put in a serious shift. School is full-on; between homework and after-school activities, most young children are scheduled to the hilt.
The summer break isn't really the problem. Shortening it even by a couple of weeks would still leave a huge gap for parents. The elephant in the room is that, unlike my 1980s/1990s childhood when almost everyone, including me, had a stay-at-home parent, today that's not the case. However, neither the length of the holidays nor level of parental support has been adjusted to reflect modern life.
Like most working parents, I dream of being able to take the whole summer off and enjoy it with my young children. At eight and five, they are in that blissful stage when their innocence and enthusiasm for life are at an all-time high. It's like a wonder-drug. If I could bottle it and sell it then I'd probably have enough money to be able to make that summer dream a reality.
For now, I'd settle for even a few modest supports that don't have me run ragged with guilt and exhaustion. What would also help is not to be told to stop complaining about how long the summer holidays are and just enjoy them while my children are still young. I'll be sure to remember that the next time I've got a work deadline, no summer camps lined up and no village or magic pot of money to call on.
Niamh O'Reilly is a journalist and mother of two living in Wicklow
Simon Lewis: No. Children aren't designed for non-stop schooling. They need breaks
Are school holidays too long? If you ask most parents then they'll reply with an emphatic 'yes' and if you ask most teachers then they'll disagree. As a teacher, I know this argument won't win me many fans, but it might give pause for thought about what we want schools to be.
Let's start with some facts. In Irish primary schools, the summer break runs for about seven-and-a-half weeks. This summer, more than half of Irish schools are running summer provision. These are intensive, small-group programmes for children with additional needs or from disadvantaged backgrounds, staffed by teachers and SNAs.
Alongside that, most teachers spend two to three weeks on continuing professional development (CPD) during summer, but unless you're living with a teacher then you're unlikely to hear much about that.
However, this debate isn't really about teachers. In my view, it's about children and maybe a bit about childcare. Children aren't designed for non-stop schooling. They need breaks. They need time to rest, play and sometimes get bored.
More school does not automatically mean better outcomes. Overloading their calendar may help parents in terms of childcare, but primary school isn't about childcare.
Irish primary pupils spend a minimum of 910 hours a year in school, well above the average of 805 hours in countries in the
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
(OECD).
In terms of holidays, our summer sits squarely in the middle, with Germany and the UK on six weeks and Italy on 12 weeks. Our seven-and-a-half weeks doesn't seem excessive. Virtually all countries still have a long summer break. It can't be without merit.
The bigger issue here isn't education. It's childcare. More specifically, it's the lack of structured, affordable wraparound care. In the absence of a proper government-funded national strategy, people understandably turn to schools to fill the gap.
For example, in the last year, I've been asked to talk about why schools should be responsible for everything from toxic masculinity to smartphone bans and everything in between.
Teaching is an intense profession. It's six hours of live performance, decision-making, emotional labour and crowd management.
I often compare it to being a doctor, but instead of seeing your patients one at a time you have 25 of them in the room, all with different needs, and you're expected to diagnose, treat and manage them simultaneously all day long.
If teaching really were the cushy number some imagine then why are we in the middle of a recruitment and retention crisis?
Schools are struggling to fill posts. Burnout is rampant. With so much time off and early finishes you'd think the issue would be too many applicants.
However, all that said, we could restructure the school year. We could have a shorter summer, with more frequent breaks during the year, and that's a fair discussion.
However, if we do shorten the summer then who runs Summer Provision? If we cut CPD time, when do teachers upskill? These aren't rhetorical questions, they're trade-offs.
If we want schools to become year-round childcare hubs then we need to say so and fund them properly. If we want them to remain focused on education, we must stop treating holidays as a perk and start seeing them as part of a sustainable system not unlike the long summer break granted to those in other professions such as third-level lecturers, which rarely draws public outrage.
None of this is about teachers asking for sympathy. It's about creating a sustainable, child-centred education system that serves the country well and about the Government providing a properly funded childcare system that meets the needs of working parents.
We can then let schools be schools and childcare be childcare.
Simon Lewis is principal of Carlow Educate Together primary school
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
35 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Two endangered red panda cubs born at Cork's Fota Wildlife Park
Two endangered red panda cubs were born in June at Cork's Fota Wildlife Park, it has been announced. Born at Fota's conservation centre, the cubs are the offspring of three-year-old mother Suzi, who arrived at Fota Wildlife Park from Berlin Zoo, and seven-year-old father Grga, who was transferred from Zagreb Zoo in Croatia in June 2019. The cubs are not yet visible to the public, remaining in a nesting box where they sleep and nurse with their mother, Fota Wildlife Park said in a statement on Wednesday. Visitors might be able to catch a glimpse of them in the next three weeks as they begin to explore their surroundings under the supervision of their mother during brief periods in the early morning or late evening. READ MORE The red panda, which has reddish-brown fur, a bushy ringed tail and a bear-like body, is classified as endangered by the World Wildlife Fund. They are often poached for their distinctive pelts in China and Myanmar . The cubs' parents are part of the European Endangered Species Programme (EEP), a collaborative initiative among European zoos and wildlife parks to ensure the survival of the threatened species through coordinated breeding efforts. The park is now home to six red pandas that live in a specially designed habitat in the Asian sanctuary, where they are fed freshly harvested bamboo grown on site. Julien Fonteneau, lead ranger at Fota Wildlife Park, said the care of an endangered species is 'one of the most meaningful aspects of the animal care work at Fota Wildlife Park'. 'We hope that the red panda births will raise awareness around species and biodiversity loss and will inspire and educate the visiting public and future generations,' Mr Fonteneau said. The park is calling on the public to help name the new cubs. Suggestions can be entered here .
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Asian hornet spotted in Cork poses a ‘significant threat to biodiversity', says wildlife service
A biosecurity alert has been declared after an Asian hornet was spotted in Cork. The National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS) said on Wednesday that the invasive species was seen by a member of the public and captured. The Asian hornet poses a 'significant threat' to Ireland's biodiversity, the NPWS said, adding that a single nest of Asian hornets can 'devastate' honeybee populations. However, they do not pose a significant public health risk. The sighting triggered a biosecurity alert, and the NPSW assembled a taskforce of Government departments and bodies to determine if this was an individual sighting or if there is evidence of a larger population. The Asian Hornet Management Group (AHMG) will monitor the situation over the coming weeks. READ MORE 'We must take even a single sighting very seriously,' said Minister for Biodiversity Christopher O'Sullivan. 'This incident shows us that members of the public are our eyes on the ground. Early detection is key if we are to prevent the establishment of this invasive species.' Mr O'Sullivan urged people to be 'vigilant' and to inform themselves so they can recognise and report any sightings of the Asian hornet. This is the second time that an individual Asian hornet has been identified in the State, the first of which occurred in Dublin in 2021 and was not associated with a wild viable population. The species was first identified in Europe in 2004 in Lot-et-Garonne in southwest France. It is believed that the species arrived in a consignment of pottery from China. The Asian hornet has now spread to many regions of France and to several countries in Europe. UK wildlife services are attempting to control the spread of the species there. The most recent Irish sighting was reported to the National Biodiversity Data Centre's website. Entomologists at the National Museum of Ireland and the NPWS confirmed it was an invasive species by analysing an attached photograph. The confirmation triggered a rapid response protocol, and the survey team was deployed to monitor and survey the area. The team did not initially find evidence of a nest or other hornet activity, but subsequent surveillance led to the trapping of a single Asian hornet on August 12th. The survey team has been engaging with locals and beekeeping associations to raise awareness about how to identify Asian hornet. Members of the public are being asked to report any suspected sightings through the National Biodiversity Data Centre's Alien Watch reporting portal. Any photographs, location co-ordinates, or samples (if safe to collect postmortem) are extremely valuable to the response team. The NPWS warns people not to disturb or capture an Asian hornet. While not generally aggressive, it may sting if provoked. The Asian hornet can be easily confused with native species such as the giant woodwasp, the dark giant horsefly and the common wasp.
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
King of Spain honours two men for work promoting historical links with Ireland
Two men have received awards from King Felipe VI of Spain for their promotion of historical ties between Spain and Ireland . Author and historian Michael Barry was awarded the Order of Civil Merit for his books on Spanish history. One of the cannons uncovered at Streedagh, Co Sligo, from the wreck of the Spanish Armada ship La Juliana, which sank in 1588. Photograph: Department of Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht/PA He recently authored 1588, the Spanish Armada and the 24 ships lost on Ireland's Shores. The book contains much new material about the tragedy that befell the Armada off the Irish coast. He also wrote a book about Muslim Spain called Homage to al-Andalus, as well as Hispania, the Romans in Spain and Portugal . Carlos Burgos, the president of the Hispano-Irish Association, has been one of the prime movers behind the attempts to find the remains of Red Hugh O'Donnell, who was buried in Mr Burgos's hometown of Valladolid in 1602. READ MORE He received the Order of Isabella the Catholic, which is named after Isabella of Castille , whose marriage to Ferdinand of Aragon marked the beginning of the modern Spanish state. Though the search for Red Hugh's remains were not successful, a mock funeral for him which has been held for the last two years attracted thousands of people to the streets of Valladolid. The next one is due to take place there on the weekend on September 26th and 27th. Thousands turned out on the streets of Valladolid to attend the mock funeral of Red Hugh O'Donnell, who was buried in the Spanish city in 1602 The awards were presented by the Spanish ambassador to Ireland, Ion de la Riva, at the ceremony in the ambassadorial residence on Tuesday. Mr de la Riva said Spain was the first country to sign a treaty with the Irish. In 1529, the Treaty of Dingle signed between King Charles V of Spain and the Earl of Desmond gave Irish people citizenship throughout the Habsburg Empire which ruled Spain and much of Europe at the time.
