Eight babies born using DNA of three people cutting genetic disease risk
Daniel Lawler
and
Julien Dury
, AFP
One out of every 5000 births is affected by mitochondrial diseases, which cannot be treated. (File pic)
Photo:
123rf
Eight healthy babies have been born in the UK using a new IVF technique that successfully reduced their risk of inheriting genetic diseases from their mothers, the results of a world-first trial.
The findings were hailed as a breakthrough which raises hopes that women with mutations in their mitochondrial DNA could one day have children without passing debilitating or deadly diseases on to the children.
One out of every 5000 births is affected by mitochondrial diseases, which cannot be treated, and include symptoms such as impaired vision, diabetes and muscle wasting.
In 2015, Britain became the first country to approve an in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) technique that uses a small amount of healthy mitochondrial DNA from the egg of a donor - along with the mother's egg and father's sperm.
Some have called the result of this process "three-parent babies", though researchers have pushed back at this term because only roughly 0.1 percent of the newborn's DNA comes from the donor.
The results of the much-awaited UK trial were published in several papers in the
New England Journal of Medicine
.
A lab worker checks the result of an IVF procedure. (File pic)
Photo:
123rf.com
Out of 22 women to undergo the treatment at the Newcastle Fertility Centre in northeast England, eight babies were born. The four boys and four girls now range from under six months to over two years old.
The amount of mutated mitochondrial DNA - which causes disease - was reduced by 95-100 percent in six of the babies, according to the research.
For the other two newborns, the amount fell by 77-88 percent, which is below the range that causes disease.
This indicates the technique was "effective in reducing transmission" of diseases between mother and child, one of the studies said.
The eight children are currently healthy, though one had a disturbance of their heart's rhythm which was successfully treated, the researchers said.
Their health will be followed up over the coming years to see if problems arise.
Nils-Goran Larsson, a Swedish reproductive expert not involved in the research, hailed the "breakthrough".
The new technique offered a "very important reproductive option" for families affected by "devastating" mitochondrial diseases, he added.
Mitochondrial donation remains controversial and has not been approved in many countries, including the United States and France.
Religious leaders have opposed the procedure because it involves the destruction of human embryos. Other opponents have expressed fears it could pave the way for genetically engineered "designer babies".
An ethical review carried out by the UK's independent Nuffield Council on Bioethics was "instrumental" in conducting the new research, the council's director Danielle Hamm said on Wednesday.
Peter Thompson, head of the UK's Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority which approved the procedure, said only people with a "very high risk" of passing on a mitochondrial disease would be eligible for the treatment.
Ethical concerns have also been raised over the use of mitochondrial donation for infertility in Greece and Ukraine.
French mitochondrial disease specialist Julie Stefann told AFP that "it is a question of the risk-benefit ratio: for a mitochondrial disease, the benefit is obvious".
"In the context of infertility, it has not been proven," she added.
Oxford University reproductive genetics expert Dagan Wells observed that "some scientists will be a little disappointed that so much time and effort has, so far, only led to the birth of eight children".
Among the children being closely monitored are three that showed some signs of what is known as "reversal", which is still little understood.
It is "a phenomenon where the therapy initially succeeds in producing an embryo with very few defective mitochondria, but by the time the child is born the proportion of abnormal mitochondria in its cells has significantly increased", he explained.
-AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
What are microplastics doing to our brains? UN talks will debate the issue next week
The most prominent study looking at microplastics in brains was published in the journal Nature Medicine in February. The scientists tested brain tissue from 28 people who died in 2016 and 24 who died last year in New Mexico, the United States, finding that the amount of microplastics in the samples increased over time. The study made headlines around the world when the lead researcher, US toxicologist Matthew Campen, told the media that they detected the equivalent of a plastic spoon's worth of microplastics in the brains. Campen also told Nature that he estimated the researchers could isolate around 10 grammes of plastic from a donated human brain - comparing that amount to an unused crayon. Speculation 'far beyond the evidence' But other researchers have since urged caution about the small study. 'While this is an interesting finding, it should be interpreted cautiously pending independent verification,' toxicologist Theodore Henry of Scotland's Heriot-Watt University told AFP. 'Currently, the speculation about the potential effects of plastic particles on health go far beyond the evidence,' he added. Oliver Jones, a chemistry professor at Australia's RMIT University, told AFP there was 'not enough data to make firm conclusions on the occurrence of microplastics in New Mexico, let alone globally'. He also found it 'rather unlikely' that brains could contain more microplastics than has been found in raw sewage - as the researchers had estimated. Jones pointed out the people in the study were perfectly healthy before they died, and that the researchers acknowledged there was not enough data to show that the microplastics caused harm. 'If (and it is a big if in my view) there are microplastics in our brains, there is as yet no evidence of harm,' Jones added. The study also contained duplicated images, the neuroscience news website the Transmitter has reported, though experts said this did not affect its main findings. 'Cannot wait for complete data' Most of the research into the effects microplastics have on health has been observational, which means it cannot establish cause and effect. One such study, published in the New England Journal of Medicine last year, found that microplastics building up in blood vessels was linked to an increased risk of heart attack, stroke, and death in patients with a disease that clogs arteries. There have also been experiments carried out on mice, including a study in Science Advances in January which detected microplastics in their brains. The Chinese researchers said that microplastics can cause rare blood clots in the brains of mice by obstructing cells - while emphasising that the small mammals are very different to humans. A review by the World Health Organisation in 2022 found that the 'evidence is insufficient to determine risks to human health' from microplastics. However, many health experts have cited the precautionary principle, saying the potential threat microplastics could pose requires action. A report on the health risks of microplastics by the Barcelona Institute for Global Health published this week ahead of the treaty talks said that 'policy decisions cannot wait for complete data'. 'By acting now to limit exposure, improve risk assessment methodologies, and prioritise vulnerable populations, we can address this pressing issue before it escalates into a broader public health crisis,' it added. The amount of plastic the world produces has doubled since 2000 - and is expected to triple from current rates by 2060. -Agence France-Presse
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Antarctic leopard seals perform unique songs for hours, study finds
Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech. Male leopard seals sing songs structured like nursery rhymes. Photo / Jamie Quirk When male leopard seals dive down into icy Antarctic waters, they sing songs structured like nursery rhymes in performances that can last up to 13 hours, scientists say. An Australian-led team of researchers compared the complexity of the songs composed by the aquatic mammals to those of other animals – as well as human musicians like the Beatles and Mozart. Lucinda Chambers, a bioacoustics PhD student at Australia's University of New South Wales, told AFP that people are often surprised when they hear the 'otherworldly' hoots and trills sung by leopard seals. 'It kind of sounds like sound effects from an 80s sci-fi movie,' said the lead author of a new study in the journal Scientific Reports. During the spring breeding season, male leopard seals dive underwater and perform their songs for two minutes before returning to the surface for air. They then repeat this performance for up to 13 hours a day, according to the study.
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Why Russia's megathrust earthquake was among biggest ever recorded, but damage was minimal
By Elissa Steedman , ABC Aerial view of Balneario de Huanchaco in Trujillo, Peru. Photo: AFP / Steffano Palomino Explainer - One of the largest earthquakes in recorded history set off tsunami warnings across the Pacific Ocean on Wednesday. But it has not proved as destructive as experts feared. Here are the factors that contributed to that outcome. It was among the 10 strongest ever recorded. The magnitude-8.8 earthquake was the largest since 2011, when a magnitude-9.1 tremor and subsequent tsunami struck off the coast of Japan and killed more than 15,000 people. Wednesday's earthquake, known as the Kamchatka earthquake, is considered a megathrust earthquake - common to each of the planet's largest recorded quakes. Earth's outer layers are split into 15 slabs known as tectonic plates. These plates slowly shift around - moving a few centimetres every year - and often get stuck against each other due to friction. When that happens, stress builds up over time until the plates suddenly shift and cause seismic waves that shake the ground. Megathrust earthquakes occur when one tectonic plate has been forced underneath another - a phenomenon known as subduction. In this case, it was the Pacific plate beneath the North American plate. Stephen Hicks, an environmental seismology expert at University College London, said megathrust earthquakes "cause some of the world's largest ruptures and trans-ocean tsunamis". Tsunamis occur when earthquakes displace large amounts of ocean water. Megathrust quakes often cause tsunamis because the faults they cause tend to come to, or even directly penetrate, the sea floor, Dr Hicks said. How much of the sea floor moves influences whether a tsunami is formed, and how big it might become, added Lisa McNeill, a tectonics professor at the University of Southampton. "Some fault movements don't move the sea floor much, and so, there is no tsunami," she said. In the case of the Kamchatka earthquake, a large slip occurred and generated a tsunami, Dr McNeill added. Despite the earthquake triggering tsunami warnings across the Pacific Ocean, no deaths were recorded, and minimal structural damage was reported. Maximum wave heights of five metres were observed in Kamchatka yesterday - a tenth of the heights recorded after the Tohoku Earthquake in 2011, which triggered the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster. Waves in Hawaii reached a maximum height of about 1.7 metres. Meghan Miller, a professor of seismology at Australian National University, said where earthquakes strike has a major impact on the severity of subsequent tsunamis. "For the tsunami and earthquake that happened in Japan in 2011, the distances [to land] were much closer," she told ABC Radio National Breakfast. "So the distance for the waves to travel to the coast of Japan was much shorter." Dr McNeill said the height of tsunami waves can also be affected by the shape of the sea floor near the coast. "[The waves] are small at sea but travel fast, and it is when they reach shallow water that they build in height again," she said. " tsunami can have varied heights on one coastline, and it could generate surprisingly large wave heights." She added that wave heights recorded after the Kamchatka earthquake were still "significant", but the potential for destruction was minimised. The tremor triggered tsunami warnings across the Pacific Ocean, as far away as Hawaii, Chile, and Ecuador. "This has been established in the Pacific since the 1960s, and people therefore receive warnings about the tsunami and can evacuate," she said. "It is harder for those living close to the earthquake as they have less time, but the earthquake is their warning of a tsunami and [the] prompt to move to higher ground." Many nations with sea borders have government-run programs to detect and monitor threats caused by earthquakes and tsunamis that may impact the region, and are charged with alerting communities of incoming threats and issuing evacuation orders. There were no warning systems in place in the Indian Ocean when the 2004 Boxing Day tsunami occurred. The enormity of the natural disaster's death toll, estimated to be about 225,000, is attributed to the lack of evacuation alerts. -ABC
