'Parents are battling a broken system that's failing special needs children'
Parents whose confidence has been eroded by the special educational needs system are "very, very fearful" support could be scaled back, a top MP has warned.
Labour 's Helen Hayes, who chairs the Commons Education Committee, said ministers' failure to confirm they won't cut education, health and care plans (EHCPs) was causing alarm for families. She said the "broken" system needed reform but warned the Government it risked repeating the same mistakes that forced Keir Starmer into a humiliating climbdown over disability benefit cuts.
The Government plans to publish a white paper in the autumn detailing reforms to the special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) system. But it is shaping up to be a fresh battle between the Prime Minister and backbenchers. Ministers however have tried to reassure parents they have "absolutely" nothing to fear over support being reduced.
But in a warning this morning, Ms Hayes told BBC Radio Four: "I hope the government will learn the lessons from the welfare bill and the events that we saw last week in Parliament and understand that the best way to get effective reform of the system, that also delivers for the public finances, is to work directly and closely with the people who are most affected by the system you're wanting to reform, and that is what we haven't seen so far with the question of SEND reform."
An EHCP is for children and young people aged up to 25 who need more support than is available through special educational needs support. It is a legally binding document which sets out the support a child is entitled to.
Ms Hayes said many families have had to battle the system to get an EHCP, which has impacted their trust in the authorities. And she said, despite it not being a perfect process, EHCPs still provide important legal protection for parents in holding authorities, schools and other services to account over the support their child should receive.
"I think it is understandable that many parents would feel very, very fearful when the government won't confirm absolutely the EHCPs and all of the accountabilities that surround them will remain in place," she said.
Admitting the EHCP system was failing families, Ms Hayes went on: "We have a system that is broken. It is failing families, and the government will be wanting to look at how that system can be made to work better.
"But I think they have to take this issue of the lack of trust and confidence and that the fear that parents have and the impact that it has on the daily lives of families. This is an everyday, lived reality if you are battling a system that is failing your child.
"EHCPs provide statutory certainty for some parents. It isn't a perfect system. I've heard from many parents who get an EHCP for their child and then find that it isn't being implemented properly and it's hard to sort that out, or they then find that the resources that should be there aren't really there. And it is also a system that many families who don't necessarily have resources to fight through the EHCP system fall by the wayside at the moment."
She added: "So it's not a system that's working perfectly at all, but it does provide important statutory protection and accountability. If you have a community who simply don't trust the system, any suggestion of the erosion of those rights and accountabilities is just the wrong place to start."
Early years education minister Stephen Morgan this morning refused to confirm whether scrapping EHCPs were on or off the table in talks about SEND reforms. Asked if EHCPs will remain, he told LBC: 'We're working through everything at the moment. I'm not going to get into the detail around what the measures will be in terms of improving outcomes for children. I want to listen to experts. I want to listen to parents. I want to listen to teachers to get it right for the future.'
But he assured parents should have "absolutely" no fear that support for children with special needs will be scaled back. Pressed by LBC if campaigners and charities should have no fear about the future of SEND support for children, Mr Morgan said: "Absolutely. What we want to do is make sure we've got a better system in place as a result of the reform that we're doing that improves outcomes for children with additional needs."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
an hour ago
- Powys County Times
Phillipson: Family hubs will give parents freedom to focus on loving children
Family hubs offering support and youth services will give parents 'the freedom to focus on loving their children', Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson said. The Government announced there will be a Best Start family hub in every local authority in England by April 2026, with £500 million targeted at disadvantaged communities. This comes alongside plans to offer £4,500 to specialist teachers, in a bid to attract staff to nurseries. Officials have also said that Ofsted will inspect all new early years providers within 18 months of them opening from next April, under the Best Start In Life strategy announced on Monday. The Education Secretary has said she wants to 'make sure every child has the chance to succeed', as ministers look to drive up quality and access in early education. In a statement to the Commons on Monday, Ms Phillipson said: 'We'll introduce a new Best Start Family Service delivered through Best Start family hubs, the first step to a national families service that ensures they can get the right support for their children from conception to age five, giving parents the freedom to focus on loving their children.' She added: 'Best Start family hubs will be open to all, rooted in disadvantaged communities. 'They will work with nurseries, childminders, schools, health services, libraries and local voluntary groups – a whole community coming together around one goal: to give children the best possible start in life. 'And Our Best Start digital service means we're ready for the future, linking families to their local Best Start Family Hub, and exploring how the power of AI (artificial intelligence) can help parents find the right information.' According to the Department for Education, some one in 10 nurseries have an early years teacher. The new incentive scheme of a government-funded and tax-free £4,500 payment will look to keep 3,000 more teachers in nurseries. These will be targeted in the 20 most disadvantaged communities, the department said. There will also be a shift towards Ofsted inspections every four years for early years providers, rather than the current six-year cycle. Officials have also said there will be more money to fund partnerships between nurseries and schools to make transition periods easier. The announcements have been welcomed by the sector, but one figure has said the 'devil will be in the detail'. Neil Leitch, chief executive of the Early Years Alliance, said: 'We're clear that this strategy will only work if it is backed up with the tangible support – financial or otherwise – that early years providers and other bodies and professionals need to build an early years system that works for all families. 'But after years of calling for a long-term vision for the early years, there's no doubt that this is a positive development, and we look forward to working with Government to turn vision into reality.' Sarah Ronan, director of the Early Education and Childcare Coalition, has described Monday's strategy as 'a turning point in how we value early education'. 'Change won't happen overnight but it starts today with a shared mission to give every child the best start in life,' she said. Shadow education secretary Laura Trott said 'the rhetoric does not match the reality' because early-years providers were suffering from the impact of increased national insurance contributions (Nics). She told Ms Phillipson: 'Nurseries across the country are on the brink because of decisions her Government have made. 'While it is welcome that the Government has continued the roll out of our early years offer, the lack of compensation for the Nics increase is forcing providers to either hike fees or shut their doors.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Bosses will be banned from using NDAs to silence victims of abuse at work
Victims of workplace abuse will no longer be forced to suffer in silence under changes to the Government's workers' rights bill to outlaw non-disclosure agreements Workers subjected to harassment and discrimination will no longer be silenced by controversial non-disclosure agreements (NDAs). The Government will amend the Employment Rights Bill to ban employers from using NDAs to cover up appalling behaviour. NDAs were originally designed to protect commercially sensitive information or intellectual property. But these gagging orders have been widely used to prevent people speaking out about their experiences in the workplace. Zelda Perkins, a former PA to disgraced movie producer Harvey Weinstein who broke her NDA to expose his conduct, said it was a victory for victims. Ms Perkins, who founded the campaign Can't Buy My Silence, said: "This is a huge milestone, for years, we've heard empty promises from governments whilst victims have continued to be silenced, to see this Government accept the need for nationwide legal change shows that they have listened and understood the abuse of power taking place. 'Above all though, this victory belongs to the people who broke their NDAs, who risked everything to speak the truth when they were told they couldn't. Without their courage, none of this would be happening." A clause will be added to the bill, which returns to the House of Lords next week, that will mean confidentiality clauses in settlement agreements or other agreements that seek to prevent a worker speaking about an allegation of harassment or discrimination will be null and void. It will allow victims to speak freely about their experiences and for witnesses to support them without fear of being sued. Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner said: 'We have heard the calls from victims of harassment and discrimination to end the misuse of NDAs. 'It is time we stamped this practice out – and this government is taking action to make that happen. 'The Employment Rights Bill will ban any NDA used for this purpose, so that no one is forced to suffer in silence.' Former Cabinet Minister Louise Haigh, who has been campaigning to change the law on NDAs, said: "Victims of harassment and discrimination have been forced to suffer in silence for too long. "This legislation is the result of years of tireless campaigning by victims and advocates. This victory belongs to them." She added: "Today's announcement will mean that bad employers can no longer hide behind legal practices that cover up their wrongdoing and prevent victims from getting justice."
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Ministers must ditch cruel plan to raid disabled kids' support to plug self-inflicted £20billion black hole
Children first MINISTERS insist that a review of school care plans for special needs children isn't about saving money. The parents of disabled children fear that, in reality, it is much more of a cost-cutting exercise than a proper rebuilding of the system. 2 They have every reason to be worried, not least because of the battles many have been forced to fight with local councils over the years to get proper support. What is plain for all to see is that the Government, after the welfare debacle of last week, risks falling into an almighty new row. We know ministers are desperate to save cash — they are staring into a self-inflicted black hole of at least £20billion after the U-turns on benefits reform and winter fuel, along with other woes. But, instead of looking at areas of shameful waste or incompetence, it is apparently vulnerable children they have in their sights. Has it not occurred to Number Ten just how awful it would look to tip further billions into housing asylum seekers in hotels, or to fail to get a grip on still rampant waste by diversity-obsessed town halls, while penny-pinching from disabled kids? Voters are enraged enough already by the many existing examples of unfairness which are being inflicted upon them. Wealth stealth CAN Labour's long-held instincts of class envy really lead them to bring in a damaging and pointless wealth tax? To the Left, soaking the rich always sounds good. But in practice, it merely drives away the income creators who are crucial to our economy — and ends up costing the Government money. In France, it was abandoned after 60,000 fled, costing the country around £4billion in lost revenue. Britain has already lost more millionaires in the last year — over 16,000 — than any country in the world as a result of our sky-high taxes. Not only do these people drive growth, the top one per cent of earners also pay 29 per cent of UK income tax. Like all socialist ideas, a punitive tax on the rich simply won't work. The Prime Minister should bin it. On our own FRANCE'S much lauded ' one-in, one-out' illegal migrant exchange plan with Britain is being held up because it may breach EU laws. While Britain is free to do a deal, the European Commission says Paris must abide by its shared border agreements. It shows that — plus ça change — Britain can't simply rely on help from France.
