Tharoor slams Kerala govt for aid to turkey in 2023; aid was part of union govt's ‘Operation Dost', Brittas reminds him
Amidst multi-party delegation's visit across the globe as part of government's outreach in wake of the India-Pakistan conflict, two Parliamentarians from Kerala Congress's Shashi Tharoor and CPI(M)'s John Brittas sparred over Kerala government financial assistance to Turkey after it was struck by an earthquake in 2023.
Mr. Tharoor in a post on 'X' on Saturday (May 24, 2025), criticised the Kerala government's ₹10 crore aid to Turkey two years ago, as 'misplaced generosity'. To which Mr. Brittas said Mr. Thaoor's comments show 'selective amnesia', since it does not mention Narendra Modi government itself had launched Operation Dost to help Turkey.
Mr. Tharoor is leading a delegation visiting the U.S., Panama, Guyana, Brazil and Colombia. Mr. Brittas is a member of a delegation headed by JD(U) MP Sanjay Jha which is touring Japan, South Korea, Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia.
'I hope the Govt of Kerala reflects on its misplaced generosity, after seeing Turkey's behaviour two years later! Not to mention that the people of Wayanad (just to take one Kerala example) could have used those ten crores better…' Mr. Tharoor posted on 'X'. His remarks come in the context of reports that Pakistan used Turkish made drones during the conflict with India. Wayanad in July 2024 was hit by a devastating landslide which killed more than 300 people and destroyed large parts of three villages.
Responding to Mr. Tharoor's post Mr. Brittas said, 'Have great regards for Shashi Tharoor. But these comments are symptoms of selective amnesia. It is amusing and puzzling why he had to belittle Kerala when he knows very well the Narendra Modi government itself had launched Operation Dost to help Turkey. Kerala basing is unwarranted.'
At a External Affairs Standing Committee headed by Mr. Tharoor held last week, several members raised concerns over Indo-Turkey relations. With many emphasising that India should take care to repair the current breach.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Delhi court acquits former coal secy HC Gupta, 2 senior officials over Jharkhand block allocation ‘scam'
A Delhi court Friday acquitted former coal ministry officials H C Gupta (secretary), K S Kropha (joint secretary) and K C Samaria (coal allocation director) in a case linked to alleged irregularities in the allocation of the Mahuagarhi coal block in Jharkhand to the company M/s Jas Infrastructure Capital Pvt Ltd (JICPL). While the three men – represented by advocates Rahul Tyagi and Mathew M Phillip – were acquitted, Special Judge Sanjay Bansal of Rouse Avenue Court convicted the firm JICPL and its director Manoj Kumar Jayaswal. Arguments on their sentence will be heard on July 8. The allegations in the case were that JICPL had misrepresented various facts in its application and had fraudulently obtained the allocation of the coal block. Allegations against the public servants were that they had acted in a manner which was 'detrimental' to public interest and that they had allowed JICPL to 'misappropriate' nationalised natural resources. In December 2016, a trial court in Delhi had framed charges in this case for alleged offences under sections 420 (cheating), 468 (forgery for the purpose of cheating), 120 B (criminal conspiracy) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and under relevant provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Initially, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) had filed a closure report in this case in April 2014, stating that no case was made out against the accused. A detailed closure report was filed on October 14, 2014. The court had on November 20 that year disagreed with the CBI's conclusion and held that a case was made out for taking cognisance of the alleged offences against the accused. A Delhi court had in 2018 sentenced Gupta, Kropha and Samaria to three years' imprisonment in a case pertaining to alleged irregularities in the allocation of Moira and Madhujore (North and South) coal blocks in West Bengal to Vikash Metal and Powers Ltd. In 2017, the three were convicted in a case related to irregularities in the allocation of Thesgora-B Rudrapuri coal block in Madhya Pradesh to Kamal Sponge Steel and Power Ltd (KSSPL). Towards the end of its tenure, the UPA 2 government started being perceived as corrupt due to allegations connected with the 'coal scam'. A Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) report had at the time pegged the loss to the exchequer at Rs 1.8 lakh crore. While 27 of the 54 cases being investigated by the CBI have been disposed of, the other half are still pending a decade later. With this case, the CBI has achieved 19 convictions. Three of its cases have ended in acquittals and two in discharge. In the aftermath of the alleged coal scam, on August 25, 2014, the Supreme Court cancelled the allocation of 204 coal blocks, deeming them illegal and arbitrary. Additionally, it also levied a penalty of Rs 295 per tonne of coal that had already been mined over the years. In his book titled Supreme Court and the Indian Economy, Pradeep S Mehta states that the apex court's decision increased the current account deficit by US$ 700 million due to additional coal imports. 'Around Rs 4.4 lakh crore was the estimated loss in royalty, cess, direct and indirect taxes, etc,' wrote Mehta, citing an SBI research report. Former Solicitor General of India Harish Salve had stated that the decision cost the economy 1 per cent of the GDP.
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Indian MPs' World tour builds narrative on Pak-based terror
Indian MPs cutting across party lines have been able to create a strong narrative against Pakistan-based terror infrastructure around the world, from Japan to Colombia and the US to Africa, Russia, Southeast Asia and West Asia over the last two weeks. While most delegations are back in India after their multi-nation tours, the delegation from the US is expected to return on Friday. Speaking at the National Press Club in Washington DC on Wednesday, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor, who is leading an all-party delegation to the US to brief key stakeholders on Operation Sindoor, dismissed the Trump administration's claim that its trade diplomacy played a major role in averting a full-fledged military conflict between India and Pakistan. During the visits, key stakeholders and ministers from across countries extended strong support to India's fight against cross-border terror as each delegation made presentations on the Pahalgam terror attack, Pak-based terror infrastructure and Operation the delegation led by Tharoor convinced the Colombian government to withdraw a statement criticising India, another delegation led by JDU MP Sanjay Jha was successful in sensitising Japan on the menace of cross-border terror. Immune from any cross-border illegal migration and extremism, the Japanese society remains passive to the threat of cross-border terror, experts on Japanese affairs pointed Brazil, the Tharoor-led delegation delivered a message on cross-border terror infrastructure which could assist in shaping the BRICS bloc's position on terrorism at the upcoming summit in Rio De Janeiro on July 6-7. The visits to Egypt and Indonesia were significant as both are attempting to blunt the Pakistani narrative in the Organisation of Islamic Conference meetings. While Indonesia (having the world's biggest Muslim population) has a principled position against any secessionism and terrorism, Egypt has a strong stance against terrorism and extremism. Similarly, visits by MPs to Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and the UAE were critical to reaffirm India's security partnerships. In Algeria, the Jay Panda-led delegation was successful in driving home the point of common threat from Pakistan-based Sierra Leone and Liberia often do not receive senior-level political figures from India and therefore the trips by MPs to these countries, which are getting into the UN Security Council as non-permanent members, were important. Both Liberia and Sierra Leone extended special gestures to back India's approach on cross-border the visits to Russia and France by MPs reaffirmed India's strong security and defence partnerships with the old strategic partners, the trips to Italy, Slovenia, Latvia, Spain and the UK were significant to drive home the point how India has been a victim of relentless state-sponsored cross-border terror. MEETING IN THE US In the US, the Tharoor-led delegation met the leadership of the Congressional Caucus on India and Indian Americans in the 119th Congress, co-chairs Rep Ro Khanna and Rep Rich McCormick and vice co-chairs Rep Andy Barr and Rep Marc Veasey. The parliamentary delegation briefed the caucus members on the cross-border terrorism faced by India. The Congressmen expressed unequivocal and bipartisan condemnation for the terror attack in Pahalgam.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
China key factor in India's confrontation with Pakistan: Shashi Tharoor
China is an absolutely impossible factor to ignore in India's latest confrontation with Pakistan, Congress leader Shashi Tharoor has said, emphasising that a thaw in relations between Delhi and Beijing over the past few months was seemingly making good progress before the conflict. Tharoor, who is leading a multi-party parliamentary to the US, said, I'm not going to mince my words, but we are aware that China has immense stakes in Pakistan." His remarks came during an interaction with representatives of think tanks organised at the Indian Embassy here on Thursday. The largest single project under the Belt and Road Initiative is the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, Tharoor said, adding that 81 per cent of Pakistani defence equipment is from China. Defence may be the wrong word here. Offense in many ways, he said. "China is an absolutely impossible factor to ignore in what has been our confrontation with Pakistan, Tharoor said. He noted that despite the tensions between China and India since the Galwan Valley clashes in June 2020, "we had actually begun a thaw with China in September of last year, which was seemingly making good progress before this tragedy occurred. Tharoor added that then we saw a very different China in terms of its practical support for Pakistan, even on the Security Council. We have no illusions about what the challenges are in our neighbourhood, but I want to remind you all that India has consistently chosen a path of keeping open channels of communication, even with our adversaries," he said. "We have tried as much as possible to focus on development, on growth, on trade. Our trade with China is still at record levels. It's not that we are adopting a posture of hostility, but we would be naive not to be aware of these other currents around, he said. Pakistan is currently a non-permanent member of the UN Security Council. Following the April 22 Pahalgam attack, the UN Security Council had on April 25 issued a press statement on the terrorist attack in Jammu and Kashmir' in which the members had condemned it in "the strongest terms. The members of the Security Council underlined the need to hold perpetrators, organisers, financiers and sponsors of this reprehensible act of terrorism accountable and bring them to justice, the press statement had said. However, the press statement did not mention The Resistance Front as the group responsible for the attack after Pakistan managed to get the name removed with the support of China. In October last year, India and China firmed up a disengagement pact for Depsang and Demchok, the last two friction points in eastern Ladakh. Days after the agreement was finalised, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping held talks in Kazan, Russia, and took a number of decisions to improve ties. External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar met Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi in November last year in Rio de Janeiro on the sidelines of the G20 Summit and the two met again in February this year in Johannesburg. During a conversation at the Council on Foreign Relations earlier in the day, Tharoor was asked about the Chinese military equipment that Pakistan used in the conflict against India and if there is a reassessment over this. Frankly, the reassessment took place while the fighting was going on, Tharoor said. He added that when India saw what the Pakistanis were attempting to do using Chinese technology, for instance, the kill chain' that the Chinese specialise in, where the radar, GPS, planes and missiles are all linked together and they react instantly, we simply did things in a different way. Otherwise, we wouldn't have been able to hit 11 Pakistani airfields and we wouldn't have been able to breach the Chinese-supplied air defences. So it's clear that assessments were taking place while the fighting was happening, and we were recalibrating our strategies in order to end as effectively as we were able to end, Tharoor said. The fact is China has immense stakes in Pakistan, the largest single project on the Belt and Road Initiative is the one in Pakistan - the China- Pakistan Economic Corridor. So we have no illusions about the degree of commitment that China may well be feeling towards Pakistan.
