Woman jailed for pushing man (82) into oncoming traffic as she tried to rob him
Edel Stirling (45), of Camden Street Lower, Dublin 2, came forward to Dublin Circuit Criminal Court on signed pleas of guilty from the District Court. She pleaded guilty to theft, robbery and criminal damage by urinating in a cell at Mountjoy Garda Station on December 13, 2024.
Advertisement
The court heard that the 82-year-old man was locking up a premises where he had been working in Dublin city centre when he heard someone rummaging through a plastic bag of tools he had left at the front of the property.
He came out to investigate and spotted Stirling running off with the bag. She was accompanied by what the victim described as 'an intoxicated man'.
The victim followed and managed to get the tools back off Stirling but she swung out at him and tried to pull the bag back claiming that it belonged to her.
A witness to the robbery described Stirling as punching the victim in the face and knocking him to the ground before she continued to punch him in the face. He said the robber also pulled the victim out in front of a taxi, causing the driver to slam on his brakes to avoid impact.
Advertisement
Stirling spat at the passerby who had come to the man's assistance and another person took a photograph of her. The victim was left with injuries to his nose, face and head.
The gardaí were alerted. They were given a description of Stirling and they were informed what direction she had run in. She was arrested a short time later and taken in for questioning but was deemed too intoxicated for interview by a doctor called to the station.
Diarmuid Collins BL, prosecuting, said Stirling urinated in the station during the course of her time there.
Counsel said she made no admissions during garda interview, when she was later deemed fit, but expressed concern for the welfare of the victim when she was shown photographs of his injuries.
Advertisement
Mr Collins said the man had not completed a victim impact statement. Stirling has 40 previous convictions including assault, assault causing harm and 25 bench warrants.
Niall Nolan BL, defending, acknowledged that this was a 'horrific' incident for this 'poor gentleman' and accepted he had suffered injuries as a result of the attack.
He said his client was a mother of two, who has a history of intoxication, addiction and homelessness but said she has detoxed since her remand in prison and is now stable.
Mr Nolan said his client has engaged with various programmes in prison and the staff on those programmes describe her as 'open and respectful'.
Advertisement
Counsel submitted that his client had been drinking heavily that day and struggled to recall the incident. He said she was remorseful for the injuries she caused the victim.
Judge Dara Hayes noted that the victim had initially got his bag back from Stirling but she continued to be abusive and insisted the bag was hers before she continued the assault.
He accepted that she had expressed 'considerable concern and remorse' and was intoxicated that day.
The judge further accepted that she engaged well with various programmes in prison.
Ireland
Former hurler Niall Gilligan found not guilty of a...
Read More
'These are serious offences. Significant violence was used against a man,' Judge Hayes said before he took into account the age of the victim and the injuries he sustained from the attack.
He acknowledged Stirling's co-operation, expression of remorse and her efforts to rehabilitate.
Judge Hayes set a headline sentence of three years and half years for the robbery offence, with the other offences taken into account.
He reduced this sentence to two years and four months before he suspended the final 15 months on strict conditions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Revealed: 200 asylum hotel residents charged with crimes this year
At least 200 people living in asylum seeker hotels have been charged with criminal offences this year, without police revealing their immigration status, The Telegraph can disclose. Court records show that 211 people living in the hotels, which are used by the Home Office to house asylum seekers, have been charged with a combined 425 offences. Of these, 109 were violent offences and 44 were sexual offences, including four counts of alleged rape. There were also 63 theft-related offences. The Telegraph analysed court records linked to 50 known asylum hotels. There are more than 200 such sites across the UK used to house those seeking asylum, with still more asylum seekers housed in private rentals. Not every defendant who lists one of these hotels as their place of residence is necessarily an asylum seeker. It has not been possible to establish how many of the alleged offenders identified by The Telegraph are currently applying for asylum in the UK. Nevertheless, The Telegraph's findings offer a sense of the numbers of asylum seekers who may be involved in crime. It came as migrants continued to arrive in the UK after crossing the English Channel on the day a ' one in, one out ' deal with France came into force. Under a pilot scheme that took effect on Wednesday, adults arriving on a small boat can be detained and returned to France for the first time in an effort to limit arrivals. This is in exchange for an approved asylum seeker in France to be brought to the UK under a safe route. On Wednesday, the Conservative Party also set out proposals under which asylum seekers who had been caught working illegally would have their claim automatically rejected and face immediate deportation, either to their country of origin or to a safe third country. All wages gained from the individual working illegally would be seized and used to cover the cost of any asylum support they received. Yvette Cooper, the Home Secretary, said this week that police should reveal more information about suspects, and that guidance to police was already being looked at. But she added it was an 'operational decision' for forces and the Crown Prosecution Service over what information to release. Police are under pressure to routinely disclose the nationality and migration status of suspects to protect community cohesion and to address a perception among some groups that asylum seekers are carrying out a disproportionate number of offences. On Tuesday, Ms Cooper told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that ministers wanted the public to have more detail about those charged, adding: 'We do think the guidance needs to change.' The Law Commission is expected to issue new guidance in the coming months that would allow nationality and asylum status to be disclosed if it is in the public interest to do so. While the majority of hotels had one or two residents charged with criminal offences, there were some with significantly more. Residents at the Holiday Inn, Empire Way, in Wembley were charged with 28 offences in the time period, while those at the Holiday Inn Express in Oxford and the Derby Midland Hotel had been charged with a combined 24 offences. In Epping, protests broke out last month after reports that an Ethiopian asylum seeker, Hadush Kebatu, had been charged with sexually assaulting a schoolgirl eight days after arriving in the UK. He has denied wrongdoing. Mr Kebatu is not the only Bell Hotel resident to face serious criminal charges. In April, another man appeared before Chelmsford magistrates' court charged with two counts of arson with intent to endanger life. The case was sent to Chelmsford Crown Court for a plea hearing on 5 May. In addition to Mr Kebatu, the review of court reports linked to 50 migrant hotels identified seven other individuals charged with a combined further 11 sex offences against children. These included the alleged rape of a girl aged 13 to 15; six counts of making child abuse material; two counts of attempting sexual communication with a child; an attempt to meet a girl under 16 after grooming; and one count of possessing child abuse material. In another case, a warrant was issued in June for a 24-year-old resident of a Liverpool migrant hotel accused of attempting to engage in sexual communication with a child. The man, who had failed to appear at Sefton magistrates' court on June 20 for his trial, allegedly sent numerous WhatsApp messages to a child under 16. According to court records, he arranged to meet the child, told her he loved her, and expressed desires to 'lay down with her and kiss and cuddle her'. He had previously pleaded not guilty to the charge. Sexual crimes against adults made up 32 of the offences reviewed by The Telegraph. The court records suggest that a significant proportion of these offences are alleged to have been perpetrated against other apparent asylum seekers. In some cases, bail conditions stipulate that the defendant cannot enter into another hotel used by the Home Office as this is where the alleged victim lives. In others, there is a marital relationship between the alleged perpetrator and victim. In one case, before a court in the north of England last month, a resident of a hotel housing asylum seekers was accused of strangling and suffocating his wife. A further 49 hotel residents were charged with 109 violent offences, including 40 counts of assault by beating, 19 of assaulting emergency workers, five of actual bodily harm, 10 of common assault and five of intentional strangulation. In one case, a 24-year-old man living in a Bournemouth hotel allegedly threatened another person with a snooker cue. He was granted unconditional bail and is due to appear at Poole magistrates' court on Aug 6 for a plea hearing. A Kurdish interpreter will attend. In another, heard on May 19, a 24-year-old asylum seeker was handed a suspended sentence at Chelmsford magistrates' court after admitting affray. Magistrates cited Sohaib Atem's 'strong personal mitigation' and 'realistic prospect of rehabilitation' in suspending an eight-month prison term for 12 months. A frequent complaint from residents living near asylum hotels is a rise in theft. Of the 63 theft offences residents in the 50 hotels were alleged to have committed, 14 were burglary offences and 37 were thefts from shops. Among them was Mamukr Kvaratskhelia, 39, who also appeared at Chelmsford magistrates' court in March charged with five counts of theft over a three-month period. He is accused of stealing designer sunglasses and fragrance worth more than £2,000, including £299 Ray-Bans from John Lewis and four pairs of glasses worth £1,165 from a local optician. Twelve hotel residents were charged with criminal damage. In one case, Akhmed Mohammad, formerly housed at Wethersfield asylum centre in Essex, was ordered to pay £380 for damaging a lavatory window in a car park. Mohammed was given until Sept 5 to pay the total amount, with magistrates citing his 'good previous character, low means and circumstances' in their decision. 'Police are in invidious position' Philip Seccombe, the Warwickshire police and crime commissioner, has pressed Ms Cooper for an urgent update on what information forces should give to the public after allegations that authorities tried to cover up alleged offences by asylum seekers. Mr Seccombe called for fresh national guidance to be issued after the charging of two men – reported to be Afghan asylum seekers – prompted accusations that the force withheld information about their immigration status. The pair are accused of raping of a 12-year-old girl in Nuneaton. Mr Seccombe said: 'Currently, police forces are in an invidious position when deciding what can and should be disclosed in sensitive cases, given that the national guidance is silent on both the ethnicity and immigration status of suspects. 'It is very easy to criticise and suggest that the balance of disclosure hasn't been correct, but it is much harder to take these decisions on the ground.'
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Stolen farm quad bikes used in urban crimes
After farming in Derbyshire for half a century, Robert Wigley became the victim of a major theft for the first time last quad bike, trailer and a selection of power tools were stolen is not alone and the National Farmers' Union (NFU) says quad bikes like Robert's are stolen and used to commit other crimes in the theft, Robert has stepped up security on his farm in Middleton-by-Youlgreave by installing CCTV cameras and he now keeps his new quad bike in a big metal shipping story is being told as part of Farmwatch, a BBC initiative which celebrates farming communities across the country. "I can't use the proper word that I would like to use, but I am annoyed," Robert said."You can't take the law into your own hands, you have to leave it up to the powers that be and hope that they come up with a result."Derbyshire Police say a 37-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of burglary and theft in connection with the incident. He has been released on bail as investigations of the day-to-day work on Robert's cattle farm is done by his son, because he needs a stick to help him quad bike was chained to a girder in a barn when it was taken - but Robert is confident that thieves will not get through his new security asked how the theft had made him feel, the 71-year-old said: "More annoyed. Definitely not nervous."We are not the sort of family that gets nervous - but we're more aware of our surroundings." The theft of quad bikes is something that is on the radar of the NFU's Derbyshire chairman Jane Bassett, who has a cattle farm in Hartington, and is in regular contact with the police."Quite often [quad bikes] go and they will be used in other areas. They will go out of the county and go further afield into cities and are part of even more crime," she said."So two crimes have been committed."According to the Police National Database, 11 quad bikes have been stolen in Derbyshire in 2025 and 19 were stolen last Andrew Huddleston, head of the National Rural Crime Unit, said these figures do not tell the full picture because some thefts will not be reported by said there was "undoubtedly" a link between these thefts and organised crime, and these vehicles were attractive to criminals because they were versatile."If you have a quad bike, or an off-road motorbike, you can go where a police car can't, you can disappear into a back street, you can go off-road, you can go up steps, you can go on a rail line," he added that many of the bikes that were stolen were involved in acts of anti-social behaviour in cities and warned that people like Robert should be on their guard because they are likely to be targeted again."If you are a victim of crime in a rural area, you are increasingly more likely to be a victim again because the criminals know you have this type of machinery, they know where you are and it is often because you are accessible to get in and out and steal things," he said.
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
Academic allowed to visit Europe while on bail for allegedly showing child abuse images during university lecture
An ex-Fair Work Commission deputy president accused of showing child abuse images during a university lecture has been permitted to fly to Europe while on bail. Former Monash University lecturer Alan Boulton, 74, faced the Melbourne magistrates court on Thursday after being charged with three child abuse material offences. Police allege he 'inadvertently displayed' inappropriate images during a university lecture on 5 February. The incident was reported to police, who began an investigation and interviewed him at his Middle Park home a week later. Electronic devices were seized and police also travelled to NSW where they searched a second property in Sydney on 13 February and took more devices. Sign up: AU Breaking News email Boulton was charged on 31 July with three counts of possessing child abuse material, including one commonwealth offence. He was placed on bail at the court on Thursday, where he appeared via video link wearing a dark grey suit and tie. Prosecutors tried to impose a bail condition preventing Boulton from travelling overseas and surrender his passport. However his lawyer Holly Baxter asked for him to be permitted to go to Europe on a 'business trip'. She said Boulton had provided prosecutors with details on his flights and itinerary on 23 July. 'No issue was taken with that, on that basis he booked the trip,' Baxter told the court. 'A serious amount of money has been spent on that trip.' The defence lawyer said Boulton had travelled overseas in May while under investigation and returned home, and he had no criminal history. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Magistrate Brett Sonnet refused the prosecution's attempt to impose travel restrictions, permitting Boulton to visit Europe. His bail conditions include that he cannot contact prosecution witnesses, is permitted to reside at two residential addresses, and must notify police within 24 hours of a change of address. Boulton is due to return to the court on 7 November for a committal mention. The 74-year-old is a former Australian Council of Trade Unions lawyer and was appointed deputy president of the Fair Work Commission in 1989. He became the commission's senior deputy president in 1993, where he served until 2015. A Monash University spokesperson said the allegations were 'very serious' but declined to comment further while the matter was before the courts. 'The safety and wellbeing of our students and staff is our highest priority.'
