Tribunal nurse calls for action after Supreme Court gender ruling
A nurse who was suspended by a Scottish health board after she objected to a transgender doctor using a women's changing room has called for action following the Supreme Court ruling on the legal definition of a woman. Sandie Peggie said she wanted NHS Fife to "immediately stop permitting any man who identifies as a woman" access to female-only single-sex spaces.The Supreme Court ruled last month that sex is defined by biology under equality law.NHS Fife previously said it would "carefully consider" the court's judgement.
Ms Peggie was suspended in January 2024 after transgender medic Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment against her. This followed a complaint from the nurse about having to share a changing room with Dr Upton at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy.Ms Peggie took the health board and Dr Upton to a tribunal earlier this year.She claimed that being made to get changed beside her transgender colleague amounted to unlawful harassment under the Equality Act.At the time, NHS guidance said that trans men and women were allowed to use the changing rooms that aligned with their gender identity.The tribunal has adjourned until July.
The Equality and Human Rights Commissioner has written to NHS Fife and the Scottish government to remind them about workplace legislation around single-sex spaces - which Ms Peggie has urged them to comply with.In her first statement since the Supreme Court ruling, she welcomed the judgement and pledged to continue litigation against NHS Fife. It said the nurse was "determined to continue with her legal claim in an effort to obtain accountability for the way she has been treated by Fife health board".Her lawyer added: "She now expects NHS Fife to immediately stop permitting any man who identifies as a woman access to female-only single-sex spaces in the workplace."NHS Fife has been asked for a comment.
New guidance
The Supreme Court ruling marked the culmination of a long-running legal battle, after the Scottish government argued that transgender people with a gender recognition certificate are entitled to the same sex-based protections as biological women.Public bodies have called for the Scottish government to update its guidance on single-sex spaces in light of the judgement. The government said earlier this week that it was working towards a "state of readiness" for an update from the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), the body in charge of regulating the Equality Act.The Scottish Parliament announced last week that transgender women would no longer be able to use the women's toilets at Holyrood. Facilities designated as male or female-only would now be interpreted as meaning biological sex, the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB) said.The parliament said it was installing new gender neutral toilets which will be open to anyone.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
21 minutes ago
- BBC News
NHS Grampian: New chief executive to lead struggling health board
A new chief executive has been appointed by NHS Grampian, as the health board faces significant financial challenges. Laura Skaife-Knight, who is currently in a similar role at NHS Orkney, will take up the role when interim boss Dr Adam Coldwells retires in the Grampian is trying to implement £23m in savings amid a huge overspend. The health board had been escalated to stage four of NHS Scotland's National Performance Framework over concerns about its finances and governance. Ms Skaife-Knight has worked for the NHS for 20 years, including spending time in England. She said she was looking forward to joining NHS Grampian, and recognised the "immediate challenges ahead". The new chief executive will oversee a savings plan which includes services being stopped or reduced on public are also planned to a service providing spiritual, pastoral and religious care to patients, their relatives and carers and to Grampian has the highest forecasted financial overspend across NHS Scotland for the year ahead - despite it getting a Scottish government loan of more than £67m to tackle the health board's chairwoman, Alison Evison, welcomed Ms Skaife-Knight's said: "Laura joins us at a challenging time, but I know that as a leader and chief executive known for putting people first that she already recognises that NHS Grampian's talented staff and proven ability to deliver the very best care."
BBC News
6 hours ago
- BBC News
'I'm worried my child will never speak if he doesn't get support'
Five-year-old Callum is autistic and nursery, he received weekly one-to-one speech and language therapy to try to develop his family says he was making good progress and when he started primary school last summer they were led to believe the support would it stopped, and they are now scared he may never is one of thousands of children struggling to access the right support with speech. Demand is increasing A new report seen by BBC Scotland News shows that demand for speech and language therapists (SLT) is increasing in Scotland but that the numbers of therapists is falling behind the rest of the says more than half of the children who need specialist support are waiting more than 18 weeks and some are waiting up to three report, by the Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists (RCSLT), says Scotland needs to increase its full-time equivalent SLT therapists by 370, from a current total of also says that Scotland is lagging behind England in terms of the ratio of speech and language therapists to RCSLT report states: "Over the past five years, Scotland's speech and language therapy workforce increased by just 2%, compared to 15% across the rest of the UK."This limited growth has not kept pace with rising demand." Freedom of Information (FOI) data, obtained by the RCSLT, shows that the number of children waiting for speech and language therapy increased from 6,503 in May 2023 to 6,727 in May 2024 - with 53% waiting longer than 18 weeks in both years. In some health boards, children are waiting for as long as two to three years for an initial contact, it Scottish government has promised to publish an Early Years Speech and Language action plan by the autumn. Glenn Carter, the head of the RCSLT in Scotland, said the report highlighted the importance of embedding SLT in nurseries and supporting children before they get to school as well as once they are said the provision of SLT was "variable", with excellent examples in some areas but low levels of funding in Carter said this led to those most in need not getting the resources they require. "There are kids experiencing significant challenges in school and that causes behavioural issues, which in turn causes stress for teachers," he said. "We feel that by positioning speech and language therapists within education we can solve quite a lot of the problems that Scotland is facing right now." One-to-one support Teachers say that since Covid more and more children are starting primary school without being able to communicate figures from Public Health Scotland show that last year more than one in 12 children recorded a delay in speech and language by age (2018/19) the figure was only one in 20. Speech and language therapy in schools is delivered by the NHS but partly funded by goes to a specialist "communication needs" school called Redburn in Cumbernauld, North father Grant said the school and staff are excellent but there is no SLT provision. He thought his son was still getting one-to-one support but then found out the therapist had been off sick."It was really upsetting," Grant told BBC Scotland News."To try to put yourself in his shoes and say how would you feel trying to survive in the world without being able to communicate?" he said."He's due that, he's got a human right to be able to have it, to give him the tools he needs to be able to survive in this world."Last week other parents at the school received a letter from NHS Lanarkshire to "apologise" for the fact they had not received SLT spoke to a teacher last month who confirmed that Callum had never been referred for speech and language therapy since he arrived at primary promised to refer him but he believes that referral hasn't been processed as he didn't receive the NHS council have pledged to offer more support in August, but Grant thinks it will be "nowhere near enough", based on the level of demand at Redburn school. Being non-verbal means Callum can get very distressed if he does not understand what is going on but also cannot tell people what he needs. His father Grant has been told that this is a crucial stage for his son to get specialist intervention for children with mutism is recognised as crucial to prevent the problem continuing into said: "I'm worried he won't be able to speak. "There's evidence that says the key age is 4-8, where if they can get assistance, then there's evidence of positive outcomes," he said. "They are failing in their duty of care if that doesn't happen." The Scottish government said it had invested in a programme to support early intervention in speech and language, helping to build confidence and capacity of staff working in early learning and childcare.A spokesman said: "As laid out in the Programme for Government, we will publish an Early Years Speech and Language action plan by autumn 2025, which will set our practical steps to support children's early speech and language development."A North Lanarkshire Council spokeswoman said: "There are UK-wide challenges in recruitment of speech and language staff, and we continue to work closely with colleagues at NHS Lanarkshire to assist in mitigating these."Pauline Downie, from NHS Lanarkshire, apologised for any distress its letter had caused. She said: "The intention of the letter is to give parents an opportunity to contact us to discuss any concerns they have regarding the speech, language and communication support for their child."
BBC News
12 hours ago
- BBC News
Hopes to open NHS ketamine clinic for treatment resistant depression
Ketamine is increasingly known as a party drug which is linked to serious health problems, even there is growing interest in Scotland in its potential to treat severe NHS Lothian psychiatrist hopes to set up a clinic by the end of the year offering the Category B drug as an alternative to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), a treatment that involves sending an electric current through the Andrew McIntosh thinks it could offer another alternative to patients with the most hard-to-treat depression. The move comes after a private clinic in Lanarkshire began offering ketamine assisted therapy to clients with treatment-resistant depression last Eulas clinic in Hamilton opened under licence from Healthcare Improvement Scotland in September and charges £6,000 for a programme of four intravenous ketamine infusions and a course of is a medical anaesthetic and while it is not licensed for the routine treatment for depression, it can be used 'off-label' by doctors and psychiatrists. Alex, who recently moved to Scotland from the United States, is one of 12 people being treated at the has experienced periods of depression and anxiety and says she turned to ketamine assisted therapy when traditional treatments didn't help."I was crying all day long while I was working, and was very resistant to doing anything new," the 40-year-old said. Ketamine, which is illegal on the streets, has nevertheless been used as a recreational drug for years because of its detached, dream-like effects. "I definitely had a psychedelic experience," Alex said. "You would see images, kind of feel like you're floating sometimes. "If you're reclined, you might feel like you're floating into different spaces for example. Or like you're going down a waterslide."Alex believes the infusions made her more receptive to psychotherapy."I think it makes it more palatable almost," she says. "You may see an image and you'll remember this image and then you'll talk to your therapist and they'll say: 'That's interesting, why do you think you saw that? What does that represent to you?"Alex had already tried ketamine therapy in the United States before being treated in Scotland and thinks it should be more widely available here."Before, I was really depressed," she said"Now I feel like I'm doing pretty well. I am active, I am trying new things, traveling again, kind of getting back to the person I felt like I used to be." Sean Gillen, the director of the Eulas clinic, says patients must have a diagnosed condition and be assessed by a psychiatrist to qualify for admits the cost of ketamine assisted therapy may be out of reach for many and hopes it will soon be available on the NHS."You're dealing with psychiatrists, anaesthetists, psychotherapists – these are real professional people and they need to be paid," he said."Most people don't have that kind of money and that's why we'd like to enter a partnership with the NHS." Ketamine is licensed as an anaesthetic but has hit the headlines for its recreational use. It can cause serious and sometimes permanent damage to the bladder, alongside a range of other complications if was linked to the death of RuPaul's Drag Race UK star The Vivienne earlier this year. And a coroner found Friends actor Matthew Perry died of the 'acute effects of ketamine' in 2023. Esketamine, a form of ketamine taken as a nasal spray, has been approved for the treatment for moderate to severe treatment-resistant depression in Scotland but intravenous ketamine has not, though it can be prescribed 'off-label'.The Royal College of Psychiatrists has previously urged caution over the use of ketamine therapy but it is due to publish a new report on psychedelics later this year, with updated information on ketamine. Andrew McIntosh, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Edinburgh and an NHS psychiatrist, hopes to set up a ketamine clinic at the Royal Edinburgh Hospital by the end of the would be offered to patients with the most hard-to-treat depression, as an alternative to said: "Even after taking multiple antidepressants and multiple different treatments, there's a small number of people who don't respond very well to any of those treatments, so ketamine gives them additional hope and it's been shown to be effective. "And it's an extra thing we could be doing to help our patients that is not currently available widely in Scotland."Prof McIntosh said it is not clear exactly how ketamine works to treat said: "Some people think it's because the brain becomes more plastic, more able to adapt. "Some people think it's because it alters the connections between different parts of the brain. "I think it's fair to say we don't fully understand how all the pieces of the jigsaw fit together and why it's effective, although we know it's very effective."He said the ketamine used to treat depression is very different to what people might take illegally."The ketamine that's given in clinical services is going to be a very pure form of the drug," he said. "It's going to be given under very controlled circumstances, and we are going to know that it's only the drug that's in the preparation, it's not the other things that are sometimes taken by people who use it recreationally. "The dose of the drug that is given for depression is also far, far lower than people use recreationally, so we think the risks of that are much, much lower than they are when it's taken in the community." NHS Lothian said it was considering the use of intravenous ketamine as an alternative to ECT, but no decision had been Gillies, executive medical director at NHS Lothian, said recent international studies suggested that the use of IV ketamine may be a cost-effective alternative to ECT. She said the introduction of any new service had to be carefully considered, with patient safety and cost factors among those to be Anna Ross, a lecturer in health and social policy at the University of Edinburgh and co-founder of Scottish Psychedelic Research Group, has carried out research with the Eulas clinic. She is interested in the potential for ketamine to treat depression and addiction problems but believes psilocybin, a Category A drug found in so-called magic mushrooms, could be more said: "I've been involved in drugs policy and drugs using communities now for about 20 years, and ketamine in and of itself has not been a substance I've known to be a positive substance as such, but it's really come to the fore in the UK because we don't have access to psilocybin. "So therefore clinics like the Eulas clinic and NHS facilities are starting to look at ketamine because it already has a scheduling and it can already be used for psychedelic therapy."A Scottish government spokesman said: "Decisions on whether to prescribe a medicine are a matter for the prescribing clinician based on individual patient need and in consultation with the patient, informed by advice and guidance about the medicine."
