Death Valley review: Timothy Spall effortlessly commands the screen but this BBC drama struggles
When did we decide we preferred our
television
detectives sunny-side up rather than served in the traditional hard-boiled fashion? At whatever point it happened, we nowadays live, beyond all hope of escape, in a cosy crime purgatory, where murder is a green light for jolly japes, and the only good cop is a whimsical one.
Cosy crime isn't new. It extends back to Agatha Christie in the 1920s and even to Wilkie Collins in the 19th century. But goodness, is it having a moment now – whether manifesting as cosy crime in the sun (Death in Paradise), cosy crime marinated in the cheesy values of 1980s US television (Poker Face) or cosy crime in upper-west-side Manhattan (Only Murders in the Building).
Alas, like a killer driven to ever more desperate extremes in the hope of attracting attention, the genre has lately arrived at the 'trying-too-hard' stage of its cycle, as evidenced by the distractingly offbeat Death Valley (
BBC
One, Sunday) – a capricious caper that cannot make up its mind whether to celebrate the tropes of the milieu or poke fun at them.
[
The Last of Us finale review: A nerve-shredding, bloody conclusion that leaves us wanting more, and soon
Opens in new window
]
The setting of small-town Wales is in the classic British tradition of dramedies taking place off the beaten track (see also: Shetland, Vera, Midsommar Murder or, in ancient times, Wicklow-set Ballykissangel). It stars veteran
Timothy Spall
as a reclusive actor once famous for playing a television detective (one gathers his character was a cross between Taggart and Bergerac). He's content in his solitude, with only his cat for the company – until a local bigwig seemingly shoots himself, and the police are called in.
READ MORE
Timothy Spall (left) plays John Chapel, with Gwyneth Keyworth as Janie Mallowan in Death Valley. Photograph: BBC/BBC Studios/Simon Ridgway
Spall earned his reputation with gritty character parts in unsentimental State of the Nation films such as Secrets and Lies by Mike Leigh (who would go on to cast him as the painter JMW Turner in a 2014 biopic). However, it is whimsy all the way in Death Valley, where his character, John Chapel, quickly joins forces with local police officer Janie Mallowan (Gwyneth Keyworth).
They're an odd pairing though you wonder how much of this is on purpose and how much has to do with the baffling decision to make Janie a devoted dispenser of gags. She's forever firing off pithy observations and commenting on life around her, whether or not anyone else has asked her to upend the contents of her brain all over their conversation. Her backstory contains its share of loss, and her outré personality is presumably a coping mechanism – unfortunately, Death Valley doesn't make any of this feel plausible.
For instance, in an early scene where she and John meet in a coffee shop to compare notes, she explains that she's reading an online piece about 'washed-up celebs and what they look like today'. She reveals that John is mentioned. But when he inquires further, she says she's only joking. Well, that's going to bring him around to her side, isn't it?
The actual mystery is solid. The dead businessman, Carwyn Rees, did not, in fact, take his own life. He was done in by people close to him amid murky dealings in his building development company and an illicit affair (or three) on the side. Here, Death Valley holds up – in so far as you can understand the motives of the perpetrators and the means by which the ghastly deed was carried out. That sets it apart from popular rivals such as Death in Paradise, where the big reveal about that week's murder invariably raises more questions than it answers.
The problem is ultimately one of tone. Death Valley wants to be flighty as anything and also have the crunchy qualities of a solid sleuth fest. It is well-intentioned and thoughtfully plotted while Spall effortlessly commands the screen as a fading luvvy who just so happens to be a top-rank crime buster in real life. But some things simply don't go well together. Now we know that this category includes off-beam humour and dark deeds in small-town Wales.
The six-part series is on BBC One on Sundays from 8.15pm
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Evan Fitzgerald: Carlow gunman was due in court to face 13 firearms and explosives charges
A man who opened fire in a busy Carlow shopping centre before fatally wounding himself was due to appear in court on Wednesday to face 13 firearms and explosives charges after being arrested last year. Gardaí believe Evan Fitzgerald (22) of Portrushen, Kiltegan, Carlow, who died at Fairgreen Shopping Centre in Carlow town on Sunday evening, was very fearful of going to prison. Though he was described by sources as posing a danger, due to his obsession with guns, he was also regarded as vulnerable. Assistant Commissioner Paula Hilman said what 'was meant to be a normal day out on a bank holiday weekend' had become a 'terrifying experience for every person that was present' at the shopping centre. READ MORE Mr Fitzgerald walked around the shopping centre discharging shots before fatally wounding himself. However, he fired into the air and did not attempt to shoot at anyone else, gardaí said. As shoppers fled from the centre, at about 6.15pm, gardaí received 999 calls alerting them to the fact shots were being fired. Uniformed gardaí were first to arrive and saw people fleeing the building before Mr Fitzgerald exited. They were followed quickly by armed detectives, who identified themselves to the gunman and drew their weapons. However, a further shot was then discharged from Mr Fitzgerald's shotgun, fatally wounding him. Garda Headquarters confirmed no shots were discharged by any of the gardaí present. Mr Fitzgerald was arrested in Co Kildare last year as part of an investigation by the Garda Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau into the purchase of guns on the dark net. He made full admissions and had been on bail awaiting trial. The operation last year resulting in the seizure of the two guns – a G3 Heckler & Koch machine gun and a Remington M1911 handgun – also involved the armed Emergency Response Unit. Gardaí believed Mr Fitzgerald and, allegedly, a number of associates had sourced the guns for recreational purposes, including shooting targets in the woods, rather than being involved in organised crime.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Death threats against Northern Ireland journalists increasing, says Amnesty
Journalists in Northern Ireland are facing a sustained campaign of violent threats from paramilitaries, making it the most dangerous place in the UK to be a reporter, according to Amnesty International . Death threats – including under-car booby trap bombs – issued to crime journalists have increased in recent years, with repeated home visits by police warning they are at risk. Others have been told they will be shot or stabbed and given 48-hour ultimatums to leave the country. Interviews carried out by Amnesty with 22 journalists uncovered more than 70 incidents of intimidation or attacks in the North since the start of 2019. READ MORE Loyalist and dissident republican paramilitaries as well as organised crime groups are behind most of the incidents. Journalists most at risk have their homes protected by bulletproof windows and doors with alarms linked to police stations. One reporter was visited by police nine times in just under a year to inform her that her life was at risk. A pipe bomb was placed close to her home after a threat. 'Several journalists report that they are receiving more threats in recent years than ever before. It goes beyond threats: they are physically attacked,' according to the Amnesty report entitled Occupational Hazard? Threats and Violence against Journalists in Northern Ireland. The report, published on Tuesday, says frustration with the police response means some journalists have stopped reporting the crimes to the authorities, citing 'time-consuming processes and lack of action or positive outcome'. [ Lyra McKee: A bright star, fallen, sacrificed to bigotry and hatred Opens in new window ] To date, two journalists have been murdered in Northern Ireland. Investigative reporter Martin O'Hagan of the Sunday World was killed close to his Lurgan home by loyalist paramilitaries in 2001 and Lyra McKee died after being struck by a bullet fired at police during rioting in Derry in 2019. Dissident republican group, the New IRA, admitted responsibility. A photographer was shot in the thigh covering a riot in Belfast in 2011. Concerns are raised in the report about a lack of prosecutions. Amnesty is calling on the State to create a 'safe environment where journalists can work freely and report without fear of reprisals'. 'It is currently failing to do so,' said Amnesty International UK's Northern Ireland director, Patrick Corrigan. 'Journalists are being threatened, attacked and even killed for shining a light on paramilitary groups and others who seek to exert control through violence. This creates a climate of fear that many assumed was consigned to history when the Good Friday Agreement was signed,' he said. Yet, he said, there has not been a single prosecution for threats against journalists from paramilitary groups. [ Lyra McKee: Lost Girl of the Troubles Opens in new window ] 'This sense of impunity only emboldens those behind the threats. When journalists are under attack, press freedom is under attack.' Among the report's recommendations is the establishment of a new media safety group, with representatives from the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI), Public Prosecution Service, media organisations and the National Union of Journalists to deliver a new journalist safety strategy. The PSNI should also review its procedural response to threats and attacks against journalists and 'conduct investigations capable of leading to successful prosecutions', the report advises. A Police Ombudsman's report examining the original police investigation into O'Hagan's murder is expected to be published this year. Amnesty recommends the UK government should order a public inquiry into the killing if 'serious failings or wrongdoing by the police' is found by the watchdog.
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Ukraine and Russia agree to new prisoner exchange in Istanbul
Ukraine and Russia agreed to hold a new prisoner exchange and swapped memorandums on a possible ceasefire to end Vladimir Putin's three-year war, despite a gulf remaining between the two sides' positions at a meeting in Istanbul on Monday. After talks at the Çırağan Palace on the Bosphorus, Kyiv's and Moscow's delegations said they had agreed to swap all seriously wounded and sick prisoners, as well as prisoners of war under 25. The talks, which lasted for just more than an hour, were the second round of negotiations brokered by Turkey and the US after the peace process resumed last month for the first time since early in the conflict. Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan said the meeting was 'great' and added that he would move to organise a summit involving Mr Putin, Ukraine's president Volodymyr Zelenskiy and US president Donald Trump . READ MORE Vladimir Medinsky, the head of Russia's delegation, said the upcoming exchange, set to involve '1,000 to 1,200' prisoners, would be the largest since the war began, adding that Russia was 'satisfied with the results' of the talks. But the two delegations did not shake hands and suggested they had made little progress on any potential deal as Mr Putin refuses to budge from his demands to cut down Ukraine's sovereignty or accept Kyiv's calls for a ceasefire. Vladimir Medinsky (secon from right), head of the Russian delegation, delivers a statement to the press after a second round of direct talks between Ukrainian and Russian delegates. Photograph: Getty Images Mr Medinsky said Moscow had offered a ceasefire for 'two to three days' on 'specific areas of the front' that would allow the sides to pick up the dead. Ukraine's delegation said that Russia had rejected its proposal for an unconditional ceasefire and for the US to be more involved in the talks after Mr Trump suggested he might attend to bring Mr Putin and Mr Zelenskiy together. Kyiv also said Russia only handed over its memorandum on a possible path to end the war at the meeting and declined to comment on it further. After the meeting, a senior Ukrainian official said that no major breakthroughs had been achieved, 'just minor steps as we expected'. The official added: 'It seems they're staging a picture of diplomacy for Trump.' Rustem Umerov, Ukraine's defence minister, said Kyiv's delegation gave Moscow a list of several hundred Ukrainian children who were deported to Russia during the war. Mr Medinsky said Russia would work to reunite stranded children with their families in Ukraine when possible but accused Kyiv of turning the issue into a 'shameful show' for the Europeans. [ Analysis: Kyiv braced for Russian summer offensive Opens in new window ] Russia's intransigence has frustrated the US president, who had bragged that he could solve the conflict on his first day in office and thought his close relationship with Mr Putin could help broker a deal. Instead, Russia dismissed a 22-point US peace plan and held fast to its demands, prompting Mr Trump to suggest the US would take a back seat in the peace process after the first round of talks in May. On Sunday, Ukraine launched one of its most daring military operations of the war, hitting dozens of Russian aircraft at four airfields as far away from the front line as eastern Siberia. Those attacks themselves came just hours after Russia launched its largest drone strike on Ukraine since 2022, attacking the cities of Kyiv, Kharkiv and Zaporizhzhia with 472 unmanned aerial vehicles. Remarks by Mr Medinsky other senior Kremlin officials in the weeks following the first meeting indicated that Moscow was not prepared to budge from its insistence on solving the 'root causes' of the conflict. [ Putin wants written pledge to halt Nato expansion in return for peace Opens in new window ] Mr Putin has previously demanded that Ukraine withdraw from four regions partly controlled by Russia — Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia — accept caps on its armed forces, and pledge never to join Nato. During the first round of talks, Mr Medinsky made what Ukrainian officials called 'unacceptable' territorial demands and threatened that Russia would conquer more regions if its conditions were not met. Russian foreign minister Sergey Lavrov also said after the first round of talks that Moscow wanted Kyiv to enshrine protections for Russian speakers in the country and roll back much of the legislation passed under Mr Zelenskiy's government. Ukraine argued that those conditions would amount to surrender and the end of its existence as a sovereign state. Russia has also downplayed the possibility of a face-to-face meeting between Mr Putin, Mr Zelenskiy and Mr Trump, saying such a summit could only be planned after results were reached at the talks in Istanbul. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
