Mayor: Post editorial misses the mark on West Palm Beach park contract decision
This letter is being written in response to a recent Palm Beach Post editorial ('Should West Palm approve contract with CEO indicted for fraud? City says yes!') criticizing me and the City Commission for the decision at the January 21 City Commission meeting authorizing execution of the contract for the Currie Park Redevelopment Park Project, after West Construction was selected as the contractor through a competitive process.
Frankly, I was appalled by the lack of research done prior to the criticism of the decision. It is as if the editorial was simply responding to the question contained in the headline for the news story ('Why did West Palm pick a firm whose CEO is under fraud indictment to rebuild Currie Park?') as opposed to doing a thorough job of understanding the basis for the decision.
Questions that should have been considered and researched before jumping to conclusion that the decision has a 'stench' related to it, include the following:
Whether or not the city could reject the decision without risking a bid protest and lawsuit?
The impact on the project that would result from a reversal of the decision?
Whether or not the federal grants committed to the project obligate the city to select the lowest responsible bidder?
Whether or not a performance bond would be posted by West?
Whether or not a performance bond would protect the city against any losses if West failed to perform its contractual obligations?
Does the writer even know what a performance bond is?
By the way, if one watched the tape, all of these issues (except for the last question) were discussed at the aforementioned commission meeting.
Now, let me share some actual facts related to the project and the decision:
The project is a signature project of the city and has been discussed by the commission since 2018.
The project is a priority project of my administration and is anxiously anticipated by the surrounding community, as at least 12 community meetings have been held since December 2020.
On June 3, 2022, the city received a federally funded grant through the U.S. Department of Commerce in the amount of $16.7 million. The deadline for the work to be performed with the proceeds of the federal grant is June 2, 2026. The failure to complete construction work by the federal grant deadlines may result in the withholding of federal grant funds and/or termination of the federal grants.
The project has received 3 state grants for the project, in the aggregate amount of $2.1 million. The failure to complete construction work by the state grant deadlines may result in the withholding of state grant funds and/or termination of the State Grants.
The parks bond which was approved by Palm Beach County voters in March 2020, allocated $8.4 million to the project. If that amount is not used for the project, the city could incur significant adverse financial consequences.
Under the city's Procurement Code, the indictment of officers of a respondent is not the basis for disqualification of the respondent from the bid process. There were no other reasons under the code for which West should be deemed disqualified.
If the city rejected West at the expense of the stated risks and selected the second low bidder, it would be obligated to pay an additional $5 million for the project, which monies are not currently available.
Selecting the second low bidder when West met the requirement of the Invitation to bid and the code, would subject the city to a bid protest by West and likely litigation related thereto. Such action would significantly delay the project, to the extent that the city would be unable to satisfy the conditions of the federal and state grants. If the city lost the revenues from the federal and state grants, it would be unable to pay for the project. In other words, the Project would die.
A performance bond in the amount of roughly $35.4 million has already been posted by West in connection with the Project. In the event that West failed to perform its contractual obligations in connection with the project, the surety would be obligated to find a contractor to complete the project using the bond funds.
Since West itself was not indicted, even if the indicted officer of West were ultimately convicted of certain crimes, West would still be able to perform its contractual obligations related to the project. In fact, a Succession Plan for West was presented to the commissioners at the commission meeting.
West has previously performed 11 significant projects in the city during the past 20 years, for a total amount of $29.5 million. This includes the recent award of the $15 million Gaines Park Redevelopment Project which was underway prior to the aforementioned indictment and on which the work is being performed at a high level. In fact, there have been no defaults or substandard performance on any of those contracts.
More: Should West Palm approve contract with CEO indicted for fraud? City says yes! | Editorial
In conclusion, while one can sit in an ivory tower and criticize the fact that West does not pass some so-called 'purity test' because of the indictment of a certain officer of West, that failure does not, in and of itself, justify risk losing the Project in totality. If West were disqualified because of the indictments of one of its officers, that certainly would have led to the demise of the project. It would be folly to jeopardize the project because of so-called 'bad optics.' The benefits of the project to this city far outweigh any negative perception created by the alleged misdeeds of a single West company officer in Tampa.
As former President Teddy Roosevelt once said, 'It is not the critic who counts: not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles or where the doer of deeds could have done better. The credit belongs to the man who is actuallyin the arena, . . .'
It is easy to sit on the sidelines and 'Monday Morning quarterback', but true leadership requires tough, difficult decisions, often in the heat of battle.
Keith A. James is mayor of West Palm Beach.
This article originally appeared on Palm Beach Post: WPB Mayor: Post editorial board didn't do homework on contract decision
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
MERGE Continues Growth Trajectory with Strategic Additions to Leadership
CHICAGO, June 11, 2025--(BUSINESS WIRE)--MERGE, a leading marketing and technology agency, announces two strategic hires to strengthen and further accelerate its mission of integrated growth and innovation. Heidi West steps into the role of Chief Revenue Officer, and John Bracey joins MERGE as Chief Data and Performance Officer. These accomplished executives bring decades of experience and expertise, fortifying the agency's leadership team as it continues to expand at the intersection of health and wellness. Heidi West, MERGE's new Chief Revenue Officer, offers over 30 years of exceptional sales leadership and a history of delivering impactful technology solutions across healthcare, including at CommonSpirit Health, Englewood Health, Mount Sinai Health System, Stanford Health Care, and other diverse industries. Most recently leading the healthcare team at Zoom, West has held sales and leadership roles at Cisco, Nutanix, and Booz Allen. "I am incredibly excited to join MERGE at such a pivotal time," said West. "I look forward to leveraging my experience in healthcare and technology to help MERGE bridge the gap between health and consumer verticals. By focusing on improving patient engagement and experience, we can deliver trusted, relatable solutions guided by AI and data-driven strategies for our clients and their audiences." West's background in healthcare and executive engagement, combined with her talent for building high-performing sales teams aligned with strategic goals, makes her an invaluable catalyst for strategic growth. Commenting on this significant leadership addition, Stephanie Trunzo, MERGE CEO, remarked, "While leading Oracle Health, I met Heidi in her role driving the health business at Zoom. Her extensive experience in the health industry, coupled with her strategic sales expertise and sincere approach will catalyze the outcome-oriented momentum of our client service and business development teams." Beyond her professional achievements, West is a passionate advocate for women in technology and STE(A)M initiatives. John Bracey, a visionary in data science and analytics, brings an impressive track record of transforming global brands into organizations driven by insight. Formerly EVP at Publicis Groupe, Bracey spearheaded data-driven transformation initiatives across a number of Publicis Groupe's largest consumer and healthcare brands. "My expertise lies where data science and strategy meet. I'm passionate about helping brands maximize the value of their data and media investments, whether by engineering insight or architecting performance," said Bracey. "Across industries, I've seen that an audience-first approach consistently drives better insights and stronger outcomes. At MERGE, I look forward to continuing this work, turning complex data into automated, actionable solutions that deliver measurable business outcomes." "John's ability to harness data to transform businesses will substantively enhance how we deliver personalized, meaningful solutions that unite people and brands. These data-smart offerings will be the electricity that runs through creative and tech implementations to identify, optimize, and predictively model impact. We're incredibly excited about the amplified innovation he will bring to MERGE," said Trunzo. The West and Bracey appointments further accelerate MERGE's strategic leadership expansion, building on the other significant executive announcements this year beginning with Stephanie Trunzo's announcement as CEO, and including Erica Denner (Chief People Officer), Kyle Smith (CTO), Paul Buranosky (CMO), and Chris Esposito (CFO). About MERGE MERGE is a marketing and technology agency built for the intersection of health and wellness. We combine deep expertise in health and consumer behavior with strategy, creativity, experience technology, and digital marketing to design personalized experiences that drive meaningful results. Powered by human insight, creativity, and AI, we weave storytelling through technology to turn complexity into clarity — strengthening relationships between people and brands. With 750+ specialists across Atlanta, Boston, Chicago, Denver, Kansas City, Los Angeles, New York, and Raleigh, MERGE partners with leading brands like Abbott, GE Healthcare, American Express, T-Mobile, Coach, and Meta to advance health, wellness, and happiness. Learn more at View source version on Contacts Mary Josephmjoseph@


Business Wire
7 hours ago
- Business Wire
MERGE Continues Growth Trajectory with Strategic Additions to Leadership
CHICAGO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--MERGE, a leading marketing and technology agency, announces two strategic hires to strengthen and further accelerate its mission of integrated growth and innovation. Heidi West steps into the role of Chief Revenue Officer, and John Bracey joins MERGE as Chief Data and Performance Officer. These accomplished executives bring decades of experience and expertise, fortifying the agency's leadership team as it continues to expand at the intersection of health and wellness. MERGE announces two strategic hires to strengthen and further accelerate its mission of integrated growth and innovation: Heidi West and John Bracey. Heidi West, MERGE's new Chief Revenue Officer, offers over 30 years of exceptional sales leadership and a history of delivering impactful technology solutions across healthcare, including at CommonSpirit Health, Englewood Health, Mount Sinai Health System, Stanford Health Care, and other diverse industries. Most recently leading the healthcare team at Zoom, West has held sales and leadership roles at Cisco, Nutanix, and Booz Allen. "I am incredibly excited to join MERGE at such a pivotal time," said West. "I look forward to leveraging my experience in healthcare and technology to help MERGE bridge the gap between health and consumer verticals. By focusing on improving patient engagement and experience, we can deliver trusted, relatable solutions guided by AI and data-driven strategies for our clients and their audiences.' West's background in healthcare and executive engagement, combined with her talent for building high-performing sales teams aligned with strategic goals, makes her an invaluable catalyst for strategic growth. Commenting on this significant leadership addition, Stephanie Trunzo, MERGE CEO, remarked, 'While leading Oracle Health, I met Heidi in her role driving the health business at Zoom. Her extensive experience in the health industry, coupled with her strategic sales expertise and sincere approach will catalyze the outcome-oriented momentum of our client service and business development teams.' Beyond her professional achievements, West is a passionate advocate for women in technology and STE(A)M initiatives. John Bracey, a visionary in data science and analytics, brings an impressive track record of transforming global brands into organizations driven by insight. Formerly EVP at Publicis Groupe, Bracey spearheaded data-driven transformation initiatives across a number of Publicis Groupe's largest consumer and healthcare brands. 'My expertise lies where data science and strategy meet. I'm passionate about helping brands maximize the value of their data and media investments, whether by engineering insight or architecting performance,' said Bracey. 'Across industries, I've seen that an audience-first approach consistently drives better insights and stronger outcomes. At MERGE, I look forward to continuing this work, turning complex data into automated, actionable solutions that deliver measurable business outcomes.' 'John's ability to harness data to transform businesses will substantively enhance how we deliver personalized, meaningful solutions that unite people and brands. These data-smart offerings will be the electricity that runs through creative and tech implementations to identify, optimize, and predictively model impact. We're incredibly excited about the amplified innovation he will bring to MERGE,' said Trunzo. The West and Bracey appointments further accelerate MERGE's strategic leadership expansion, building on the other significant executive announcements this year beginning with Stephanie Trunzo's announcement as CEO, and including Erica Denner (Chief People Officer), Kyle Smith (CTO), Paul Buranosky (CMO), and Chris Esposito (CFO). About MERGE MERGE is a marketing and technology agency built for the intersection of health and wellness. We combine deep expertise in health and consumer behavior with strategy, creativity, experience technology, and digital marketing to design personalized experiences that drive meaningful results. Powered by human insight, creativity, and AI, we weave storytelling through technology to turn complexity into clarity — strengthening relationships between people and brands. With 750+ specialists across Atlanta, Boston, Chicago, Denver, Kansas City, Los Angeles, New York, and Raleigh, MERGE partners with leading brands like Abbott, GE Healthcare, American Express, T-Mobile, Coach, and Meta to advance health, wellness, and happiness. Learn more at

Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Councilor wants paid parking at Willard Beach for non-residents
Jun. 10—The city of South Portland is considering charging people from out of town to park at Willard Beach as early as next summer. On Thursday, Councilor Natalie West will request that the City Council set up a workshop to discuss the potential parking change. This is a preliminary step, and at least two other councilors must support this workshop for it to move forward. In her request, West argued that the city needs to identify a revenue source to maintain Willard Beach, and that it is appropriate that non-residents contribute to covering these costs. She recommended converting the Willard Beach parking lot, which has approximately 60 parking spaces, and the Willard Hose parcel, which could potentially fit 75 parking spaces, into paid parking lots for non-residents. She also proposed the creation of a seven-person subcommittee with two councilors and members from the Conservation, Economic Development and the Bike-Ped committees to look into the practicalities of instituting paid parking for non-residents. The Willard Beach Master Plan, a comprehensive document that was approved by the City Council in 2023, first recommended the idea of paid parking for non-residents. This document presented a number of considerations for the implementation of paid parking: the need for additional staff, the purchase of residential stickers, the installation of a digital parking machine and the bounds for which the paid parking should extend within the neighborhood. Approval of the master plan stipulated that if the city wanted to move forward with any of the suggestions, they would need to bring it forth in the workshopping process. If approved on Thursday, that process would begin. Copy the Story Link