French Court To Rule On Assad Immunity In Chemical Attack Case
Rights activists say that if the Court of Cassation confirms Assad does not enjoy immunity due to the severity of the accusations, it could set a major precedent in international law towards holding war criminals to account.
But if the reasoning is that the warrant is valid because France did not consider Assad to be a legitimate ruler at the time of the alleged crimes, it would not have the same impact.
French authorities issued the warrant against Assad in November 2023 over his alleged role in the chain of command for a sarin gas attack that killed more than 1,000 people, according to US intelligence, on August 4 and 5, 2013 in Adra and Douma outside Damascus.
Assad is accused of complicity in war crimes and crimes against humanity in the case, though Syrian authorities at the time denied involvement and blamed rebels.
The French judiciary tackled the case under the principle of universal jurisdiction, whereby a court may prosecute individuals for serious crimes committed in other countries.
An investigation -- based on testimonies of survivors and military defectors, as well as photos and video footage -- led to warrants for the arrest of Assad, his brother Maher who headed an elite army unit, and two generals.
Public prosecutors approved three of the warrants, but issued an appeal against the one targeting Assad, arguing he should have immunity as a head of state.
The Paris Court of Appeal in June last year however upheld it, and prosecutors again appealed.
Assad's circumstances have since changed.
He and his family fled to Russia, according to Russian authorities, after Islamist-led rebels toppled him in December last year.
Agnes Callamard, a French human rights activist and the secretary general of Amnesty International, said the court's decision could "pave the way for a major precedent in international law" if it decided immunity should be lifted in certain cases.
"A ruling lifting Bashar al-Assad's immunity would help strengthen the founding principles of international law in its fight against the impunity of war criminals," she wrote in the newspaper Liberation on Thursday.
Callamard however noted that it was unlikely any arrest warrant would lead to Assad being detained as he was protected by Russia.
The high court's prosecutor has recommended the arrest warrant be upheld, but on the grounds that France had not recognised Assad as the legitimate ruler of Syria since 2012.
Mazen Darwish, a prominent Syrian lawyer who heads the Syrian Center for Media and Freedom of Expression, a civil party to the case, said the prosecutor's argument was "very clever".
But it "undermines the moral foundation" according to which "immunity should not apply" in cases of war crimes and crimes against humanity, he said.
The reasoning "also grants a single foreign government the power to decide who is or is not a legitimate head of state, which sets an extremely dangerous precedent", he said.
French investigating magistrates in January issued a second arrest warrant against Assad for suspected complicity in war crimes for a bombing in the Syrian city of Deraa in 2017 that killed a French-Syrian civilian.
Friday's hearing is scheduled to start at 1300 GMT.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
DW
3 hours ago
- DW
Trump tariffs: Where do we stand as deadline expires – DW – 07/31/2025
Countries whose exports are facing sweeping US tariffs have been in a scramble recently to sign trade deals. While some were successful, others are facing the prospect of no deal and increased levies. In his election campaign, Donald Trump once said that "tariff is the most beautiful word in the dictionary." Now, after six months in office, the US president is eager to turn his very specific vison of global trade into reality. With a move that shocked both politics and business across the world, Donald Trump announced on April 2 this year that he would impose a "baseline tariff" of 10% on all goods imported to the United States. In addition, goods from about 60 other trade partners would face so-called reciprocal tariffs that were even higher and meant as payback for the unfair trade policies of what Trump called "the worst offenders." While the baseline tariffs came into effect immediately, the US President was forced to postpone the deadline for reciprocal tariffs for 90 days in response to turmoil in the financial markets following April 2. They are now coming into effect on August 1, with the US president having made abundantly clear that he's holding strong on the deadline for countries that haven't reached new trade agreements with his administration. "It stands strong, and will not be extended," Trump wrote in a Truth Social post on Tuesday, adding: "A big day for America!!!" While deals have been made with some major US trading partners, many others are facing the prospect of no deal and increased levies on their exports to the United States. Scores more are somewhere in the middle — with no trade deal signed, but as yet no threat of higher tariffs. Among them are some of America's closet allies and biggest trading partners, including Australia, Taiwan and New Zealand. Days before the deadline, the US and the European Union on Sunday agreed that European goods imported to the US would face a 15% baseline tariff. This includes the EU's crucial automobile sector which had been subject to a 25% levy since Trump took office earlier this year. By contrast, the EU will charge US firms no duties at all, and has pledged to buy US energy worth $750 billion, as well as make investments in the US of around $600 billion, according to the White House. The agreement, which still needs to be signed off by all 27 EU members, has already received strong criticism. French Prime Minister Francoise Bayrou said the EU had capitulated and described Sunday as a "dark day." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The United Kingdom was the first country to strike a trade deal with Washington. British products will be subject to a 10% base rate, with exceptions for some industries. The UK is still negotiating exemptions for its steel and aluminium products from the 25% rate in force. In return, the UK had to open its market further to US ethanol and beef. Under a deal struck in July, Japan's exports to the US will be taxed at 15%, including automobiles, an industry accounting for 30% of Japanese exports to the US in 2024. Tariffs of 50% on Japanese steel and aluminium will continue to apply and the White House said that under the deal, Japan would make an unspecified $550 billion investments in the US. With regard to South Korea, recent negotiations have resulted in a 15% baseline tariff on all imports from that country — down from a threatened 25% for one of the US's top-10 trading partner and key Asian ally. Trump said on Wednesday that South Korea had also agreed to invest $350 billion in US projects and to purchase $100 billion of liquefied natural gas and other energy products. Furthermore, South Korea will accept American products, including automobiles and agricultural goods into its markets and impose no import duties on them, he added. Other trade deals made by Washington include the Philippines, Vietnam, Indonesia, and Pakistan. Products from the Philippines — a major exporter of hi-tech items and apparel — will face a 19% levy. Vietnam was able to lower a threatened reciprocal tariff of 49% under a deal reached in early July. A main exporter of clothing and shoes to the US, Vietnam will see its shipments subject to a 20% tariff. However, a 40% tariff will be imposed on so-called transshipments — goods manufactured in third countries that use Vietnam to circumvent steeper trade barriers. US goods will not face any tariffs entering Vietnam. Indonesian exports to the US will be taxed at 19% and, according to Washington, nearly all US goods will be able to enter Indonesia tariff-free. Pakistan, which was facing a potential 29% tariff under Trump's April 2 announcement, said on Thursday it had struck a deal that would result in lower tariffs, as well as an agreement in which Washington would help develop the country's oil reserves. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video China — the world's second-largest economy — is a special case. Washington and Beijing had raised tariffs on each other's goods to more than 100% before temporarily lowering rates for a 90-day period. That pause is set to end on 12 August. China has taken an aggressive stance in response to Trump's brief threat of imposing a 145% levy on imports, retaliating with tariffs of its own on US goods and blocking the sale of vital rare earth minerals and components used by American defense and hi-tech manufacturers. Brazil is one of the few major economies that run a trade deficit with the United States, meaning Brazil imports more from the US than it exports to the country. Nevertheless, the US president has threatened to impose a 50% tariff on Brazil's products because of political differences. Trump called a current trial against former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro a "witch hunt," and has demanded the release of the ultraconservative politician. Brazil's president, Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, in turn called Trump an "emperor" and said he didn't fear publicly criticizing Trump. India, meanwhile, has caused Trump's ire for its huge trade surplus with the US and its trade ties with Russia. As a result, Trump announced on Wednesday that he would impose a 25% tariff on Indian goods, plus an additional "penalty" because of India's purchasing of Russian oil that helps Moscow finance its war in Ukraine. On his Truth Social platform, Trump also wrote that India "is our friend," but added its tariffs on US products "are far too high." Canada and Mexico — two of the the US's biggest trading partners — haven't been spared Trump's tariff threats either, even though the three neighbors' trade is governed by the US-Mexico-Canada (USMC) trade agreement. Trump has threatened to impose a 30% tariff on Mexican goods, accusing the country of not doing enough to curb drug smuggling. Nevertheless, Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum has previously said she was confident an agreement could be reached before August 1. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney is more skeptical about a positive outcome of bilateral trade talks after Trump has threatened to impose a 35% levy on imports not covered by USMC. In March, Trump already imposed a 25% tariff on Canadian cars and auto parts, adding a 50% levy on steel and aluminium imports in June. The new rate would apply to all other goods. On Wednesday, Trump said that Canada's decision to back statehood for Palestine would make it "hard for us to make a trade deal with them."
DW
3 hours ago
- DW
Ukraine: Bill restores independence of anti-graft bodies – DW – 07/31/2025
Ukrainian lawmakers have passed revised legislation to restore the independence of anti-corruption bodies. Meanwhile, eight people were killed and dozens injuried in Russian airstrikes overnight. DW has the lawmakers have unanimously approved a bill restoring the independence of two anti-corruption agencies after President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and his government bowed to pressure from protesters at home and Western allies abroad. Last Wednesday, Ukraine's parliament, the , had passed legislation which effectively brought the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU) and the Specialised Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office (SAPO) under the control of the state prosecutor's office. The move saw thousands of protesters take to the streets of Kyiv and also drew criticism from the European officials who warned that Ukraine was jeopardizing its bid for European Union membership by curbing the powers of its anti-graft authorities. EU Enlargement Commissioner Marta Kos had called the changes "a serious step back" but welcomed Thursday's U-turn, saying: "Today's law restores key safeguards, but challenges remain. The EU supports [Ukrainian] citizens' demands for reform. Upholding fundamental values and fighting corruption must remain the priority." Both the NABU and SAPO were established with western support in 2015 to complement traditional police and state prosecutors in their battle against corruption — an undemocratic legacy of the Soviet Union which remains a significant problem in Ukraine despite the toppling of the pro-Russian government under former President Viktor Yanukovych in 2014. Even after Zelenskyy submitted the revised bill, demonstrations had continued, with hundreds rallying near the presidential administration in Kyiv late on Wednesday chanting "Shame!" and "The people are the power!" Speaking in parliament before voting, opposition lawmaker Yaroslav Yurchyshyn thanked Ukrainians for stopping their politicians who he said had been "one step from the abyss" of autocracy. The whole episode constituted the biggest expression of displeasure with President Zelenskyy since the full-scale Russian invasion in February 2022. The eradication of graft is seen as key in distinguishing Ukraine from Russia, and is also a requirement for Kyiv to join the EU, which many Ukrainians see as critical to their future. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The Russian Defense Ministry claimed on Thursday that its forces had finally "liberated" the key Ukrainian frontline town of Chasiv Yar after 16 months of fierce fighting. Located just to the west of Bakhmut, which fell to Russian forces in May 2023 after one of the bloodiest battles of the war, the hilltop settlement overlooks a highway connecting the towns of Kostiantynivka, Kramatorsk and Sloviansk — important Ukrainian logistics bases which are considered key to controlling the eastern Donetsk region. Video footage verified by the Reuters news agency showed Russian soldiers raising a paratrooper banner and the Russian flag among the ruins of the town, but a Ukrainian military spokesman told the AFP news agency that the Russian claims were a "total lie" designed to "create a psychological effect." The Ukrainian online mapping platform DeepState, which tracks territorial changes along the frontline, claimed that western parts of the town were still in Ukrainian hands. Russia unilaterally claimed the annexation of Donetsk in September 2022, despite still only controlling about 60% of the region. Following the latest deadly overnight strikes on civilian targets in Ukraine, a furious Volodymyr Zelenskyy has called for tougher action against Russia, including the total confiscation of frozen Russian financial assets and even a change of regime in Moscow. "Russia keeps launching such attacks even when the whole world is calling on it to stop the war, a war that Russia started, a war that Russia keeps dragging on, a war that only the Russian leadership wants," the Ukrainian president said at a conference in Helsinki, Finland. He accused the Russian government and military leadership of being "mentally stuck in another century, a time of brutal violence [and] total disregard for human rights and equality" and said that the current regime in the Kremlin is founded on "a total rejection of the post-Second World War world." Referring to Russian assets frozen in the European Union, Zelenskyy said: "It's time to confiscate the Russian assets, not just freeze them … to use them to serve peace, not war. We need to fully block Russia's war machine, cut off its arms industry [and] limit its energy profits." In some of his strongest terms yet, he warned: "If the world doesn't aim to change the regime in Russia, that means, even after the war ends, Moscow will still try to destabilize neighboring countries." At least eight people, including a six-year-old boy and his mother, were killed in further Russian airstrikes on Ukraine overnight, according to Ukrainian authorities. Another 88 people were reported to have been injured, including ten children — the youngest being a five-month-old girl. "Today, the world once again saw Russia's response to our desire for peace, shared with America and Europe," wrote Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyyon social media, describing the latest attacks as "showcase killings." According to Zelenskyy, the Russian military launched eight rockets and over 300 drones at targets across the country. The Ukrainian Air Force claimed to have shot down three of the rockets and most of the drones but nevertheless reported 27 hits across the capital, Kyiv. "This is a horrific morning for Kyiv," wrote Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha, while Kyiv mayor Vitali Klitschko spoke of the highest casualty rate among children in a single night since the war began in February 2022. "This is how the Kremlin responds to calls for peace: with deliberate terror and the systematic targeting of Ukraine's civilian population," said Ukrainian Prime Minister Yulia Svyrydenko. "[Russian President Vladimir] Putin is not seeking a solution. He is testing the world's resolve, continuing to receive confirmation that mass murder has no real consequences." Hello and welcome to DW's coverage of developments in Russia's ongoing invasion of Ukraine on Thursday, July 31. After overnight Russian drone and missile strikes across Ukraine left at least seven people dead and over 80 injured, a furious Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has called for the confiscation of frozen Russian financial assets and even regime change in Moscow. In response, Ukrainian drones reportedly targeted an electronics plant in western Russia. Meanwhile, on the frontline, Russian forces have claimed to have captured the embattled town of Chasiv Yar — denounced as a "lie" by Kyiv.
Int'l Business Times
4 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
Thousands Of Afghans Scramble For Chance To Work In Qatar
When Mohammad Hanif heard Qatar was opening jobs to Afghans, he joined thousands of others to put his name down for a shot to make a living in the gas-rich emirate, his own country wracked by unemployment. The Taliban authorities announced a deal with Gulf state this month to recruit 3,100 workers from Afghanistan, who started applying on Tuesday at centres across the country. By Wednesday, more than 8,500 people had put their names down from the capital Kabul and surrounding provinces, labour ministry spokesman Samiullah Ibrahimi told AFP, and more than 15,500 people are expected to register nationwide. The Taliban government says the jobs will help fight steep unemployment and poverty in the country of around 48 million people, facing what the United Nations says is one of the world's worst humanitarian crises. "Our country has many problems, most people are poor and work odd jobs," said Hanif, who travelled to western Herat from neighbouring Badghis to register. "I have skills in car mechanics and cooking, and I have certificates to prove it," said the 35-year-old, adding he was grateful to Qatar for employing Afghans. Competition is steep, however, with centres swarmed by hopeful applicants ready to present the required passports, identification cards and professional certificates to nab roles ranging from bus driver to cleaner, cook, mechanic and electrician. More than 1,000 people have applied in southern Kandahar for around 375 positions allocated to the region, and in Herat, around 2,000 people lined up on Wednesday to try for one of a few hundred jobs, AFP journalists said. Qatar, where the Taliban opened an office during the two-decade war with US-led forces, is one of the handful of countries to have strong diplomatic ties with Afghanistan's rulers after they swept to power in 2021. Only Russia has so far officially recognised the Taliban government. Discussions are also underway with Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Oman, Turkey and Russia to set up similar deals, labour minister Abdul Manan Omari said in a statement on Tuesday. The process "will undoubtedly have a positive impact on the country's economic situation and reduce unemployment", said Abdul Ghani Baradar, the deputy prime minister for economic affairs. Nearly half of Afghanistan's population lives in poverty, and the unemployment rate (over 13 percent) affects nearly a quarter of young people aged 15 to 29, according to the World Bank. Those who do have work often support large, extended families on stretched salaries. High unemployment has been driven by infrastructure hamstrung by 40 years of conflict, drought impacting the crucial agriculture sector and the recent mass removals of Afghans from neighbouring countries, said Noorullah Fadwi, head of an association of job search companies. This year, nearly two million Afghans have returned to their country after being driven out or deported from Iran and Pakistan, where many had lived for decades. "We are grateful to Qatar and ask other (Arab) countries to hire Afghan workers too, because the situation in Iran and Pakistan is very bad," said 39-year-old Noor Mohammad, who registered in Herat, hoping for a hotel job. The Taliban authorities have not yet detailed how the Afghan recruits will be housed or their potential working conditions, while pledging to safeguard their rights. Qatar, where foreigners make up nearly 90 percent of the three million-strong population, has faced heavy criticism over the treatment of migrant labourers, particularly during construction leading up to hosting the 2022 FIFA World Cup. Qatar has since introduced major reforms to improve workers' safety and punish employers who violate the rules. It has dismantled its "kafala" labour system, which gave employers powerful rights over whether workers could leave their jobs or even the country. Mohammad Qasim, 37, said he would not go to Qatar if he could find a job in Afghanistan, but he earned a university degree in education four years ago and has been unemployed ever since. "I tried very hard to find work but there is nothing," he told AFP, saying he applied to be a cleaner at a centre in Kandahar. At least in Qatar, he said, "I will earn something." Afghan men wait in queues to submit their documents while applying for job vacancies in Qatar AFP More than a thousand people applied already in southern Kandahar for around 375 positions allocated to the region AFP The Taliban authorities have not yet said how the Afghan recruits will be housed or their potential working conditions AFP Nearly half of Afghanistan's population lives in poverty, and a quarter of people aged 15 to 29 are unemployed AFP
