French Court To Rule On Assad Immunity In Chemical Attack Case
Rights activists say that if the Court of Cassation confirms Assad does not enjoy immunity due to the severity of the accusations, it could set a major precedent in international law towards holding war criminals to account.
But if the reasoning is that the warrant is valid because France did not consider Assad to be a legitimate ruler at the time of the alleged crimes, it would not have the same impact.
French authorities issued the warrant against Assad in November 2023 over his alleged role in the chain of command for a sarin gas attack that killed more than 1,000 people, according to US intelligence, on August 4 and 5, 2013 in Adra and Douma outside Damascus.
Assad is accused of complicity in war crimes and crimes against humanity in the case, though Syrian authorities at the time denied involvement and blamed rebels.
The French judiciary tackled the case under the principle of universal jurisdiction, whereby a court may prosecute individuals for serious crimes committed in other countries.
An investigation -- based on testimonies of survivors and military defectors, as well as photos and video footage -- led to warrants for the arrest of Assad, his brother Maher who headed an elite army unit, and two generals.
Public prosecutors approved three of the warrants, but issued an appeal against the one targeting Assad, arguing he should have immunity as a head of state.
The Paris Court of Appeal in June last year however upheld it, and prosecutors again appealed.
Assad's circumstances have since changed.
He and his family fled to Russia, according to Russian authorities, after Islamist-led rebels toppled him in December last year.
Agnes Callamard, a French human rights activist and the secretary general of Amnesty International, said the court's decision could "pave the way for a major precedent in international law" if it decided immunity should be lifted in certain cases.
"A ruling lifting Bashar al-Assad's immunity would help strengthen the founding principles of international law in its fight against the impunity of war criminals," she wrote in the newspaper Liberation on Thursday.
Callamard however noted that it was unlikely any arrest warrant would lead to Assad being detained as he was protected by Russia.
The high court's prosecutor has recommended the arrest warrant be upheld, but on the grounds that France had not recognised Assad as the legitimate ruler of Syria since 2012.
Mazen Darwish, a prominent Syrian lawyer who heads the Syrian Center for Media and Freedom of Expression, a civil party to the case, said the prosecutor's argument was "very clever".
But it "undermines the moral foundation" according to which "immunity should not apply" in cases of war crimes and crimes against humanity, he said.
The reasoning "also grants a single foreign government the power to decide who is or is not a legitimate head of state, which sets an extremely dangerous precedent", he said.
French investigating magistrates in January issued a second arrest warrant against Assad for suspected complicity in war crimes for a bombing in the Syrian city of Deraa in 2017 that killed a French-Syrian civilian.
Friday's hearing is scheduled to start at 1300 GMT.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
4 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
Ill-equipped And Tired: A Night With A Ukrainian Air Defence Unit
A menacing buzz reverberates through the night sky in eastern Ukraine. Explosions ring out, flashes illuminate sunflower fields below and the smell of gunpowder poisons the air. "There! Three kilometres away!" shouted one Ukrainian serviceman in the air defence unit equipped with Soviet-era weapons and tasked with intercepting Russian drones, before they home in on Ukrainian towns and cities. The long-range unmanned aerial vehicles originally designed by Iran but improved and launched by Moscow have been devastating Ukraine since the early chapters of the Kremlin's invasion launched in early 2022. Moscow has trumpeted its industrial-scale production of the cheap weapons, with state-television broadcasting what it called the world's largest drone factory. The rare footage showed the assembly of hundreds of jet-black triangle-shaped Gerans -- geraniums in Russian. On the night in July that AFP embedded with an air defence unit in Ukraine's eastern Dnipropetrovsk region, Russia launched 344 drones, but its largest-ever barrage comprised of more than 700. "It's rotten tonight, just like the day before," said one serviceman in the air defence unit, leaning over a radar. Increasingly sophisticated Gerans are flying at higher altitudes and able to alter course en route, but Vasyl's unit is equipped with old, short-range weapons. "They fly chaotically and unpredictably. It has become harder to destroy them," the 49-year-old told AFP. "We're effective, but I can't promise that it will be like this every week," he added. Oleksandr, a fellow serviceman defending airspace near Pavlograd city, was scrutinising a radar where hundreds of red dots were appearing. "There's nothing we can do. It's not our area," he said of the incoming drones. His 20-year-old daughter, who lives in Pavlograd, was not answering her phone, he told AFP while lighting a cigarette. "But I warned her," added Oleksandr, who like others in this story identified himself with his first name or army nickname in line with military protocol. An explosion boomed, the horizon glowed crimson and dark smoke appeared in the sky moments later. President Volodymyr Zelensky has secured several Patriot batteries from allies since the invasion began and is appealing for funding for 10 more systems. But the sophisticated systems are reserved for fending off Russian missile attacks on high-priority targets and larger cities. Ukraine is instead seeking to roll out cheap interceptor drones to replace units like Vasyl's, and Zelensky has tasked manufacturers with producing up to 1,000 per day. "People and modern weapons" are what Ukraine needs to defend its air space, Vasyl told AFP. The teams get little sleep -- two hours on average, or four on a good night, and perhaps another one between drone waves, Vasyl said, adding that the deprivation takes a physical toll. One serviceman with another air defence unit in the eastern Donetsk region, who goes by Wolf, told AFP he has problems sleeping anyway due to grim memories he has fighting in east Ukraine. Belyi who works alongside Wolf was assigned to the unit regiment after he sustained a concussion and a shell blew off part of his hand while he was fighting in eastern Ukraine. Both were miners in eastern Ukraine before Moscow invaded. Russian drones are threatening their families in the city of Kryvyi Rig, in the neighbouring region further west. Neither has been granted leave to visit home in more than two years and they are instead working around the clock, seven days a week. Back near Pavlograd, sunrise reveals dark circles under the soldiers' eyes, but the buzz of a new drone wave emerges from the horizon. The unit's anti-aircraft gun fires one volley of tracer rounds, then jams. The team grabs WWII-era machine guns and fire blindly in the air. Another drone in the Russian arsenal is the Gerbera, once an unarmed decoy used to overwhelm air defence systems that have since been fitted with cameras and are targeting Vasyl's team. "Only fools are not afraid. Really," he said. On his phone he showed an image of his two blond-haired children who are now living in the capital Kyiv -- also under escalating bombardments. "I'm here for them," he told AFP. Ukrainian servicemen fire a Soviet made ZU-23 anti-aircraft twin autocannon towards a Russian drone during an air attack near Pavlograd AFP The teams get little sleep -- two hours on average, or four on a good night, and perhaps another one between drone waves AFP On the night in July that AFP embedded with an air defence unit, Russia launched 344 drones AFP
DW
10 hours ago
- DW
Putin has 10-12 day deadline to reach Ukraine deal — Trump – DW – 07/28/2025
US President Donald Trump escalated pressure on his Russian counterpart, Vladimir Putin, for Russia to make progress toward ending the war in Ukraine or face consequences. US President Donald Trump said Monday he will set a new deadline of "10 or 12 days" for Russian President Vladimir Putin to bring an end to the war in Ukraine. "I'm disappointed in President Putin," Trump told reporters as he met UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer at his luxury golf course in Turnberry, Scotland. "I'm going to make a new deadline of about 10 or 12 days from today. There's no reason in waiting, we just don't see any progress being made," he added. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Before returning to the White House in January, Trump had vowed to end the conflict within 24 hours, though he never revealed how. Trump set the 50-day deadline for Putin earlier this month after repeatedly airing frustration with his opposite number in Moscow for continuing attacks on Ukraine. The US president has threatened new sanctions on Russia and buyers of its exports unless a peace deal is reached. Trump has also aired frustration with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. None more so than when the pair had an acrimonious meeting at the White House in February when, in full view of the media, the US president earned praise from Russian officials for confronting his Ukrainian counterpart, and later declaring Zelenskyy was "not ready for peace." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Once again on Monday, Trump talked up his tough stance on the Russian president, but he has not always followed up on his promises regarding Putin. "We thought we had that settled numerous times, and then President Putin goes out and starts launching rockets into some city like Kyiv and kills a lot of people in a nursing home or whatever," Trump said. "And I say that's not the way to do it." Ukraine on Monday praised Trump for saying he would cut the 50-day deadline. "Clear stance and expressed determination — right on time, when a lot can change through strength for real peace," Zelenskyy posted on X. "I thank President Trump for his focus on saving lives and stopping this horrible war. Ukraine remains committed to peace and will work tirelessly with the US to make both our countries safer, stronger, and more prosperous." "Thanks to President Trump for standing firm and delivering a clear message of peace through strength," Ukrainian presidential aide Andriy Yermak said on social media, adding: "When America leads with strength, others think twice." Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, an escalation of a conflict that began with Moscow's annexation of Crimea in 2014. Last week, the Ukrainian and Russian delegations concluded negotiations in Istanbul by agreeing to carry out another prisoner exchange, but there was nothing that resembled a move towards peace. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
DW
12 hours ago
- DW
Israeli NGOs say Israel is committing genocide in Gaza – DW – 07/28/2025
Two prominent NGOs said Palestinians had been "stripped of their humanity and rights," accusing Israel of actively destroying Gaza's healthcare infrastructure. Israel's government said the accusations were "baseless." Two Israeli human rights organizations accused the government of Israel of committing genocide against Palestiniansin Gaza. The groups represented the first major voices within Israeli society to level the strongest possible accusation against the state. Rights group B'Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights Israel released their reports at a press conference in Jerusalem, saying Israel was carrying out "coordinated, deliberate action to destroy Palestinian society in the Gaza strip." While claiming to target only Islamist extremist group Hamas, the Israeli government carried out a policy of "mass killing" through direct attacks and by creating catastrophic living conditions in Gaza that drove the death toll higher, the NGOs said. The report also found that Israeli forces caused "serious bodily or mental harm to the entire population of the Strip" and carried out "large-scale destruction of infrastructure" along with "destruction of the social fabric, including Palestinian schools and cultural sites." "The people of Gaza have been displaced, bombed and starved, left completely stripped of their humanity and rights." said Yuli Novak, B'Tselem's executive director. Physicians for Human Rights Israel focused on damage to Gaza's healthcare system, saying: "Israel's actions have destroyed Gaza's healthcare infrastructure in a manner that is both calculated and systematic." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video An Israeli government spokesperson called the allegation made by the human rights groups "baseless." Since the early days of the Gaza war, Israel has repeatedly denied accusations of genocide—including in a case brought by South Africa at the International Court of Justice in The Hague, which Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called "outrageous." The 1948 Genocide Convention, adopted globally after the Nazi genocide of Jews during World War II, defines genocide as intentional acts meant to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. When Amnesty International last December accused Israel of committing genocidal acts, Israel's foreign ministry slammed the global rights group as a "deplorable and fanatical organization."
