Cost-of-living: Judgment reserved in anti-poverty strategy challenge
Judgment has been reserved in a legal challenge brought against Stormont for "failing to adopt" an anti-poverty strategy for Northern Ireland.The human rights group, the Committee on the Administration of Justice (CAJ), has claimed that ministers have failed to put in place a programme to alleviate poverty.The challenge is directed against the Department for Communities and the Executive Office, along with the first and deputy first ministers.A lawyer representing the human rights group, Karen Quinlivan KC, described the case "as an attack on the lack of an anti-poverty strategy".
A spokesperson for the Department for Communities said that a strategy is currently in development.Ms Quinlivan said it had been a decade since the High Court previously held that the Executive committee was "in breach of its duty" to adopt a programme to deal with poverty.She added: "It is frankly appalling that that breach had never been rectified."The court heard the requirement to adopt an anti-poverty strategy was inserted into the Northern Ireland Act, following the St Andrews Agreement in 2006.The case, brought by the CAJ, is also supported by members of the Equality Coalition including Unison, Barnardo's NI and the Northern Ireland Anti-Poverty Network.
A lawyer representing the different departments argued the current legal duty to adopt a strategy only commenced when the current Executive was formed in February 2024.He added that progress is now being made to ensure any legal obligations are met.The judge, Mr Justice Humphreys, reserved judgment until a later date.
'Still without a strategy'
Speaking outside court the director of the CAJ, Daniel Holder, said he was concerned the current Assembly mandate would expire without an anti-poverty strategy in place.He said: "There are a whole series of measures that were recommended for Stormont to pick up within an anti-poverty strategy on issues like child poverty, child payments, the establishment of a child poverty commission... None of that is in place."We are a full year on from the Executive being re-established and we are still without an anti-poverty strategy with those elements in it."
Emma Cassidy, senior engagement lead for Public Interest Litigation Support, which is supporting CAJ, said the group was "challenging nearly two decades of delay".She said she hoped the court would "compel" politicians to take action."We are still in the grips of a cost of living - or cost of survival – crisis and there's no plan of how this is going to be sorted out," she said."It sounds bizarre if it wasn't so serious."John Patrick Clayton from Unison described a strategy as "absolutely vital".He said he hoped today was an "important step" towards it being taken forward by the Executive.He added that tackling poverty needs "to be collectively taken forward by the executive as a whole" and a "strategy is the right way to do that".
Cross-departmental commitment
A spokesperson for the Department for Communities said that the Northern Ireland Executive Anti-Poverty Strategy, which is currently in development, "will aim to mitigate impacts, reduce the risk of falling into poverty and support people in exiting poverty". The spokesperson continued: "It will set out a cross-departmental commitment to a joined-up, long term approach to addressing poverty and the department is currently engaging with colleagues across all other departments to refine the draft strategy and the action plan that will underpin it with a view to a paper being presented to the Executive in the coming weeks."The spokesperson said the department "continues to provide support and a wide range of services to those in need". Benefits entitlement can be checked through the Make the Call service.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
What will Spending Review mean for NI public services?
Next week the Chancellor Rachel Reeves will reveal the outcome of her Spending will allocate money to day-to-day public services for the next three will also set infrastructure budgets for the next four review will directly impact on what Stormont Ministers have to spend on public services in Northern Ireland. What do we already know? Last year Reeves set what is known as the "spending envelope" – the amount by which total government spending will change in a given spending is planned to grow by an average of 1.2% above the rate of inflation each year for the next three spending is planned to grow by 1.3% above inflation a year over the next four are much lower growth rates than this year and last year, reflecting the new government's "emergency" injection of cash into the health service and public sector pay Wednesday the Chancellor will break it down further, making allocations to each central government precise allocation of this money matters for Stormont's spending plans. Health vs Defence: Why it matters? More than 90% of what Stormont ministers have to spend comes from the Treasury through what is known as "the block grant."The increase in the block grant is worked out using a calculation known as the Barnett formula, which is based on the annual changes in UK central government departmental gives Stormont an equivalent spending increase for the size of the NI population, adjusted for the extent to which each service is services, like health, are almost entirely devolved but defence is not the government decides it is going to spend more on defence at the expense of other services that will have an impact on the amount of extra money in the Stormont simple terms: If the UK Department of Health sees its budget increase by £100m, then Northern Ireland would get approximately £3m the Ministry of Defence budget increases by £100m Stormont does not get anything extra. A bigger Stormont top-up? When devolution was restored in 2024 the government agreed a financial package which included an automatic top-up of any money awarded by the Barnett government was persuaded that the level of need in Northern Ireland means it requires spending of £124 per head for every £100 per head spent in Northern Ireland was funded below that level, the government said that in future every £1 that comes through the Barnett formula will now come with an extra will apply until the overall level of funding need is independent Fiscal Council has estimated that will be worth £815m over five government said the size of the top up could be reviewed if "independent and credible sources" provide that end the Executive commissioned a study from the economist Prof Gerry Holtham, an expert in the devolution of public BBC understands that his work has come back with a range of possible funding central estimates are £123 per head, for every £100 spent in England, if agricultural spending is excluded and £128 per head if agriculture forms part of the the Treasury is persuaded to accept the higher end of the range it will be worth tens of millions of pounds extra over the next five years. Softening the cliff edge? The devolution financial package also brought a large dollop of one-off UK government funding, largely to pay for public sector pay that creates a cliff-edge drop in Stormont funding of about £500m in 2026/27 when that short term money runs government committed to review "concerns about 2026-27 funding" at the Spending Fiscal Council has suggested options to tackle the cliff edge could include more one-off funding or setting a new, higher baseline for Stormont's it is also possible that the normal operation of Spending Review will allocate enough money to largely remove the cliff edge. Casement Park breakthrough? The Chancellor will be allocating trillions of pounds in the Spending Review but it is a tiny fraction of that which may have most political impact in Northern is a growing expectation that the UK government will come up with additional money for the construction of a new GAA stadium at Casement Park in project has been bogged down in labyrinthine planning and funding GAA official leading the project has told the BBC he is cautiously optimistic that the Spending Review will include a new financial contribution for the redevelopment project.
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Stormont strategy to tackle poverty 'not fit for purpose'
The first draft strategy agreed by the Northern Ireland Executive to tackle poverty is "not fit for purpose", according to a children's anti-poverty strategy was first proposed in 2006, with the aim of reducing social exclusion and March, Stormont's Executive Committee was found by a court ruling to be in breach of its legal obligation to adopt the News NI has now seen a leaked copy of the document, which was agreed by executive ministers earlier in May, but has yet to be made public. 'No new actions' Trása Canavan of Barnardo's NI, who is also chair of the Anti- Poverty Strategy Group, was among groups who met Communities Minister Gordon Lyons earlier this week about the said she had "serious concerns that it will not make any difference to the lives of the children, families and communities that our organisations support every day, and we raised this with minister Lyons this week"."The current draft of the Anti-Poverty Strategy is not fit for purpose. "It clearly shows that the government has committed no new actions or funding to tackle poverty in Northern Ireland."The 28-page paper sets out the executive's approach to tackling poverty over the next 10 outlines efforts already being taken by various departments to help minimise the risks of people falling into poverty in Northern Ireland, as well as reducing its impacts and ways to help people get out of poverty. The document states that poverty is "not a problem which the executive can solve in isolation", but one that requires community groups, business, councils and voluntary groups to adds that the strategy will be accompanied by a programme of delivery to be updated on an ongoing Canavan added that earlier this year her group had outlined what it wanted to see in the document in order for it to be effective."This included clear and time-bound targets, a lifecycle approach, new actions and clear funding commitments, rather than counting work that is already under way."Unfortunately, the draft strategy does not meet any of these key principles."It is quite simply not good enough for the people of Northern Ireland. "Our group remains committed to working constructively with the government to eradicating poverty in Northern Ireland." 'Deeply underwhelmed' The SDLP, Stormont's official opposition, said it is "impossible to be anything other than deeply underwhelmed" by the H Durkan said the executive should be "embarrassed to present a document that reads more like a list of vague hopes than a plan of action".The paper sets out measures already being taken by the executive and says it will "continue to deliver a package of welfare mitigations" while lobbying Westminster on reforms and to maintain the triple lock on adds that legislation being brought by Education Minister Paul Givan will ensure all school uniforms are affordable, and that strategies on fuel poverty will be also promises that "everyone, including those in or at risk of poverty, has access to good quality, affordable and sustainable homes".But Durkan said: "This document acknowledges the direct link between housing and poverty and yet the Executive have confirmed they will only build half of the homes intended this year."The strategy also fails to confront one of the most damaging policies hitting low-income families: the two-child limit. Ministers have the power to address these issues, but once again they've chosen not to."When it was agreed last month by the executive, First Minister Michelle O'Neill said the plan probably could "go further" but denied there was a row between Sinn Fein and the DUP over it. 'Fiscal challenges' Communities Minister, Gordon Lyons, whose department oversaw the design of the draft strategy, said it had "drawn heavily on the work that has already been carried out".The DUP minister succeeded Sinn Féín's Deirdre Hargey in the role when Stormont was restored in 2024 after a two-year Department for Communities said: "The draft Strategy reflects the Executive's priorities in the context of the ongoing fiscal and other challenges we face."The minister has listened to a wide range of views ahead of the consultation launch, which will give people from all communities a chance to have their say on how we tackle poverty and transform lives in Northern Ireland. "Minister Lyons would encourage all stakeholders in this area to provide their feedback when the consultation formally opens."It added that officials were working to launch the consultation as soon as possible.
South Wales Guardian
3 days ago
- South Wales Guardian
Antrim Gaels urge Secretary of State to honour promises around Casement Park
It comes as long-awaited plans for the redevelopment of the now derelict ground remain mired in uncertainty. Plans for a 34,000-capacity venue face a major funding gap of around £150 million. Stormont has committed £62.5 million to Casement, while the Irish Government has offered roughly £42 million and the GAA has pledged to contribute at least £15 million. There has been speculation the UK government will announce next week whether it will plug the remaining funding gap for the estimated £270 million cost. Ahead of that, representatives of South Antrim GAA, including young people from clubs across the county, travelled to the Northern Ireland Office base at Erskine House in Belfast city centre to hand a letter in to Mr Benn. The letter notes that next week will mark the 12th anniversary of the last GAA game to be played at Casement Park. They said while investment in the Windsor Park football stadium and rugby ground at Ravenhill promised in 2011 were delivered, Casement is still waiting. The letter also refers to further disappointment last year when hopes of rebuilding Casement as a venue for the 2028 Euros were dashed. It reminded Mr Benn of an assurance by former secretary of state Chris Heaton-Harris that funding would be found to rebuild Casement. 'That promise was as empty as the stands at Casement Park today, and the Euros will now be played elsewhere,' they said. 'The GAA, the Irish Government and the Executive have each made formal commitments to this project, all of which remain firmly in place. 'We are now calling on you as Secretary of State, to honour the commitment given to our members that Casement Park will be built, and that the money will be found.' The letter continued: 'Casement Park will leave a legacy that transforms Gaelic Games in Antrim and Ulster, creating unparalleled sporting and economic opportunities, and enhancing community relations setting the tone for reconciliation that will be remembered for generations to come. 'It's time to stop the dithering and delay. It's time to live up to all the promises and commitments. It's time to finally build Casement.'
