logo
Indonesia faces brain drain as skilled graduates leave for jobs abroad

Indonesia faces brain drain as skilled graduates leave for jobs abroad

Straits Times2 days ago

A recent report finds Indonesia lagging other countries in South-east Asia when it comes to youth employment. PHOTO: THE JAKARTA POST/ANN
JAKARTA – Indonesia has seen an increasing outflow of skilled young adults seeking work abroad in a brain drain phenomenon experts attribute to concern around job opportunities within the country.
Twenty-five-year-old political science graduate Fikri Haikal obtained a working holiday visa (WHV) in Australia and now makes a living as a poultry factory worker.
'I never thought I would be a factory worker,' he said, explaining that his original plan was to go abroad for higher education, but he failed to get a scholarship, and peer influence then convinced him to join the WHV programme instead.
He searched and applied for jobs in Indonesia, Mr Fikri said, but received no job offers.
'Meanwhile, in Australia, securing a job is easy, because there is a shortage of labour in certain sectors, such as in manufacturing,' he told The Jakarta Post on May 23.
Indonesians are the largest citizenship group in Australia's WHV programme, with the number of granted visas surging from 2,984 in the 2022-2023 period to 4,285 in 2023-2024, according to the Australian Department of Home Affairs.
On social media, graduates and young professionals have been sharing their experiences with the WHV programme, citing better pay and quality of life, though some caution that 'it is not as easy as it looks'.
Frustrated jobseekers
The hashtag #KaburAjaDulu (Just get out first) has been gaining traction on social media in 2025, as frustration and pessimism mount over Indonesia's economic situation and work conditions, encouraging people to seek better jobs abroad.
The blue-collar job in Australia provides Mr Fikri with a salary exceeding his living costs, in addition to access to public facilities and a diverse sociocultural experience.
On the other side of the globe, Ms Viona Maharani, a graduate from a vocational tourism college in Bali, is interning in the hospitality industry after recently relocating to the United States.
With prior experience as a casual worker at three five-star hotels in Bali, Ms Viona sought to develop her career.
Acquaintances of hers who had worked abroad told her that the US offered better opportunities for income and skill development.
'I will highly (value opportunities) to keep enriching my experience of working abroad, whether that will continue to be in the US or another country,' Ms Viona said.
Experts say this brain drain – or the large-scale emigration of highly educated graduates and skilled professionals in search of better opportunities and a higher standard of living – threatens economic growth, if not handled properly.
Centre of Reform on Economics (Core) Indonesia executive director Mohammad Faisal warned that a prolonged brain drain could lead to Indonesia losing its best talent that would otherwise contribute to job creation at home by helping to attract investment and driving technological progress.
Limited job opportunities mean the country's skilled workforce is not optimally absorbed, he said, as reflected in a shrinking share of formal, compared with informal, employment.
A recent report published by Core finds Indonesia lagging other countries in South-east Asia when it comes to youth employment, or those aged 15 to 24.
In 2024, the International Labour Organisation estimated that the youth unemployment rate in Indonesia stood at 13.1 per cent, higher than in peer countries like India, Malaysia, Vietnam, the Philippines and Thailand.
A biannual survey published earlier in June by Statistics Indonesia (BPS) put youth unemployment at 16.16 per cent, more than three times the overall unemployment rate of 4.76 per cent.
According to the Core report, the stagnating youth employment reflects a failure to tap into Indonesia's demographic dividend, with Indonesia now at risk of a demographic paradox: getting old before getting rich.
Mr Tadjuddin Noer Effendi, a labour expert at Gadjah Mada University (UGM), expressed doubt about the 'Golden Indonesia' vision of turning the country into one of the world's largest economies by 2045, given that skilled talent was moving abroad.
'The brain drain can slow down innovation and hinder technological development, which ultimately affects economic competitiveness,' he said.
Mr Tadjuddin also argued that the brain drain was driven by increasing labour market uncertainty amid a lack of job opportunities and a surge in layoffs in 2025, as well as by widespread corruption and extortion disrupting the investment climate.
He warned that the emigration of skilled workers could leave sectors like health, technology and education facing labour shortages, and should more young and productive workers move overseas, the country risked being left with an aging population.
From brain drain to brain gain?
However, Mr Tajuddin noted a silver lining in the fact that migrants were often 'heroes of foreign exchange'.
Often well paid, Indonesian skilled workers living abroad could contribute to an increase in foreign exchange through remittances.
Migrants have long contributed significantly to the country's foreign exchange receipts, with the remittance inflow rising 13 per cent to 253 trillion rupiah (S$20 billion) in 2024, according to the Indonesian Migrant Workers Protection Agency (BP2MI).
Mr Tajuddin also suggested that the government seize the opportunity of maximising the potential of brain gain, which would require providing adequate innovation infrastructure and facilities to attract and retain skilled talent.
'In the future, if the government can (invite Indonesians living abroad) back to Indonesia, it will be a huge gain, because they have plenty of experience and knowledge from abroad,' he said. THE JAKARTA POST/ASIA NEWS NETWORK
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Indonesia faces brain drain as skilled graduates leave for jobs abroad
Indonesia faces brain drain as skilled graduates leave for jobs abroad

Straits Times

time2 days ago

  • Straits Times

Indonesia faces brain drain as skilled graduates leave for jobs abroad

A recent report finds Indonesia lagging other countries in South-east Asia when it comes to youth employment. PHOTO: THE JAKARTA POST/ANN JAKARTA – Indonesia has seen an increasing outflow of skilled young adults seeking work abroad in a brain drain phenomenon experts attribute to concern around job opportunities within the country. Twenty-five-year-old political science graduate Fikri Haikal obtained a working holiday visa (WHV) in Australia and now makes a living as a poultry factory worker. 'I never thought I would be a factory worker,' he said, explaining that his original plan was to go abroad for higher education, but he failed to get a scholarship, and peer influence then convinced him to join the WHV programme instead. He searched and applied for jobs in Indonesia, Mr Fikri said, but received no job offers. 'Meanwhile, in Australia, securing a job is easy, because there is a shortage of labour in certain sectors, such as in manufacturing,' he told The Jakarta Post on May 23. Indonesians are the largest citizenship group in Australia's WHV programme, with the number of granted visas surging from 2,984 in the 2022-2023 period to 4,285 in 2023-2024, according to the Australian Department of Home Affairs. On social media, graduates and young professionals have been sharing their experiences with the WHV programme, citing better pay and quality of life, though some caution that 'it is not as easy as it looks'. Frustrated jobseekers The hashtag #KaburAjaDulu (Just get out first) has been gaining traction on social media in 2025, as frustration and pessimism mount over Indonesia's economic situation and work conditions, encouraging people to seek better jobs abroad. The blue-collar job in Australia provides Mr Fikri with a salary exceeding his living costs, in addition to access to public facilities and a diverse sociocultural experience. On the other side of the globe, Ms Viona Maharani, a graduate from a vocational tourism college in Bali, is interning in the hospitality industry after recently relocating to the United States. With prior experience as a casual worker at three five-star hotels in Bali, Ms Viona sought to develop her career. Acquaintances of hers who had worked abroad told her that the US offered better opportunities for income and skill development. 'I will highly (value opportunities) to keep enriching my experience of working abroad, whether that will continue to be in the US or another country,' Ms Viona said. Experts say this brain drain – or the large-scale emigration of highly educated graduates and skilled professionals in search of better opportunities and a higher standard of living – threatens economic growth, if not handled properly. Centre of Reform on Economics (Core) Indonesia executive director Mohammad Faisal warned that a prolonged brain drain could lead to Indonesia losing its best talent that would otherwise contribute to job creation at home by helping to attract investment and driving technological progress. Limited job opportunities mean the country's skilled workforce is not optimally absorbed, he said, as reflected in a shrinking share of formal, compared with informal, employment. A recent report published by Core finds Indonesia lagging other countries in South-east Asia when it comes to youth employment, or those aged 15 to 24. In 2024, the International Labour Organisation estimated that the youth unemployment rate in Indonesia stood at 13.1 per cent, higher than in peer countries like India, Malaysia, Vietnam, the Philippines and Thailand. A biannual survey published earlier in June by Statistics Indonesia (BPS) put youth unemployment at 16.16 per cent, more than three times the overall unemployment rate of 4.76 per cent. According to the Core report, the stagnating youth employment reflects a failure to tap into Indonesia's demographic dividend, with Indonesia now at risk of a demographic paradox: getting old before getting rich. Mr Tadjuddin Noer Effendi, a labour expert at Gadjah Mada University (UGM), expressed doubt about the 'Golden Indonesia' vision of turning the country into one of the world's largest economies by 2045, given that skilled talent was moving abroad. 'The brain drain can slow down innovation and hinder technological development, which ultimately affects economic competitiveness,' he said. Mr Tadjuddin also argued that the brain drain was driven by increasing labour market uncertainty amid a lack of job opportunities and a surge in layoffs in 2025, as well as by widespread corruption and extortion disrupting the investment climate. He warned that the emigration of skilled workers could leave sectors like health, technology and education facing labour shortages, and should more young and productive workers move overseas, the country risked being left with an aging population. From brain drain to brain gain? However, Mr Tajuddin noted a silver lining in the fact that migrants were often 'heroes of foreign exchange'. Often well paid, Indonesian skilled workers living abroad could contribute to an increase in foreign exchange through remittances. Migrants have long contributed significantly to the country's foreign exchange receipts, with the remittance inflow rising 13 per cent to 253 trillion rupiah (S$20 billion) in 2024, according to the Indonesian Migrant Workers Protection Agency (BP2MI). Mr Tajuddin also suggested that the government seize the opportunity of maximising the potential of brain gain, which would require providing adequate innovation infrastructure and facilities to attract and retain skilled talent. 'In the future, if the government can (invite Indonesians living abroad) back to Indonesia, it will be a huge gain, because they have plenty of experience and knowledge from abroad,' he said. THE JAKARTA POST/ASIA NEWS NETWORK Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.

From marketplace to mess: Tokopedia unravels after merger
From marketplace to mess: Tokopedia unravels after merger

Business Times

time5 days ago

  • Business Times

From marketplace to mess: Tokopedia unravels after merger

IT ALL started with a two million rupiah (S$158) discount. Ary Mozta, a Jakarta-based marketing executive, runs a Tokopedia shop where he sells his pre-loved electronic gadgets. In April, the marketplace offered him the above coupon, which he can use to offset seller fees. There was just one catch: he had to migrate to TikTok Shop. The request was not a surprise. After all, TikTok shelled out US$1.8 billion last year in a megadeal to acquire 75 per cent of Tokopedia, just to keep TikTok Shop running in the country. Mozta complied with the request. However, the coupon did not work, and he ended up paying the full amount of 1.3 million rupiah. On May 4, he complained to Tokopedia's customer service team. A month later, the issue has not been resolved. Mozta has since stopped selling on the platform. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Nearly 1.5 years after the deal was announced, TikTok Shop is still struggling to integrate with Tokopedia. Frustrated sellers have taken to social media to air their complaints about the process. As ByteDance remakes Tokopedia in TikTok Shop's image, merchants and employees worry it will be a hollowed-out version of its former self. Massive layoffs at TikTok Shop, possibly as soon as July, are also on the table. A TikTok spokesperson tells Tech in Asia that it is committed to 'continue investing in Tokopedia and Indonesia'. But beneath the complaints about slumping sales and logistical snags lies something deeper: a sense of loss over an e-commerce platform that was once an important part of many Indonesians' daily lives. Mozta wrote in a LinkedIn post that he 'barely recognises the place'. Here's where the cracks started to show. The quiet toll on one merchant One of TikTok Shop's tweaks? Auto-accepting orders. Not a simple adjustment for Agus Mulyono. He has run a business card-focused print shop on Tokopedia since 2016. Previously, sellers could manually accept orders, giving them time to check inventory or, in Mulyono's case, confirm whether a customer's file was ready for printing. With auto-accepting orders, merchants must cancel manually, risking hits to their ratings. Mulyono's cash flow is also feeling the squeeze. Tokopedia used to release funds two days after delivery, assuming that most buyers rarely hit the 'confirm' button and had received their orders in good condition. But that grace period has quietly stretched up to six days for non-integrated merchants, while integrated ones get three days. Free delivery promos can further complicate matters. Previously, sellers could opt out of offering free delivery. Now, it's mandatory: all Tokopedia Plus members automatically get free shipping, whether sellers like it or not. 'If you are a buyer, of course you are happy, because you can buy something for 10,000 rupiah and still get free delivery,' said Mulyono. Free delivery promos also lead to another issue. Tokopedia sellers often have preferred third-party logistics (3PLs) providers, based on hard-earned experience. Mulyono, for example, stands by local player JNE. It's not the cheapest option, but it's consistently reliable. But sellers cannot choose free delivery couriers – Tokopedia does, based on its own priorities such as cost. Sellers can end up getting stuck with 3PLs that offer lower service levels, like slow pickups or late deliveries. Mulyono's store sits in a bustling part of Jakarta, so orders are typically picked up the same day or the next. But lately, some have sat untouched for up to two days before a courier shows up. Not having free rein on couriers can cause friction with Mulyono's customers, who often need business cards on short notice. But more often than not, customers will choose free delivery promos. Sidelined sellers, silent layoffs One early red flag for Mulyono came in 2024, when Tokopedia laid off its account managers, including the one he'd worked with. 'From then on, they only provided account managers to national brands such as Unilever,' he said. Tech in Asia understands that non-major brands can still qualify for account managers, but smaller 'homemade' stores – even those with official store status – were generally cut off. The result: smaller merchants feel sidelined while big brands get top billing. Mulyono saw it firsthand while juggling multiple 3PLs. 'Large brands typically use an e-commerce enabler to handle their e-commerce orders, so this isn't an issue for them,' said a current Tokopedia executive. 'But MSMEs don't have the resources to send packages to multiple 3PLs every day.' TikTok Shop is also rumoured on social media to be planning the shutdown of Dilayani Tokopedia, a fulfilment service that gave MSME sellers outside Java access to warehouses and cheaper shipping. Focusing on MSMEs should be a no-brainer for a company with Tokopedia's DNA. But the integration has left not just small merchants but also the company's own staff feeling sidelined. It's understood that ByteDance, as a global platform, makes strategic calls from its Singapore headquarters and rolls them out top-down. That includes Tokopedia ads, now folded into TikTok Shop's system. Sellers who want to run campaigns on the platform now have a steeper budget requirement of at least 500,000 rupiah. The focus now is 'maintenance mode', as in doing business as usual instead of innovating, says one former employee. Resources such as marketing budgets are mostly funnelled to TikTok Shop. 'This has made many employees demotivated,' said the former employee. 'We are less involved in the discovery stage of an initiative and mostly only handle the execution part.' Layoffs were inevitable. Beyond the 2024 cut of account managers, employees say the hits kept coming, quietly, and more often than the headlines suggest. 'The mass layoffs happened with [junior level] employees at the beginning,' says the current Tokopedia executive. In some divisions, as much as half the team was let go, the person adds. Some cuts come disguised as performance reviews, suggests the executive. Affected employees often walk away with severance worth about 1.5x their tenure, though the amount can vary. 'In terms of morale, many are already tired and are just waiting for the golden handshake,' said the current executive, referring to the severance package. 'Chances for career advancements are almost nonexistent, and many high-level employees and leaders are also set to be cut.' A TikTok spokesperson says the company 'routinely evaluates business needs and makes adjustments,' but they declined to share how many have been retrenched since the integration. Where TikTok takes Tokopedia now Shopee now dominates Indonesia's e-commerce scene by a wide margin, according to estimates by market intelligence firm Sensor Tower. Tokopedia has slipped behind Lazada as of the first quarter of 2025. However, according to data on the Tokopedia app, Tokopedia and TikTok Shop together serve 200 million consumers. Since TikTok Shop is not a standalone app, this figure likely reflects TikTok's total user base in Indonesia. SOURCE: SENSOR TOWER ESTIMATES There's some concern around anti-competition, but it's not a deal-breaker – as long as Shopee, Lazada, and Blibli are still in the game, says Heru Sutadi, executive director at the Indonesia ICT Institute and a former commissioner at the country's consumer protection agency. KPPU, the Indonesian commission handling competition laws, recently raised concerns over the TikTok-Tokopedia deal, citing a 'significant increase in market concentration', among other things. One 'proactive measure,' Sutadi says, is blocking TikTok Shop from selling its own goods on the platform – a response to TikTok's Project S test run in 2023. Sentimentality aside, Tokopedia has plenty to learn from ByteDance. The former employee admits the Chinese giant is 'far more advanced', with deeper talent, a stronger tech stack, and far bigger bets on R&D. Still, both Mozta and Mulyono agree that nothing today matches what Tokopedia was in its prime: a homegrown marketplace built for Indonesia. 'Maybe TikTok offers automation, or is faster and cheaper. But if that means sacrificing some parts of our 'local wisdom' or what made the business successful, it's very unfortunate,' Mulyono said. He's still selling with Tokopedia, at least for now. Could TikTok Shop actually retire the Tokopedia brand? Unlikely, say employees – the reputation risk far outweighs the reward. 'I see all this as a pure business decision,' said the former employee. However, 'it's sad to see [TikTok Shop] slowly tone down a company that we were so proud of.' TECH IN ASIA

Indonesian jailed for Bali bombing starts coffee business, Asia News
Indonesian jailed for Bali bombing starts coffee business, Asia News

AsiaOne

time5 days ago

  • AsiaOne

Indonesian jailed for Bali bombing starts coffee business, Asia News

SURABAYA, Indonesia - An Indonesian convicted in the deadly 2002 Bali nightclub bombings has launched his own coffee business after being released on parole, and has said he will use some of the earnings to help survivors of the attacks. Umar Patek, a member of the al Qaeda-linked Jemaah Islamiyah group, was jailed for 20 years in 2012 after he was found guilty of making bombs that ripped through two Bali nightclubs, killing 202 people, including 88 Australians and 38 Indonesians. He was released on parole in 2022 and has apologised to the victims. Patek's release sparked anger in Australia and Indonesia. At the launch of the coffee business on Tuesday (June 3), a banner with Patek's face festooned a cafe in the Indonesian city of Surabaya on Java island. It is owned by dentist David Andreasmito and will use the beans Patek supplies and roasts. "I was still shell-shocked by the outside world," Patek said, adding he had trouble finding work after his release and was worried his image would affect the business. "The stigma of a former terrorism convict made it hard for me to find work," he said. Patek said he understood that many people were still angry with him but pleaded to them "not to let that doubt stick", adding he would give portions of his earnings to survivors. David said he went into business with Patek because he had apologised and wanted people to give him a second chance. Since Patek's release, Indonesian authorities have highlighted him as an example of the deradicalisation efforts launched by the world's most populous Muslim-majority country to counter a resurgence in Islamic militancy. Chusnul Chotimah, a survivor of the Bali attacks who is covered in burn scars and says she struggles to pay for life-saving treatments, jostled in front of the crowd to speak to Patek at the launch. "I used to have grudges against you," she said. "I forgive you for what you did. I know you've changed for the better." Chusnul later said she hoped Patek could help out the survivors. "Don't just say sorry," she said. Tumini, another survivor, said in Bali's capital Denpasar that she is still struggling to pay for her treatment and that government aid should be prioritised for victims still in recovery. [[nid:714944]]

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store