Council fined millions after three busway deaths
Jennifer Taylor, Steve Moir and Kathleen Pitts died after collisions on the Cambridgeshire busway between 2015 and 2021.
Sentencing Cambridgeshire County Council at Cambridge Crown Court, Judge Mark Bishop criticised the authority for its "rigid and blinkered response" to the fatalities, as well as numerous near-misses and accidents.
The authority previously admitted two safety breaches and said it was "truly sorry". It was ordered to pay the fine over three years.
Cambridgeshire County Council runs the transport link that serves Cambridge, St Ives and Huntingdon. It opened in 2011 and much of the 16-mile (26km) route involves a modified bus being guided along a track.
Ms Taylor, 81, was hit by a bus when she crossed the track on foot at Fen Drayton in November 2015.
Mr Moir, 50, fell into the path of a bus after clipping a kerb with his bicycle that separated him from the busway in Cambridge, in September 2018.
Pedestrian Kathleen Pitts, 52, was struck by a bus on the same stretch in October 2021.
A fourth person, Leon Leeson, was left with memory loss, a broken collarbone, a tear in his liver and the loss of hearing in one ear, following an incident.
The county council previously admitted two charges under Section 3 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, relating to the public trying to cross the busway at designated crossings and being struck while moving alongside the busway.
In a statement, the family of Ms Taylor said: "As a family we would like to thank the HSE [Health and Safety Executive] for their tireless efforts in bringing this case to court.
"We hope that the lessons learned will lead to sustained safety improvements and help avoid tragedy, injury and suffering in the future.
"Jenny was deeply loved by all of us, and we dearly miss her."
Mr Moir's brother, Rob Moir, said outside court afterwards: "There are no winners here. It's taxpayers' money at the end of the day.
"Hopefully it will be sufficient to make sure that not just this county council but other people, other councils, wake up and make sure they apply the due diligence that they should to health and safety."
The council's chief executive, Stephen Moir, said he was "truly sorry for these failures".
"This should never have happened," he said.
Dr Moir promised the failings the court considered would not be repeated and said changes had been made to the busway's safety regime.
It included installing fencing on the southern section of the busway, reduced speed limits and reviews of all signs.
He said: "I'd like to reassure all those who use the guided busway that we have learnt our lessons the hard way and changed our approach for the future.
"The busway is and remains an important, accessible and safe public transport system for all the people who live in, work in, travel through or visit Cambridgeshire."
In court, the council was criticised for its dismissive and defensive handling of concerns that included poor signage, unsafe crossings and poor lighting.
It heard there was no risk assessment in place until 2016 - a fact the judge described as "particularly shocking".
Several accidents had also never been reported to the HSE, the court was told.
It heard that when the health and safety watchdog issued an improvement notice in 2018, the authority appealed the notice.
The council claimed it was "unwarranted and unlawful" as it had never been in breach of safety laws, the court was told.
Ben Compton KC, for Cambridgeshire County Council, requested that the authority be given six years to pay the £6m, adding: "It's a council - these are hard times."
But the judge rejected this, saying it had more than £18m in reserves to cover legal risks. It gave it three years to pay, and ordered that it paid more than £292,000 in outstanding costs.
Follow Cambridgeshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Busway death 'a preventable accident', court told
Judge due to sentence council after busway deaths
Health and Safety Executive
Cambridgeshire County Council
The Busway
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
08-08-2025
- Yahoo
County Durham waste company fined after worker crushed by excavator
A County Durham waste management company has been fined after an employee was run over by an excavator and left with serious injuries. The 24-year-old Farm XS (Northern) Limited employee was only in his second week of employment at the Staindrop Road site when he was struck from behind by an excavator and run over. He suffered fractures to both feet. An investigation by the Health and Safety Executive found that the company had failed to ensure a safe system of work was in place. The employee was working on a waste pile near moving vehicles with no physical separation between them and there was no risk assessment or system of work to protect pedestrians from vehicle movements. HSE guidance clearly states that pedestrians and vehicles should be segregated when waste is being manually sorted, and by law, employers must ensure traffic routes can be used without risking the safety of workers nearby. . READ MORE: Man arrested over 'strangulation and suffocation' at Haggerston Castle Holiday Park READ MORE: Three children riding on back of motorcycle seriously injured in Kenton crash as biker flees scene At Teesside Magistrates' Court on Tuesday, August 5, Farm XS (Northern) Limited, of Shaw Bank, Barnard Castle, pleaded guilty to breaching section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at work Act 1974. It was fined £4,000 and ordered to pay £4,285 in costs. After the hearing, HSE inspector Richard McMullen said: "The outcome could have been much worse. But the failures that day meant a worker received serious injuries. "This incident was easily avoidable by implementing control measures and safe practices to ensure that workers were not put at risk from moving vehicles, including clear segregation and safe refuges. This should be a reminder to the waste industry of the need to consider workplace transport risks and to introduce appropriate control measures to separate vehicles and pedestrians." Our ChronicleLive Daily newsletter is free. You can sign up to receive it here. It will keep you up to date with all the latest breaking news and top stories from the North East.
Yahoo
07-08-2025
- Yahoo
Council fined after ‘preventable' death of care home dementia patient
A council has been fined following the 'preventable' death of a dementia patient who went missing from a care home during the night. Allan MacLeod, 69, disappeared from his bedroom at St Brendan's Care Home in Castlebay on the Isle of Barra in the early hours of March 9 last year without staff realising. He was found near the home about four hours after going missing, with facial injuries consistent with falling, and died a short time later in hospital. Western Isles Council was fined £80,000 at Lochmaddy Sheriff Court on Wednesday August 6 after it admitted breaching the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said. Mr MacLeod had been a resident at the home – one of five operated by the council throughout the Western Isles – for about six months at the time of his death. An HSE investigation by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) determined that he had made several previous attempts to leave the home. It found that any measures that staff had taken to mitigate this, by fitting an electronic tag to his clothing that indicated his whereabouts, had been defeated by Mr MacLeod removing it. HSE said that on March 8, having been settled in bed at about 9pm, hourly checks were carried out to ensure he was alright however, at 2am on March 9, staff found that he was not in his bed. Investigations found that he had left the home via the only door that did not have an alarm which was located 10 metres from his bedroom. Following a search involving the coastguard, RNLI and firefighters, he was found near the home on the patio of a residential property. HSE inspector Ashley Fallis said: 'This was a tragic and preventable death. The council should have made sure the home had stronger measures in place with Mr MacLeod's risks already known and assessed. 'Although changes have since been made, they came too late to prevent his death.' HSE said that after Mr MacLeod's death, the home introduced a regime of half hourly checks on residents. Arrangements had already been made to install keypad entry systems on all doors, but this work had not been completed before he died. A spokesperson for Western Isles Council (Comhairle nan Eilean Siar) said: 'Comhairle nan Eilean Siar once again extends its sincere condolences to the family and friends of the late Mr Allan F MacLeod for the circumstances surrounding his tragic passing on 9 March 2024. 'Yesterday at Lochmaddy Sheriff Court, the comhairle accepted that health and safety shortcomings contributed to the tragic incident and pled guilty to the charges brought by the procurator fiscal. 'The comhairle hopes that the conclusion of this case will offer the family some closure. 'The door security system in use at St Brendan's Care Home was a key factor in this case. 'A new door security system had been procured but at the time of the incident the works to install it had not been completed. 'Comhairle nan Eilean Siar is committed to the delivery of high standards of care to all residents in our residential homes. In this instance these standards were not fully met. 'The comhairle has implemented health and safety improvements and will continue to work with the Care Inspectorate to ensure that our residential homes operate to the highest possible standards.'
Yahoo
24-07-2025
- Yahoo
Scottish airport fined £144,000 for failures that led to death of employee
The company that runs Glasgow Prestwick Airport has been fined more than £144,000 for failures that led to a member of airport staff falling to his death when a guardrail gave way. Joseph Dempsey, an experienced member of the airport's ground handling team, died in the incident on January 11 2023. The 59-year-old had been preparing to unload cargo from an aircraft using a pallet loader. He had positioned the loader alongside the aircraft and was repositioning a guardrail when it suddenly gave way and he fell to the tarmac some 10 feet (three metres) below. Mr Dempsey's colleagues immediately went to his assistance and paramedics attempted CPR and advanced life support. However, these efforts proved unsuccessful and Mr Dempsey was pronounced dead at the scene. An investigation by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) found that one of the guardrail posts had completely fractured, and that there were visible signs of significant corrosion, discolouration and flaking white paint around the area. At Ayr Sheriff Court on June 25, Glasgow Prestwick Airport Ltd pled guilty to a breach of health and safety legislation, having failed to ensure the pallet loader was maintained and in good repair. At the same court on Thursday, the company was fined £144,050, including a victim surcharge of £10,050. Debbie Carroll leads on health and safety investigations for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS). Speaking after the sentencing, she said: 'Joseph Dempsey lost his life in circumstances which could have been avoided if Prestwick Airport had in place a suitable and adequate maintenance and inspection programme to ensure the equipment he was using was in a good state of repair. 'This prosecution should remind duty holders that a failure to fulfil their obligations can have fatal consequences and they will be held accountable for this failure.' Metallurgical examination of the guardrail posts carried out during the investigation found differences in chemical composition, manufacturing, and wall thickness which indicated the posts were manufactured from two different tubing sections. The HSE found these welded sections were not a feature of the manufacture's original design, and appeared to have been modified while the loader was under the ownership of Prestwick Airport. The investigation also found the welds on both the guardrail posts contained defects which would allow moisture in, creating a corrosive environment and speeding up deterioration. It was also found that the maintenance programme in place at the time did not cover the parts of the guardrail where failure or deterioration could lead to health and safety risks. Graeme McMinn, HM principal inspector of health and safety, said: 'Employers have an absolute legal duty to ensure that equipment they use at work is maintained in an efficient state and in good repair and full working order. 'This incident is a tragic reminder of what can result when that does not happen.' Since the incident, Prestwick Airport has undertaken a review of all work at height, and checks of the guardrails on the platform loaders have been made part of the regular service and inspection schedule.
