Dublin City Council grants permission for 14-storey office block despite opposition from OPW, local school and religious trust
In granting planning permission to Ventaway Ltd, a council planner's report concluded that the scheme 'will result in the redevelopment of a massively under-utilised vacant site in a prominent location within the city centre'.
The report found that the proposed alterations 'ensure that the development will not only create valuable commercial space but will also add much-needed artistic spaces, while also providing managed space for the adjoining school'.
Underlining the scale of the scheme, the council has ordered Ventaway to pay €3.18m in planning contributions towards public infrastructure and €1.08m towards the Luas C1 line scheme.
The current plans follow An Coimisiún Pleanála refusing planning permission in May 2024 to Ventaway to develop what would have been Dublin's tallest building at 24 storeys for the same site.
School's board of management was objecting 'in the strongest possible terms'
Ventaway lodged its revised plans last December and the scheme – designed by architects Henry J Lyons – is 61.05m tall, which is a 46.95m height reduction on the 108m-high scheme refused in 2024.
Principal of City Quay National School, Philip Kelly, told the council that the school's board of management was objecting 'in the strongest possible terms' to the new planning application.
The OPW is the state agency charged with the care and management of the James Gandon-designed Custom House and in its objection, the OPW stated that the construction of a building at this scale and magnitude 'has the potential to adversely impact the historic and architectural character of the Custom House'.
In a separate objection on behalf of St Laurence O'Toole Trust and the Administrator of the Parish of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, planning consultant Declan Brassil stated that the scheme 'represents a significant overdevelopment of the site'.
The country's largest industry lobby group, Ibec, also weighed in stating that approval should be granted.
Ibec's head of infrastructure and environmental sustainability, Aidan Sweeney, told the council that the proposal 'offers an effective revitalisation of a prime location in the city centre and is exactly the sort of project Dublin requires going forward'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Objections to City Arts Centre development lodged
Plans to construct a 14-storey office block scheme on the site of former City Arts Centre at City Quay in Dublin 2 have been stalled. Three parties – An Taisce ; the St Laurence O'Toole Trust and administrator of the parish of the Immaculate Heart of Mary; and City Quay National School – have lodged appeals with An Coimisiún Pleanála (ACP) against Dublin City Council 's grant of permission last month. The council granted planning permission to Ventaway Ltd . headed up by developer, David Kennan and Winthrop engineering group founder, Barry English. In granting planning permission, a council planner's report concluded that the scheme would 'result in the redevelopment of a massively underutilised vacant site in a prominent location within the city centre'. However, the principal of City Quay National School, Philip Kelly, in the school's initial objection said that 'should the development proceed, it will have a big negative impact on the ability of the school to deliver high quality education to the pupils in our care'. The school has 178 children enrolled and Mr Kelly said that the 10-year planning permission sought was 'entirely unacceptable and should not be facilitated'. 'It is unnecessary and unreasonable and discards the rights of adjoining occupiers, ' he said. In a separate objection on behalf of St Laurence O'Toole Trust and the administrator of the Parish of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, planning consultant, Declan Brassil said that the scheme 'represents a significant overdevelopment of the site'. Mr Brassil said that the trust owns four properties in the vicinity – 7/8 City Quay; The Presbytery, 9 City Quay; The Church of the Immaculate Heart of May and City Quay National School. Mr Brassil said the monolithic design and scale of the proposed building would visually overwhelm the adjoining properties. Dublin city planning officer with An Taisce, Kevin Duff told the council that the proposal 'lacks coherent architectural expression, appearing jumbled and consisting of too many parts and elements'. Mr Duff said: 'The problem appears to be that the basic silhouette or profile of the building is excessively massed and monolithic and does not lend itself to successful breakdown. Earlier this month, Mr Justice Richard Humphreys quashed the decision made by An Bord Pleanála in May 2024 to refuse planning permission for Ventaway's original 24-storey scheme for the site. The decision to grant planning permission for a 14-stoey block allows Ventaway to resubmit its proposal for the 24-storey tower to An Coimisiún Pleanála for fresh consideration.
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Drinks Ireland warned Taoiseach that alcohol health labelling plans seen as ‘trade barrier' by US
A drinks industry representative organisation warned Taoiseach Micheál Martin that plans for health labels on alcohol have been 'identified as a barrier to trade by the US' during a meeting sought to discuss the impact of US president Donald Trump's threatened tariffs. The meeting also heard that the industry was seeking a delay in the introduction of the planned labelling regime. The rules – which are to include cancer warnings – were due to take effect in May 2026. The Government decided on Tuesday to delay the measure for two years amid ongoing trade uncertainty. A report published by US trade representative Jamieson Greer's office at the end of March detailed what the United States regards as trade barriers worldwide. READ MORE The Irish plans for alcohol health labelling were included in a section on the European Union . The report notes that the US industry has 'raised concerns' that the intended unique labelling requirements in the Republic are in addition to EU-wide regulations and 'would be costly and may disrupt US exports within the EU single market'. Do Sinn Féin need to change tack after slump in the polls? Listen | 38:36 Drinks Ireland – part of business lobby group Ibec – met Mr Martin on April 11th, along with several alcohol producers. A note of the meeting released by the Department of the Taoiseach under the Freedom of Information Act says that Drinks Ireland highlighted how the labelling requirements were identified as a barrier to trade by the US. The note also said: 'The sector, while open to labelling requirements, was seeking some delay from Government on their introduction.' Mr Martin is said to have 'noted the comments of Drinks Ireland in this regard'. In response to an Irish Times query on the meeting, the department said that 28 of the 31 provisions in the Public Health (Alcohol) Act – which includes the labelling plans – have been started. These include 'major changes on advertising, sponsorship, retail display of alcohol, and alcohol promotions, as well as the introduction of minimum unit pricing. 'The Minister for Health is aligned with the Taoiseach, Tánaiste, and all Ministers on the need for a whole-of-Government response to trade and tariffs.' A Drinks Ireland statement said it welcomed the 'opportunity for ongoing engagement ... to avoid further escalation and to seek a negotiated resolution. The Irish drinks sector is export-focused, with €2 billion in annual exports, and the US market is critical for our members throughout the country.' The statement added that the sector is 'particularly exposed' to US tariffs. On Tuesday, Minister for Trade Simon Harris updated Cabinet on the ongoing trade talks between the EU and US to reach an agreement in advance of Mr Trump's August 1st tariff deadline. As part of this, Ministers were advised that the alcohol health warning labels would be deferred for two years to 2028, following concerns raised about the impact of their implementation in the current global trading environment. The delay is to allow industry, domestic and international, to prepare for their implementation. The Cabinet was told the decision follows concerns raised by domestic interests at the Government trade forum around the potential to undermine international competitiveness.
Irish Times
18-07-2025
- Irish Times
Fresh bid for Dublin's tallest building on City Arts Centre site after High Court quashes An Bord Pleanála ruling
The company behind a plan to redevelop the site of the former City Arts Centre at City Quay is to renew its bid to build Dublin's tallest building there. Having secured planning permission from Dublin City Council just two weeks ago for a 14-storey office block, Ventaway, a company headed up by David Kennan and Winthrop engineering group founder Barry English, is aiming once again to deliver a 24-storey structure on the site. The proposal is being revived on foot of a judgment delivered by Mr Justice Richard Humphreys earlier this week in which he quashed the decision made by An Bord Pleanála in May 2024 to refuse planning permission for the scheme. In arriving at his decision, the judge found that the board was in breach of Section 172 of the 2000 Planning and Development Act by refusing permission for the scheme 'in the absence of a properly conducted environmental impact assessment (EIA) by the board with a reasoned conclusion'. READ MORE The judge also found that there was a 'complete absence of engagement' by the board in relation to the ten-page analysis of its own inspector, which highlighted the fact that the urban development and building heights guidelines for planning authorities issued by former minister for housing Eoghan Murphy in December 2018 supported the granting of permission for a taller building. According to these, local authorities may assess permissible building heights on a qualitative basis, rather than by the limitations imposed by development plans or local area plans. The former City Arts Centre as it is today Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill The Irish Times understands that following this week's court ruling, Ventaway will pursue its entitlement to submit its proposal for the 24-storey tower to the planning appeals board, which is now known An Coimisiún Pleanála, for its consideration. Should it get the go-ahead, the 24-storey tower would rise to a height of 108m (354.33ft) and comprise 22,587 sq m of office space over 23 of its floors, along with 1,404 sq m of artist studios and exhibition space distributed across the front of the building at its lower-ground, ground and first-floor levels. A computer generated aerial image of the scheme proposed for the former City Arts Centre site While the 14-storey building, for which Ventaway currently has permission, would, in contrast, be 61.05m (200ft) in height, the building would be wider, providing additional office space – 23,501 sq m compared to the 22,587 sq m in the taller scheme. The lower-rise scheme would provide less arts and cultural space, with 910 sq m being dedicated to artist studios and exhibition areas compared to the 1,404 sq m provided for in the proposed 24-storey structure.
