logo
Trees removed from memorial site landscape plan

Trees removed from memorial site landscape plan

Perth Now28-05-2025
A peace deal has been struck between the City of Belmont and the local RSL over landscaping plans for a war memorial.
Trees had been proposed to be planted in the forecourt of the Belmont war memorial in Faulkner Park during works to revamp the area around the park's ornamental lakes.
New features in the park would include timber decking, new seating and shelters, lighting upgrades and an extensive pathway network.
Your local paper, whenever you want it.
The war memorial, gazebo and Six Seasons sculpture in the park were integrated into its $4.75 million redesign.
The city's site said they would be retained and protected during the works.
But City of Belmont RSL Sub-Branch president Alan Richardson raised concerns at the city's April 15 meeting about four grass trees proposed to be planted in the memorial's forecourt, claiming they were not in the plans originally presented to the group. A floral tribute from the City of Belmont on Anzac Day. Credit: City of Belmont
He said the original concept plan showed terracing out the front and a new platform which would take troops in front of the memorial.
Mr Richardson told PerthNow this week the trees had since been removed from plans.
'It was negotiated very quickly and all resolved,' he said.
'They've removed the grass trees and reinstated the forecourt as it was. It will still be complementing the works behind it.'
He said at the meeting that forecourts in the 4000-plus memorials across Australia were clear of any plantings.
'You look at Parliament House; there's 5.7km straight through that avenue in Canberra. Not one tree or anything is in front of it,' he said.
City CEO John Christie told PerthNow the original design for the Ornamental Lakes project included more grass tree throughout the park.
'This included areas around the City of Belmont war memorial to integrate it with the landscape design throughout the park,' he said.
'These designs were shared with key stakeholders, including the local RSL, prior to construction. A plaque of the Belmont war memorial's history. Credit: Michael Palmer
'Following feedback from the local RSL, the trees near the front of the war memorial were relocated to other locations within the park.'
Mr Richardson said the works behind the memorial prevented a form-up and march being part of this year's Anzac Day service but expected it to be sorted by next year.
He said he had attended services at the memorial since 1967 when it was originally on Great Eastern Highway.
'It was moved from the highway up into its present location because of the crowds that used to form up on Great Eastern Highway,' he said.
'When we moved up here and we placed the memorial in the gardens in approximately 1973-75, there was plenty of room in the forecourt for parades.
'People would march from the front of the memorial around and they would congregate in front of the memorial.'
The Faulkner Park revamp is expected to be completed in June.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Developers push for new city at North Arm Cove north of Sydney
Developers push for new city at North Arm Cove north of Sydney

News.com.au

time3 days ago

  • News.com.au

Developers push for new city at North Arm Cove north of Sydney

Like some Mayan mystery, a fully designed city lies hidden in the Australian bushland just two hours north of Sydney and it could soon become the country's newest settlement. Located in present-day North Arm Cove, just north of Newcastle in the Hunter Valley, the city includes a complex web of housing lots with plans for train and port terminals and administrative buildings. For years, it lay dormant as a 'paper subdivision', meaning it has been legally divided into lots but has never been physically developed with roads or power infrastructure. But that is now changing and a recent rezoning decision means the lost city could soon rise up out of the bush. 'It's going to be developed, it's just a question of how,' Desim Arch architect Dejan Simovic told NewsWire this week. 'It's part of the northern suburbs of Newcastle, so sooner or later … it's definitely going to be developed.' Mr Simovic and his wife Tatjana Djuric-Simovic are pushing for 'sustainable' development at North Arm Cove and hope to fulfil a vision for the city outlined by legendary Canberra architect Walter Burley Griffin a century ago. Mr Griffin sketched out the city, which he called Port Stephens City, on 'garden city' principles, typified by expanding concentric rings of development all connected via train. 'You can see that really clearly in the Port Stephens city design,' urban planning guru Sam Austin told NewsWire. 'It has a very central rail terminal and then you can see a concentric circle design that extends out of it.' The Simovics worry about 'western Sydney' style development engulfing the area and propose instead a 'circular economy' city that is self-reliant at a local level. 'It will be local, precinct based,' Mr Simovic said. 'We're going to have our own treatment plant for water and then generating electricity and data and for the roads. 'It's all based on a circular economy, all based on locals using and reusing water and power and recycling the waste. 'That's the basic principle. We would like to be the first circular city or town in Australia.' There are powerful reasons, however, why the city has remained bushland scrub for decades. The area sits within the Mid-Coast Council local government area and the council has long argued development at North Arm Cove would be 'prohibitively expensive' given the lack of any road, power or drainage infrastructure. The council pushed for the area to be rezoned to 'environmental management', which would have stopped any development. But in 2024, the state government instructed the council to rezone it into 'environmental living', which has cracked open the door to new building. 'Council has always rejected the notion they could rezone this land because there are too many constraints and the cost was too high,' North Arm Cove Ratepayers Association president David Buxton told NewsWire. 'But all of that seems to have changed in the past five years, for a number of things.' Mr Buxton said NSW's sharpening housing shortages had in part prompted the state government's rezoning push. The new local environment plan is expected to come into effect later this year. There are about 4000 lots at North Arm Cove, with about 1000 of them owned by the council. There were now 'two entities' eager to build out the area, Mr Buxton added. Those are Desim and a property developer called Alathan. Alathan has lodged a 'scoping proposal' with the council outlining how the company sees the future of the area. 'They (Alathan) are going down the investigative path, they are getting feedback,' Mr Buxton said. 'In my way of thinking, they are committed, they are willing to spend the money, as long as they don't get ridiculous hurdles put in front of them.' The next phase is a development control plan, which is a detailed document that outlines building dimensions, form and scale. Mr Buxton estimates the cost to produce a plan to be in the range of $5m to $10m. Mr Simovic said he would apply for federal government grant funding to finance his DEP. Building out infrastructure for the new city would likely cost north of $1bn, Mr Simovic said. 'We already have interest from infrastructure companies to fund doing the infrastructure and then later managing it and repayments through loans and other things,' Mr Simovic said. 'We have all of that structure set up, the question now is just who is going to fund preparation plans. 'That's where we expect support from the government, just to get the grant from the federal government.' But there are huge challenges in getting the city up. Aside from the cost of the infrastructure build-out, any development plan needs majority approval from landholders. Mr Austin, meanwhile, has expressed caution about building brand new cities. 'I much prefer to see urban consolidation or development around existing settlements, particularly given there is very strong ecological value in that area,' he said. 'I do have some reservations on broad scale development in essentially pristine bushland, which is what it is.'

The RSL survival guide: A new model emerges for an old institution
The RSL survival guide: A new model emerges for an old institution

Sydney Morning Herald

time3 days ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

The RSL survival guide: A new model emerges for an old institution

Earlier this month, the RSL released a consultant's report, which found that some sub-branches were too small or poor to deliver meaningful services to veterans. The report said the state office was also struggling financially because of the increasingly complex demands of veterans, which encompass mental illness, housing, legal troubles and elder abuse. And it warned RSL Victoria was overly reliant on revenue from its 52 pokies venues, which are at risk from the state government's long-awaited gambling reform package. 'Financially, the current state is fragile and not sustainable. However, without a viable state branch, the sub-branch network will cease to exist,' the report said. It recommended forcing sub-branches to hand over more revenue to the state RSL office. The charity should also increase engagement with younger veterans, solicit bequests from current members, and switch from an incorporated association to a company limited by guarantee, the report said. RSL Victoria's new president, Mark Schroffel, has thrown his weight behind the report, although discussions with sub-branches regarding funding and the future of venues are just beginning. 'We need to have their support because ultimately, it's their organisation,' Schroffel said. Former Victorian premier Jeff Kennett is a member of the amalgamated Camberwell 'Pompey' Elliott RSL sub-branch in Melbourne's east, which has a car wash to boost revenue. He said RSL Victoria faced a 'massive challenge to remain relevant' to younger generations. 'The RSL, does it have a future? Yes. But unless they're careful, the number of branches will continue to decline,' he said. 'We live in very different times, and as much as I hate to say it, I'm not sure the RSL has moved with the times.' At Coburg RSL, young reservist Johannes is not a member because he is busy working two jobs. He said he didn't expect to become heavily involved in the near future. 'I'm 100 per cent supportive,' he said. 'More broadly, things like country fire stations and Men's Sheds and those sorts of community groups – because this is a community group at the end of the day – the people who get involved are retired.' Beyond the report's recommendations, others say RSL Victoria should extend its memberships to police officers, paramedics and SES workers, get out of pokies and sell some sub-branches' land to councils. But Schroffel said the head office could not decide to sell off sub-branches to reinvest the proceeds. 'It's not our property,' he said. 'Those independent sub-branches, they and their members actually own those buildings.' Schroffel said membership fees could increase for the first time in 10 years, and RSL was open to selling its pokies venues, potentially to not-for-profit racing organisations. Martin Thomas, chief executive officer of the Alliance for Gambling Reform, said RSLs were designed to be a safe space for veterans and their families, yet international research showed veterans suffer a higher rate of gambling harm than non-veterans. 'With their new president, we would be calling on the RSL to start that change to remove pokies machines from their venues, or at the very least to be at the vanguard of a carded play system that we know from all the evidence greatly reduces the harm that happens,' he said. Journalist and anti-pokies activist Stephen Mayne said RSL Victoria's sub-branches were worth at least $1 billion, according to council valuations. Loading 'They should close all the pokies venues, sell off a few – Box Hill is worth $70 million on its own – and then live off their investments and all operate like Hawthorn, Camberwell and Templestowe and many other successful, traditional RSLs. Find yourself a benevolent council landlord and operate with the support of your council.' Peter Whitelaw is a member of the Melbourne sub-branch, the original RSL in Australia. The Spencer Street club is trying to attract young veterans with guest speakers, networking events, mentoring and co-working spaces. 'I think the primary thing that we are wrestling with is that the RSL is dominated by seniors, of which I am one, and there's got to be a generational change,' Whitelaw says. 'That's fundamental to the future of the RSL. 'Fundamental change has to occur on a number of fronts. One of those is really focused on getting younger veterans engaged with the RSL and carrying it forward.'

The RSL survival guide: A new model emerges for an old institution
The RSL survival guide: A new model emerges for an old institution

The Age

time3 days ago

  • The Age

The RSL survival guide: A new model emerges for an old institution

Earlier this month, the RSL released a consultant's report, which found that some sub-branches were too small or poor to deliver meaningful services to veterans. The report said the state office was also struggling financially because of the increasingly complex demands of veterans, which encompass mental illness, housing, legal troubles and elder abuse. And it warned RSL Victoria was overly reliant on revenue from its 52 pokies venues, which are at risk from the state government's long-awaited gambling reform package. 'Financially, the current state is fragile and not sustainable. However, without a viable state branch, the sub-branch network will cease to exist,' the report said. It recommended forcing sub-branches to hand over more revenue to the state RSL office. The charity should also increase engagement with younger veterans, solicit bequests from current members, and switch from an incorporated association to a company limited by guarantee, the report said. RSL Victoria's new president, Mark Schroffel, has thrown his weight behind the report, although discussions with sub-branches regarding funding and the future of venues are just beginning. 'We need to have their support because ultimately, it's their organisation,' Schroffel said. Former Victorian premier Jeff Kennett is a member of the amalgamated Camberwell 'Pompey' Elliott RSL sub-branch in Melbourne's east, which has a car wash to boost revenue. He said RSL Victoria faced a 'massive challenge to remain relevant' to younger generations. 'The RSL, does it have a future? Yes. But unless they're careful, the number of branches will continue to decline,' he said. 'We live in very different times, and as much as I hate to say it, I'm not sure the RSL has moved with the times.' At Coburg RSL, young reservist Johannes is not a member because he is busy working two jobs. He said he didn't expect to become heavily involved in the near future. 'I'm 100 per cent supportive,' he said. 'More broadly, things like country fire stations and Men's Sheds and those sorts of community groups – because this is a community group at the end of the day – the people who get involved are retired.' Beyond the report's recommendations, others say RSL Victoria should extend its memberships to police officers, paramedics and SES workers, get out of pokies and sell some sub-branches' land to councils. But Schroffel said the head office could not decide to sell off sub-branches to reinvest the proceeds. 'It's not our property,' he said. 'Those independent sub-branches, they and their members actually own those buildings.' Schroffel said membership fees could increase for the first time in 10 years, and RSL was open to selling its pokies venues, potentially to not-for-profit racing organisations. Martin Thomas, chief executive officer of the Alliance for Gambling Reform, said RSLs were designed to be a safe space for veterans and their families, yet international research showed veterans suffer a higher rate of gambling harm than non-veterans. 'With their new president, we would be calling on the RSL to start that change to remove pokies machines from their venues, or at the very least to be at the vanguard of a carded play system that we know from all the evidence greatly reduces the harm that happens,' he said. Journalist and anti-pokies activist Stephen Mayne said RSL Victoria's sub-branches were worth at least $1 billion, according to council valuations. Loading 'They should close all the pokies venues, sell off a few – Box Hill is worth $70 million on its own – and then live off their investments and all operate like Hawthorn, Camberwell and Templestowe and many other successful, traditional RSLs. Find yourself a benevolent council landlord and operate with the support of your council.' Peter Whitelaw is a member of the Melbourne sub-branch, the original RSL in Australia. The Spencer Street club is trying to attract young veterans with guest speakers, networking events, mentoring and co-working spaces. 'I think the primary thing that we are wrestling with is that the RSL is dominated by seniors, of which I am one, and there's got to be a generational change,' Whitelaw says. 'That's fundamental to the future of the RSL. 'Fundamental change has to occur on a number of fronts. One of those is really focused on getting younger veterans engaged with the RSL and carrying it forward.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store