Bombay HC criticises Maharashtra government for arresting student over post about Operation Sindoor
The Bombay High Court on Tuesday criticised the Maharashtra government for arresting a Pune student for an allegedly objectionable social media post about Operation Sindoor, PTI reported.
A division bench of Justices Gauri Godse and Somasekhar Sundaresan directed the student's counsel to file a bail petition, adding that it would be granted immediately.
The bench also criticised the 19-year-old's college for rusticating her for the social media post, saying that educational institutes need to help students and not turn them into criminals, Live Law reported.
The court was hearing a petition filed by the engineering student challenging her rustication.
The bench said that the student had already faced the consequences after being rusticated by the college and that she must be released.
The 19-year-old is a second-year information technology student at Sinhgad Academy of Engineering, a private unaided college affiliated to Savitribai Phule Pune University.
On May 7, she had allegedly reposted a post on Instagram from an account that criticised the Indian government, PTI reported. The post was related to military tensions between India and Pakistan after Operation Sindoor, according to Live Law.
She had deleted the post and apologised after receiving threats online.
However, she was arrested on May 9 following protests against her post, according to PTI. She was rusticated by the college on the same day.
In its rustication letter, the Sinhgad Academy of Engineering claimed that the action was justified as the student had brought disrepute to the institution. She had anti-national sentiments and posed a risk to the campus community and society, PTI quoted the institute as having alleged.
The student had challenged her rustication in the court, terming it a gross violation of her fundamental rights, PTI reported. In her petition, she urged the court to quash the rustication and allow her to appear for her semester examinations that was scheduled to begin on May 24.
During the hearing on Tuesday, Justice Godse verbally questioned the action taken by the college.
'You are ruining the life of a student?' Live Law quoted Godse as having asked the counsel representing the college. 'What kind of conduct this is? Somebody expresses something you want to ruin the life of the student? How can you rusticate? Did you call upon an explanation?'
Godse asked if the purpose of an educational institute was 'only to educate academically'.
She said that the college cannot stop her from writing the examinations. 'Let her appear for the remaining three papers,' Godse added.
Additional Government Pleader Priyabhushan Kakade, appearing for the state government, alleged that the girl's social media post was against national interest, PTI reported.
The court responded that national interest would not be hurt by a post by a student who had realised her mistake and apologised.
The bench said that 'such a radical reaction' by the state 'will further radicalise the person'.
'You need to reform her and not convert her into a criminal,' Live Law quoted Godse as having said. 'What does the state want? It doesn't want the students to express their opinions? You want to convert students into criminals?'
The court permitted the student to either convert the matter into a criminal petition or file a fresh petition, adding that it would hear it on Tuesday evening and order her release. 'Educational institutes need to help students but not help them become a criminal,' it said.
Kakade also told the court that the student can appear for her examinations with police escort, Live Law reported.
In reply, Godse stated: 'She isn't a criminal. She cannot be asked to appear with police around her. She has to be released. She cannot be stopped from appearing in exams. She cannot be asked to appear with police around her.'
Student's plea
In the petition against her rustication, the student said that the order passed by the Sinhgad Academy of Engineering was 'arbitrary and unlawful', PTI reported. The petition added that the order was issued without a show cause notice or giving her an opportunity to defend herself.
'The action [of rustication], triggered solely by a social media post expressing personal opinions, was taken without affording the petitioner any opportunity of hearing and is hence in gross violation of the principles of natural justice and fundamental rights under Article 14, 19(1)(a) and 21,' PTI quoted her petition as saying.
While Article 14 of the Constitution pertains to the right to equality, Article 19(1)(a) guarantees the right to free speech and Article 21 right to life.
The student also said that she had reposted the social media post without ill-intent and had immediately apologised.
Tensions between New Delhi and Islamabad had escalated on May 7 when the Indian military carried out strikes – codenamed Operation Sindoor – on what it claimed were terrorist camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir.
The strikes were in response to the terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam, which killed 26 persons on April 22.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
13 minutes ago
- Time of India
Gautam Adani visits Chinese equipment makers as US legal woes linger
Indian billionaire Gautam Adani traveled to China last week to meet industrial equipment manufacturers, marking what appears to be his first overseas trip since the US unveiled criminal and civil cases against him in November. The visit, including to a solar module maker, underscores Adani's continued efforts to maintain momentum in renewables even as he faces heightened scrutiny abroad. Sagar Adani , who oversees the green arm of the conglomerate's sprawling empire, accompanied his uncle on the trip, according to a social media post by one of the companies he visited. The trip to China could signal a renewed push for international engagement as Gautam Adani tries to shake off controversies, from US legal troubles to investor concerns about corporate governance practices, following a bruising short-seller report in early 2023. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The Prices of Solar Panels Might Actually Surprise You Solar Panels | Search Ads Get Info Asia's second-richest person, along with his nephew Sagar, face criminal and civil charges in the US over their alleged involvement in a $250 million bribery scheme to pay regional officials in India to lock in solar-power contracts. — BROAD_ltd (@BROAD_ltd) Live Events The Adani Group has denied the claims, though both Gautam and Sagar have curtailed their international travel since the indictment was announced. The Indian conglomerate is building one of the largest renewable energy parks — five times the size of Paris — near India's western coast with solar panels and wind turbines. The billionaire visited a Jinko Solar Co. manufacturing plant, inspecting the facility's automated production lines, the Shanghai-based company said in a statement on June 4. Its energy storage solutions are well-suited to India's high-temperature conditions and will be integrated into Adani's projects to bolster grid stability and renewable energy absorption, it said. Adani also visited Broad Group's facilities, the Chinese firm said in a post on X. The company has a range of subsidiaries that includes a wind turbine manufacturer. A spokesperson for Adani didn't immediately comment. The group's renewable energy ramp up plans are crucial for two of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi 's policy pledges — making the country carbon neutral by 2070 and self-reliant, especially in manufacturing. India is one of the biggest markets for China's solar modules and Adani's visit could also signal room for better business ties between the two countries. While relations between the nuclear-armed neighbors remain fraught, there have recently been signs of a thawing. In January, they agreed to resume direct flights, facilitate visas and restart sharing data of trans-border rivers. A few months later, the nations announced the resumption of an annual pilgrimage to the Tibet Autonomous Region, organized by India's foreign ministry, that had been suspended for years after border clashes erupted.
News18
13 minutes ago
- News18
Indian Entrepreneurship In Times of War
Last Updated: A war needs warriors. Will the MSMEs of today's Bharat rise to the occasion? India has got habituated to a hard wiring of its intellectual capabilities, after six decades of losing a substantial number of its engineers and technically qualified personnel to the US or to stultifying employment in Indian megacities where they burn out in a couple of decades. Even today, the sons and daughters of well-heeled businessmen do not wish to augment the value that only they can bring to their family company but rather prefer to sell their talent at a CTC that is a fraction of their intrinsic value to their lucky employer. It is understood at top levels that foundational change is required across all institutions that have acted subservient to prolonged colonial interests to the extent that our young minds feel more aligned to external interests rather than feeling that they need to be a part of the economic revival of Bharat. What is entrepreneurship? It is the transition of an activity that starts with an individual and goes on to become an organisation with a financial outcome. For a nation with ambitions suppressed for decades, and the largest young population, we have dreams waiting to be realised. Entrepreneurship steers one away from seeking set patterns of talent for sale that employment represents towards an expanding ecosystem where an entire supply chain of individuals steers towards disproportionate financial rewards. What is war? Taking a disinterested view of things, humankind is living in one of the apparently most 'peaceful' eras it has ever known. Armed strife remains localised, and transcontinental devastation wrought by the ravages of war have been relegated to faint memories. Yet, is peace defined merely by the absence of mobilised militaries engaging in pitched battles? Or can the supposed converse of peace, namely war, be taken as any adversarial interaction in which rivals compete using any and all methods whatsoever, be they military or otherwise? Wars today are economic, social, cultural and ideological, and may even be waged using food and yes, even water as weapons. War is everywhere. It is a system of rewards and consequences for winners and losers. It is not very different from the jungle world of predators and prey. Corporate wars that eat local businesses and pharma wars that threaten millions with manipulating health diagnostics are today's wars. Like all wars they are unacceptable because in one way or the other they threaten the harmony of daily life. International relations today have become fraught, fickle, transactional and transient as the world discards the so-called rules-based-order and moves towards a no-rules-whatsoever-disorder. The global situation today is truly dynamic. This generalised anarchy has immense consequences for India's economy—especially its entrepreneurial class and the way in which MSMEs need to be restructured in our country. What are the entrepreneurial changes specifically needed in India in times of war? MSMEs in times of peace are engineered to be in a condition of equilibrium. In times of war, they enter a phase of metastable equilibrium and at the worst, violent disequilibrium leading to their quick collapse. This basic fact needs to be considered by young entrepreneurs and venture capital financiers. Here, we highlight two specific aspects that connect MSMEs in a war-like condition that affects the world in general, and India in particular. The first point we mention is how an MSME should adapt itself to a new way of thinking, whatever be the commodity or service with which it is connected. The second point is how an MSME can connect itself with an activity related to the actual physical and mental war we are engaged in with our two and a half enemies. Firstly, there is the matter of timing. There are no war whistles. Escalations are quick and unannounced; in a matter of minutes, a drone swarm can appear carrying an arsenal. Preparedness for war in a highly technological environment is being in a state of round the clock readiness. One cannot lapse into complacency at any time. For any sort of MSME, an ability to react quickly to any adverse condition is a must. For this, back up plans are essential and continuous vigilance. Our current war with Pakistan and with nations dictating new tariffs and sanctions at the drop of a hat we must eschew the compartmentalised approach of industry with its great dependence on foreign Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs). Just recently with China stopping its export of high flux permanent magnets to India (and also the USA) we seem to have woken up to the fact that China has a virtual monopoly of neodymium supply chains; for neodymium is a rare earth element (REE) that is essential to fabricate these magnets. Why were we sleeping all these days? What we needed was an MSME that might have been geared to finding neodymium deposits in India. Things like this needed to be looked into; instead we encouraged MSMEs that were looking at ice cream that doesn't melt or kirana shops on two wheelers. An empowered, regional MSME working in closer collaboration with a technological institute (IIT) is a more dependable ally in today's time, as we move to modular engineering. Dual Use Technologies to Interdisciplinary excellence have led to a newer array of mechanisms capable of weaponizing our industrial production on the one hand, and to jeopardising essential services and command centres of the enemy on the other hand. Drones can carry payloads without risking human lives in critical missions at a fraction of the cost of more conventional technologies and without the use of expensive satellites (for surveillance). We need to gear many more MSMEs to drone technology so that we compete effectively with Turkey, Iran and China in this domain. Other technologies like 3D printing, Digital Twins and AI should also find their place in the Indian MSME ecosystem. What about adaptability? Why should Indian VCs invest in Defence Tech? India's defence budget has been amongst its top three spends running into several hundred thousand crores of rupees. The total addressable market for defence startups is therefore a lucrative investment that must be leveraged effectively to protect India's IP. In general, however, and in any domain, not necessarily even connected with the defence and military establishment, a war mindset is a must; we need to come out of our sluggish approach that has slowed the MSME sector for many decades. This is the need of the hour. With brilliant minds from every region migrating to limited Tech hubs or indeed, out of the country itself, it is imperative that the industrial ecosystems need to reorganise themselves to new opportunities. Talent needs to identify opportunity, and in return, opportunity must ignite talent. This must be prioritised over all else. Basically, this amounts to a cultural reset for our MSME, industrial, academic and investor institutions. Finally, we address the matter of self-realisation as it relates to entrepreneurship. This is relevant because at the core of entrepreneurship is a confidence that can only come from a certain degree of self-awareness. In times of war, this self-realisation can and must only become more robust. Even with the highest potential and capability, Arjuna did not have integrity of purpose on the eve of the war. Only this could lead to clarity and coherent action on his part. For him to acquire this and carry out his dharma, it needed The Creator Himself to remove the shadows of doubt that had come upon the highest warrior on the planet at the time. As for integrity, it is immanent in an individual and war is a mere test of its manifestation. It matters not if one is in a classroom, a boardroom or a war room. What a war needs is warriors. Will the MSMEs and VCs of today's Bharat rise to the occasion? Gautam Desiraju is in the Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru and in UPES, Dehradun. Duke Vashisht is founder of Orbitonormics Research, and is based out of Gurugram. Views expressed in the above piece are personal and solely that of the authors. They do not necessarily reflect News18's views. tags : entrepreneurship MSMEs in India Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: June 11, 2025, 14:46 IST News opinion Opinion | Indian Entrepreneurship In Times of War
Scroll.in
16 minutes ago
- Scroll.in
ED raids premises linked to Congress MP E Tukaram, 3 MLAs in Karnataka ST corporation scam case
The Enforcement Directorate on Wednesday conducted searches at premises linked to Congress MP from Ballari E Tukaram and three MLAs in Karnataka in a case about alleged irregularities in the state Maharshi Valmiki Scheduled Tribes Development Corporation, PTI reported. Five locations in Ballari and three in Bengaluru belonging to Tukaram and the three MLAs – the Congress' Nara Bharath Reddy, JN Ganesh and NT Srinivas – were being searched under provisions of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, the news agency quoted unidentified officials as saying. Commenting on the searches, Chief Minister Siddaramaiah said that the state government would not support any violation of the law nor come in the way of its implementation, PTI reported. 'Let them do whatever they want in accordance with the law…We won't obstruct it,' he said. The case pertains to the alleged misappropriation of funds belonging to the state Maharshi Valmiki Scheduled Tribes Development Corporation. The matter came to light in May 2024 after its accounts superintendent, Chandrashekhar, died by suicide. In a note left behind, Chandrasekhar alleged that funds to the tune of Rs 187 crore had been transferred from the corporation's bank account. A Special Investigation Team set up by the Karnataka government is looking into the allegations of misappropriation of funds. The team has arrested 14 persons in the case, including two officials of the corporation – managing director Padmanabha GJ and accounts officer Parashuram Dugganavar, The Indian Express reported. The Enforcement Directorate has also claimed that Rs 20.19 crore of the funds siphoned from the Maharshi Valmiki Scheduled Tribes Development Corporation was used to support the Tukaram's campaign from Ballari constituency during the 2024 Lok Sabha elections.
