Hong Kong court backs transgender right to use bathroom matching chosen gender identity
Judge Russell Coleman on Wednesday suspended the effect of the ruling for a year. The suspended ruling is to 'consider whether it wishes to implement a way to deal with the contravention'.
The judge said the rules banning transgender people from using the bathroom matching their gender identity are discriminatory and violate the right to equality under Hong Kong's Basic Law.
He said in the judgment that the regulations and "drawing the line of a person's biological sex at birth create a disproportionate and unnecessary intrusion into the privacy and equality rights".
The decision came on the complaint of a person identified as K, who was born a woman and identifies as a man in 2022. K launched a legal petition to allow transgender people to use public toilet that aligns with their identified gender.
K called to expand the exemption in the Public Conveniences (Conduct and Behaviour) Regulations to those transgender people who have been diagnosed with gender dysphoria and have a medical need to undergo the process of living in their identified gender.
'This is a matter of the line-drawing, which seems to me to be a question for the government or legislature to address,' Mr Coleman wrote in his judgment.
He said the matter of drawing a line between a 'female person' and a 'male person' is 'an answer not appropriately given by the courts, and is more appropriately a matter for legislation'.
Currently, only children under 5 years old accompanied by an opposite sex adult can enter a public washroom designated for the opposite sex. Those violating the rule face a fine of up to 2,000 Hong Kong dollars (about $255).
This marks the latest step towards recognising the rights of LGBTQ+ people in Hong Kong, which has in recent years revised policies for the community after legal challenges.
Earlier this year, Hong Kong's government proposed a registration system that would recognise same-sex partnerships formed overseas, granting such couples more rights in the city.
In 2023, Hong Kong's top court ruled that full sex reassignment surgery should not be a prerequisite for transgender people to have their gender changed on their official identity cards.
In April 2024, activist Henry Tse, who won the legal battle in 2023 and received his new ID card reflecting
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
14 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Trans activist hailed by Justin Trudeau makes VERY sinister post about JK Rowling's yacht after tracking it
A Canadian transgender activist once praised by former Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau 's government is facing fierce backlash after posting a chilling public message that appeared to reveal the location of author J.K. Rowling 's private yacht. Morgane Oger — a controversial figure in the LGBTQ + advocacy world — sparked outrage after tracking Rowling's yacht near Vancouver and inviting the author to a 'chit chat' in what many are calling a thinly veiled threat. 'Billionaire boating bigots prefer trans-inclusive vacationing spots such as British Columbia. Am I right, @jk_rowling?' Oger wrote. 'Enjoy our hospitable province, don't forget to tip, but maybe don't stay too long. Stop by English Bay and come for drinks or a bbq if you'd like a chit chat between just us yachties.' The message, tinged with both sarcasm and hostility, immediately triggered a wave of condemnation online. 'This is stalker behaviour. Leave her alone,' one user wrote. Another misgendered Oger as a 'sad little man' while saying her action was 'beyond creepy.' 'I'm sure giving someone's location online is illegal,' a third person said. 'She's very welcome here, and this is creepy doxing-like behaviour, proving many of her opinions that you hate her for,' a fourth added. Critics accused Oger of engaging in dangerous intimidation and potential doxxing just for the crime of holding dissenting views on gender identity. Rowling, a vocal supporter of women's sex-based rights, has long been targeted by transgender activists for her stance that biological sex is real and relevant in law and society. The uproar stands in stark contrast to the accolades Oger has previously received from Canadian leaders. In December 2023, Oger was awarded the Meritorious Service Medal, one of Canada's highest civilian honors, in recognition of her work advancing legal protections for transgender Canadians. She was celebrated at the time as a 'champion of diversity' whose efforts helped change national and provincial laws. 'Her courage, vision and perseverance have helped redefine the fundamental issue of equality and have advanced inclusiveness for gender-diverse Canadians,' the award citation stated. It the time, Oger was delighted with the award telling media, 'It feels really, really, really nice. We don't live in a day and age where medals come about very often, and the campaign to bring equality still has a lot of road ahead of us.' But her track record has also been marred by controversy especially among Canadian feminists and women's groups. In 2019, Oger spearheaded a successful campaign to strip Vancouver Rape Relief Canada's oldest rape crisis shelter of city funding because it refused to admit transgender women. The shelter, which serves female victims of male violence, argued that it could not adequately support those who hadn't experienced life as girls and women. 'We do not have the experience to offer services to people without the same life experience… this is not our work,' the shelter stated. Nonetheless, Vancouver City Council voted to yank its $34,000 grant unless the shelter changed its policy. 'Trans women are women and sex work is work. Trans women and sex workers deserve care and protection… I can't support orgs who exclude them,' Councilor Christine Boyle declared at the time. Oger, speaking before council, said the shelter's exclusion of trans women violated the city's inclusion criteria. Following the funding decision, the shelter was hit by waves of vandalism. 'Kill TERFS, trans power,' was scrawled on its windows, and a dead rat was nailed to the door. Oger denounced the attacks as regrettable, but blamed the shelter for provoking them. The shelter blasted Oger's campaign as 'discrimination against women in the name of inclusion,' and warned the city it was attempting to coerce them into abandoning core principles. That same combative energy is what critics say underlies Oger's post about Rowling's yacht. While Rowling is no stranger to threats and vitriol, including death threats, the public revelation of her real-time location has many stunned.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
AG Pam Bondi orders grand jury probe of Obama officials over Trump-Russia 2016 collusion investigation
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging. At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story. The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it. Your support makes all the difference.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Trump's new NASA boss wants to build a nuclear reactor on the MOON
New NASA Administrator Sean Duffy's first project will be an attempt to take American energy dominance to the moon. Duffy, who is also Secretary of Transportation and took the job as NASA Administrator after the White House shut out Elon Musk's preferred candidate, will announce plans to build a nuclear reactor on the moon this week. The Daily Mail has reached out to NASA and the White House for comment. In 2022, NASA announced plans to put a nuclear reactor on the moon by 2030 as part of a vision to turn the lunar body into an orbiting power station but Duffy wants an expedited, more definite timeline. The goal is for United States to outpace China in 'winning the second space race,' a source told Politico. Earlier this year, it was revealed China may team up with Russia in an attempt to build their own lunar nuclear reactor. Sure enough, Duffy's directive claims that China or Russia or any American enemy could 'declare a keep-out zone which would significantly inhibit the United States' if they got to the moon first. Duffy's directive commands NASA to get someone to lead the effort in the next 60 days and solicit companies that can help launch ahead of China. A former Fox News and reality TV star, Duffy is also pushing an effort to replace the International Space Station. Duffy, a former Congressman from Wisconsin, oversees the $25 billion space agency. In 2022, the US space agency chose three design concept proposals for a fission power system that could be ready to launch by the end of the decade. It is unclear if Duffy is going from the same plans. The plan is for the 40-kilowatt class fission power system to last at least 10 years in the lunar environment, with the hope that it could one day support a permanent human presence on the moon, as well as support manned missions to Mars and beyond. If NASA is to build a base on the lunar surface, one of the major problems to solve will be how such a proposed settlement would be powered. Solar panels are great for powering rovers, but a human base would need a continuous and reliable source of power. NASA experts are looking into nuclear fission as the answer because the technology has been used extensively on Earth. Relatively small and lightweight compared to other power systems, fission systems are reliable and could enable continuous power regardless of location, available sunlight, and other natural environmental conditions, the US space agency said. If the demonstration of such a system on the moon was successful, it would pave the way for the fueling of longer duration journeys through space. It is hoped that the development of these fission surface power technologies will also help NASA advance nuclear propulsion systems that rely on reactors to generate power. These could then be used for deep space exploration missions. The goal will also be to beat China and Russia to the same mission. The East Asian country aims to become a major space power and land astronauts on the moon by 2030, and its planned Chang'e-8 mission for 2028 would lay the groundwork for constructing a permanent, manned lunar base. In a presentation in Shanghai, the 2028 mission's Chief Engineer Pei Zhaoyu showed that the lunar base's energy supply could also depend on large-scale solar arrays, and pipelines and cables for heating and electricity built on the moon's surface. Russia's space agency Roscosmos said last year it planned to build a nuclear reactor on the moon's surface with the China National Space Administration (CNSA) by 2035 to power the International Lunar Research Station (ILRS). The inclusion of the nuclear power unit in a Chinese space official's presentation at a conference for officials from the 17 countries and international organisations that make up the ILRS suggests Beijing supports the idea, although it has never formally announced it. 'An important question for the ILRS is power supply, and in this Russia has a natural advantage, when it comes to nuclear power plants, especially sending them into space, it leads the world, it is ahead of the United States,' Wu Weiren, chief designer of China's lunar exploration program, told Reuters on the sidelines of the conference. After little progress on talks over a space-based reactor in the past, 'I hope this time both countries can send a nuclear reactor to the moon,' Wu said.
