NCEA overhaul sparks optimism and concern
Photo:
Getty Images
Teachers' unions are cautiously optimistic changes to the country's secondary school qualifications framework will work, provided they are implemented and resourced well.
But the opposition is concerned the "complete overhaul" goes too far.
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Education Minister Erica Stanford
on Monday
said NCEA Level 1 would be replaced with foundation literacy and numeracy tests. Levels 2 and 3 would be replaced with a New Zealand Certificate of Education and an Advanced Certificate.
Students would be required to take five subjects and pass at least four to get each certificate. Marking would be out of 100, and grades range from A to E.
Stanford said as a parent, she did not understand how NCEA (National Certificate of Educational Achievement) worked.
"I thought that if you're sitting English, everyone's sitting the same English - but that's not the case… There is too much credit counting and bringing together of sometimes quite ad hoc standards because we moved to the standards-based assessment that are not setting students up for success."
But the new system is not a return to the days of single three-hour exams measuring a students' learning for the year, nor will it be graded, forcing a certain percentage of students to fail.
"I think it's really important to know that this is still standards-based assessment," Post Primary Teachers' Association president Chris Abercrombie told
Nine to Noon
.
"So the real heart of NCEA, that standards base, is still there, which is really good to see because we know that helps students show their knowledge and understanding in various forms, so that's really good to see that that still exists…
"Because it's all standards-based assessment… the 'bell curve' is not going to be put into the marking. So it's not gonna change that aspect fundamentally, which is really good."
The new system is expected to be implemented one year at a time, so students will not be doing a mix of NCEA and and the new qualifications.
Abercrombie said implementing it in a planned, robust and well-resourced way would be key to its success.
"There's a significant concern about this because we know because of the poor implementation plan of Level 1, it did create a lot of stress on schools and teachers and principals to do that.
"So, as I say, implementation is going to be absolutely key. We cannot repeat the mistakes made during the implementation of the new Level 1, and the co-requisites literacy and numeracy."
Secondary Principals Association president Louise Anaru said the government must give teachers the training, resources and time they needed to introduce the overhaul.
"The staging and sequencing of the changes are really important, and I can see that there is a timeline in place. Our schools will need to be resourced sufficiently, and they also need adequate time to implement all of the changes."
Anaru said the overhaul retained the best parts of NCEA.
Abercrombie noted that so far, principals had been consulted on the changes - but not teachers.
"We need to make sure the sector really is listened to in this and so, hopefully the consultation period will allow that to happen."
He also noted teachers "asked to do a lot of work for a 1 percent" pay increase, so "some more movement on the negotiation table" would be expected from the government.
Consultation closes on 1 September.
Students who will miss out on the new qualifications should not be worried, Abercrombie said.
"[NCEA] will still be recognised at universities. We have students using their NCEA grads to attend universities all around the world. We've had 20 years of people being lawyers and doctors and builders and plumbers and nurses and everything in between, based on their NCEA results…
"It's a very valid assessment, and they'll be able to reach their goals whatever they want to with that."
Education Minister Erica Stanford and Prime Minister Christopher Luxon announce changes to NCEA.
Photo:
RNZ / Nick Monro
Stanford agreed, saying her kids were doing NCEA - even her son, who had a choice between that and the alternative International Baccalaureate programme.
"It is a good qualification. Children still get into universities around the world with this qualification. We can make it so much better. There is a lack of consistency, but my message to parents who are still going through NCEA like me, you can still rely on NCEA. It's a good qualification, but we need to look to the future and be more ambitious for our kids, and that's what I'm doing."
Claire Amos, president of the Auckland Secondary Principals' Association and principal of Albany Senior High School, told
Midday Report
aside from replacing Level 1, the changes felt "a little bit like window dressing".
She feared there would be a narrowing of the current 67 subjects schools could choose to offer.
"It does look like it will be less flexible, with a focus on whole subjects rather than at present, we could actually put together a whole lot of achievement standards and unit standards to make up a total of 60 credits for students - and in some schools, that may not be just made up of four or five subjects."
She said rather than being dismissed as a "patchwork" qualification, NCEA Levels 1 and 2 should be seen as a "diverse definitions of success".
Amos was also concerned with the
discussion document's mention
of possibly raising the school leaving age from 16 to 17.
"On paper, that sounds great. But if you've got young people who don't see themselves in the qualification framework that's on offer, we're actually going to be managing these disengaged learners."
Opposition parties warned the overhauled risked throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
Photo:
RNZ / Angus Dreaver
Labour education spokesperson Willow-Jean Prime said NCEA was not perfect, but changes must be based on evidence and proper sector consultation.
"People are reading the consultation document and asking questions like, what will this mean for the subjects? What subjects are going to be offered? How will they be weighted?
"There's those questions that are unanswered and families are looking for and needing certainty for their children. What we don't want to see is these rushed overhauls and a generation of children being used as guinea pigs for things that have failed in the past,
like national standards
."
Green Party education spokesperson Lawrence Xu-Nan said the proposals risked turning back the clock on decades of progress, with a return to a one-size-fits-alls rigid approach.
"NCEA definitely has its strengths. It's a well-designed, inclusive and flexible qualification and it is an internationally recognised qualification. Chucking it all out isn't going to address the real problems, which are policy instability and under-resourcing of education."
He said there was a lot of "engineered fear" that the NCEA system could be gamed.
"By and large if you're talking to students and teachers, that doesn't happen as commonly as people think it does. There are areas of NCEA that need to be rejigged, but not to the extent of what we are seeing in the announcement today, which is a complete overhaul."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Solomon Islands government moves to raise legal marriage age to 18
At the moment, someone can legally marry at 15 with parental consent. Photo: UNICEF/Naftalin The Solomon Islands government is making moves to raise the legal marriage age to 18. At the moment, someone can legally marry at 15 with parental consent, something that may change following a review of the Islanders' Marriage and Divorce Act. Additionally, children can be married in accordance with customary law, which provides no minimum marriage age. Local media reported that Foreign Minister Peter Shanel Agovaka told parliament this week that a proposed change in a section of the Act aims to align marriage laws with other legal matters, such as the voting age. He said the move is in line with international human rights standards and growing calls for stronger child protection laws. World Vision, ChildFund and Save the Children, as members of the Solomon Islands Endim Vaelens Agenstim Pikinini (SIEVAP) Coalition, started the 'Make It 18' campaign to advocate for a change in the Marriage Act to set a minimum marriage age of 18. A report led by the coalition of charities said one in five girls in Solomon Islands is married before the age of 18, and this increases to one in four in rural areas. Around six percent of girls are married before the age of 15 in Solomon Islands. Save the Children advocacy and research director Jacqui Southey said there was widespread public support to increase the age. "There was consensus between children and adults, parents and community members that children's experiences should be playing with their friends, being at school, learning skills," Southey said. "They also thought that children getting married too young could lead to problems and we know that through the data that problems such as increased risk of domestic violence is a real concern, the inability to finish school, the inability to have good earnings prospects later in life and greater risk of exploitation." In June, the Koleasi Community Bylaw , developed in partnership with Hope Trust and Tearfund, came into force - explicitly prohibiting marriage under the age of 18. A breach carries a maximum fine of SI$1000. Penalties also apply for organising a forced marriage or harbouring someone against their will.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Children the priority in first round of Social Investment Fund
Photo: Supplied The Social Investment Agency has revealed that its initial round of funding will focus on children of families with complex needs. To qualify for funding, organisations will need to be working with children whose parents are, or have been, in prison, or working with children whose parents experienced the care system. It also covers children that were stood down or suspended from school when they were 12 or younger. The secretary for Social Investment, Andrew Coster, says children who have had these experiences are more likely to experience poor outcomes and require significant social support throughout their lives.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Contact boss wants Kiwis to be more adaptive in push for renewable energy
Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Kiwis need to get over themselves when it comes to accepting renewable power projects in their area, an energy boss says. Contact Energy is ramping up its renewable energy supplies, saying investment in that area is critical to the economy. It's just lodged resource consent to expand a battery for power storage it's built on the outskirts of Auckland, which will power another 220,000 homes. Its chief executive Mike Fuge told Morning Report: "Batteries are a great technology, the price of lithium is coming down rapidly. We see batteries as a key part of the system - they take care of the morning and evening peaks." It has 100 megawatts being installed at Glenbrook, it had received consent for another 500mW at Glenbrook and intends to apply for another 500mW for Stratford. "So yes they will form very much part of the new ecosystem and they are part of that solution." However, he was not a supporter of the Onlow battery project proposed by the last Labour government in part because its cost was so high at $24 billion. In response to discussion of a proposed wind farm for Southland which has attracted opposition, Fuge said Kiwis needed to be more receptive to change and adapt to the renewable energy boom. "We're going to have to make trade-offs. Wind farms - they are visual. If you're Dutch you've learned to live with wind farms over a 500-year period and so it's just change, and so we just have to step into that change and make some very deliberate choices as a country that this is what we want to do." Contact's focus was on building new baseload renewable energy and geothermal. It had spent $1.5 billion on Tohara and Tohuka 3 which had brought on 5 percent. Te Mihi 2A which would replace Wairakei was underway as was the country's biggest solar farm, Kowhai Park, in Christchurch and there were plans for a wind farm. "This is our opportunity to move the market to reliable renewable energy which isn't going to just serve us, it's going to serve our tamariki and our mokopuna." The Te Mihi power station. Photo: Contact Energy Asked if all the plans and projects should have advanced faster, he responded: 'Jeez, how could I go faster?" Contact had been accepted into the government's fast track process and he hoped this would lead to faster resource consents. He said increased lines charges were around 6 or 7 percent to bills but the company had committed to the energy component of the increase would be no higher than the inflation rate. "We know that Kiwi homes are doing it tough at the moment and we know that electricity at the best of times is not something people love paying for ... we're doing our best to keep those prices moderated." Four of the 10 highest peaks have occurred this winter while wholesale prices have been 70 percent lower than last year. "Just the calmness is so important." Fuge said Contact was working with a range of industries such as dairy and meat processing to get them converted to electricity at reasonable prices. The country's energy supply was in a much better position than last year when a dry year coincided with outages and some industries were closing although the dramatic drop in gas supply had caught everyone off guard. Another six terrawatt hours of renewable energy had been added in the last six years which was the equivalent of two-thirds of Maui at its peak and around 15 percent of the country's supply. It was made up of wind, solar and baseload geothermal. As well there was the Huntly HFO so that a large coal stockpile (amassing up to 600,000 tonnes) could be used "in an extreme dry year". Long-term gas supply had also been secured. "So I've always argued that in terms of security of supply it's never a magic solution out there .... you've got to do all these things in quick order and that's what we've done that but underpinning this is the renewable energy supply." The removal of the government's oil and gas ban would be "helpful", he said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
