Ollie Pope signals to Ben Stokes after sending Yashasvi Jaiswal packing with DRS call, makes Atherton eat his words
Such was Pope's record with DRS calls that former England captain Michael Atherton had no doubts that it was another addition to Pope's long list of disastrous DRS calls. To be fair to Atherton, it did look like Jaiswal had got an inside edge before the ball thudded onto his pads. There was a clear defelction and a double noise. Perhaps that is exactly why umpire Hasan Raza gave it not out.
"Inside edge. The discussion here must be about the two noises. Oh, Pope has gone for it. He has got his last 14 DRS calls wrong, I'm afraid, this will be his 15th," said Atherton on commentary.
Playing his first match of the series, Gus Atkinson got one to come back in with the angle to the left-hander from around the wicket. Jaiswal was rooted to the crease. A tentative prode did little to stop the ball from hitting his pads. Atkinson and the England slip cordon went up in a spontaneous appeal only to be denied by the umpire.
The bowler, however, seemed confident, and so did Pope. Despite his horrible track record with DRS calls, credit to Pope for trusting his instincts and his bowler so early in the Test match. He signalled for the DRS.
Even as the replays were getting ready, Atherton repeated, "There has to be an inside edge." The first replay changed everything. There was a huge gap between Jaiswal's bat and the ball. The ball clipped his front pad and hit his back pad, creating the double noise that confused Atherton and even the umpire.
It was pitching in line, the impact was in line and it was hitting middle and leg. Umpire Hasan Raza was asked to change his decision to out. As soon as the giant screen flashed three reds, Pope turned to the England dressing room, both arms in the air and signalled to Ben Stokes, who could not stop giggling.
One could guess that the entire England team was aware of Pope's dubious DRS record.
Ahterton accepted his mistake immediately: "Well, he's got better eyes than I."
Jaiswal had to take the long walk back for 2 as England got off to a good start in the deciding Test.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
3 minutes ago
- First Post
'The truth is England panicked": English media slams cricket team for losing Oval Test, letting go of 'biggest win' of Bazball era
The English media did not held back after the England cricket team 'panicked' under pressure against India on Day 5 of Oval Test, losing the match by just six runs. As England were forced to settle for a series draw, the media slammed the team. read more English media praised the thrilling cricket between India and England but rued the fact that the hosts could not win the series. Images: Reuters The English media weren't very kind to the England cricket team in particular as India secured a thrilling 2-2 series draw on Monday with a sensational session of play on the last day of the five-match Test series. Needing just 35 runs to win the fifth Test at the Oval, England lost their remaining four wickets in under an hour to finish on a disappointing 367, chasing 374. England's downfall was orchestrated by an inspired Mohammed Siraj, who spat fire with his outswinging deliveries and was ably supported by Parsidh Krishna under overcast conditions in London. Sira dismissed STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Jamie Smith, Jamie Overton and Gus Atkinson on Day 5 of the fifth Test, with Atkinson being the last to fall in the match, while Krishna cleaned up Josh Tongue in the final session of play. Vaughan says England panicked on Day 5 vs India It was a miraculous turnaround from India in a match where England looked the favourites despite being handed a 374-run chase, as they nicely motored to 332/4 with Joe Root batting on 105. Even with only 35 needed on Day 5 and Indian pacers having worked overtime, the hosts were the favourites, but the lower-order crumbled under the pressure, former England captain Michael Vaughan wrote in his column for The Telegraph. 'Let's be honest, England should have won,' Vaughan's column was headlined. The former batter acknowledged England losing big names for the Oval Test as Ben Stokes and Jofra Archer sat out, but he conceded that the hosts eventually lost due to their failure to handle the pressure on Day 5. 'But the truth is England panicked,' Vaughan wrote on England's batting. 'The closer they got, within 70, they tried to be more high-risk. The approach was wrong on the final morning. It was too risky.' 'If India lost in that fashion, we would have said they yipped up. If South Africa lost like that, we would say they choked. It was that bad a miss. The defeat will really hurt England. When you know you should win a game, it is so painful,' he added. England accused of squandering biggest win of Bazball era Also, in The Telegraph, British cricket journalist Nick Hoult wrote about how 'England let biggest win of Bazball era slip after all-time epic.' It was a sentiment shared by other English media outlets as well, who pointed out that Brendon McCullum's team blew the chance to secure their biggest win after losing the plot in the final session of the Test series. Lawrence Booth, writing in The Mail, penned a column headlined: 'Brendon McCullum's era is still lacking a prize scalp as England come up short again.' 'Thanks to the Manchester rain in 2023, and India's fightback here, their two home series against Australia and India under Brendon McCullum have finished all square. 'Their record under Stokes and McCullum remains strong, but Bazball's critics — mainly in Australia and India, though plenty in England — will not take them seriously until they beat one of the other members of the so-called Big Three,' Booth wrote. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD BBC's chief cricket reporter, Stephan Shemilt, in his piece from the Oval, termed England's defeat at the ground as a 'missed opportunity.' 'It was highly creditable for England to get so close to chasing down 374, what would have been their second highest of all time. It was also a missed opportunity for a statement series win,' he wrote.
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
India vs England: Shubman Gill has more ‘clarity' on captaincy now
India's player of the series India's captain Shubman Gill on day five of the fifth cricket test match between England and India at The Kia Oval in London, Monday, Aug. 4, 2025. (AP Photo/Kirsty Wigglesworth) London: Shubman Gill landed in England after having been given the Test captaincy at 25 years of age, without a proven Test record. A 2-2 scoreline after five gruelling Test matches and 754 runs at an average of 75.4 later, he has retained his poise. On the field, he is the quintessential in-your-face millennial Indian cricketer. Off it, he has been a departure from the norm. 'There are moments like these where you feel the journey is worth it. You should be able to navigate through the highs and lows of life and try to stay balanced, irrespective of winning or losing. It's difficult, but it's a process. That's the real journey,' Gill said calmly after India's win here on Monday. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! There has been a clear attempt to not come across as an over-the-top cricketer. At the start of the tour, he did throw the gauntlet by declaring his wish to finish as the highest run-getter in the series. Now that he has done that by a fair distance, Gill himself mentioned his indifferent record before coming on the tour. — ShubmanGill (@ShubmanGill) 'Each hundred that I scored had a different significance. In Leeds, I was under a bit of pressure after not being able to perform in this format. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Jolie-Pitt Family Proudly Stands By Shiloh's Change Drivepedia Undo The double century and the second innings hundred in Birmingham helped to seal that match. And the one in Manchester, to be able to save that game from that situation was special. Each of them has a story and each of them means a lot to me,' Gill said. Poll What do you think of Shubman Gill's performance as a Test captain at 25? Impressive for his age Needs more experience Too early to judge Not a fan of his captaincy The journey as a batter has been fulfilling. As a captain, he acknowledges that he now has a better understanding of the areas he needs to work on. 'I have more clarity where I personally need to work on as a captain,' Gill said before adding, 'There will always be opinions in hindsight. What matters to me is I want to take the most probable decision in that moment.' Shubman Gill and Mohammed Siraj press conference: India stars answer all questions Gill defended the decision to play with three strike bowlers instead of four throughout the series. 'You learn something new. From the first match, there were many things that I got to learn. A lot of people were thinking that I should have played a fourth fast bowler. Karun played instead of the fourth pacer and his half-century in the first inning was equally important for us. Opinions are made after the match,' he said. At various stages of the series, he has looked a bit lost as a captain. There were times when his deputy Rishabh Pant and KL Rahul would look more involved. On Monday, he looked in control. He had conversations with his two pacers after every ball. He left the field open for Gus Atkinson to take easy singles even with No. 10 and No. 11 at the crease. 'We wanted them to take 30 scoring shots instead of a few to the boundary,' was his curt explanation of his tactics. The result shows the move paid off. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
England Face Searching Ashes Questions After India Series Thriller
England suffered an agonising six-run loss to India at the Oval on Monday as one of the most dramatic Test series of recent times ended in a 2-2 draw. Their next major red-ball assignment is a five-match Ashes series away to arch-rivals Australia -- where England have gone 15 Tests without a win -- starting in November. Below AFP Sport looks at some of the key issues that emerged from England's rollercoaster contest with India and what they mean for their quest to regain the Ashes 'Down Under'. Stokes central to England's hopes What England gain from having Ben Stokes in their side was never more evident than when their inspirational captain missed the fifth Test with a shoulder injury -- a fresh worry following his history of hamstring trouble. The 34-year-old all-rounder was the most threatening member of England's attack against India, taking 17 wickets at 25 in 140 overs -- the most he has bowled in a series. Stokes also looked back to his best with the bat, scoring 141 in England's mammoth total of 669 in the drawn fourth Test at Old Trafford. By contrast specialist opener Zak Crawley failed to reach three figures in nine innings. And at the Oval, the sight of vice-captain Ollie Pope running off to the dressing room to receive what appeared to be tactical guidance from Stokes did not say much for England's depth of leadership. England limited-overs captain Harry Brook, also a mainstay of the Test team and a lively skipper in the Stokes mould, could yet prove a better fit as vice-captain against Australia. Fast-bowling plan under threat England have long believed a battery of genuinely fast bowlers is essential if they are to win an Ashes series in Australia for the first time since 2010/11. But fitness issues could blight their best-laid plans. Jofra Archer made an encouraging return to Test cricket against India but played just two matches as England looked to manage the express paceman's workload. Mark Wood, another bowler with genuine pace, has not played Test cricket for nearly 12 months and had knee surgery earlier this year. The inconsistent Josh Tongue's return of 19 wickets at under 30 in the India series could well see him selected for Ashes duty, with Gus Atkinson's five-wicket haul on his return to Test duty at the Oval doing his cause no harm. Spin dilemma England, and Stokes in particular, have shown huge faith in Shoaib Bashir, a 21-year-old off-spinner unable to hold down a regular place in a county side but who has now taken 68 wickets in 19 Tests at 39. In the India series, Bashir's 10 wickets came at an expensive average of 54.1, before a finger injury ruled him out of the last two Tests. But Hampshire stalwart Liam Dawson failed to seize his chance in the drawn fourth Test, with Stokes appearing to tell the left-armer where he should be bowling on the Old Trafford pitch. Leicestershire's 20-year-old leg-spinner Rehan Ahmed, already England's youngest Test cricketer, is another option. England, however, didn't bother with a specialist spinner at the Oval, deploying Joe Root and Jacob Bethell -- clean bowled following a reckless charge down the pitch during a second-innings collapse -- for a mere 11 overs combined. But former Australia captain Ricky Ponting believes England should stick with Bashir for the Ashes because of his similarity to outstanding Australia off-spinner Nathan Lyon. "Australia will have probably three or four left-handers in their line-up which will aid the right-arm off-spinner as well," Ponting told Sky Sports. "And it's the over-spin that you need in Australia.
