Cara Darmody: The law breakers are at the Cabinet table
Let's cut straight to the chase in this opinion piece — I'm here today to call out the blatant assessments of needs law-breaking by the Taoiseach and the Government! Three different taoisigh have made promises to me to fix this issue, and all have dramatically failed.
I'm the 14-year old disability rights campaigner who performed a 50-hour protest on the dirty street outside Leinster House three weeks ago, and I'm the campaigner who was credited by the previous taoiseach for the allocation of €10m of Government funding to what he calls "Cara's fund".
Let me explain how the Government is breaking the law. The Disability Act of 2005 states an assessment of need must be carried out on an autistic child within six months, full-stop. That six-month timeframe is there because every single person knows early intervention is the key.
It's also generally accepted that when early intervention does not occur, that permanent damage is caused to children with disabilities. It's a no-brainer.
Cara Darmody is escorted by Sinn Féin Maurice Quinlivan as she arrives at Leinster House to address the Oireachtas committee on disability matters. Picture: Sam Boal/Collins
My own story is very simple — while I'm not autistic, I have two brothers Neil, 12, and John, eight, who are, and who have severe and profound intellectual disabilities. They were both failed dramatically by the State in relation to assessments and services and Neil remains in an inappropriate school place.
Our story is the story of so many thousands of other families. I cannot do anything to change the permanent damage caused to Neil and John, but I can advocate to stop damage being done to thousands of autistic children in the future.
And this law-breaking by the Government isn't like parking on double yellow lines, where people can simply drive around you. This is law-breaking that causes permanent damage to autistic children.
Let's look at what's happening in Ireland right now — in 93% of cases, children are assessed outside the six-month timeframe. So let's call a spade a spade — the law is being systematically smashed by the Government. In Co Tipperary, where I'm from, the present waiting time is 48 months. This isn't a close call.
There are presently more than 15,000 children waiting on HSE assessments of needs waiting lists. Shockingly, the HSE has revealed the figure will go to 25,000 by Christmas.
All because the Government is asleep at the wheel and in a non-emergency mode of action. No spin or political waffle can hide the truth of these figures.
The Cabinet is breaking the law, the Taoiseach is breaking the law. I get it that they don't want to hear that kind of criticism, I do, but it's the truth — they are law-breakers when it comes to assessments of needs. And if they don't like that criticism, then here's my advice — stop breaking the law!
It's a sad indictment on our country that if someone asked me to find a location in Ireland where 100% of the people present are breaking a law of some type, then I would go to the Taoiseach's department on a Tuesday morning for the Cabinet meeting. That's shocking to say but it's true.
Three weeks ago, I was so grateful to be invited to meet our Taoiseach during my protest. But I was shocked he would not declare this as a national emergency. He's breaking the law, and the HSE has now handed him evidence that this crisis is totally out of control, with figures to rise by 10,000 children over the next seven months.
Cara with then taoiseach Simon Harris in 2024. Picture: Mark Darmody
How many does that number have to reach before he declares this as a national emergency? 30,000? 40,000? 50,000?
Cara at Leinster House halfway through her 50-hour sleepout. Picture: SAM BOAL/Collins Photos
So let's look at the Taoiseach's own words — he says they're 'not in a position to uphold the law'. Seriously! Could you imagine any citizen in this country being allowed to get away with such a statement. He also said: 'It's a technical breach of the law.' Well I have news for him — this is not a technical breach of the law, it's total and utter blatant law-breaking.
I'm going to be blunt to the Taoiseach. Your law-breaking is causing permanent damage to children with disabilities. You and your Cabinet need to wake up and show some initiative and urgency. Children are suffering permanent damage at your hands and your conduct needs to be called out.
And why do I believe the Government is asleep at the wheel? It's because they are stuck in the captivity of negativity, an endless cycle of negative thinking that fails to remove barriers on the road to progress.
So if the Taoiseach feels he can't sit down with the HSE chief executive Bernard Gloster to urgently seek solutions to this national crisis, then I'll give it a go myself. I'm delighted to have secured a meeting Mr Gloster on July 1 at HSE headquarters where I hope we can make huge progress on this crisis.
My message to the Taoiseach today is very simple — immediately declare this as a national emergency, set up a taskforce to physically knock on every private psychologist and therapist's door in the country with an emergency request for help, and dramatically finance Cara's Fund.
And finally, Taoiseach — stop breaking the assessments of needs law!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Government advisers call for tripling of EV grants in bid to slash transport emissions
A new top-rate grant of €10,000 would apply to smaller models costing less than €35,000, with priority given to lower-income households in areas lacking public transport. The cost would be at least partly funded by increased taxes on the sale of new petrol and diesel cars. The calls come from the Climate Change Advisory Council (CCAC), which says the Government is stalling on steps to achieve the dramatic cut needed in greenhouse gas emissions from transport. In a report published today, the council says sales of new EVs fell 24pc last year and there were just 72,640 electric cars on the roads – a figure that must increase almost 12-fold to meet the 2030 target of 845,000. Public EV charging points are only one-third the EU average rate – seven per 10,000 people compared to 20 per 10,000 across the EU. School buses carry just 18pc of pupils, with hundreds of thousands left to be ferried by car every day. Re-alloaction of road space to cycle lanes and safer footpaths has been 'incremental' instead of transformational. Ireland is one of the few EU countries without Low-Emission Zones that designate certain urban areas for EVs, bikes and pedestrians only. Transport emissions fell by 1.3pc last year – the first reduction since the temporary fall during the Covid-19 pandemic. However, emissions need to reduce by 50pc over the next five years and the CCAC says there is no sign of this happening. Transport uses more energy than any other sector in Ireland and it produces the second most greenhouse gas emissions after agriculture, accounting for 21.5pc of the national total. ADVERTISEMENT Public transport passenger numbers are rising and EV numbers are increasing but the growing population and increasing size of cars cancels out the gains. 'Urgent and decisive action must now be taken by Government to end our reliance on fossil fuels and deliver the kind of transformative change that is required in this sector,' said CCAC chair Marie Donnelly. Recommended actions include a revamp of EV supports, retaining the existing €3,500 grant for new cars up to the value of €60,000 but offering the much greater incentive for smaller, more efficient cars to applicants in lower income brackets and certain geographic areas. Scrappage schemes for petrol and diesel cars and supports to buy second-hand EVs are also recommended, including possibly interest-free loans. The CCAC is also urging much greater investment in all forms of public transport and a substantial widening of eligibility for the school transport scheme. Concerns are also raised about the vulnerability of key transport infrastructure – in particular ports – to extreme weather events such as Storm Éowyn last January.
Irish Examiner
5 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Emergency laws to extend RPZs nationwide will be pushed through this week
New emergency laws to extend rent pressure zones (RPZs) across the country are set to be pushed through by the end of the week, despite accusations that they have 'not been thought through'. James Browne, the housing minister, has said it is a matter of 'priority and urgency' to extend RPZs across the entire country to prevent landlords from hiking rents by more than 2% per year. Mr Browne has conceded that it would be 'unworkable' to introduce 'special exemptions' for students living in the private rental sector to prevent rents being reset when they leave a property. 'There's always challenges like that. Students, nurses, gardaí, doctors, consultants,' said Mr Browne. 'I think, to try and engineer into the legislation that a landlord would then have to identify what that person's role is. Are they a student? Are they a full-time student, a part-time student, or what qualifies a student? It will be unworkable and I think it would be unenforceable in those particular sets of circumstances.' The new laws will expand existing RPZ protections to the approximately 17% of tenancies across the country which are not currently in rent-controlled areas. Despite criticism by opposition TDs in the Dáil on Tuesday night, the Dáil schedule for Wednesday has been revised to allow the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Bill 2025 go through all of its stages. It is expected the legislation will then move to the Seanad for further approval tomorrow before the bill is signed into law by the President on Friday. At present, landlords outside RPZs are not restricted in how much they can increase the rents they charge each year. The changes to introduce a national RPZ come ahead of wider rental reform from the Government expected to come into effect on March 1, 2026. The new proposals will allow for landlords to reset their rents either after six years or if a tenant voluntarily leaves the property. Mr Browne said: I do need the support and expect the support of the opposition to do this as well. Labour housing spokesman Conor Sheehan said the Government's response to a Sinn Féin motion supported by the opposition and debated last night was 'very disappointing'. He said the Coalition has effectively 'thrown renters under a bus by completely undermining housing options for young people, for students, for junior doctors , for transient, and migrant workers'. TDs recounted being contacted by constituents who were sleeping in their cars, with Sinn Féin's Pearse Doherty stating the Government, in its 'ivory towers', does not recognise that 'it's not just raining, but it's lashing on ordinary people the length and breadth of the country'. Mr Doherty told the housing minister: You don't get it, you don't get what people are going through. Social Democrats TD Rory Hearne described the housing, rent, and homelessness crisis as a 'social catastrophe' and raised the 'despair and anxiety' of 500,000 people stuck in their childhood bedrooms and unable to see a time when they can hope to begin their adult lives. He added that housing is human right and hit out at decades of bad decisions from successive governments, which has focused on 'investor funds and corporate landlords profiting from housing'. Labour has submitted emergency amendments to the Government's bill which would introduce a two-year rent freeze and roll out fines of up to €100,000 for landlords breaking the law. It is expected that other opposition parties will also table amendments to the proposed laws.
Irish Examiner
5 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Cara Darmody: The law breakers are at the Cabinet table
Let's cut straight to the chase in this opinion piece — I'm here today to call out the blatant assessments of needs law-breaking by the Taoiseach and the Government! Three different taoisigh have made promises to me to fix this issue, and all have dramatically failed. I'm the 14-year old disability rights campaigner who performed a 50-hour protest on the dirty street outside Leinster House three weeks ago, and I'm the campaigner who was credited by the previous taoiseach for the allocation of €10m of Government funding to what he calls "Cara's fund". Let me explain how the Government is breaking the law. The Disability Act of 2005 states an assessment of need must be carried out on an autistic child within six months, full-stop. That six-month timeframe is there because every single person knows early intervention is the key. It's also generally accepted that when early intervention does not occur, that permanent damage is caused to children with disabilities. It's a no-brainer. Cara Darmody is escorted by Sinn Féin Maurice Quinlivan as she arrives at Leinster House to address the Oireachtas committee on disability matters. Picture: Sam Boal/Collins My own story is very simple — while I'm not autistic, I have two brothers Neil, 12, and John, eight, who are, and who have severe and profound intellectual disabilities. They were both failed dramatically by the State in relation to assessments and services and Neil remains in an inappropriate school place. Our story is the story of so many thousands of other families. I cannot do anything to change the permanent damage caused to Neil and John, but I can advocate to stop damage being done to thousands of autistic children in the future. And this law-breaking by the Government isn't like parking on double yellow lines, where people can simply drive around you. This is law-breaking that causes permanent damage to autistic children. Let's look at what's happening in Ireland right now — in 93% of cases, children are assessed outside the six-month timeframe. So let's call a spade a spade — the law is being systematically smashed by the Government. In Co Tipperary, where I'm from, the present waiting time is 48 months. This isn't a close call. There are presently more than 15,000 children waiting on HSE assessments of needs waiting lists. Shockingly, the HSE has revealed the figure will go to 25,000 by Christmas. All because the Government is asleep at the wheel and in a non-emergency mode of action. No spin or political waffle can hide the truth of these figures. The Cabinet is breaking the law, the Taoiseach is breaking the law. I get it that they don't want to hear that kind of criticism, I do, but it's the truth — they are law-breakers when it comes to assessments of needs. And if they don't like that criticism, then here's my advice — stop breaking the law! It's a sad indictment on our country that if someone asked me to find a location in Ireland where 100% of the people present are breaking a law of some type, then I would go to the Taoiseach's department on a Tuesday morning for the Cabinet meeting. That's shocking to say but it's true. Three weeks ago, I was so grateful to be invited to meet our Taoiseach during my protest. But I was shocked he would not declare this as a national emergency. He's breaking the law, and the HSE has now handed him evidence that this crisis is totally out of control, with figures to rise by 10,000 children over the next seven months. Cara with then taoiseach Simon Harris in 2024. Picture: Mark Darmody How many does that number have to reach before he declares this as a national emergency? 30,000? 40,000? 50,000? Cara at Leinster House halfway through her 50-hour sleepout. Picture: SAM BOAL/Collins Photos So let's look at the Taoiseach's own words — he says they're 'not in a position to uphold the law'. Seriously! Could you imagine any citizen in this country being allowed to get away with such a statement. He also said: 'It's a technical breach of the law.' Well I have news for him — this is not a technical breach of the law, it's total and utter blatant law-breaking. I'm going to be blunt to the Taoiseach. Your law-breaking is causing permanent damage to children with disabilities. You and your Cabinet need to wake up and show some initiative and urgency. Children are suffering permanent damage at your hands and your conduct needs to be called out. And why do I believe the Government is asleep at the wheel? It's because they are stuck in the captivity of negativity, an endless cycle of negative thinking that fails to remove barriers on the road to progress. So if the Taoiseach feels he can't sit down with the HSE chief executive Bernard Gloster to urgently seek solutions to this national crisis, then I'll give it a go myself. I'm delighted to have secured a meeting Mr Gloster on July 1 at HSE headquarters where I hope we can make huge progress on this crisis. My message to the Taoiseach today is very simple — immediately declare this as a national emergency, set up a taskforce to physically knock on every private psychologist and therapist's door in the country with an emergency request for help, and dramatically finance Cara's Fund. And finally, Taoiseach — stop breaking the assessments of needs law!
