
Willie Collum on Celtic's denied penalty vs St Johnstone
Callum McGregor, Daizen Maeda, Adam Idah, and Jota all scored in a rampant 5-0 victory.
Read more:
Celtic were 4-0 up at the break but didn't let up in the second 45. Just before he was withdrawn on 64 minutes, James Forrest looked to weave his way through the opposition defence.
He was eventually brought to ground as he did so, and referee Calum Scott initially pointed to the spot.
After co-operation with VAR, however, he changed his decision.
The SFA's Head of Refereeing, Collum, recently spoke out on the incident: "So there is an initial challenge outside the box, but as they come into the box, the first challenge is what the referee initially awards the penalty for," he said [VAR Review Show].
"Watching the footage live in the VAR centre, it looked like a penalty kick, but when you start to analyse the challenge the referee has punished, there is no contact or minimal contact.
"There has been talk about an arm coming across [the face of Forrest] - that's not enough in terms of a threshold for us to award a penalty kick here.
"This is a correct intervention."
Celtic are back in league action this afternoon as they travel to face Dundee United at Tannadice. Avoid defeat, and Rodgers' men will be crowned champions of Scotland for the fourth consecutive season.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
There has to be ambition from everyone – Brendan Rodgers sends contract message
Rodgers is entering the final season of his three-year deal and told principal shareholder Dermot Desmond and chief executive Michael Nicholson that he is not interested in performing a maintenance job. The Celtic manager reiterated he would be going nowhere of his own volition before his contract expires but his long-term future remains unclear. Asked about his contract situation ahead of Celtic's William Hill Premiership opener against St Mirren on Sunday, Rodgers said: 'Dermot and Michael and I had a conversation over the summer on where we were at. 'I said: 'I'm very happy here'. There's conditions we want to be able to improve and be better because I'm not the type of manager that's good at maintaining anything. If it's just something to maintain, I'm not the manager of Celtic. It'll be someone else. 📸Focused on Sunday#CELSTM | #CelticFC🍀 — Celtic Football Club (@CelticFC) August 1, 2025 'But to build and grow and develop and push, then of course I love being at Celtic. 'I'm not the one that's going to sit here and just maintain levels. My commitment here to Celtic is this is a really fast-moving club and you have to keep moving, move quickly. 'It's one of the biggest clubs in world football. It has a demand and an expectation on it and the only way you get better within that is by improving and developing.' Rodgers stressed he was not saying the club had to match his own ambition. 'I don't want to be really arrogant to say that,' he said. 'Celtic clearly has an expectation and should have an expectation because of the size of the club we are, and what the demands are here. 'What I'm saying, for clarity, I love being here. And, yes, there's been some challenges on and off the pitch since I've arrived, but that's management, that's coaching. But in the main, I've absolutely loved it here and I will continue to do so however long that is. But like I said, there has to be that ambition from everyone. 'In terms of my situation, I'm relaxed on it only because I know what I give every single day. And if the club choose to offer (a contract) and see that as the way forward, great. If not, it doesn't really matter to me in relation to what I give to the job. 'My ambition is for Celtic. It's not for me. My ambition is for Celtic to be the best that it can be. 'I've been in the game quite a long time now. So I think I understand what we need to succeed. We did that last year. We brought in certain players that helped our profile when we moved into the Champions League. And those players really helped us in the Champions League. 'So my ambition now is to keep us going in that direction. And that's what our conversations are about.' Rodgers has stressed the need to bolster their attacking options in recent weeks. Shin Yamada arrived as a belated replacement for Kyogo Furuhashi but the sale of Nicolas Kuhn to Como has compounded a lack of wide players following the long-term knee injury Jota suffered in May. Rodgers said: 'There's no doubt I would have liked to have had players in now, but it's not the case. I'm not going to kill my own joy and overthink. I focus on what's here. We know the work that we need to do and it's my responsibility to convince the club that we really need them. 'Clearly, I'm not doing that job as well as maybe what I can, but I will continue to pursue that because it's something that's really important for us.'


Scottish Sun
4 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Celtic vs St Mirren: Visitors aim to spoil the party as Hoops hope to celebrate flag day with victory
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) CELTIC will begin the defence of their Scottish Premiership title at home to St Mirren on Sunday. Hoops legend Paul McStay will unfurl the flag at Celtic Park before kick off after their success last season took their tally to 55 league trophies. Sign up for the Celtic newsletter Sign up It extended Celtic's title winning run to four as they finished 17 points clear of fierce rivals Rangers. St Mirren boss Stephen Robinson though insists they are not there to make up the numbers. The Buddies came within minutes of an upset on the final day of last season against Celtic before James Forrest struck an injury-time equaliser. It continued his remarkable success of scoring in 16 consecutive seasons. Celtic played seven friendlies over the course of last month, with standout victories over Sporting Lisbon and Newcastle United. They wrapped up their pre-season schedule with a penalty shoot-out win over Saudi Arabia side Al-Ahly in the Como Cup last week. But Rodgers has made no secret of his desire to strengthen the squad to replace the goals lost after the departures of Nicolas Kuhn, Kyogo and Matt O'Riley over the past 12 months. And fans are frustrated too with what they see as a lack of transfer activity. Meanwhile, Saints have punched above their weight in recent seasons securing three top-six finishes in the last three years. Stephen Robinson's men have made a promising start to the new campaign, qualifying for the last 16 of the Premier Sports Cup after victory against Ayr Utd last weekend. They'll host Hearts later this month but for now the focus is on league action as the Premiership returns this weekend. When does Celtic vs St Mirren kick-off? Celtic face St Mirren on Sunday, August 3 The match takes place at Celtic Park. It kicks off at 4.30pm Don Robertson is the referee and Greg Aitken is on VAR duties Is Celtic vs St Mirren on TV? Can I live stream it? Celtic vs St Mirren has been selected for live TV coverage by Sky Sports It'll be shown live on Sky Sports Football, Sky Sports Main Event and Celtic TV. Coverage gets underway on Sky channels after the Falkirk vs Dundee United game. Sky Sports subscribers can live stream the match via Sky Go The match is also available to watch with a one-off Now TV subscription You can also follow every kick with SunSport's LIVE match blog Latest team news Jota is out for the hosts and won't be back until after the new year after rupturing his cruciate ligament. Swedish star Benjamin Nygren, signed in a cut-price deal from Nordsjaelland, is in contention to make his debut for Celtic whilst there also could be second league debut for Kieran Tierney. Japanese striker Shin Yamada could feature as well but the game is likely to come too soon for Jahmai Simpson-Pusey, who is on the verge of joining from Manchester City on loan. For the visitors, Robinson has made nine summer signings as well as bringing back Roland Idowu and Killian Phillips. But he says not all of them will be in contention for starts on Sunday. Richard King though is expected to make his Buddies league debut at centre-back after joining from Cavalier FC in the Caribbean. Latest odds* Celtic 2/11 Draw 7/1 St Mirren 16/1 *odds as of Friday, August 1. 22:30


Glasgow Times
4 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Celtic defender vows to make Scottish Cup separation temporary
Canadian right back Johnston was devastated when he had his penalty kick saved by Dimitar Mitov in a dramatic shootout at Hampden back in May and his side failed to triumph in the Scottish Gas-sponsored competition and complete another domestic treble. The defender put the painful reverse firmly behind him when he married his long-term partner Peyton Pesavento at Pollok House in Glasgow in June with several of his team-mates in attendance. However, he has made being reunited with the Scottish Cup a top priority in the 2025/26 campaign. Read more: 'Once I got to the wedding and saw my friends and family I pretty quickly forgot about football,' he said. 'You remember that there are still more important things in life, your family, your wife. 'It was nice to kind of put the failure of that cup final behind me and kind of really just reset, focus on the people that were there and then get ready for the internationals. 'But once we got through that tournament, I remembered, 'Okay, we've got something to come back and try and win back when I get back into Scotland'. So I think there's an extra level of motivation now. (Image: Craig Williamson - SNS Group) 'You can see it through the entire group. There's definitely a bit of a burning passion there to get back what we think is our trophy. That's something that we have a challenge of this year.' Johnston added, 'If you never lose, then you kind of forget what the feeling of winning really is. I want to sit here and say that I want to win every single trophy. That is the case. 'But, at the same time, when you do lose one you probably come back with a bit more of a fire in your belly to go out there and really kick on that following year. So I don't think that it's necessarily a bad thing. Read more: 'It is in the past. Obviously, we would have loved to have won a treble. It didn't happen. But now that gives us all the extra motivation to go out there and try and make it happen this year. 'So that's a really positive thing that comes out of it. I think you need to try and find what are the learnings and the growths from that match so we can learn from it and make sure that doesn't happen again. But at the same time, that's football. You're not going to win every single match. 'We'd love to do that. So I think that, you know, going into this year, it really does just kind of add a little bit of extra fire to everyone that's in this. You want to put things right. Ideally, to have our trophies back is kind of the plan.'