Willie Collum on Celtic's denied penalty vs St Johnstone
Brendan Rodgers' men ran riot at Hampden as they booked their place in next month's Scottish Cup final.
Callum McGregor, Daizen Maeda, Adam Idah, and Jota all scored in a rampant 5-0 victory.
Read more:
Celtic were 4-0 up at the break but didn't let up in the second 45. Just before he was withdrawn on 64 minutes, James Forrest looked to weave his way through the opposition defence.
He was eventually brought to ground as he did so, and referee Calum Scott initially pointed to the spot.
After co-operation with VAR, however, he changed his decision.
The SFA's Head of Refereeing, Collum, recently spoke out on the incident: "So there is an initial challenge outside the box, but as they come into the box, the first challenge is what the referee initially awards the penalty for," he said [VAR Review Show].
"Watching the footage live in the VAR centre, it looked like a penalty kick, but when you start to analyse the challenge the referee has punished, there is no contact or minimal contact.
"There has been talk about an arm coming across [the face of Forrest] - that's not enough in terms of a threshold for us to award a penalty kick here.
"This is a correct intervention."
Celtic are back in league action this afternoon as they travel to face Dundee United at Tannadice. Avoid defeat, and Rodgers' men will be crowned champions of Scotland for the fourth consecutive season.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edinburgh Reporter
10 minutes ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Guests announced for Hibs European Pioneers Celebration Dinner
Hibs have confirmed three of the guests for the upcoming European Pioneers Celebration Dinner on Tuesday 8 July 2025. Held in the Famous Five Suite, the special evening will be hosted by Luke Shanley and will feature a three-course meal, card bar, and exclusive Q&A sessions with iconic names from Hibs and beyond. The names announced today include Des Bremner, a key member of the Turnbull Tornadoes and a European champion, who made 287 Hibs appearances under legendary manager Eddie Turnbull between 1972 and 1979. At Hibs, Bremner won the 1973 Drybrough Cup, played in European competitions and helped the Club to the final of both the Scottish Cup and League Cup, before moving on to Aston Villa – where he lifted both the European Cup and European Super Cup in 1982. Joining Bremner will be John O'Neil, who spent three years with the Club from 2000 to 2003 and was a part of the Hibernian side that took on AEK Athens in the UEFA Cup in 2001. O'Neil also memorably scored twice at Hampden Park against Livingston to send Hibs to the 2000/01 Scottish Cup Final. and also scored in the famous 6-2 demolition derby at Easter Road. Former Hibs and Rot-Weiss Essen defender Mathias Jack is the third guest. The German defender joined Hibs in 1999 and was a popular figure in EH7 over the turn of the millennium. Before his four-year Hibs stay, Jack had previously played for Rot-Weiss Essen between 1993-95. He was instrumental in Essen's remarkable run to the 1994 DFB-Pokal Final and also won the Lower Rhine Cup at the club. Book tickets here: Like this: Like Related
Leader Live
17 minutes ago
- Leader Live
Referee Bobby Madley says VAR is ruining football's emotion
Madley, who takes charge of games in the EFL and is a fourth official for Premier League matches, spoke out about the technology which continues to be a source of controversy in football. He said the introduction of VAR had meant that moments like Sergio Aguero's stoppage-time winner to hand Manchester City their first Premier League title in 2012 would not be repeated. 'As a fan, hate it, hate it. Love the Championship, love League One, I'm still a fan,' the Yorkshire-born referee said. 'I love League One because you score a goal, you look at the referee… you look at the assistant, he hasn't put his flag up, it's a goal. 'And that Sergio Aguero moment that we had years ago, where the referee was blowing, nobody's flagging, they've won the league. 'You are never, ever going to see that again in football, because they'll score in that moment and what will happen is the referee will stand there, everyone will panic, they're just checking potential offside 15 seconds ago. 'It takes that emotion away from it and football is a game where there could be one moment in the game, one goal, and that's it. 'To take that emotion away, to have to wait and wait, and what feels like an eternity, as a fan, I'm not a huge fan of that experience.' Madley, who was speaking at the Cheltenham Science Festival during an event on technology in sport, said football was a billion-pound business and the use of technology was inevitable. 'There's so much money in football, it's business driven. So any mistake is perceived to cost people money,' Madley said. 'And I don't think most football fans were clambering over each other to get video technology. 'The players weren't, the referees weren't, but the people who run football, they are multimillion-pound and billion-pound people, and they had issues with referees getting things wrong. 'I think we've got to the stage where people go, 'Sorry, we're ruining football with this now'. 'But we knew the monster that had been created, as referees, we knew what was coming. But I thought, so that's where we are.' Madley said the use of VAR had changed the psychology of refereeing because before, if mistakes were made, you would not know until after the game had finished. 'All of a sudden you've got to process 'I've made a wrong decision' in front of 75,000 people, in front of 100million people watching. What if I make another one?' Madley said. 'You know, I can't keep making wrong decisions because sometimes the players are going to say, 'How many more?' 'If you're sent to the screen for a second time, the trust weighs a little bit and that's a dangerous place to be as a referee. 'When people stop trusting your decision-making, that can be a very dangerous place. 'That's why we have so much training with VAR and that's why we have that bar set as a clear and obvious error.' The Professional Game Match Officials Limited, the English game's referees' body, has been approached for comment.
Daily Record
34 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Greg Taylor cover broken amid Celtic transfer wait as Kvistgaarden emphatic amid £7.5m payday roadblock
It's set to be a blockbuster transfer window for the champions - and moves are already underway PAOK technical director Christos Karipidis has lifted the lid on talks with Greg Taylor. The Celtic left-back is weighing up his options ahead of his current Parkhead deal expiring this month - with Brendan Rodgers previously stating he is keen to keep the Scotland cap and see him battle it out with Kieran Tierney. But with the 27-year-old arriving from Arsenal, Taylor will see his status as first-choice left-back come under major scrutiny. PAOK have been strongly linked with the 27-year-old as they prepare for their Europa League campaign - and are said to have offered two year contract with the option of a third that will trump his current Celtic salary. Taylor is currently in Dubai with his family on holiday following the end of the double-winning season and speaking to Greek outlet Alpha, Karipidis appeared confident over an agreement. When asked about Taylor, he said: "We are simply awaiting the formal part." In terms of arrivals, Celtic are weighing up a blockbuster £12m bid for the Brondby star Mathias Kvistgaarden who is rated as one of the hottest properties in the Superliga. He has been called up to the Denmark national side for the first time amid rocketing interest from Eintracht Frankfurt and the Hoops - who have long been admirers of the 23-year-old. Before the end of the Danish season, the forward expressed he was ready to leave Brondby this summer. Speaking to TV 2 Sport after his first call-up he said: "I think I'm ready. I've made my mark at Brondby and in the Superliga, so I'm ready to take the next step." The club are also looking to offload fringe men - and despite Olympiacos will not pick up the £3.5million option-to-buy in Luis Palma 's loan El Heraldo report that the player's representatives are looking for "a route out of Celtic" permanently this summer. Gustaf Lagerbielke's permanent exit could also land the club a windfall - but FC Twente won't bring in the Swede long-term with a £3million option-to-buy with VI reporting there is a "good chance" he will return to Glasgow. Follow Record Sport on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram for all of the up-to-the minute breaking news, video and audio on the SPFL, the Scotland national team and beyond. You can get all the news you need on our dedicated Rangers and Celtic pages, and sign up to our newsletters to make sure you never miss a beat throughout the season. here and our Celtic community here.
