Clock ticks for Jackson Walker, US Trustee in ethics case involving ex-judge
An ethics scandal that rocked the corporate bankruptcy world nearly two years ago is ratcheting up again, with pressure mounting for law firm Jackson Walker and the U.S. Justice Department's bankruptcy watchdog to reach a deal or go to trial over efforts to claw back millions of dollars in legal fees from the firm.
For months, the U.S. Trustee has demanded that Jackson Walker disgorge $11 million or more in fees that the firm was awarded by former U.S. Bankruptcy Judge David Jones, whose romance with one of Jackson Walker's partners threw his Houston court in turmoil when it became public and the judge resigned two years ago.
U.S. District Judge Alia Moses in Houston this week gave, opens new tab Jackson Walker and Kevin Epstein, the U.S. Trustee for the Southern and Western Districts of Texas, until July 15 to reach a settlement after weeks of mediation in the trustee's case against the firm. If they fail at the mediation, which is being overseen by a retired bankruptcy judge, Moses said she will schedule the case for trial.
Jackson Walker has acknowledged that it knew by March 2022 that its then-partner Elizabeth Freeman was in a relationship with Jones but told no one, a federal bankruptcy judge said in September 2024.
The firm has argued it acted responsibly in its handling of the relationship. In December 2022, Freeman left the firm. Jones publicly disclosed the relationship and resigned from the bench in the fall of 2023.
The trustee objected to fees Jackson Walker earned in at least 26 cases, arguing, opens new tab that Jones' failure to recuse himself from any case involving Jackson Walker tainted the fee awards the firm received from him.
Spokespersons for Jackson Walker and the U.S. Trustee declined to comment.
Legal experts watching the case say the stakes are high for both sides, and the settlement could hinge both on the size of any deal and the trustee's interests in policing the bankruptcy system.
A purely financial settlement "lets people set the payment price for a failure to disclose," said Nancy Rapoport, a law professor at the University of Nevada focused on ethics and bankruptcy law.
The U.S. Trustee is charged with overseeing the integrity of the bankruptcy system, said Robert Lawless, a law professor at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. A "nominal" financial settlement could signal that corporate bankruptcy lawyers play by a different set of rules than everyone else, Lawless said.
"What happened was very troubling," Lawless said. "From the U.S. Trustee's perspective, if there's no consequence to this, it's bad for the system."
A trial on the trustee's claims would be a major event for the Houston bankruptcy bar, potentially airing internal firm communications, details about Jones' relationship and returning scrutiny to the parties' actions in long-closed bankruptcy cases.
That could be averted even if Tuesday's mediation deadline passes without a deal, Rapoport noted, since the firm and the trustee could still hammer out a settlement on their own.
-- Quinn Emanuel has escalated its fight for $30 million in legal fees the firm says it's owed by a former client, 3D printer Desktop Metal, after it prevailed in litigation that forced Israeli tech firm Nano Dimension to follow through with a planned merger with the company.
Quinn Emanuel on Tuesday sued, opens new tab Nano Dimension and its CEO Ofir Baharav in Massachusetts state court, alleging that Nano and Baharav, now in charge of the merged company, are refusing to pay.
"Now under Nano's control, Desktop Metal is employing the same playbook of delay, deception, and sharp tactics against Quinn Emanuel that Nano previously deployed against Desktop Metal itself," the firm said in its lawsuit.
The lawsuit said the firm could receive triple damages from Nano and Baharav. A Quinn Emanuel spokesperson had no immediate comment.
A spokesperson for Nano and Baharav did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Quinn Emanuel is pursuing litigation over the same fees against Desktop Metal in New York state court, and is in arbitration with its former client.
-- Leading U.S. and international law firms jostled for market share as global M&A activity rose in the first half of the year, despite uncertainties stemming from U.S. President Donald Trump's trade war, high interest rates and broader geopolitical tensions.
The value of global M&A deals announced during the first half of 2025 hit $1.98 trillion, a 33% increase compared to the first half of 2024 and the "strongest opening period for deal making since 2022," the London Stock Exchange Group said in its rankings of M&A legal advisers released last week.
But the volume of deals has hit a five-year low, LSEG found. More than 24,000 deals were announced during the first half of the year, a 10% decline compared to the first half of 2024.
Latham & Watkins, the second highest-grossing U.S. law firm by revenue, was the top principal adviser on global M&A deals in LSEG's rankings for the period by deal value, working on 372 global announced deals worth $257 billion. The firm said in a statement it was grateful to clients for trusting its lawyers on major deals.
Latham was followed by New York law firm Wachtell Lipton Rosen & Katz, which served as principal adviser on 55 deals worth $204 billion. Wachtell's lawyers are "quite busy across a wide range of industries, and with some large deals in the pipeline as well," said Andy Nussbaum, the co-chair of Wachtell's executive committee.
Wachtell served as a legal advisor to U.S. Steel, which was acquired by Japan's Nippon Steel in a politically sensitive $14.9 billion deal that closed last month. Nussbaum said in an email the firm was pleased to see that deal close.
Wachtell and Latham are serving as legal advisers to Charter Communications and Cox Communications, respectively, for Charter's $34.5 billion acquisition of the privately held Cox. The deal is the largest of the year, according to LSEG.
-- Kellogg Hansen and other firms have asked a U.S. judge in California to award them nearly $20 million in fees after they prevailed at trial in May against Johnson & Johnson subsidiary Biosense Webster.
Plaintiff Innovative Health in 2019 accused Biosense Webster of anticompetitive practices focused on clinical services tied to Biosense's cardiac mapping catheters. Innovative alleged it was being excluded from the market. The jury awarded damages, opens new tab of $147 million that were automatically trebled under antitrust law to more than $442 million.
The 100-lawyer Kellogg Hansen firm jumped into the litigation last year as lead trial counsel. Kellogg Hansen's Derek Ho was the firm's highest biller, opens new tab at $1,795 an hour. Ho did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Kellogg Hansen, Berger Montague, Theodora Oringher and the other firms for Innovative said the complexity of the case and risk of taking it on justified their fee request. Biosense had denied any wrongdoing. Johnson & Johnson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Read more:
Litigation funders get a boost in budget bill drama, court wins
How much does Hunter Biden's lawyer charge?
Litigation funder fires back at Tyson Foods over settlement interference claims
Mike Scarcella contributed reporting from Washington. D.C.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
I'm a middle-class woman slipping into sex addiction. After an 'unforgivable' act at my best friend's birthday, I've been kicked out the group chat: ASK JANA
Dear Jana, I'm fresh out of a divorce and dating this incredible guy, but he turns into a detective on steroids whenever my past comes up.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
West Virginia governor to deploy National Guard troops to US capital
Aug 16 (Reuters) - West Virginia Governor Patrick Morrisey is deploying 300 to 400 National Guard troops to the District of Columbia at the request of the Trump administration, the governor's office said in a statement on Saturday. The deployment is "a show of commitment to public safety and regional cooperation" and will include providing equipment and specialized training alongside the "approximately 300-400 skilled personnel as directed," the statement, opens new tab said. Drew Galang, a spokesperson for Morrissey, said the state's National Guard received the order to send equipment and personnel to D.C. late on Friday and was working to organize the deployment. Earlier this week President Donald Trump said he was deploying hundreds of National Guard troops to Washington and temporarily taking over the city's police department to curb what he depicted as a crime and homelessness emergency in the nation's capital. A White House official said on Saturday more National Guard troops would be called in to Washington to "protect federal assets, create a safe environment for law enforcement officials to carry out their duties when required, and provide a visible presence to deter crime." According to U.S. Justice Department data, violent crime in 2024 hit a 30-year low in Washington, technically a self-governing federal district under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Congress. District of Columbia officials and the Trump administration negotiated a deal on Friday to keep D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser's appointed police chief in charge of the police department after D.C. Attorney General Brian Schwalb filed a lawsuit to block the federal takeover of the department. Trump, a Republican who has suggested he could take similar actions in other Democratic-controlled cities, has sought to expand the powers of the presidency in his second term, inserting himself into the affairs of major banks, law firms and elite universities. It is not clear how the administration could deploy National Guard troops elsewhere. A federal judge in San Francisco is expected in the coming weeks to issue a ruling on whether Trump violated the law by deploying National Guard troops to Los Angeles in June without California Governor Gavin Newsom's approval. The National Guard serves as a militia that answers to the governors of the 50 states except when called into federal service. The D.C. National Guard, however, reports directly to the president.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
The Mayor of New Orleans had a years-long romance with her bodyguard. She's been indicted for spending city money on hotels and wine tastings with him
The mayor of New Orleans had been treating her bodyguard to trips on the taxpayers' dime during their years-long affair, a new federal grand jury indictment alleges. New Orleans Mayor LaToya Cantrell was indicted on Friday resulting from a corruption investigation. Cantrell's lawyer confirmed to The Associated Press that an indictment was returned, and her name was read aloud by a federal magistrate judge as a defendant. She has been charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to obstruct justice, and making false statements and false declaration before a grand jury, according to the indictment. The city of New Orleans told NBC News it will have no comment on the indictment until the mayor's legal team has time to review the indictments. "The Mayor's attorney, Eddie Castaing, recently received the information, and is thoroughly reviewing the document," the statement said. "Until his review is complete, the City will not comment further on this matter." The indictment is the culmination of a long-running federal investigation into Cantrell, the first female mayor in the City's 300-year history. Prosecutors allege that Cantrell was having a romantic relationship with New Orleans Police Officer Jeffrey Paul Vappie II, who is on the department's executive protection unit. That relationship allegedly occurred between 2021 and 2024. Cantrell was married during the period of the alleged affair to attorney Jason Cantrell. He died in August 2023. 'To hide their relations from detection and to maximize their time together, Cantrell and Vappie exploited their public positions to develop and implement a scheme to defraud the city of New Orleans and the New Orleans Police Department by engaging in personal activities while Vappie claimed to be on duty and was paid for,' the indictment says. They further claimed that the pair had exchanged some 15,000 messages, photos, and audio clips on WhatsApp over an eight month period. The investigators also allege that Cantrell and Vappie were using the app to intimidate their subordinates and hide evidence. Vappie and Cantrell traveled together on 14 trips in eight months, several of which were romantic vacations under the pretense of work trips, according to prosecutors. In total, the city spent $70,000 to sent Vappie along with the mayor on her trips — which in some cases included visits to wine tastings — the prosecutors claimed. Vappie was initially charged with wire fraud and making false statements. He has pleaded not guilty. Cantrell was added to the case after an investigation into Vappie's actions. If the pair are convicted, both could go to prison, though for how long varies based on the indictment. Some indictments carry a five year penalty, and others could put them away for up to 20. The term-limited Democratic mayor will leave office in January.
