Future of Right to Repair Bill uncertain as NZ First pulls support
Photo:
RNZ / Mark Papalii
Green Party co-leader Marama Davidson says she's not giving up on her bill that would give consumers the right to get goods repaired.
The Consumer Guarantees (Right to Repair) Amendment Bill would compel manufacturers to make repair parts available locally to consumers to extend the lifetime of products and reduce waste.
The legislation was sent to Select Committee after passing its first reading in February with support from Labour, the Greens, Te Pāti Maori and New Zealand First.
It appeared to have enough support to progress into law, but the Economic Development, Science and Innovation Committee has now recommended, by majority, that the bill not be passed.
What the Consumer Guarantees (Right to Repair) Amendment Bill proposes:
Davidson told RNZ New Zealand First appeared to have pulled its support for the legislation.
"The reason we got it through first reading is because we had [support from] all of the opposition parties, plus New Zealand First, so we were able to get it to Select Committee, which was fantastic.
"We heard from submitters, oral submissions, written submissions, overwhelming support for the bill. At the end of the select committee process, the bill was reported back, and, at least at this stage, the New Zealand First members have voted against progressing the bill."
She said she would not give up on the bill, especially when she had adopted changes, like narrowing the goods covered to above $100 in value, at the suggestion of government members.
"It's a little rough to have done all that deep work to make the bill better but the positive is we have now got incredible improvements that we know government members were in support of because they helped us make them.
"So there is massive mandate there for the public to have what they've asked for, which is the right to repair their own goods. "
New Zealand First leader Winston Peters said his party had changed its mind because of the bill's "unworkability and cost".
"We said we'd vote it to Select Committee. We get to the Select Committee, we find it's unworkable. Now that's a sound way of proceeding with politics and with policies."
Peters was asked about the concessionary changes Davidson had made to the bill at the request of government ministers.
"Marama Davidson wouldn't know how to build a dog house. Excuse me, I've been a lawyer and acted for thousands of house buyers. I know their costs."
The committee's report on the Right To Repair Bill notes opposition parties had "serious concerns" about the way the committee had conducted its work on the bill.
"Opposition members participated in this work in the reasonable expectation that such engagement was aimed at building genuine cross-party agreement," the report said.
"The result was otherwise. The committee spent significant time, and drew on the resources of Parliamentary Counsel and departmental advisors, to explore and draft changes to resolve the concerns of government members that they then ultimately chose not to support," the report states.
"That decision is of course within their rights. But when extensive collaborative work is undertaken with the tacit implication that it might secure support, only for that support to be withheld, the effect is to undermine trust between members.
"It also risks the perception that the process was used to keep the committee occupied rather than to improve the bill, at a cost to the public purse."
The decision comes as the government rolls back a series of waste-reduction measures. The container-return scheme has been scrapped, plastic bans pared back, and product stewardship rules delayed.
In December 2024, the government
quietly cancelled
several waste minimisation initiatives focused on recycling and kerbside food scraps composting. Four out of five planned policies will no longer go ahead, including mandatory kerbside composting and recycling for all urban areas.
A planned national Circular Economy & Bioeconomy Strategy was also put on hold.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
22 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Ports of Auckland works first project to get consent under fast-track regime
The Ports of Auckland expansion starts next month. Photo: RNZ / Kymberlee Fernandes The government is celebrating the first project to get consent under the coalition's fast-track regime. The Ports of Auckland expansion starts construction next month, and includes a new reinforced concrete-piled wharf at the Bledisloe Terminal, an extension of the Fergusson North Berth, a cruise passenger terminal and other upgrades. The new multi-cargo wharf will relocate roll-on/roll-off capacity and have capacity for cruise ships more than 300m long, allowing the Princess Wharf berth to be reserved for smaller ships. The Fergusson extension will enable more cranes to access the full length of the berth. Since 7 February, the 149 projects included in the Fast-Track Approvals Act have been able to apply for consideration by expert panels under the new process. The panel approved the Ports of Auckland works after 66 working days. Infrastructure Minister Chris Bishop and Regional Development Minister Shane Jones said the project would boost efficiency of a critical part of Auckland's economy and support long-term growth. "The Bledisloe North Wharf extensions will enable larger cruise ships to berth, and increase New Zealand's importing and exporting capacity," Bishop said. "I am working closely with minister Bishop to consider what tweaks to the legislation can be made to make this process even more efficient and get these projects approved and under way," Jones said. Another 10 projects are currently being considered by panels, including five residential or retirement developments, one mining extension in Waihi, a power scheme consent renewal, an industrial subdivision and consents for a metropolitan centre and a quarry in Drury, south of Auckland. A further three further projects are lined up to be considered "shortly" including a wharf extension in Tauranga, seabed mining in Taranaki and an extension to Kings Quarry in Auckland. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Skellerup posts record profit
Gumboots were the dress code for the launch of the Te Wai Koiora project at Te Aroha Marae in Kai Iwi north of Whanganui. Photo: RNZ / Robin Martin Rubber goods maker Skellerup has reported record revenues and profits as it prepared to counter the longer term effects of US tariffs. Key numbers for the 12 months ended June compared with a year ago: Chief executive Graham Leaming said the group had consistent performance across the company with a ninth successive year of underlying profit growth. The company, known for its 'red band' gumboots, is also a big producer of components for industrial and agricultural products, and it increased earnings in both divisions, while lowering its finance costs. The US is a key market producing 37 percent of Skellerup's revenue, and Leaming said the company had anticipated tariffs and built up stock levels before the tariffs were imposed, and looked to control costs and adjust prices. "Also, and importantly - both ahead of and post their imposition - we have been investing in modernising our manufacturing capability to build a more flexible platform capable of in-market deployment." The tariffs are expected to cost the company $5 million in the current year. Chairperson John Strowger said the company's business was durable but it was looking to expand manufacturing overseas. "It will be important to develop new markets for our products - the establishment of in-market capability would result in capacity at existing facilities. The management team is undertaking work in this area now. "Some of the future initiatives we may implement - in particular, if the establishment of in-market capability is pursued - will be more significant, from both a financial and operational perspective."
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Auckland Council meets to decide if it will support new intensification plan
The government will require Auckland Council to allow apartments of at least 15 storeys around three City Rail Link stations. Photo: RNZ / Kate Newton Auckland Council is meeting to decide whether it will support and consult on a plan to increase intensification and strengthen hazard rules for new buildings. The draft changes to the Auckland unitary plan aim to replace Plan Change 78, while retaining its focus on housing in town centres. The council's Policy and Planning Committee is meeting on Thursday to discuss the changes that would allow for more apartments and terrace homes in walking distance of train and bus stations, more restrictive consenting requirements to increase resilience, and an increase in mixed housing suburban zones. Council will decide if it wants to endorse the plan to go out for consultation with iwi authorities, government, and local boards. It will have to decide in September whether it will withdraw from Plan Change 78 and proceed with the replacement plan. In June, the government announced it would require Auckland Council to allow apartments of at least 15 storeys around the Mount Eden, Kingsland, and Morningside Stations, and 10 storeys around the Mount Albert and Baldwin Avenue stations. The changes will be part of the Resource Management (Consenting and Other Matters) Amendment Bill which allows Auckland Council to withdraw its intensification plan change, PC78, with a requirement to notify a new plan change by 10 October this year. In June, Housing Minister Chris Bishop said the new directive from the government was supported by Auckland mayor Wayne Brown and most councillors. It was important to unlock housing capacity around public transport in Auckland, Bishop said. Auckland Council recently approved a zoning change for the city centre to allow unlimited building heights for a small section of the central business district and double height limits for the rest of the city centre to 20 storeys, or 72.5 metres. It expects that will allow four times the number of homes and businesses to be built in the central city. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
