Florida's social media law has been temporarily blocked by a federal judge
A federal judge has temporarily blocked Florida's new law that bans some children from using social media and requires parental consent for others, according to court documents. Judge Mark Walker ruled in favor of two tech organizations (NetChoice and the CCIA) representing social media organizations like Meta, Snap and X, saying that the state's bill HB3 signed into law in March this year is "likely unconstitutional."
The law requires parent or guardian consent for 14- and 15-year-olds to make an account or use a pre-existing account on a social media platform, while children under 14 are banned altogether. Platforms must abide by requests to delete these accounts within five business days and each violation could result in a $10,000 fine. That increases to $50,000 per instance if it is ruled that the company participated in a 'knowing or reckless' violation of the law.
"Floridians have the right to access lawful speech without the government controlling what they say, share or see online,' said NetChoice Director of Litigation, Chris Marchese.
The state of Florida tried to bypass normal first amendment free speech protections by employing the "narrowly tailored" rules, saying the law is designed to protect children from five addictive features of social media: push notifications, auto-play videos, live streaming, infinite scrolling and personal metrics. However, the judge ruled that the application is too broad in ways that have been shot down before by the Supreme Court.
"As applied to Plaintiffs' members alone, the law likely bans all youth under 14 from holding accounts on, at a minimum, four websites that provide forums for all manner of protected speech: Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, and Snapchat," Judge Walker wrote. "It also bans 14- and 15-year-olds from holding accounts on those four websites absent a parent's affirmative consent, a requirement that the Supreme Court has clearly explained the First Amendment does not countenance."
Children could also be banned from social media even if the platforms created youth accounts without any of the five addictive features — as long as they were available for adults. The judge also called out the law's specificities about the ability of a child to access a platform based on how much time all children spend on the app.
The ruling does leave one provision in place. Social media companies are still required to "terminate any account held by a youth under 16 in the state upon the request of a parent or guardian," as required by the bill.
Yahoo, the parent company of Engadget, is a member of NetChoice.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
33 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Trump administration races to fix a big mistake: DOGE fired too many people
Across the government, the Trump administration is scrambling to rehire many federal employees dismissed under DOGE's staff-slashing initiatives after wiping out entire offices, in some cases imperiling key services such as weather forecasting and the drug approval process. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up Since Musk left the White House last week, he and Trump have fallen out bitterly, sniping at each other in public over the cost of Trump's sweeping tax legislation and government subsidies for Musk's businesses. But even before that, the administration was working to undo some of DOGE's highest-profile actions. Advertisement Trump officials are trying to recover not only people who were fired, but also thousands of experienced senior staffers who are opting for a voluntary exit as the administration rolls out a second resignation offer. Thousands more staff are returning in fits and starts as a conflicting patchwork of court decisions overturn some of Trump's large-scale firings, especially his Valentine's Day dismissal of all probationary workers, those with one or two years of government service and fewer job protections. A federal judge in April ordered the president to reinstate probationary workers dismissed from 20 federal agencies, although a few days later the Supreme Court - in a different case - halted another judge's order to reinstate a smaller group. Advertisement Some fired federal employees, especially those at retirement age or who have since secured jobs in the private sector, are proving reluctant to return. So the administration is seeking work-arounds and stopgaps, including asking remaining staff to serve in new roles, work overtime or volunteer to fill vacancies, according to interviews with 18 federal workers across eight agencies and messages obtained by The Washington Post. A Post review found recent messy re-hirings at agencies including the Food and Drug Administration, the IRS, the State Department and the Department of Housing and Urban Development. The ever-shifting personnel changes are yet another strain on a workforce already weary of Trump-induced uncertainty, said current and former employees, most of whom spoke on the condition of anonymity for fear of retaliation. 'They wanted to show they were gutting the government, but there was no thought about what parts might be worth keeping,' said one FDA staffer who was fired and rehired. 'Now it feels like it was all just a game to them.' A White House official said in an interview that it is no secret Trump arrived in Washington determined to streamline the government. During that downsizing, the official acknowledged, some people were fired who shouldn't have been. The official spoke on the condition of anonymity to candidly discuss a complex issue that spans many federal agencies. Advertisement 'Each agency has made an appropriate determination as to who should be on the payroll in the respective agency,' the official said. 'If by chance mistakes were made and critical employees were dismissed, each individual agency is working diligently to bring these people back to work to continue the adequate functions of the federal government.' In statements, some agencies also admitted to errors, while promising the government is working to fix them. 'During this process,' said an Agriculture Department spokesperson, 'USDA has been transparent about any mistakes that were made.' 'They need some of the expertise' Lynn McKerral holds a sign in support of Social Security Administration workers in front of the agency's headquarters in Woodlawn, Maryland, on May 20, 2025. Wesley Lapointe/For The Washington Post The administration has already had to race to undo its own cuts. In February, the Agriculture Department launched a campaign to rehire bird flu response workers after avian influenza sent egg prices soaring. That same month, the Trump administration fired nearly 17 percent of the National Nuclear Security Administration's workforce, temporarily imperiling the safety and security of America's 5,000 nuclear warheads - before hiring them back after an outcry. In recent weeks, other agencies have seen similar patterns. At the start of April, the FDA let go of thousands, including laboratory staff, librarians and those who helped manage the budget. The dismissals hit particularly hard at the Office of Drug Policy, the Office of Regulatory Policy and teams that worked on Freedom of Information Act requests and patent extensions, according to interviews with eight current and former FDA employees. But three weeks later, fired workers began getting calls on their personal cellphones - and soon, a message to their personal emails: They were all due back. The 'Notice of Reduction in Force (RIF) issued to you … is officially RESCINDED [and] you will not be separated from employment,' read an email sent to terminated staff in May and obtained by The Post. 'You are expected to return to duty the next business day following your receipt of this notice.' Advertisement One FDA worker said she complied only because she hadn't found other employment yet. 'Being back feels like a funeral,' she said. 'Morale is terrible. Everyone is stressed and feels the absence of our colleagues. … I'm looking for another job.' At the IRS, managers received a notice on May 19, a Monday, that all probationary workers would be coming back to the office on Friday, according to a copy obtained by The Post. The turnaround was so swift that some probationary staff probably wouldn't have a desk or a laptop initially, the announcement acknowledged: 'If a seat assignment is not available … your employees should begin teleworking until local management secures a seat assignment for them.' Asked about the FDA's back-and-forth, a Health and Human Services spokesperson wrote in a statement that 'any reassignment or restructuring is being done to strengthen outcomes. Our restructuring is delivering leaner and better government services to the American people.' The IRS did not respond to requests for comment. At USAID, thousands have been out of work since early this year, when their agency became ground zero for Trump and Musk's overhaul of government. But at the start of this month, some ex-USAID officials began hearing from former colleagues about potential new jobs at the State Department, which has assumed responsibility for distributing foreign aid, once USAID's task. The outreach soon morphed into formal offers, with an application deadline of May 19. One former senior USAID official said she decided to go for it. Advertisement 'I was like, well, I definitely don't want to work for this administration, but, yes, I need a job, so put my name down,' she said. 'Why not? I have nothing to lose.' Overall, few USAID workers are expected to return. According to documents shared with The Post, less than 200 total positions were advertised, a tiny fraction of the roughly 10,000 people employed by USAID before it was torn apart. Though the Trump administration has cut more than 80 percent of USAID programs, the State Department has taken over the remainder, controlling billions in foreign assistance. A State Department spokesperson, who declined to be named, said Secretary of State Marco Rubio 'approved the hiring of a small number of positions … in connection with the Department assuming responsibility for limited former USAID programming. 'I'm not risking it again' Meteorologist Joe DeLizio prepares to release a weather balloon for the National Weather Service in Gaylord, Michigan, on April 28, 2025. Marvin Joseph/The Washington Post As other agencies grapple with fallout from dismissals and departures, managers are leaning on remaining employees to fill the gaps - and in some cases, hiring new workers to replace those who have left. At the National Weather Service, waves of DOGE-led early retirements and probationary firings left some local forecasting offices without enough staff to maintain 24/7 operations, while others lost the ability to launch as many weather balloons, a key forecasting tool. In one Kentucky office, the agency had to stagger shifts ahead of a tornado outbreak to ensure enough meteorologists were working to cover the overnight threat. Last month, as meteorologists and Democrats in Congress warned that staffing cuts could leave the Weather Service unable to fulfill its mission of saving lives and protecting property from extreme weather, the agency sought to make up for the cuts by reassigning staff from across the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Weather Service director Ken Graham, meanwhile, assured employees throughout the spring that the agency was close to securing a public safety exemption to the government-wide hiring freeze. Advertisement It finally arrived Monday, Graham told Weather Service staff in an email, obtained by The Post, that began: 'Big news! Fantastic news!' The agency will soon post job listings for 126 meteorologist, hydrologist, physical scientist and electronics technician roles, which Graham described as 'a targeted number of critical positions' that would 'further stabilize front line operations.' 'Together, these hiring authorities and staffing flexibilities will allow us to continue meeting our foundational mission, including issuing timely and accurate forecasts and warnings,' he added. The agency confirmed the hiring in a statement and said it was part of a series of steps to address staff losses. At the Department of Housing and Urban Development, some offices saw so many people take Trump's early resignation offer that officials are now seeking to redeploy staff to cover the absences. Community Planning and Development, a HUD department that responds to wildfires and hurricanes and administers billions of dollars in grants, is especially strained. That department's Office of Field Operations has 13 field offices with two or fewer employees left, according to an internal presentation from May 27 obtained by The Post. More than 30 field offices have broader staffing concerns, the presentation showed. Department staff sent a 'voluntary reassignment' offer to employees within Community Planning and Development, where about 40 percent of employees had already resigned. Headcount dropped from 936 employees at the start of Trump's term to 560 by May, according to a staffer who attended the presentation. Officials 'learned that certain Regions and Field Offices have lost serious staffing capabilities,' according to a May 23 message to staff obtained by The Post, which noted the reassignment offers are meant to 'immediately cover skill gaps and critical functions.' Staffers would be required to work in person but will not have moving costs covered, according to the employee. 'In some cases, supervisors are left with no staff, or staff are left with no supervisors, or offices are left with nobody to keep programs delivered,' the email to staff read. A HUD spokesperson wrote in a statement that, given roughly 2,300 employees are 'taking the opportunity to find a new path, it only makes sense that the department would have a plan in place to ensure that mission critical functions and the highest quality service to rural, tribal and urban communities remain uninterrupted.' Within the FDA, the Center for Drug Evaluation and Research is struggling to recover from the loss of too many 'timekeepers,' personnel who handle pay, leave and travel logistics, emails show. A plaintive message sent to the center's staff in early May noted the department 'is still working on a long-term solution for our timekeeping needs.' It asked for volunteers. 'If folks are willing to be trained as a timekeeper or have prior timekeeping experience (does not need to be recent),' the missive said, 'please respond back to this email to let us know if you are interested.' In other agencies, managers are having to fix problems from Trump- or DOGE-driven restructurings. At the Social Security Administration's call center in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, IT workers were told by managers in mid-April that they needed to request a transfer or face possible firing, said Barri Sue Bryant, president of the American Federation of Government Employees Local 2809. Nearly all of the 40-plus workers in that office did so, sending their laptops and spare equipment to the agency's Baltimore headquarters and awaiting a new assignment while the union attempted to explain to leadership how essential these employees were, Bryant said. 'We are critically understaffed in all of our departments,' Bryant wrote in an email to leadership. 'Having systems and employees down is not contributing to the goals of this agency.' But management would soon find out on their own. A specialized scanner that can quickly input forms and scan barcodes broke down and was unusable for a day. A customer service representative who was supposed to answer the 800 number couldn't take calls for three days while her computer was in disrepair. 'It really sent everyone for a loop,' Bryant said. After three days, the agency told the union the decision had been reversed. The employees got back their equipment and resumed their normal jobs in Wilkes-Barre. Asked about the IT workers, Social Security provided an emailed statement from an unnamed official, whom it declined to identify. The statement did not address the reassignments but criticized 'the fake news media, specifically the Washington Post' for 'pushing a false narrative about Social Security. The truth is that President Trump is protecting and strengthening Social Security just like he promised.' Federal workers caught in similar situations described being on an unsettling roller coaster. One USDA safety inspector remembered answering a call from their manager one weekend to learn they were fired for 'performance,' even though they had received positive reviews, according to personnel documents reviewed by The Post. But by Monday - the day before the employee was supposed to turn in their badge - the manager called back to say the termination was rescinded. In April, when the Trump administration offered early retirement, the employee leaped at it and was soon placed on administrative leave. A few days later, former colleagues reached out: The government was now looking to fill the person's job again. Did they want back in? 'I was like, yep, nope, I'm not risking it again,' the employee said. 'I'm gonna try to take the money and try to find something else.'
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Ex hostage Liri Albag eulogizes former classmate killed soldier St. Sgt. Raver
St.-Sgt. Raver, 19, from Sde Warburg, served in the IDF's elite Yahalom unit. Former hostage Liri Albag eulogized killed soldier and former classmate St.-Sgt. Yoav Raver in an Instagram story on Friday, after his death was announced along with the deaths of three other soldiers who were all killed in the same incident in Khan Yunis. "Yoav was in my class. He's someone who does everything calmly and quietly. He always respects everyone and makes those around him feel at ease," Albag said. The four soldiers were killed when a bomb detonated, causing a building to collapse on the troops. Five soldiers were wounded in the same incident, one severely. "Yoav was the son of Lior and Gili Raver and the brother of Tamar and Omri, a graduate of Ami Asaf Educational Center. Our hearts are broken," the Drom Hasharon Regional Council said in a Facebook statement. Warr. Ofc. Gross, 33, from Gan Yoshiya, was named as another soldier killed in the explosion. The names of the two other killed soldiers were not cleared for publication. The Emek Hefer Regional Council grieved Gross's death. "Chen was the son of Irit and Adi and the brother of Mor and Raz, a graduate of Ma'ayan Regional High School in Emek Hefer. We embrace the family, friends, and residents of Gan Yoshiya with immense sorrow." Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called it "a sad and difficult day," stating, "On behalf of all the citizens of Israel, my wife and I send our deepest condolences to the families of our four heroic fighters who fell in Gaza in the campaign to defeat Hamas and return our hostages." Defense Minister Israel Katz expressed his hopes for the wounded soldiers' recovery and posted on X/Twitter, "There are no words that can comfort the magnitude of the loss." He added that the soldiers acted "with strength and determination against a cruel enemy, for the security of our citizens and for the release of the kidnapped." President Isaac Herzog underscored the national pain. "The cost of war is extremely heavy. This is a time of great sorrow — but also of great commitment: To stand behind the generation of heroic warriors, to embrace the families of the fallen, and to ensure that their names and heroism are never forgotten. An entire nation is overwhelmed with grief." Opposition leader and Yesh Atid head Yair Lapid remarked, "Every Shabbat table in Israel will be quieter and sadder tonight." He extended condolences to the families of Raver and Gross, "the heroes of Israel who fell in the incident in Gaza," and wished a swift recovery to the wounded. Former prime minister Naftali Bennett acknowledged the devastation for the bereaved families. "The people of Israel grieve with you and surround you with all their love. The boys fell in action in the heart of Khan Yunis against Hamas murderers. How sad. How painful." National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir also offered his condolences and wrote in a Facebook post that he is "praying together with all the people of Israel for the recovery of the wounded." Just before Shabbat, Likud MK and Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana expressed his condolences to the friends and families of those killed. Deputy Prime Minister and Justice Minister Yariv Levin called the news unbearable. "I send my heartfelt condolences to the families of Warr. Ofc. Chen Gross, St.-Sgt. Yoav Raver, and the two other fighters whose names have not yet been released, and I wish a swift recovery to the soldiers wounded in the same incident.' Energy and Infrastructure Minister Eli Cohen added, 'I send my condolences to the families who lost their most precious loved ones defending the country, and wish a speedy recovery to the soldiers wounded in this difficult incident." Echoing the grief felt nationwide, Economy and Industry Minister Nir Barkat reflected, 'They went to fight for the country they loved so much, courageously battling on the frontlines against a cruel enemy for the security of us all." Democrats MKs, Naama Lazimi and Gilad Kariv, also sent condolences to the family and friends of the killed soldiers, noting the significance of their loss to them.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Trump admin asks Supreme Court to lift injunction blocking dismantling of Education Department
The Trump administration is asking the Supreme Court to block a lower court ruling that is keeping it from restructuring the Department of Education. "That injunction effectively appoints the district court to a Cabinet role and bars the Executive Branch from terminating anyone, even though respondents conceded that some other [reductions in force] would plainly be proper," the SCOTUS filing reads. On Wednesday, a federal appeals court declined to lift a judge's order blocking President Donald Trump from carrying out his executive order that would shut down the department, according to Reuters. In the executive order, which was issued in March, Trump asserted that "closing the Department of Education would provide children and their families the opportunity to escape a system that is failing them." Federal Appeals Court Throws Roadblock At Trump's Education Reform Agenda U.S. District Judge Myong Joun initially blocked the Trump administration's attempt to dismantle the DOE in May. The ruling stopped a mass firing at the DOE that was announced in March and ordered the reinstatement of those who have been fired. The DOE quickly rejected Joun's ruling, with Deputy Assistant Secretary of the DOE's Office of Communications and Outreach Madi Biedermann saying, "President Trump and the Senate-confirmed Secretary of Education clearly have the authority to make decisions about agency reorganization efforts, not an unelected Judge with a political axe to grind. This ruling is not in the best interest of American students or families. We will immediately challenge this on an emergency basis." Read On The Fox News App Trump made it clear that he would seek to restructure and even dismantle the DOE during his second term in office. In fact, when he nominated Education Secretary Linda McMahon, he said her goal should be to "put herself out of a job." The president cited poor performance as one of his reasons for seeking to shut down the DOE. Department Of Education Designates June As 'Title Ix Month' Amid Transgender Athlete Debate The Nation's Report Card, which assesses how American students are performing in various subjects, showed seven out of 10 fourth graders are not proficient readers, which is a worse score than the last report card in 2022. The report card noted that reading scores showed "no significant change" since 1992. The administration has faced both political and legal pushback on its quest to get rid of the department. In February, several Democrats attempted to enter the Department of Education building in D.C., but were blocked by an employee. During the incident in February, Democrats repeatedly slammed the Trump administration and accused it of lacking transparency. Fox News Digital's Anders Hagstrom contributed to this article source: Trump admin asks Supreme Court to lift injunction blocking dismantling of Education Department
