Bernard Jackman conflicted about Rugby World Club Cup
Last week, EPCR confirmed that the respective leagues and unions had voted in favour of the tournament, which will take place once every four years.
To accommodate the summer tournament, there will be no Champions Cup quarter-finals, semi-finals or final in the year of each World Club Cup. Instead, the eight 'quarter-finalists' will advance to the World Club Cup, with the rest of the 16-team competition drawn from Super Rugby and Japan.
It will mean that once every four years there will be no official Champions Cup final, something Jackman believes is dangerous for the furturre of an already struggling competition.
"I actually think it devalues the Champions Cup, because you're not going to have a winner every four years. It's a different competition," he said on the RTÉ Rugby podcast.
The current format of the Champions Cup has been much maligned since it was introduced in 2020, with the current pool format eliminating just eight of the 24 teams involved.
And Jackman believes the EPCR may be better off putting their efforts into restoring the Champions Cup to its former glory, before looking to expand it globally.
"I think the best solution is to try and focus on how you can actually get the Champions Cup back to having more games that are ultra important.
"The knockout stage of the Champions Cup, we've seen some brilliant rugby but in the group stages it's been too lenient. You're not getting that jeopardy, that must-win mindset that I think we all loved about the old format.
"I would have been happy with the winners of the Champions Cup playing the winners of Super Rugby in a one-off game, or over two legs. For me that would have been a fitting World Cup."
The former Ireland international conceded that he sees the logic behind the tournament, which will pit the best of the Top14, Premiership and URC against some of New Zealand and Australia's biggest clubs.
And while he has reservations around how it will eventually look, he recognises how the game's current financial situation may have dictated the decision.
"I also have to say the game is struggling to bring new fans, to bring revenue, so I don't want to be too critical of people who are trying to do something different. But my gut on this is that we had a very good competition and the tinkering with it has devalued it to a certain extent, and that's where the issue is.
"It's going to be nice to see a Munster or an Ulster or Leinster play the Chiefs. I am interested in that.
"Then you're going to have the issue of how many of those teams or how many of the Champions Cup teams will believe they can win it, and if it's a competition worth winning and are we going to see half-arsed games.
"That's also a worry for me at the moment, without that absolute clarity around what the value of winning it or getting to the final.
"Will it make the group stage for the European Cup that year even more farcical, where teams don't want to go and play an away leg in Australia?
"They're the questions in my mind, and until I see exact details around what that looks like, post qualification for that, I'm going to hold my opinion."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Eamon Dunphy column: Roy Keane is a bully, an unpleasant character, a little man
My starting point is the ending point of a doomed World Cup campaign. I was sitting in a television studio that night, analysing the game for RTE. Across the corridor, Keith Andrews was carrying out the same role for Sky Sports. The date was November 2017. Ireland were playing Denmark. The half-time score was 2-1 to the Danes, prompting the Irish management team of Martin O'Neill and Roy Keane to make the following calls; Wes Hoolahan replaced David Meyler; Aiden McGeady came in for Harry Arter. Carnage followed. Ireland started the game without a decent striker; they ended it without any structure. The final score was Ireland 1-5 Denmark. An embarrassment. Read more: Eamon Dunphy column: If Liverpool sign Isak and Guehi then the Premier League will be over before it begins Read more: Eamon Dunphy column: Mikel Arteta is becoming more graceless by the day - he should shut up and show some class I was critical of O'Neill and Keane that night and when I was subsequently told that Keith Andrews had also called the Ireland management out, I didn't bat an eyelid. 'He is just doing his job,' I thought. I knew Keith. I had worked with him. He is honest, confident and knowledgeable. The fact he was critical of a tactical blunder is a reflection of his say-it-as-he-sees-it nature. Now there is a difference between what Keith said about Keane and O'Neill that night and what Roy Keane has done to him subsequently. In an interview with the Sunday Independent, Keane said: 'I've heard a lot of bullshitters over the last 10 years, and Keith Andrews is up there with the best of them.' His old pal, Martin O'Neill, recently joined in when asked about Andrews' suitability for the Brentford job. 'It is not as easy as sitting in a pundit's chair and criticising someone, who, in all honesty, had a much better career than he had,' said O'Neill of Andrews, referencing the fact Keith played 'at the bottom end' of the league when O'Neill was 'winning the European Cup'. As an example of pure football snobbery, O'Neill hit the jackpot with that remark. Whereas Andrews was analytical of their management, O'Neill and Keane made their criticism personal. Keane made another snide remark last weekend ahead of Brentford's opening game against Nottingham Forest. Andrews was someone 'who talks a good game', he said, the implication being that he does not, in effect, speak with consideration. Well, that's where Keith differs from Roy Keane. Roy Keane Because it is Keane who is a bullshitter. What's more, he is a bully. Now, behaving that way didn't do him any harm when he was a player. Both his team-mates and his opponents danced to his tune. Yet while that led to his greatness as a player, the continuation of that behaviour in his post-playing days has seriously diminished his credibility as a person. Look at what he has become, a caricature of himself, doing television ads which play on his intimidating nature, one where he frightens a window cleaner, another where he is rude to a barista. Let's call this out for what it is. He is glorifying bullying in these ads. He is doing them for monetary gain, making a few quid out of his persona. There's no class in that. Nor is there any class in going after a young Irish coach who is starting out in his managerial career. Given his status as a serial Premier League winner, someone who was a superb player, Keane should be bigger than this. And so should O'Neill. Neither man forgot the criticism they received without ever accepting the fact they did a bad job when they were with Ireland. They should, as a former captain and a former manager of Ireland, want to see the national team do well and to see Irish players and managers excel. Let's face it, there has been a huge shortage of Irish managers in the Premier League. The fact a new one has just arrived should be a cause for celebration, or at the very least, hope. What if Andrews turns out to be an excellent choice? Think of the doors that could open for emerging Irish players. Think of the future. We could have our next Ireland manager here. Instead we have someone with status, which Keane undoubtedly has as a former United captain, criticising Andrews from the off. That's seriously undermining because the Brentford board will hear those comments as will their players and fans. Words do have an impact, especially when they come from a man of Keane's standing. I don't consider him a pleasant character at all. As a television analyst, there is no depth to his commentary; and in terms of his personality, he is clearly thin-skinned. And that's before we address the hypocrisy. Both he and O'Neill were critical of pundits when they were in charge of Ireland. Yet they deliver their criticism from a pundit's chair - Keane at Sky, O'Neill at Talksport. Why do they feel the need to attack Keith Andrews? Is it because of what he said eight years ago? Seriously? The game where Andrews called them out ended in a 5-1 defeat. What did O'Neill and Keane expect after that drubbing? A statue outside the Aviva? For two men who had outstanding playing careers, each winning the European Cup, they should be big enough to wish Keith well. I certainly hope he succeeds, especially as the circumstances are so difficult, Brentford having sold their three best players across the summer. As for O'Neill and Keane, I wish they'd just go away. Both are behaving like little men. Get the latest sports headlines straight to your inbox by signing up for free email .
Extra.ie
6 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Bemand will have 'eyes on' a World Cup final for Ireland believes Cantwell
The Women's Rugby World Cup finally gets underway this Friday as hosts England take on the USA at the Stadium of Light in Sunderland. It will be the first chance to see Ireland play in the competition since they hosted it back in 2017. It's been a long eight years for the Girls in Green. They sank to the lowest of lows when they failed to qualify for the 2021 edition and soared to the highest of highs possible last year when they beat the reigning World Champions Black Ferns of New Zealand at WXV1 in Vancouver. This rollercoaster of form has made Ireland somewhat of an unknown quantity, but they're one that is on the rise and a lot of the credit for that rise has to go to Scott Bemand. Scott Bemand. Pic: INPHO/Ben Brady The former England backroom coach has been involved in several World Cup campaigns and while speaking at an event for Defender, the official partners of the Women's Rugby World Cup, former Ireland international Lynne Cantwell said that while Bemand is in charge, Ireland will be aiming high in this tournament. 'They've got an exceptionally competitive and ambitious head coach in Scott Bemand, you know, he missed out in 2017 and 2021[losing in the final both times] He was assistant coach for those two World Cups. So he's been to two World Cup finals and literally that's what he's got his eyes on.' Brian O'Driscoll and Lynne Cantwell have teamed up to celebrate Defender as Principal Partner for the Women's Rugby World Cup 2025. Pic: Photocall Ireland Cantwell went on to talk about Ireland's chances over the next month especially with the returning players from injuries. 'I think they're very competitive, to our point before, they beat New Zealand last year. They pushed Canada really far and they were kind of board number two, three at the time. And I think their performances are mounting. They've had a couple of injuries, but I think the kind of system set-up that they've set up is one that it's a little bit bulletproof in regards of who's in there, they're still going to be competitive. 'So I think their goal, I think every team's goal is, first step is try and get out of the pools, and then kind of navigate your way through quarters and semis and so on. So I think they're being quite ambitious with this World Cup. 'I think they're aiming for a minimum semis.' Aoife Wafer. Pic: INPHO/Ben Brady It comes as on Thursday it was confirmed that Aoife Wafer will miss Ireland's first game at the World Cup but will join up with the squad over the weekend ahead of their pool matches against Spain and New Zealand. But it all kicks off on Sunday for Ireland as they play Japan at Franklin Gardens in Northampton. Kick off is at 12pm and it's live on RTÉ2. Defender partners with Women's Rugby World Cup 2025 , which runs from 22 August to 27 September in eight cities across England, kicking off with England vs USA at the Stadium of Light in Sunderland .
The Irish Sun
7 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Hallgrimsson given Sammie Szmodics injury update ahead of World Cup qualifiers after scary collision with Ireland star
Kieran McKenna has given an update on the Irishman FEARED THE WORST Hallgrimsson given Sammie Szmodics injury update ahead of World Cup qualifiers after scary collision with Ireland star SAMMIE SZMODICS is poised to be cleared for international duty - despite a collision with Ireland colleague Gavin Bazunu. Szmodics was hurt in a collision with Bazunu during the 1-1 draw between Ipswich Town and Southampton last weekend. 2 Sammie Szmodics is set to overcome injury to play for Ireland in the World Cup qualifiers Credit: Stephen McCarthy/Sportsfile 2 He was involved in a collision with Ireland teammate Gavin Bazunu, not pictured, last weekend Credit: Getty Images - Getty The attacking midfielder completed the game but it was feared that he had broken his arm. That would have ruled him out of Ireland's opening World Cup qualifiers against Hungary and Armenia. Ipswich Town boss Kieran McKenna said: "We feared it was a break, but X-rays have cleared that. He's got some really heavy bruising there, but he's recovering well." The 29-year-old started all six of Heimir Hallgrímsson's six games in charge but missed the first four Ireland matches of 2025 with an ankle injury. Hallgrímsson will name his squad for the double-header on Tuesday with the fixture against Hungary of particular interest to Szmodics. Szmodics - who qualifies for Ireland through his grandmother - was also eligible for Hungary through his grandfather. Hungary boss Marco Rossi accused the former Blackburn Rovers player or his agent of leaking his approach to him in an effort to stir interest from Ireland. But Szmodics claimed he had never spoken to Hungary and was committed to Ireland, despite withdrawing from several squads before winning his first cap against Belgium in March last year.
