Bernard Jackman conflicted about Rugby World Club Cup
Bernard Jackman says he has conflicted feelings over the new Rugby World Club Cup, which is set to take place in for the first time 2028.
Last week, EPCR confirmed that the respective leagues and unions had voted in favour of the tournament, which will take place once every four years.
To accommodate the summer tournament, there will be no Champions Cup quarter-finals, semi-finals or final in the year of each World Club Cup. Instead, the eight 'quarter-finalists' will advance to the World Club Cup, with the rest of the 16-team competition drawn from Super Rugby and Japan.
It will mean that once every four years there will be no official Champions Cup final, something Jackman believes is dangerous for the furturre of an already struggling competition.
"I actually think it devalues the Champions Cup, because you're not going to have a winner every four years. It's a different competition," he said on the RTÉ Rugby podcast.
The current format of the Champions Cup has been much maligned since it was introduced in 2020, with the current pool format eliminating just eight of the 24 teams involved.
And Jackman believes the EPCR may be better off putting their efforts into restoring the Champions Cup to its former glory, before looking to expand it globally.
"I think the best solution is to try and focus on how you can actually get the Champions Cup back to having more games that are ultra important.
"The knockout stage of the Champions Cup, we've seen some brilliant rugby but in the group stages it's been too lenient. You're not getting that jeopardy, that must-win mindset that I think we all loved about the old format.
"I would have been happy with the winners of the Champions Cup playing the winners of Super Rugby in a one-off game, or over two legs. For me that would have been a fitting World Cup."
The former Ireland international conceded that he sees the logic behind the tournament, which will pit the best of the Top14, Premiership and URC against some of New Zealand and Australia's biggest clubs.
And while he has reservations around how it will eventually look, he recognises how the game's current financial situation may have dictated the decision.
"I also have to say the game is struggling to bring new fans, to bring revenue, so I don't want to be too critical of people who are trying to do something different. But my gut on this is that we had a very good competition and the tinkering with it has devalued it to a certain extent, and that's where the issue is.
"It's going to be nice to see a Munster or an Ulster or Leinster play the Chiefs. I am interested in that.
"Then you're going to have the issue of how many of those teams or how many of the Champions Cup teams will believe they can win it, and if it's a competition worth winning and are we going to see half-arsed games.
"That's also a worry for me at the moment, without that absolute clarity around what the value of winning it or getting to the final.
"Will it make the group stage for the European Cup that year even more farcical, where teams don't want to go and play an away leg in Australia?
"They're the questions in my mind, and until I see exact details around what that looks like, post qualification for that, I'm going to hold my opinion."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
'Winning ugly' may serve Leinster better than blowouts
Hugo Keenan admits that Leinster won ugly against Scarlets but getting over the line in nervy contests may serve them better at the business end of the BKT URC. Just a couple of weeks ago, head coach Leo Cullen wondered about "some of these blowout games, I'm not sure what we necessarily have learned from a few of them". He was referring to the Champions Cup wins over Harlequins (62-0) and Glasgow Warriors (52-0) that did little in the way of preparing them for the dogfight that was coming down the line against Northampton in the semi-final. The 76-5 victory over Zebre a week later was of similar worth in the long run. So Cullen will be able to take some solace from the fact that Leinster were able to prevail in tighter affairs against the Warriors two weeks ago and the Scarlets, 33-21, on Saturday. URC half-time: Leinster 15-14 Scarlets - Scarlets go the length of the field at the end of the first half. Updates: LIVE: — RTÉ Sport (@RTEsport) May 31, 2025 Captain Jack Conan called the performance "inaccurate" and said they "just forced things a little bit of over-eagerness." Full-back Keenan, named player of the match, said: "It's all about getting the job done, getting the win. "It wasn't pretty, it wasn't perfect, we were ill-disciplined and a little bit scrappy, especially in that first half. "That's sometimes what it's about, winning ugly a little bit." Leinster led by just a point at the break but grabbed two tries in the third quarter to stay out of reach of Dwayne Peel's side, who had won their regular season tie at the end of April. "There was a heavy downpour at the start of the second half and we had to manage the game a bit better," added the Ireland full-back (below), who scored the fourth try. "Jamo [Gibson-Park] and Sam [Prendergast] and the lads put us in the right positions and kept them at arm's length, which was important," "In these knockout games, you can't really be taking high risks and playing rugby all the time." RTÉ Rugby analysts Jamie Heaslip and Donncha O'Callaghan were unimpressed by the Leinster showing, which sets them up for a semi-final meeting with defending champions Glasgow this Saturday (2.45pm, live on RTÉ2 and RTÉ Player). Heaslip called it "lacklustre"; while "rudderless was O'Callaghan's verdict. Hooker Dan Sheehan was asked about how the squad was dealing with the fall-out from the Saints defeat. "It's been up and down but I think we've done a good job of sticking together, trying to block out as much outside noise as possible," said the Ireland front row, who will go on the Lions tour. "I think mentally we're in a good spot, we're looking after each other well and I think that's all we can do. "We'll rip into our prep now for Glasgow during the week and go again." The Scottish side have lost nine of their last 11 games against Leinster, including both games this season. Head coach Franco Smith believes his team, who impressed in the 36-18 win over Stormers on Friday, are better set for another swing at Leinster. "You must put the Leinster games in perspective," he said. "The first one, we were in the middle of the season, there were a lot of injuries in that period. There were so many out at that certain stage. "The expectation [on Leinster] was massive because they hadn't played their top team since the Six Nations. "Everything worked for them. Nothing went well [for us]. "If that happens with Leinster, they could put international teams away like that. That's what we took from that. "The next time, we were more ready for the challenge. Hopefully that will help us this time."
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Leo Cullen: 'It's knockout rugby, what matters is getting through'
URC: Leinster 33 Scarlets 21 Alone they stand of Ireland's four provinces, again, and yet this URC quarter-final defeat of an honest but limited Scarlets side only heightened the suspicion that something is just not clicking for Leinster this season. Leo Cullen was happy to have 'won ugly' by the end of a game that they won by four tries to three and a dozen points against a side that played 20 second-half minutes with 14 men, but this won't do again. Not nearly. Keep playing like this and either Glasgow Warriors or one of the two South African sides in the other semi-final will do for them before this playoff run is out and it will be a fourth year on the trot without a trophy to decorate their efforts. Leinster had 65% possession and 70% territory on Saturday and they still couldn't shake off their Welsh opponents at any stage – this despite a whirlwind start that had them 12-0 to the good after just ten minutes. The perception abroad is that the men in blue are gettable. Scarlets head coach Dwayne Peel inferred as much afterwards when he spoke about how they felt a screw could be turned if they just hung in there long enough. Mental concerns may well be feeding into the mechanics. The much-vaunted Jacques Nienaber blitz defence was shredded by Northampton Saints in that Champions Cup semi-final and Scarlets highlighted areas of concern again here. Leinster had to make only one-third as many tackles as Scarlets but they succeeded with only 65% of them. The evidence was apparent to the naked eye in the ease with which space and two scores were found for the first and third Scarlets tries. The theory goes that Leinster's dominance through the regular season might be working against them when push comes to shove and they are untested in terms of arm wrestles and jeopardy come the knockout stages. Cullen seems to buy into that. He picked out their last two league ties, against Zebre and Glasgow, when they had little or nothing to play for and compared it to the 'cup rugby' that Scarlets had been playing long before this quarter-final. 'Sometimes that creates a little bit of bad habits when you play games like that,' he said. Whatever about the vibes inside the dressing-room and on the field, the atmosphere at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday spoke for the sense of drift that has enveloped the province with less than 13,000 punters paying in. The loss to the Saints has clearly fed into that, so did the Bank Holiday. Cullen also posited how supporters still need to get their heads, and their calendars, around a season that now stretches so far into June. Added into this is the fact that, regardless of concerns over the team's efforts, the expectation was that they would breeze past the Scarlets, that there would be another, bigger, day to tempt people to open their wallets. Cullen is mindful of all that, too, but he understands the need to rally the troops. 'It shouldn't be a drudge,' he said in trying to generate excitement for the semi-final to come and highlighting the danger posed by Glasgow. That said, he is not using a subdued crowd as reason for any struggles. 'No, no, no no. I don't want to use that at all. We played here in front of empty stadiums in Covid and I would much rather have what we had there [on Saturday]. In no way am I giving out here, in no way… 'We'll just keep beating the drum. We are asking supporters to come out here again next Saturday. It is short. We had a two-week lead-in and this is one week so it is more challenging again.' Glasgow are, lest we forget, reigning URC champions and they did it by beating Munster in Limerick in the last four and then overcoming the Bulls in Pretoria. Leinster beat them 52-0 in the last eight of Europe but only 13-5 in the URC earlier this month. The Irish province is still capable of routing an opponent, but liberal seeds of doubt have been sown deep into their psyche in recent weeks and if that Scarlets team can push them so close then Glasgow, Bulls and Sharks will be sniffing blood. 'It's a knockout game so what matters is just getting through,' said Cullen. 'People tend not to remember the detail as in what actually happens in these games. We just need to go through.' Leinster: H Keenan; J O'Brien, J Osborne, J Barrett, J Lowe; S Prendergast, J Gibson-Park; A Porter, R Kelleher, T Clarkson; J McCarthy, J Ryan; R Baird, J van der Flier, J Conan. Replacements: S Penny for van der Flier (29); D Sheehan for Kelleher and RG Snyman for Ryan (both 46); R Slimani for Clarkson (58); L McGrath for Gibson-Park and J Boyle for Porter (both 66); M Deegan for Conan (68) and Snyman (74); C Frawley for Keenan (75). Scarlets: B Murray; T Rogers, J Roberts, J Williams, E Mee; S Costelow, A Hughes; A Hepburn, R Elias, H Thomas; A Craig, S Lousi; V Fifita, J Macleod, T Plumtree. Replacements: M van der Merwe for Elias (51); K Mathias for Craig (58); I Lloyd for Costelow (59); M Page for Rogers and S Wainwright for Thomas (both 65); J Taylor for Hepburn (67); D Davis for Macleod and E Jones for Hughes (both 75). Referee: H Davidson (SRU).
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Neymar SENT OFF for attempting to score Maradona-style Hand of God goal after old club PSG win Champions League
NEYMAR channelled his inner Diego Maradona as he was sent off for a blatant handball. The forward, 33, is currently back at his boyhood club Santos after a Advertisement 4 Neymar punched the ball into the back of the net 4 The former PSG and Barcelona superstar was sent off Credit: Getty 4 It could prove to be his last appearance for boyhood club Santos Credit: Reuters The Brazilian side lost 1-0 to Botafogo yesterday to leave them 18th and in the relegation zone after 11 games of the season. Their issues were compounded when captain Neymar got red carded for doing his best Hand of God impression. With the score goalless after 75 minutes, the Botafogo goalkeeper palmed a cross towards him and it struck his midriff. A defender was going to beat him to the loose ball and clear, only for Neymar to jump forward and punch it into the back of the net from close range. Advertisement READ MORE IN FOOTBALL The referee saw it clearly, giving the superstar a second yellow and red card. With And it could prove to be Neymar's last appearance for the club as his short-term contract expires on June 30. He is suspended for their next game against Fortaleza and the fixture after versus Palmeiras is on July 12. Advertisement Most read in Football Latest JOIN SUN VEGAS: GET £50 BONUS Neymar has failed to roll back the years on his return to It comes after a disastrous time with Al-Hilal as his Neymar breaks down in tears and reveals 'each day I am away is a day of suffering' after injury hell And to add insult to injury, Neymar's old club Advertisement 4 Neymar did not go unpunished unlike Diego Maradona's infamous handball against England at the 1986 World Cup Credit: Getty
