How Palace are fighting to keep European dream alive
Crystal Palace are anxiously waiting to hear whether their European dream is over before it even begins. Winning the FA Cup - the Eagles' first major trophy triumph - resulted in the south London club qualifying for the Europa League, the club's only qualification into continental football in their 164-year history.However, whether Palace can start planning for European football is in the hands of governing body Uefa, who must decide whether the Eagles have breached its rules on teams under one multi-club ownership structure competing in the same European competition.Uefa's final ruling will centre on American businessman John Textor, owner of Eagle Football - which holds a 43% stake in Palace.Eagle Football also owns a 77% stake in French side Lyon, who - like Palace - have qualified for next season's Europa League.Here BBC Sport outlines the details of Palace's defence as they fight for their European lives.
Palace deny operating multi-club model
Uefa's regulations are in place to prevent collusion between clubs. At the heart of Palace's argument is that their historic FA Cup win and consequential European qualification was an achievement accomplished entirely on their own merit.Palace are insisting they are an entity that operates entirely independently, and not within the structures of a multi-club model.Sources with knowledge of the situation have told BBC Sport that Textor's personal share in the Selhurst Park side does not meet the 30% threshold - which is key in Uefa determining decisive influence - and that he has just 25% of the voting rights.Uefa's rules state that "no individual or legal entity" can hold a majority of shareholder voting rights at two clubs in the same European tournament.Additionally, it is understood Palace have made clear they had no assistance in winning the FA Cup, in that they have not collaborated with Lyon since Textor's original investment into the club in August 2021 and will have no connection with the French side during next year's Europa League.The Premier League side are believed to have pointed out that there have been no transfers between the clubs since Jake O'Brien, now at Everton, left Palace for Lyon in August 2023.Palace also say there has been no employee, backroom staff or coach sharing, no dialogue, no collaborative strategy, no combined partnerships, sponsorships or commercial deals and no collective scouting, analysis or software collaborations.It is accepted, and been widely reported, that chairman Steve Parish and his leadership team make all final decisions in relation to the management and operations at Palace.That working structure has existed for a decade and is supported by fellow shareholders Josh Harris and David Blitzer.Indeed, Textor, who only has one vote, has publicly spoken about his lack of influence at Selhurst Park."As proud as we are to have been a part of the resurgence of Crystal Palace, it remains true that Crystal Palace is an independent club, run by a man with a steady hand, who has achieved a level of sustainability that is incredibly uncommon in today's Premier League," said Textor in May 2024."An integrated sporting model, such as ours at Eagle, is simply not a perfect fit for Crystal Palace."It has been pointed out to Uefa that Textor is an individual and minority shareholder and, when he first invested into Crystal Palace in 2021, he owned no other clubs and his investment into other teams followed later.Textor's takeover over Lyon was confirmed in 2022, 16 months after he secured a stake in Palace.
Textor could resign as Palace director
Under Article 5 of Uefa's rulebook, which relates to the integrity of the "competition/multi-club ownership", a club is required from March 1 2025 to have complied with the requirements necessary to prove they are not "simultaneously involved in any capacity whatsoever in the management, administration, and/or sporting performance of more than one club participating in a Uefa club competition".In the past clubs have sought to divest the stakes of key shareholders with a view to complying with Uefa's regulations.For example, the City Group, Ineos, Red Bull group and most recently Nottingham Forest owner Evangelos Marinakis have adapted their shareholdings in clubs accordingly to ensure their teams can compete in the same European competitions.Last year Ineos, which owns Manchester United, put its shares in French club Nice into a blind trust to ensure both clubs could compete in the Europa League last season.Ineos made a similar move earlier this season by placing its ownership of Swiss club Lausanne-Sport into a blind trust, before a potential conflict in the 2025-26 campaign.Uefa's rules regarding the March 1 deadline are clear - and clubs have sought to comply with the regulations and cut-offs. A template for Palace to follow is in place.However, Palace are understood to have made clear that Textor's position means he cannot be enforced by the club to place his shares into a blind trust, owing to a lack of legal authority, unlike previous precedents where a single entity owns multiple clubs.Parish, as has been well documented, effectively holds the deciding vote at Palace with the backing of Harris and Blitzer, so existing shareholder agreements would need to be altered to enforce a blind trust scenario - which is not within the club's power and infringes on Textor's property rights.There is also a sense that the chain of events that have left Palace's position in European football in jeopardy were unforeseen and is a factor towards why they failed to meet the deadline for ownership restructuring.Palace faced Millwall in the FA Cup fifth round on March 1. Since then they beat Champions League clubs Aston Villa and Manchester City en route to winning the trophy.French side Strasbourg conceded a 90th-minute goal on the final day of the season to hand Lyon the final Europa Conference League spot, before Paris St-Germain later won the French Cup to elevate Lyon into the Europa League.If Uefa rules that Lyon and Palace cannot both compete in the Europa League, regulations state that the French side will play in the competition because of their higher league finish.In that scenario Palace could play in the Europa Conference League, but even then there is the added complication that Danish club Brondby, who have qualified for the Conference League, are owned by Harris and Blitzer.Having missed the deadline, Palace have expressed to Uefa that they are prepared to take immediate steps to comply with their requirements.Sources with knowledge of the situation have told BBC Sport that one of those measures includes the resignation of Textor as a director of Palace, which would mean he will have no influence in any capacity.
'Europa League ban is disproportionate'
It is understood Palace are arguing that banning them from the Europa League would result in a disproportionate sanction and unfairly punish the club, players, staff, fans and local community.Their thoughts are that preventing the club from competing in the Europa League next season would result in an injustice, particularly given their breach is technical and that no competitive harm has transpired.It is believed Palace also feel that refusing them a place would contradict the promotion of football's development that ensure that "sporting values always prevail", as per Article 2 of Uefa's statutes.Therefore, sources are indicating that Palace believe a fine or temporary oversight measures - for example the monitoring of transfers - would appropriately punish a breach, without harming stakeholders who have no involvement in the ownership issue.Uefa is expected to confirm its decision in the coming weeks.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
7 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Syme is a sparkling success in Amsterdam as Scot claims his first DP World Tour title
Scotland's Connor Syme enjoyed a champagne-drenched celebration after claiming his first title on the DP World Tour. The 29-year-old went into the final round at the KLM Open in Amsterdam with a two-shot lead over playing partner Joakim Lagergren — and maintained the same advantage despite a brilliant closing eagle from the Swede. Syme finished 11 under after shooting a one-under-par 70 and making only one bogey in his final 38 holes. He said: 'Unbelievable, it was so, so difficult the last few days. I just felt so much better this week, I felt really ready to do it, and I'm so, so happy I managed to do it. 'Everyone helped so much and I'm buzzing to do it with Ryan McGuigan on the bag as well. I'm overjoyed.' Wife Alanis flew out to the Netherlands to surprise Syme on the final green, where he also enjoyed being soaked in champagne by compatriot Ewen Ferguson — who hit a hole in one earlier in the day to help him finish in a tie for fourth — and England's Richard Mansell. 'It's so, so nice that they stuck around,' said Syme. 'I've obviously been really pleased for them (when they've won titles) and I'm really happy to have joined them and won myself, so it's just amazing. Amazing.' Lagergren also closed with a 70, while South Africa's Jayden Schaper finished in third place, a further five shots behind, with a 69. Ferguson shot 67 to tie with fellow Scot Richie Ramsay (72) and Englishman Jack Senior (66).
Telegraph
12 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Labour ‘abandons' manifesto pledge to hire more teachers
Labour has been accused of abandoning its flagship manifesto pledge to recruit 6,500 new teachers. In its pitch for the 2024 election, the party vowed to enlist 6,500 extra teachers in key subjects to tackle shortages across the country. The Government has since claimed it is on the right track, pointing to more than 2,000 new teachers recruited last year. But it has now admitted that it is not counting primary school teachers towards the target, shortly after it emerged their numbers have fallen by nearly 3,000. The revelations, first reported by TES, the specialist education magazine, have led to claims that Labour is fiddling the figures to inflate its achievements. In a statement on Thursday, the Department for Education (DfE) said there are now '2,346 more teachers in secondary and special schools in England compared to last year, as Government makes progress on its additional 6,500 teacher target '. However, the overall number of teachers in state-funded schools in England fell in 2024-25. This is because the primary school total has dropped by about 2,900, while the number of secondary and special school teachers, as well as those working in pupil referral units, has gone up by about 2,350. The DfE has since confirmed to TES that primary teachers will not count towards the 6,500 target. Outrage from Tories It has sparked outrage from the Tories, who accused Labour of abandoning one of their central manifesto pledges. Neil O'Brien, the shadow education minister, told The Telegraph: 'Labour have abandoned not just their main education pledge but one of their main promises in their whole election manifesto. 'And everyone knows why they have dropped it. The statistics show the number of teachers overall is down under Labour. 'Falling teacher numbers are driven by a particularly sharp fall of 2,900 fewer primary school teachers under Labour. So now they are suddenly saying that primary school teachers don't count, which is so rude to primary teachers.' The drive to recruit 6,500 teachers was supposed to be funded by Labour's VAT raid on private schools. But questions have been raised about the amount of cash the change will raise, with Treasury analysis suggesting it could actually require the Government to spend an extra £650 million per year. In March, the National Foundation for Educational Research found teacher vacancies in England were at their highest rate since records began. 'They broke both promises' Mr O'Brien added: 'They promised that taxing independent schools would pay for more state school teachers and also promised they would compensate schools for the national insurance tax increase. 'They broke both those promises and now children are losing out as a result, and their response is to try to fiddle the figures. It's pathetic.' Damian Hinds, the former education secretary, also suggested that the DfE had been dishonest about the target. Last year, the Tory MP tabled a parliamentary question asking which phases of education would count towards the goal. In response, Catherine McKinnell, the education minister, said: 'This Government will work with the sector to deliver its pledge to recruit 6,500 additional teachers across schools and colleges over the course of this parliament to raise standards for children and young people and deliver the Government's mission to break down the barriers to opportunity at every stage.' Mr Hinds posted on X: 'In a written question I asked ministers specifically 'which phases of education count towards the 6,500 target of new expert teachers'. 'The answer says 'across schools and colleges' and does not say 'except primary'.' The DfE has been approached for comment.
The Guardian
15 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Audacious Banton turns tables on West Indies to seal series for England
The drought continues for the West Indies men. A total of 196 looked serious enough to end a sequence of nine consecutive away defeats against England, a run going back to the bio-bubble Test series of 2020. With the hosts requiring 71 off 39 balls, Jos Buttler and Harry Brook gone, the game looked up. Then came Tom Banton, a first-ball six and a change of tune, the final summary a four-wicket victory to secure an unassailable 2-0 lead in the Twenty20 international series. The Somerset right-hander is usually a top-order man but was dominant in the middle alongside Jacob Bethell as the pair put on 43 off just 15. Banton pummelled Gudakesh Motie's left-arm spin while Bethell struck Alzarri Joseph for three monstrous sixes. The left-hander's failed ramp on 26 mattered little as Banton remained, his own audacity including a reverse-flick for four off Jason Holder. He finished on 30 off just 11, steel to go with the tricks, nine balls left to spare. A golden glow over Bristol turned grey just before the start of play, a breeze for Luke Wood to embrace, the left-arm quick bowling in his first England appearance since September 2023. He was appealing within seconds, the first ball of the match a swinging toe-bruiser that trapped Evin Lewis in front. Wood's first couple of overs cost just four, but there was less comfort for England from the other end. Brook opted for just two seamers in his lineup, a repeat of the template used in the Durham series opener. But this was a bold call on a smaller ground as Liam Dawson's first two overs went for 20, the amount he had conceded across four in his comeback game. Shai Hope, like Brook, is a newly appointed captain trying to state his own authority. The No 3 was tough on Brydon Carse, thumping sixes over long-off as he advanced rapidly to 49, only to be undone by Adil Rashid's old-world mastery. The tossed-up leg-break drifted into the right-hander, the sharp turn away followed by an even sharper stumping by Jos Buttler. Rashid puckered his lips, a quiet acknowledgement of his own brilliance. Brawn lies across this entire West Indies lineup, even in the absence of Nicholas Pooran, one of the best in the world but rested for this series after playing at the Indian Premier League (an apt summary of the sport's power balance). While Sherfane Rutherford perished quickly and Johnson Charles finished on 47 off 39 balls, Rovman Powell tucked into Dawson on his way to 34 off 15. Holder was even more brutal with a nine-ball 29. Rashid was entrusted with the penultimate over and the all-rounder began with three consecutive sixes, the final blow caught by the diving Banton but beyond the long-on rope. A single brought some quiet but Romario Shepherd marmalised a couple down the ground to make it a 31-run over. A first-ball six by Roston Chase closed the late show. Holder's damage continued with the ball as Jamie Smith skied him to mid-off for four, but that only granted Buttler more time to settle. The former England captain repeated the blows of his 96 two days previous, embracing the straight hits as he put on 63 with Ben Duckett inside seven overs. Sign up to The Spin Subscribe to our cricket newsletter for our writers' thoughts on the biggest stories and a review of the week's action after newsletter promotion Buttler should have perished on 43 to Joseph, but Charles mis-juggled in the deep. Another misfield from Charles minutes later added to his misery but redemption followed in the next over. Akeal Hosein, who landed in the morning after visa troubles had delayed his arrival, had Buttler caught by Charles at deep third for 47. Brook could not carry much forward, dismissed by Chase for the second consecutive game in a row, the equation leaning towards the visitors. But Banton, who ventured out to the middle and immediately swept the off-spinner for six, was not having it.
