EFF's Omphile Maotwe advocates for 'apartheid tax' to safeguard vulnerable families from VAT hike
EFF treasurer-general Omphile Maotwebhas urged the government to tax the rich more.
EFF Treasurer-General Omphile Maotwe has urged the government to introduce an "apartheid tax" on inherited apartheid-era wealth instead of raising Value Added-Tax (VAT).
Speaking to journalists outside the Western Cape High Court on Tuesday—during the first hearing challenging the legality of the planned VAT hike—Maotwe argued that such a tax reform would not only generate significantly more revenue than the R28 billion shortfall the government seeks to address.
She said this would also ease growing tensions within the Government of National Unity (GNU) over fiscal policy.
She further criticised Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana for lacking the political will to impose taxes on the wealthy, suggesting that the Minister was 'afraid to approach the rich,' and instead opted for a VAT increase that disproportionately impacts the poor.
'That will give you far more money than the R28bn they're looking for. But the easy target is often the poor. We can't afford to put bread on the table. Imagine with the impact of the VAT increase.
'Our people will die from poverty. The triple oppression of poverty, inequality and unemployment is going to get worse,' she said.
The EFF and the DA requested the court to halt tax hikes, arguing that it will cripple the public's pockets. The court is yet to rule.
The hike is expected to come in on May 1.
In his defence, Finance Minister Godongwana emphasised the necessity of the VAT hike to sustain critical public services, including healthcare, education, transportation, and public safety.
Legal submissions from the Treasury argued that the VAT increase is the most viable and sustainable option given current fiscal constraints, limited borrowing capacity, and the risks associated with further budget cuts.
In contrast, Maotwe has advocated for a more progressive taxation approach.
She has called on the government to shift the fiscal burden onto high-net-worth individuals by introducing a wealth tax and closing loopholes that allow trusts and luxury properties to evade fair taxation.
'We are telling him he doesn't need to increase VAT. He needs to tax the rich. Introduce a wealth tax. Many trusts hold luxury properties which are not being taxed, but they use the portfolios to apply for loans at the banks,' she said.
She also proposed an increase in the corporate tax rate from the current 27% to 29%, citing strong profit margins in the private sector.
kamogelo.moichela@iol.co.za
IOL Politics
Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
6 hours ago
- IOL News
Godongwana urges MPs to ensure proper expenditure of R1 trillion infrastructure budget
The report on the Fiscal Framework and Revenue Proposals easily garnered the majority vote from the Government of National Unity partners and other smaller parties. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana on Tuesday challenged parliamentarians to ensure that the R1 trillion allocated for infrastructure in the 2025/26 budget was spent efficiently and effectively. Speaking moments before the vote on the Fiscal Framework and Revenue Proposals and report of the standing committee on finance, Godongwana said he has discharged his responsibility. 'MPs have to make sure that this R1 trillion on infrastructure is spent effectively and efficiently,' he said. His comment was a sequel to the remarks by National Coloured Congress leader Fadiel Adams who sympathised with Godongwana after he was asked 'to pull off a miracle with nothing in revising the budget'. 'That should be the concern of these members … If not spent properly, that is your duty as MPs to do oversight,' he said. The report on the Fiscal Framework and Revenue Proposals was tabled in Parliament for the third time. On Wednesday, the report garnered the majority vote from the Government of National Unity (GNU) partners and other smaller parties. The report was passed with 268 votes in favour, 68 MPs, from the MK Party, EFF and United African Transformation were in opposition and two abstained. Godongwana, who had to redraft the budget and scrap initially proposed VAT increases, said it was a painful journey to have the budget adopted. 'From the National Treasury's perspective, we drew a number of lessons, but I suspect also members of this House must draw a number of lessons as to how we in practice are to manage debate around the Fiscal Framework moving forward,' he said. The passage of the Fiscal Framework and Revenue Proposals was despite the adjustment in the fuel levy, which was criticised by many during the debate. Tabling the report, ANC MP and standing committee on finance chairperson Joe Maswanganyi said Godongwana's third budget presentation underscored a steadfast commitment to fiscal responsibility and transparency. Maswanganyi said the budget adoption process within a coalition government can be quite complex due to the multitude of interests involved as coalition partners often bring diverse priorities, ideologies, and agendas to the table, which can complicate consensus-building efforts. 'Anyone calling for the Minister's head for the budget delay, is out of tune with coalition government dynamics all over the world,' he said in veiled attack on the MK Party, whose motion to censure Godongwana failed on Tuesday. Maswanganyi said during the budget hearings, stakeholders had welcomed the withdrawal of the VAT increase and additional allocations to SARS. 'The stakeholders, however, raised concerns about the proposed adjustments to the fuel levy, the lack of adjustment to PIT (personal income tax) brackets, above-inflation increases in excise duties, the withdrawal of zero-rated food items and the National Treasury's failure to increase Social Relief of Distress grant allocations,' he said. DA spokesperson on finance Mark Burke said his party supported the Fiscal Framework because it reflected some critical breakthroughs for ordinary South Africans. 'This is not a moment for celebration, it is a moment to push even harder for real economic reform that streamlines government, creates jobs and delivers growth,' Burke said. He praised the DA's firm stance against the VAT hike, securing billions in infrastructure investment, a commitment to root out ghost workers and an urgent review of government spending. 'These represents real breakthroughs that protect both the poor and the economy, but they are not enough,' Burke said. MK Party's Des van Rooyen said the GNU has subjected the country to a high fuel levy increase. 'Fuel levy is the most regressive taxing system and far worse than VAT is,' he said. Van Rooyen also said the report refusing their proposal for the introduction of a wealth tax, confirmed that 'the so-called GNU was a platform to protect the wealthy few, using puppets'. The EFF'S Omphile Maotwe said her party rejected the Fiscal Framework that was supported by the GNU, which replaced VAT with 'the regressive fuel levy that will affect the poor and the working class and failed to adjust the personal income tax brackets in line with inflation'. 'The Minister of Finance has declared to increase fuel taxes without even bringing a bill to Parliament. This tax is already in effect. It is a violation of the basic constitutional principle that no tax be imposed without the authority of legislation,' she said. The ACDP's Steven Swart said they welcomed the removal of VAT but it was sadly replaced by the maligned fuel levy hike. 'We will support the report but will be closely monitoring it. We want to be builders, not breakers,' said Swart in backing the Fiscal Framework report. BOSA leader Mmusi Maimane, whose party abstained in the vote, said the obsession should be about the rate of investment brought into the country, saying the projected economic growth was far too low. 'I suggest that we be aggressively declaring economic zones and giving infrastructure support, digital connectivity, efficient public transport and ethical government,' he added.
The Citizen
6 hours ago
- The Citizen
Thandiswa Mazwai says she would've accepted invite to national dialogue had Ramaphosa sent it
Thandiswa Mazwai's music often has social and political commentary On Tuesday, President Cyril Ramaphosa announced the date and names of those invited to the national dialogue, where some of the country's pressing issues will be discussed. 'There have been many of these over the years, and I have attended some,' Thandiswa Mazwai tells The Citizen. The renowned singer-songwriter says she wasn't invited by Ramaphosa, but says she would've accepted the invitation had it come. 'There is much to be legislated in our industry and much to be done to protect artist rights, livelihoods and dignity,' shared Thandiswa. ALSO READ: Ready to dazzle: Afro-soul singer Thandiswa Mazwai releases 'Sankofa' album Singing truth to power In the art and creative space, the president invited elders Dr John Kani and author and poet Gcina Mhlope. The dialogue has drawn mixed reactions throughout the country, with the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) describing it as a 'meaningless publicity stunt by a limping president who is leading a limping former liberation movement'. Through her music, Mazwai has provided social and political commentary, often targeting those in power. Her song, Kunzima: dark side of the rainbow, is a perfect example of her sharp melodic criticism. 'Fools for leaders, their minds left destitute by greed, no souls to speak of, they cannot be redeemed, fiends for war…' Thandiswa sings on the song. The politically charged song is part of Thandiswa's Sankofa album, which was released just over a year ago. Thandiswa spoke to The Citizen ahead of her performance at the Lyric Theatre at Johannesburg's Gold Reef City, where she will celebrate a year of Sanfoka. 'This show will exclusively cover the music from Belede and Sankofa,' she shares. ALSO READ: 'I cannot believe it's been 20 years' – Thandiswa Mazwai on new album and 20 years of 'Zabalaza' A year of Sankofa Sankofa was released on 10 May 2024. Before its release, Thandiswa had last released a body of work in 2016 with Belede. Despite the long break between her albums, during which the world had changed, Thandiswa said she wasn't nervous about how her music would be received. 'Not at all,' she says. 'Even though I haven't released new music, I have been performing a lot, and the audience has been getting exposed to all the things I experiment with. Especially Jozi audiences, who can sometimes get impromptu rock performances or a set with a DJ.' She says the release of Zabalaza in 2004 taught her that people can grow with her sonically. 'Sankofa is a very layered and lush album, and I know there is an audience for that. It has also been very masterfully put together by all the musicians who were involved.' The word sankofa is derived from the Akan Tribe of Ghana, which can be translated into 'go back and get it'. The essence of the meaning symbolises going back in order to move forward. This was somewhat literal for Thandiswa, as she delved into the International Library of African Music (ILAM) at Rhodes University, an archive of African sounds. The launch of the album at Carnival City's Big Top Arena last year was more than a musical experience; it also offered itself as a safe space for black women in particular. Thandiswa's concerts inevitably become a place of healing, love and a safe space for her core fans – a significant part of that fandom is the queer community. She preceded the performance of her latest single, Kulungil, by sharing a bit about her past traumas − her backdrop was an old photo of a young Thandiswa in the rural Eastern Cape. She even revealed that on the day the photo was taken, she had experienced something traumatic. It was more than just a music show for black women. It was a safe space for them to be. Her performances at last year's Bushfire Festival and the Standard Bank Joy of Jazz were equally appreciated by a more diverse demographic. 'We have really enjoyed playing this music along with the rest of the discography around the world. It's always such a trip watching people sing new music back to you,' says Thandiswa with gratitude. ALSO READ: Collaborative Wouter Kellerman bags Grammy nomination as Thandiswa's 'Sankofa' misses out Awards and such Sankofa lost out on a Grammy nomination and also failed to win at the Metro Awards, where it was nominated in the Best Jazz category. 'I don't usually win awards,' Thandiswa says. 'I'm experimental, and awards require very constant ideas on what constitutes genre. For instance, Sankofa was nominated in the jazz category, but it really isn't jazz. It is a sound all on its own, and it definitely has jazz influences, but it also has deep Xhosa and Senegalese influences.' The Metro Award went to saxophonist and composer Linda Sikhakhane for iLandi, whom Thandiswa congratulated. The Grammy nomination, which saw Mzansi's Wouter Kellerman nominated and eventually win, is a lot trickier, where Academy members vote for entries in two rounds. 'This was our first attempt, and we enjoyed the experience, but I am acutely aware of the fact that we don't need these awards for validation,' she shares. 'So as long as it's all good fun and not a bar to measure our worth, it's all good.' Thandiswa has a wide range of fans, from the youthful ones who were aware of her performance on Tiny Desk and cheered her on, to the more senior ones who aren't able to navigate YouTube. 'It feels good to be seen. It feels good to be appreciated. It feels good to be affirmed and reminded that you are indeed doing what you were called to do.' NOW READ: Thandiswa Mazwai creates a safe space for black women at Carnival City
Eyewitness News
7 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Parliament gives Fiscal Framework and Revenue Proposals underpinning budget green light
CAPE TOWN - Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has described the first budget cycle of the Government of National Unity (GNU) as a painful journey. But he's standing by the second version of the budget he presented to Parliament three weeks ago, saying he believes he's delivered an expenditure-and-revenue raising plan that is fiscally sustainable. While opposition parties on Wednesday rejected the Fiscal Framework and Revenue Proposals that underpin the 2025 budget, GNU parties have come out in support of the revised budget, saying it is a product of compromises to achieve much-needed economic growth. This is a relief for Godongwana as his budget blueprint for 2025 has finally passed political muster. Godongwana has acknowledged it's been a tough road that's been paved by political contestation and legal challenges. ALSO READ: 'We've had a painful journey to arrive at this date, where the fiscal framework is being approved. Definitely from the Treasury perspective, we've drawn a number of lessons.' Godongwana has rejected claims from the opposition that this is an austerity budget that's not pro-poor. 'If you look over the last four months, what we've been fighting about is not by how much we cut the budget, it's about how much we are going to increase the budget and how we are going to fund that increase.' The Fiscal Framework has been passed with 268 votes to 88. Parliament's finance committees can now get to work scrutinising the money bills which apportion funding to municipalities, provincial governments and State departments.
