University of Cambridge Gaza injunction bid worries legal centre
A legal organisation that offers help to rights campaigners has criticised the University of Cambridge's attempts to prevent protesters causing disruptions.Last week, a High Court judge granted an injunction, applied for by the university, aimed at preventing pro-Palestinian demonstrators from disrupting a graduation ceremony.The European Legal Support Centre (ELSC) has said the injunction the university sought was "broader" than comparable orders and would prohibit a "wide array of conduct".The university has said any claim that it was trying to "restrict protest" was "ridiculous".
Mr Justice Fordham is expected to consider arguments about further injunctions at a future hearing.
Lawyers representing the university made the application in the wake of protests in Cambridge following the outbreak of the current conflict in Gaza between Israel and Hamas following the latter's killing of 1,200 people across the border in Israel and the taking of 250 Israeli hostages on 7 October 2023.Pro-Palestinian campaigners alleged the university had not acted on previous agreements to review investments concerning the arms industry.The university said in response that it was committed to reviewing its "approach to responsible investment".ELSC appointed representation and wrote to Mr Justice Fordham to share its concerns about wider injunctions and he agreed it could "intervene" in the litigation.Grant Kynaston, barrister for ELSC, said it had only become aware of the university's injunction two days before Thursday's High Court hearing in London.
'Implications'
In the ELSC's written argument, Mr Kynaston said the "scope" of the order the world-renowned university wanted was "broader than any comparable newcomer injunction in the university protest context"."It would potentially affect all those who manifest any speech action or belief 'connected with the Palestine-Israel conflict', whether or not in the context of protest," he argued."It would cover highly symbolic properties in the heart of the University of Cambridge. It would prohibit a wide array of conduct, all of which is said to somehow ground a claim in trespass or nuisance."He added that "severe human rights and equality implications" were involved in the issues raised in the litigation and the issue "required determination" after consideration of "full legal submissions and evidence".Mr Kynaston said ELSC had "the legal and other resources" available to "assist the court".
Yasser Vanderman, the barrister who led the university's legal team, said some "defendants" formed part of a "well organised" group with "strong and committed" views on the conflict.The university wanted "injunctive relief" to "restrain threatened acts of trespass and nuisance", he said.Mr Vanderman asked for an injunction to last five years - with annual reviews - arguing that given the "long-standing nature" of the Gaza conflict, such a time-frame was reasonable.A university spokesman said it was trying to protect students and staff.
Follow Cambridgeshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Dawn French sparks backlash after filming peculiar video about October 7 Hamas attacks on Israel
Dawn French has sparked a ferocious backlash after describing the October 7 attacks unleashed by Hamas terrorists on Israel as 'a bad thing' during a bizarre social media rant. The Vicar of Dibley star, 67, posted to X discussing her thoughts on the 'nuanced' situation in Israel and Gaza. Adopting a baby-like voice, French appeared to belittle supporters of Israel's actions amid the ongoing war against Hamas. During the 40-second video, the actress can be heard saying: 'Complicated, no, but nuanced. But [the] bottom line is no,' inferring that Israel should cease its military campaign. The British comedian then adopted more infantile tones as she gave an impression of those with opposing views to her own. 'Yeah, but you know they did a bad thing to we want that we have history… Those people aren't really even people, are they?' she can be heard saying in a whining manner. At the end of each statement French returns to her natural voice and emphatically says 'No'. Critics have seized upon the video, which has racked up 4.7million views since it was first posted on Thursday, and accused French of 'mocking' the events of October 7. Actress and playwright Tracy-Ann Oberman, who is Jewish, said she was 'saddened' by the post. 'This mocking voice 'bad thing' of October 7 that Dawn (who I revere by the way) appears to be mocking involved the most horrific terrorist attack involving rape, sexual violence, burning alive child, mutilation and the taking of civilian hostages. 'Why would Dawn seem to deny that which has affected so many of us personally in the most painful way possible. 'I can mourn the horrors of the war in Gaza whilst also remembering the horrors of what started it. 'Is this how most of our industry feels now – Oct 7 was a 'little thing'? NO!' Former MP and author Louise Mensch accused French of having a 'chuckle and chunter'. She said: 'A 'bad thing'? Rapes, murders, torture, strangled a couple of infants, etc etc, so let's have a good chuckle and chunter, shall we Dawn? 'But the saddest thing about this post is not its casual cruelty, but that you think you're a progressive. You're not.' Former MP and author Louise Mensch accused French of having a 'chuckle and chunter' Meanwhile comedy screenwriter and activist Lee Kern said French had 'sneeringly mocked' the October 7 massacre. He wrote: 'I imagine you think you are moral and righteous and taking a stand against pain and suffering. 'But not only do you remain intellectually incurious about who the architect of all this suffering is, (Hamas), not only do you fail to say NO to them in front of your audience and condemn them for their retention of the hostages, use of human shields, fighting from hospitals, schools and civilian proactively broadcast - with misplaced pride - a wicked glee in your mockery and dismissal of Jewish suffering, pain and death...' French later responded to Oberman's post to emphasise she did not 'support the atrocities of Oct 7th.' She wrote: 'I do not say 'a little thing'. In NO WAY do I support the atrocities of Oct 7th. Of course not. Appalling. Horrific. 'But starving innocent children is not the answer. NO is the answer to ALL of it Tracy.' Israel has been waging a military campaign in Gaza since Hamas' brutal massacre on October 7, 2023, in which 1,200 people were murdered and 251 taken hostage. At least 20 of the remaining 56 hostages still held by Hamas are thought to be alive. According to official Hamas figures, at least 54,000 people have been killed in Gaza since the start of the war. The Israeli military issued an evacuation order on Friday for residents of parts of Gaza City ahead of an attack that 'will strike all areas from which rockets are launched'. Israel has recently stepped up its campaign in Gaza in what it says is a renewed push to defeat Hamas amid growing international calls for a negotiated ceasefire.
Channel 4
6 hours ago
- Channel 4
Mass casualties ‘change you as a person', says Gaza surgeon
In Israel, the military has said that four of its soldiers were killed today and five injured when a booby-trapped building collapsed in Khan Younis, in the south of the Gaza Strip. Israeli airstrikes, meanwhile, killed at least 16 Palestinians. In Jabalia to the north one strike reportedly left dozens trapped under rubble. It comes as Gazans marked the Islamic festival of Eid al-Adhar amid a precarious humanitarian situation. The controversial Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation said it had given out over eight thousands food boxes today at two sites – but then halted all operations due to what they called 'excessive crowding'. We spoke to Goher Rabhour, an NHS surgeon who has been working in Gaza's Nasr hospital.
South Wales Argus
7 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
BBC art dealer from Bargain Hunt jailed for terror offence
The 53-year-old admitted to eight counts of failing to disclose during business under the Terrorism Act 2000. Judge Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb said Ojiri was aware that he had sold art to Nazem Ahmad, who had been sanctioned in 2019 by the US authorities. Bargain Hunts star Oghenochuko Ojiri jailed for selling art to suspected Hezbollah financier Hezbollah is considered a terrorist organisation in the UK (Image: Ben Whitley/PA) She stated: "These offences are so severe that only a custodial sentence can be justified." According to the BBC, the judge added: "You knew about Ahmad's suspected involvement in financing terrorism and the way the art market can be exploited by people like him. "Your hard work, talent and charisma has brought you a great deal of success... You knew you should not have been dealing with that man." She added that there was no evidence that Ojiri supported any form of extremism but that his conduct undermined he detection of terrorist financing. Representing the BBC Bargain Hunt star, Gavin Irwin said that the art expert's "humiliation is complete," adding that the star has lost "his good name" and the "work he loves." Mr Irwin added: "He'd like to apologise for undermining trust" in the art market. Discussing the case, Cdr Dominic Murphy, head of the Metropolitan Police Counter Terrorism Command, said: "Raising money for terrorism is a core part of how terrorist groups are then able to cause harm around the world." Bethan David, head of the CPS Counter Terrorism Division, said Ojiri's motivation appeared "to be financial, along with a broader desire to boost his gallery's reputation within the art market by dealing with such a well-known collector." He added: "This prosecution is believed to be the first of its kind, and the CPS will not hesitate to bring criminal charges against individuals who flout the law in this way." What is Hezbollah and why is it considered a terrorist group? According to the House of Lords Library, Hezbollah is an armed Shiite militia group that is backed by Iran, which largely operates in Lebanon. Giving the UK Government's reasoning for classifying it as a terrorist group in 2024, it added: "It has been proscribed in its entirety by the UK as a terrorist organisation since 2019. "The current conflict between Hezbollah and Israel continues. Hezbollah has fired rockets at Israeli territory whilst Israel has launched retaliatory airstrikes—including that which saw the death of Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah." It concluded by saying: "The UK has called for an immediate ceasefire to provide space for a diplomatic settlement."
