300 to 1k+ beds: Pvt hosps get bigger but manpower an issue
Mumbai: Krishna Institute of Medical Sciences (KIMS), a chain of hospitals from South India, made its "Mumbai debut" by opening a 300-bedded super-specialty hospital in neighbouring Thane city.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
In Juhu, a multi-storeyed building is coming up within the 330-bedded Nanavati Max Hospital complex, set to more than double the present bed strength. Civil work on the proposed 1,000-bedded hospital by D-Mart owners in Borivli East is progressing. Clearly, hectic activity is ongoing in the city's hospital space.
While announcing the BMC budget in Feb, commissioner Bhushan Gagrani said the city has 15,302 beds in govt hospitals and 31,076 beds in private hospitals, with another 3,515 beds being added through renovations to various BMC hospitals.
The expansion trend, though, has multiple layers. For one, private hospitals that usually stuck to a few hundred beds are aiming closer to 1,000 beds—a number usually reserved for public super-specialty hospitals that have medical schools attached to them.
For another, multiple hospitals are witnessing an exodus of human resources as "competition" heats up.
At present, Bombay Hospital in New Marine Lines and Kokilaben Ambani Hospital in Andheri have over 700 beds.
But Nanavati and the D-Mart hospitals too will be big; a medical school by the Adani group in Kandivli will have 1,500 beds. "Many hospitals have begun adopting the marginal costing theory," said Dr Vivek Desai of HOSMAC, a hospital management consultancy firm. This means they will opt to build large capacities but will not focus on getting the same cost for each bed from all patients.
"Many beds will go to patients who are retired govt servants or from economically weaker sections who are supported by govt schemes such as CGHS or Ayushman Bharat," said Dr Desai.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The Maharashtra govt has also announced universal healthcare for people aged over 70 years that will allow them to get subsidised or free care at some private and public hospitals respectively.
With more beds, not only will the volume of patients be higher, but diagnostics and therapeutic services will be better utilised. The idea of a multispecialty hospital appeals to corporate healthcare providers as they can put up the revenue-earning specialties of cancer, cardiology, gastroenterology and orthopaedics under one roof. However, a senior doctor with a BMC hospital said that the "movement" in the private healthcare space may suffer due to a "paucity of skilled personnel, both medical and non-medical".
Studies done by NGOs in the past have shown gaps in healthcare in suburbs, with few public beds in the distant northern suburbs.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
6 hours ago
- The Hindu
Haryana IMA seeks clarity on State govt.'s cashless treatment scheme for accident victims
In the wake of the Haryana Health Department's order to onboard all hospitals for a cashless road accident victims treatment scheme, the State chapter of the Indian Medical Association (IMA) has sought clarity on its various aspects, including the rates prescribed for the treatment. The scheme, launched in Haryana earlier this year as a pilot project along with five other States, had failed to take off after the private hospitals backed out of it citing several reasons, including the meagre treatment rates. In a letter to the Director General Health Services (DGHS) seeking clarification on the various aspects of the scheme, the Haryana IMA has sought details about the rates prescribed for the services such as consultation, ICU charges, room rent; the mode of payment; procedure for the empanelment of non-Ayushman Hospitals and access to the portal for the registration of these cases. The DGHS has directed all civil surgeons to onboard all hospitals for the scheme, especially those not empanelled under the Ayushman Bharat. Under the scheme, notified by Ministry of Road Transport and Highways in 2025, the road accident victims would be administered cashless emergency care of up to ₹1.5 lakh with a cap of maximum of seven days. The scheme is applicable across all categories of roads including National and State Highways and municipal roads. Former IMA chief Ajay Mahajan told The Hindu over phone that the government had earlier offered very low rates, only ₹1,000 per day including ICU charges, surgery, medicines and the investigations expenses. 'It is a good scheme and could help save road accident victims offering timely treatment. But the rates offered earlier were not practical. Many Ayushaman empanelled hospitals came forward, but had to back out due to very low rates and delayed payments. The road accident victims suffer multiple injuries and might require a lot of investigations such as frequent MRI. So, this scheme failed to take off in Haryana and now DGHS has asked civil surgeons to enrol other hospitals too. But there is no clarity on how the hospitals would be paid. This is bound to fail again,' said Dr. Mahajan. 'Meagre payment' In March too, the IMA had written to the DGHS after the launch of the scheme expressing concerns over low rates and lack of clarity on various issues. 'Unfortunately, at present the pilot project is being launched in Haryana without proper preparations. There are no proper guidelines on how the payments will be made, no separate MoU has been done and few cases that have been claimed are being paid a measly sum of ₹1,000 per day for general ward for a head injury case in Intensive Care Unit,' the letter had read. DGHS Manish Bansal did not respond to calls and text messages to seek his response.
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
IMA seeks clarity on emergency scheme for road accident victims in Haryana
Gurgaon: Indian Medical Association (IMA)'s Haryana chapter on Friday sought immediate clarification about the cashless treatment pertaining to road accident victims. In fact, private hospitals, which have been roped in, are flagging a lack of clarity on operational guidelines, payment mechanisms and treatment rates. The development comes against the backdrop of a statewide rollout of Haryana's cashless treatment scheme for road accident victims, which has been facing serious roadblocks. The scheme, aimed at ensuring free emergency care for accident victims during the crucial first seven days or up to Rs 1.5 lakh, was earlier restricted to Ayushman Bharat-empanelled hospitals. However, with limited participation due to extremely low reimbursement rates and infrastructure constraints, directorate general of health services (DGHS), Haryana, issued fresh instructions on June 4 to onboard non-Ayushman hospitals as well. In a letter addressed to DGHS, IMA has sought guidelines on how the new hospitals will be empanelled, which portal will be used to register and track patients and how payments will be made. IMA has requested DGHS to immediately issue a detailed guideline outlining onboarding steps, financial coverage, payment timelines and rate revisions to ensure that hospitals can realistically provide care without suffering financial losses. IMA Haryana president Dr Mahaveer P Jain told TOI, 'There is no clarity on who will pay for these services, how the bills will be submitted or processed, or what rates will be given for ICUs, surgeries or diagnostic tests.' 'Without this, the scheme will collapse before it starts,' Jain said. IMA has also flagged the Ayushman Bharat rates — under which hospitals are expected to provide comprehensive trauma care at around Rs 1,000 per day, including medicines, ICU care and CT/MRI scans — as completely unviable. 'This was the main reason the scheme failed to take off earlier in Haryana,' former IMA president Dr Ajay Mahajan said. 'The state is now asking more hospitals to join, but without fixing the fundamental flaws,' Mahajan said. The recent directive by DGHS to involve other hospitals is seen as an attempt to revive the programme. But without a standard operating procedure (SOP), notification system for hospitals, or clear reimbursement policy, medical professionals say it's set up for another failure. 'Unless the state addresses these gaps swiftly, it's just another policy on paper. Meanwhile, lives that could have been saved continue to be lost,' Dr IMA Haryana secretary Dhirendar K Soni said. A senior official from DGHS (Haryana) said, 'The objective is to ensure no road accident victim is denied emergency care due to lack of financial resources. We are actively working on streamlining the onboarding process for non-Ayushman hospitals and will soon issue clear SOPs, including case registration protocols and payment mechanisms.' Additional chief secretary, health and family welfare, Sudhir Rajpal on June 4 chaired a review meeting on the implementation of the scheme aimed at providing free and cashless emergency medical treatment to road accident victims across the state. During the meeting, it was informed that all hospitals empanelled under the Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (AB-PMJAY) are by default automatically included under the road accident treatment scheme. However, it was highlighted that a greater number of hospitals need to be brought on board to ensure that accident victims receive timely and quality care at the nearest available health facility. The scheme showed promising results during a pilot project conducted at IIT Chennai, where full govt funding for the first week of post-accident treatment helped significantly reduce fatalities. Inspired by this, the Centre rolled it out in five states — including Haryana — under the condition that only Ayushman-empanelled hospitals would be included. However, this restriction, combined with low package rates, limited the scheme's effectiveness. As traffic accident numbers continue to rise, healthcare professionals warn that any further delay in resolving these issues could prove fatal — not just for victims on the road, but for the credibility of the state's emergency healthcare initiatives. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Eid wishes , messages , and quotes !
India Gazette
13 hours ago
- India Gazette
WHO DG holds talks with PM's Secy on partnership at Global Traditional Medicine Centre
Geneva [Switzerland] June 6 (ANI): Director-General of the World Health Organization, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus on Thursday (local time) held talks with PK Mishra, Principal Secretary to Prime Minister where they discussed their partnership on the WHO Global Traditional Medicine Centre, outposted in Jamnagar. Ghebreyesus thanked Mishra for India's leadership on the Pandemic Accord adoption, and support of increased assessed contributions to WHO's work to advance health for all. 'Had good meeting with P.K. Mishra, Principal Secretary to PMO India, on the many areas of close collaboration between WHO and India. We discussed our partnership on the WHO Global Traditional Medicine Centre, outposted in Jamnagar, which will help the world benefit from the potential of traditional medicine and complement modern approaches to health. I thanked Dr Mishra for India's leadership on the Pandemic Accord adoption, and support of increased assessed contributions to WHO's work to advance Health for All. I also commended India for its investment in health care infrastructure, the 'Ayushman Bharat' scheme to expand universal health coverage, and in digital health.' Mishra also held talks with Hara Hiroaki, Vice-Minister for Policy Coordination of Japan, on margins of Global Platform for Disaster Risk Reduction 2025. In a post on X, the Indian Permanent Mission at Geneva stated, 'Fruitful discussions between Principal Secretary to PM Dr. P.K Mishra and Mr. Hara Hiroaki, Vice-Minister for Policy Coordination of Japan, on margins of GPDRR 2025. Explored enhanced India-Japan collaboration on disaster resilience and exchanging expertise in risk reduction strategies.' Mishra also held talks on disaster preparedness with Major General Ariunbuyan Gombojav, Chief of National Emergency Management Agency of Mongolia, on the sidelines of GPDRR 2025. 'Principal Secretary to PM Dr. P.K Mishra meets with Major General Ariunbuyan Gombojav, Chief of National Emergency Management Agency of Mongolia, on the sidelines of GPDRR 2025. Valuable exchange on disaster preparedness strategies and exploring opportunities for India-Mongolia cooperation in DRR.' Mishra also held talks with Head of UNDRR Kamal Kishore on strengthening India's disaster risk reduction partnerships and advancing global resilience frameworks. Meanwhile, BIMSTEC countries convened at the High-Level UNDRR-BIMSTEC event on the margins of GPDRR 2025 in Geneva. India's head of delegation to GPDRR, Principal Secretary to PM PK Mishra, highlighted the role of the BIMSTEC Centre for Disaster Management, as announced by PM Narendra Modi at the 6th BIMSTEC Summit, to accelerate the region's implementation of the Sendai Framework. (ANI)
