Donegal Judge says court cannot continue to adjourn cases to facilitate gardaí as case list doubles
Judge John Aylmer voiced his annoyance at the ongoing situation as the list of criminal cases for the current three-week Letterkenny Circuit Court sitting reached more than 200 cases.
Advertisement
Judge Aylmer noted that the spiralling list had more than doubled from around 100 cases in the past 18 months.
As well as a list of 212 criminal cases for the current court session, there are extensive civil cases, licensing matters, and District Court appeals to address on the list.
Addressing the court on the first day of the current sittings yesterday, he told State prosecutor, Ms Fiona Crawford, that he wanted a message to go out 'loud and clear' to An Garda Síochána.
Judge Aylmer said that the schedule for the Circuit Court is known from October of each year.
Advertisement
He added that gardaí should not take holidays during sessions and that officers who aren't present should have to take an oath in the witness box to explain why.
And he warned of the consequences if the court was forced to adjourn cases because of the absence of gardaí.
He said: 'We can't facilitate guards in that way or we will have a list of 300 (cases).'
He said the State prosecution team should have clear instructions on cases by the start of the court term.
Judge Aylmer added, 'The list is taking too long to call because you don't know what the position is.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Dublin woman who took hospital prescription pad to get tablets is jailed
A woman who took half a pad of prescriptions from a Dublin hospital which she later used to make fake prescriptions for sleeping tablets has been jailed for 18 months. Kym Dunleavy (50) St Josephs Place, Dublin 7, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to multiple charges of using a false instrument, a medical prescription which she knew to be false, on various dates between November 2018 and April 2019. Advertisement She has 71 previous convictions, mostly for theft and fraud offences. Keith Spencer BL, defending, told the court at a previous court hearing, that his client 'suffered unimaginable trauma' over the years, including the fact that her mother was murdered by her (Dunleavy's) brother, two of her brothers were shot dead and her son was killed while he was working with the British Armed Forces. Garda Joseph Melvin told Fiona Crawford BL, prosecuting, at that same hearing that gardaí were contacted after one particular pharmacy raised concerns that a customer had used a false prescription in an attempt to purchase medication. Dunleavy was identified as a suspect after gardaí viewed CCTV footage from the pharmacy. They later secured a warrant to search her home where a prescription pad from Beaumont Hospital was found under a mattress. Advertisement Gardaí spoke to the head pharmacist in Beaumont Hospital who confirmed that while Dunleavy had previously been a patient there, she had not attended the hospital for a number of years. The pharmacist confirmed that they were forgeries but said the prescription pad was legitimate. Gda Melvin agreed with Mr Spencer that Dunleavy told gardaí during interview that she had 'behaved rather badly' and had taken the pad from Beaumont. She said she had approached her GP because the one sleeping tablet she had previously been prescribed was not enough to deal with her anxiety. Dunleavy told gardaí that the anxiety was 'coming noon and night – horrific visions from my past that were prone to surface at night'. She said the sleeping tablets assisted her as she would 'just sleep and when I wake there are no horrors'. Advertisement Dunleavy told gardaí that the doctor increased her prescription to two tablets but it was still not enough and she used the forged prescriptions to get more tablets. 'I am exceptionally drained from this. I have visions of my mother's murder – they are frightening,' Dunleavy said before she told gardaí she had put 'a brave face' on her addiction for a long time. 'I was not raised to be this person,' Dunleavy told gardaí. Mr Spencer told the court that Dunleavy's brother was murdered in 2005 and her mother was murdered by Dunleavy's other brother in 2013. Her sister also died giving birth and Dunleavy had helped to care for that baby. Advertisement Counsel said Dunleavy's son had died while on tour with the British Armed Forces. Mr Spencer said since this offence Dunleavy has managed to self-detox but has isolated herself from the local community in order to achieve this. She hopes to get back into community once she has got a handle on her addiction. Mr Spencer said his client had been referred to the psychiatric services but she has not followed up on it. Judge Orla Crowe said that Dunleavy has a considerable history of offending and a probation report puts her at high risk of re-offending. Advertisement She said however, there are 'certain positives' in Dunleavy's life, including that she has no convictions since 2021 and she no longer abuses prescribed medication. Judge Crowe noted that Dunleavy has not followed through on referrals to psychiatric services nor has she properly engaged with the Probation Service, even though the service has indicated that Dunleavy would benefit from probation supervision. Judge Crowe had previously adjourned the case to allow Dunleavy the opportunity to 'put her best foot forward'. Ireland Physiotherapist who gave Botox-like drug to client... Read More Sentencing her on Monday, Judge Crowe said that since her remand in custody Dunleavy 'is still struggling'. She noted that the maximum penalty for the offence was 10 years before she said because of the 'considerable amount of time that has since passed' she felt a headline sentence of two and half years would be appropriate. Judge Crowe said taking the mitigation in the case into account she would impose a sentence of 18 months in prison. Dunleavy said the prison term was 'disgraceful' and 'ridiculous' as she was escorted away by prison officers.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Politics watch: Taoiseach defends EU-US trade deal amid criticism
Here, we have a look at the topics likely to dominate political discourse in the week to come. EU-US trade deal The Taoiseach has welcomed a new trade agreement between the US and EU as having 'avoided a damaging trade war'. Advertisement Taoiseach Micheál Martin also said there is 'much to be negotiated' following what he termed a 'framework agreement'. Speaking to the media in Dublin on Monday, Mr Martin said it 'opens up the prospect of more significant strategic collaboration between the US and Europe on quite a number of issues'. 'It also avoids further escalation, or indeed a trade conflict, which would be very, very damaging to the economies of the United States and of the European Union,' he said. 'It's important to say that Europe never sought tariffs, or never sought to impose tariffs, and fundamentally, we are against tariffs: we believe in an open trading economy.' Mr Martin said it is a very different situation than before April 1st. Advertisement 'New realities are in play and so at a broader level, the stability and predictability that this agreement brings is important for businesses, is important for consumers and indeed patients when it comes to the manufacturing and distribution of medicines,' he said. 'In essence, we have avoided a trade conflict here which would have been ruinous, which would have been very damaging to our economy, and to jobs in particular. 'The challenge now for Europe is to work on its own inefficiencies, to reduce barriers within the single market, to press ahead more ambitiously and more proactively on trade diversification and trade deals with other countries that would facilitate that market diversification that is required. 'Meanwhile, there is much to be negotiated in the aftermath of this framework agreement.' Advertisement Asked about mixed reactions to the deal in Europe, Mr Martin said: 'Nobody is welcoming tariffs with open arms. 'I think we've been consistent in saying that we don't agree with tariffs, that we prefer if there weren't tariffs, but we have to deal with realities. 'I understand people criticising, but given the balance and the options here… in my view, I would appreciate the work of the (European) Commission in this regard, and the avoidance of a trade war is preferable, in my view, and that's the key issue.' Businesses have had a mixed reaction to the agreement. Advertisement In a statement, business lobby group Ibec said the deal will still leave a "substantial burden" for some industries. Ibec chief executive Danny McCoy said: "Today's trade agreement between the US and EU brings an end to a significant amount of uncertainty for some businesses. However, a 15 per cent tariff still represents a substantial burden for many industries. Sectors which rely heavily on the US market and operate within small margins, will once again be significantly impacted by an additional 5 per cent tariff, on top of what they have already had to absorb over the past several months and well in excess of the 1 per cent effective tariff which existed before April." Mr McCoy added: "Our message to the Government, as it was with the 10 per cent tariff, is that the most exposed sectors will require support similar to the interventions provided as a response to Brexit. "It is important to note that the details are still emerging and will only be worked out as today's framework is fleshed out. These details will be critically important for Ireland. Pharmaceuticals and Semiconductors which equate to 75 per cent of Ireland-US trade are, we understand, included in the 15 per cent deal. However, there is still a question around the stability of that rate over both the short and long-term in the face of ongoing Section 232 investigations." Advertisement Speaking on RTÉ's News at One, IEA chief executive Simon McKeever: "I think the EU was backed into a very difficult negotiating position because of the lack of investment in defence and security spending over the last number of years. It's totally dependent on the US in that space. "I don't think it's a good deal. I don't think it's a great deal and for Irish businesses, they're now faced with a 15 per cent tariff they weren't faced with before and they'll need to deal with that. "I think that we were negotiating with one if not two hands tied behind our back. I don't think we were in a very strong position because of the defence issue." He called on Tánaiste Simon Harris to get the trade forum together urgently. "Companies are going to need help. We have called for a tariff adjustment fund, which is based on the Brexit adjustment reserve and was brought out in 2021. "Irish companies are going to need time to get to grips with this. I'm calling on Simon Harris to please get the trade forum together tomorrow or on Wednesday, because we need to get back to our members with this." French prime minister François Bayrou called the deal a "dark day" for Europe. 'It is a dark day when an alliance of free peoples, united to assert their values and defend their interests, resigns itself to submission,' Mr Bayrou wrote on X. Michael D Higgins tells EU presidents silence on Gaza would be a 'moral failure' President Michael D Higgins has written to other European presidents to say that silence on Gaza would be a moral failure. He said that while Israel has a right to defend itself, they cannot let the 'horrific' attack on October 7th, 2023, 'provide a licence or cover' for the scale of civilian deaths in Gaza. Mr Higgins wrote the letter to the Arraiolos Group, an informal organisation representing presidents of EU countries which meets once a year. The political forum is named after the Portuguese town where the first meeting took place in 2003. 'I am sure that we all remember with horror the moment when news broke of the horrific atrocities carried out by Hamas as we returned from our meeting of the Arraiolos Group in Porto in October 2023,' he said. 'These atrocities were rightly condemned by all member states. We were not silent and called for the unconditional release of all hostages. 'While Israel has a right to defend itself, we cannot let that horrific event provide a licence or cover for the totally unacceptable loss of life, including from malnutrition and dehydration by infants and mothers that is now being perpetrated in Gaza.' Abroad The EU-US trade deal was announced during US president Donald Trump's visit to Scotland, where he appeared alongside European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen. He also appeared with UK prime minister Keir Starmer at a press conference on Monday, where they addressed a range of topics. Mr Trump said the focus in Gaza was getting food to people amid ongoing Israeli blockades of aide that have left the population on the brik of mass starvation. Mr Trump also suggested he will bring forward a deadline for Russia to agree a ceasefire with Ukraine.
ITV News
3 hours ago
- ITV News
'Still a huge sense of disbelief' says Mayor of Ennis following death of mother and two children
The Mayor of Ennis in County Clare says, "there's still a huge sense of disbelief" at the murder of Vanessa Whyte and her two children in Co Fermanagh. Vanessa Whyte, 45, a vet originally from Co Clare, her son James, 14, and daughter Sara, 13, were killed in a suspected triple murder and attempted suicide at a house in Maguiresbridge on Wednesday morning. On Sunday, over 100 miles away from Fermanagh, a special prayer service was held at the Church of the Immaculate Conception in Bearfield in their honour. Today, Mayor of Ennis, Cllr Clare Colleran Molloy revealed they had been planning a holiday to Vanessa's hometown in Co. Clare just this week. Speaking about the recent service she said: "The silence in that church was extraordinary, you could actually hear a pin drop. "I never experienced that kind of silence before. "There still is a huge sense of disbelief, and just really a lot of heartache for the family."Her children would certainly will be remembered here locally from they were due to come down on holidays this week and there's a big family of them Vanessa certainly will not be forgotten and she will not be forgotten by her school friends and the people she grew up with in her community." Vanessa, 14-year-old James, and 13-year-old Sarah Rutledge loved sports, including GAA and cricket. On Sunday during the All-Ireland final at Croke Park in Dublin, they were remembered. Flowers, messages, and a cricket bat have now been placed at the fence of their home in children's father remains in a serious condition in hospital in Belfast with gunshot Saturday, detectives from the major investigation team, who are carrying out the murder investigation, said they are continuing with their inquiries and appealed for information involving the movements of a Chief Inspector Neil McGuinness said: 'Our investigation is ongoing and we are working tirelessly to determine the exact circumstances of this tragedy.'I would continue to appeal generally for anyone with information to come forward, and more specifically, I would ask anyone who saw a silver Mercedes saloon car being driven in the Clones Road area of Newtownbutler, or between Maguiresbridge and Newtownbutler, on the evening of Tuesday July 22 to call detectives on 101, quoting reference 276 23/07/25.'Anyone who was travelling in the area and who may have captured dashcam footage which could assist, please get in touch.'The man who remains in a serious condition in hospital was a member of the same household, the PSNI funeral for all three is expected to take place in County Clare. Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know.
