BREAKING NEWS Wissam Haddad BANNED from making anti-Semitic remarks in public after fiery sermons
Wissam Haddad, a cleric at the Sydney-based Al Madina Dawah Centre, was accused of racial discrimination in relation to a series of fiery sermons, which have racked up thousands of views online, since November 2023.
In the speeches, the preacher, also known as Abu Ousayd, referred to Jewish people as vile, treacherous, murderous, and mischievous.
Justice Angus Stewart on Tuesday found the speeches were disparaging and likely to offend, insult, harass or intimidate Jewish people.
'The imputations include age-old tropes against Jewish people that are fundamentally racist and anti-Semitic,' Justice Stewart said.
'They make perverse generalisations against Jewish people as a group.'
During the landmark case testing the limits of religious expression and hate speech, two Jewish leaders argued the online lectures were offensive and could incite violence towards Jews.
They sought the removal of the published speeches, a public declaration of error and an order restraining Mr Haddad from making similar comments in future.
Mr Haddad denied breaching anti-discrimination laws and claimed he was delivering historical and religious lectures on events from the Koran to contextualise the war in Gaza.
He said he was speaking about 'Jews of faith' rather than ethnicity while trying to explain that 'what the Israeli government is doing to the people of Gaza' is 'not something new'.
Ruling against the preacher would be tantamount to restricting the free exercise of religious expression, Mr Haddad's lawyer argued.
Justice Stewart rejected the defence on Tuesday and ordered Mr Haddad to remove the speeches.
He directed the preacher not to make any further comments that convey similar disparaging imputations.
Mr Haddad has also been ordered to foot the legal bill for Executive Council of Australian Jewry co-chief executive Peter Wertheim and deputy president Robert Goot.
The preacher did not appear in the Federal Court when Justice Stewart handed down his decision, arriving late.
His speeches were delivered during a time of heightened sensitivity after the designated terror group Hamas attacked Israel on October 7, 2023, sparking Israeli retaliation that has left the Gaza Strip in turmoil.
The reporting of the war prompted questions and concerns from Mr Haddad's congregants and at the same time left Jewish Australians feeling unsafe, the court was told.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
14 minutes ago
- The Independent
Israel plans to widen coming offensive beyond Gaza City into last areas not under its control
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says Israel plans to widen its coming offensive beyond Gaza City to the last areas not yet under Israeli control, and where most of Gaza's 2 million residents have sought shelter as the territory slides toward famine. The mobilization of forces is expected to take weeks, and Israel may be using the threat of a wider offensive to try to pressure Hamas into releasing more hostages or surrendering after 22 months of war sparked by its Oct. 7, 2023, attack into Israel. Any expansion of Israeli operations is likely to bring even more death and destruction to the war-ravaged territory, around 75% of which is already largely destroyed and controlled by Israel. A wider offensive would also force more people to flee and further disrupt the delivery of humanitarian aid during a severe hunger crisis. The plans have also sparked controversy in Israel. Families of the remaining hostages fear another military escalation could doom their loved ones, while former senior security officials have said there is little to be gained militarily. Netanyahu says Israel will go into the central camps Israel announced last week its plans to take over Gaza City, where it has already carried out major raids and heavy bombardment throughout the war. On Sunday, Netanyahu told a news conference that operations would be expanded into the 'central camps" and beyond. He appeared to be referring to the built-up Nuseirat and Bureij camps in central Gaza that date back to the 1948 war surrounding Israel's creation. Israel has carried out near-daily airstrikes in the camps since the start of the war but no major ground operations. Netanyahu referred to Gaza City, the central camps and Muwasi — a vast cluster of displacement camps along the coast — as Hamas strongholds. These areas, along with the central city of Deir al-Balah, are the only parts of Gaza that have not been almost completely destroyed in previous Israeli operations. They are also areas where Hamas may be holding hostages in tunnels or other secret locations. An Israeli official, speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss aspects of the plans that have not been made public, said the operation will not begin immediately and will take a significant amount of time to scale up. One indication will be the potential mobilization of thousands of reservists. The official said the announced plans were partly aimed at putting pressure on various parties. Few places left to flee Netanyahu said Israel will allow civilians to flee to 'designated safe zones,' where 'they will be given ample food, water and medical care, as we have done before.' He did not say where they would go. Israel designated Muwasi as a humanitarian zone earlier in the war. The barren stretch of sandy coastline was soon filled with tents housing hundreds of thousands of people with little in the way of food, running water, toilets or trash collection. Israel has regularly carried out airstrikes against what it said were militants hiding out there, often killing women and children. Last month, Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz reportedly floated the idea of transferring Gaza's population to a so-called 'humanitarian city' that the military would build on the ruins of the southernmost city of Rafah — now a largely uninhabited Israeli military zone — on the border with Egypt. Netanyahu has vowed to eventually relocate much of Gaza's population to other countries through what he refers to as voluntary emigration. The Palestinians and much of the international community see it as forcible expulsion because Israel's offensive has made much of Gaza uninhabitable. They fear that concentrating people in the south would be a step toward implementing such plans. A possible negotiating tactic Netanyahu has said he will end the war if Hamas gives up power, lays down its arms and releases the remaining 50 hostages — around 20 of whom are believed by Israel to be alive. Israel would still maintain open-ended security control over Gaza and facilitate the departure of those who wish to leave, according to Netanyahu. He has said Arab forces friendly to Israel would administer the territory, but none are known to have volunteered, aside from an Israeli-backed armed group known for looting aid. Hamas has said, in line with international demands, that it would release the remaining hostages in return for a lasting ceasefire and an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. The militant group says it is willing to hand over power to other Palestinians but will not give up its weapons as long as Israel occupies lands the Palestinians want for a future state. Israel may hope that ratcheting up pressure will yield further concessions from Hamas in U.S.- and Arab-mediated talks that appear to have broken down last month. But the hostages are Hamas' only remaining bargaining chip, and it is unlikely to give them up if it believes that Israel will then resume the war, attempt to eradicate the group and carry out plans to depopulate Gaza. Israel ended a previous ceasefire in March that had facilitated the release of 25 hostages and the remains of eight others. Since then, it has imposed a 2 1/2 month blockade that pushed the territory toward famine, launched daily airstrikes across Gaza, expanded its buffer zone and ordered mass evacuations. Hamas has only released one hostage during that time, as a gesture to the United States. Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251 others in the 2023 attack. More than half of the hostages have been released in ceasefires or other deals. Israel's offensive has killed around 61,500 Palestinians, according to Gaza's Health Ministry. The ministry, which is part of the Hamas-run government and run by medical professionals, does not say how many of those killed were civilians or combatants, but it says women and children make up around half of the fatalities. The agency's numbers are considered a reliable estimate by the U.N. and independent experts. Israel disputes them but has not offered its own figures. ___ Associated Press Writer Melanie Lidman in Tel Aviv, Israel, contributed to this report. ___
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Killing of Al Jazeera staff in Gaza ‘silencing journalistic voices'
Israel's killing of journalists in Gaza was 'silencing of some of the few journalistic voices left' in the region, Ireland's deputy premier has said. Prominent Al Jazeera correspondent Anas al-Sharif, 28 and four of his colleagues were killed while sheltering outside al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City on Sunday night. Another reporter was also killed in the Israeli airstrike. The National Union of Journalists is to hold a protest at the Spire in Dublin on Monday evening to condemn the killing of reporters and camera operators in Gaza by Israel. Ireland's deputy premier and foreign affairs minister Simon Harris said he is to engage with his EU counterparts in relation to Gaza on Monday. 'Can I say firstly, just to extend the sympathy and solidarity of the people of Ireland with Al Jazeera and the journalists – the five staff members of Al Jazeera and the one other reporter – who have been killed in a horrifying attack in Gaza,' he said speaking outside Government Buildings on Monday. 'In many ways, it is the silencing of some of the few journalistic voices left in Gaza. 'Of course, any attack on any civilian – including, of course, any attack on any journalist – should always be absolutely condemned for what it is. 'At a time when the people of Gaza desperately need to see a ceasefire, an end to the violence, a surge in humanitarian aid, and of course, the release of the hostages, all of the indications from (Israeli President Benjamin) Netanyahu is of an Israeli government intended to go in the complete opposite direction to that. 'I do think it is interesting in recent days to have seen an increase in protest within Israel, Israeli people standing up and saying to their government 'not in my name'. 'Israeli people wanting to live in peace and security as well, alongside the Palestinian people and, of course, Israeli people rightly wanting hostages released immediately too.'
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
‘Just horrific': Witnesses tell how missiles tore through journalists' tent in Gaza
The Al-Jazeera journalists sheltering in tents on the grounds of the Shifa hospital complex in Gaza City had just bade each other good night. Another day of reporting the violence, starvation and brutality swallowing up their besieged homeland had ground to an end. Fifteen minutes later, Israeli missiles tore through the sky and eviscerated the tent where they were sleeping. Anas Al-Sharif, 28, one of the news channel's most prominent voices in Gaza, was killed alongside reporter Mohammed Qreiqeh, and cameramen Ibrahim Zaher, Mohammed Noufal and Moamen Aliwa. Al-Sharif had been intentionally targeted by the Israelis, who accused him of being the head of a Hamas terror cell, but offered no credible evidence to back up their claim. There was no explanation for the killing of the other men alongside him. Anas al-Sharif, Ibrahim Zaher, Mohammed Noufal, Moamen Aliwa and Mohammed Qreiqeh Late on Sunday, an Israeli strike shook al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City, targeting a journalists' tent by the people rushed to help, it became apparent that five Al Jazeera staff had been killed, including Anas al-Sharif, one of the most famous faces of Arabic reporting from Gaza. (Al Jazeera) Saed, a Palestinian journalist staying in a nearby tent on the same hospital site, was thrown to the ground by the deafening explosion when the strike hit. 'I lost consciousness,' he told The Independent. 'Suddenly, my eyes went back to the area, and I saw that the journalists' tent had been targeted.' Amer, 31, also in the same compound, came rushing out. He described seeing one journalist, injured in the legs and back, screaming for help. Al-Sharif - who had face numerous death threats in the run up to the strikes - was lying dead on the ground behind him. His colleague Mohammed Qraiqaa was alive, just about, but on fire. Those around him scrambled to try to extinguish the flames, Amer continued. 'One man was killed while sitting in a chair, and another was killed inside the journalist tent next to us. It was horrific,' he added, visibly shaken. A member of the media inspects the damage at the site of an Israeli strike on a tent near Shifa Hospital where Al Jazeera journalists Anas Al Sharif, Mohammed Qreiqeh, Ibrahim Zaher, and Mohammed Noufal were killed, in Gaza City August 11, 2025 (Reuters) Shrapnel had sprayed the journalist syndicate tent, killing a sixth journalist who did not work for Al Jazeera, as well as a passer-by. 'These journalists were the voice and the image of our suffering here in Gaza — and now they have become the subject of the stories they were covering,' Amer said. 'Anas expected that he would be targeted at any moment. He accepted the possibility, based on the threats against him. He was reporting to the world what was happening, conveying the images and the massacres being committed in the Gaza Strip. There was no place for him to hide.' Prepared for his death, a lengthy heartbreaking statement was posted to Al-Sharif's X account after he was killed read: "This is my last will and testament. If these words of mine reach you, know that Israel has succeeded in killing me and silencing my voice.' The message concluded: 'Do not forget Gaza… And do not forget me in your sincere prayers for forgiveness and acceptance.' Shortly before his death, he posted that there was 'non-stop bombing' in the area. The Committee to Protect Journalists, CPJ, warned last month it was gravely concerned for Al-Sharif's safety as he was being 'targeted by an Israeli military smear campaign' and the unfounded accusations 'represented an effort to manufacture consent to kill Al-Sharif'. Sara Qudah, the group's director for the Middle East and North Africa had said tat the time the two weeks ago danger to Al-Sharif's life was 'now acute'. Anas Al-Sharif reporting from Gaza (AP) A UN expert previously warned that Al-Sharif's life was in danger due to his reporting from Gaza, while special rapporteur Irene Khan said last month Israel's claims against him were unsubstantiated. Israeli military claimed responsibility for the attack claiming he was a Hamas militant who was responsible for coordinating rocket attacks. Jodie Ginsberg, chief executive of CPJ, said they had yet to see "any credible evidence" to back the Israeli allegations against Al-Sharif. 'They've been making this claim for many, many months, most recently in the last couple of weeks following a report that Anas did on starvation in Gaza, in which he cried on air," Ms Ginsberg said. "We've asked for evidence repeatedly from Israel." The journalists' deaths were roundly condemned across the world with Sir Keir Starmer's spokesman saying the PM was 'gravely concerned by the repeated targeting of journalists in Gaza'. He went on: 'Reporters covering conflicts are afforded protection under international humanitarian law, and journalists must be able to report independently, without fear, and Israel must ensure journalists can carry out their work safely." Demonstrators hold placards depicting portraits of the late Palestinian journalist Anas Al-Sharif as they gather for a vigil to commemorate all journalists killed in Gaza, at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in The Hague, on August 11, 2025. (ANP/AFP/Getty) Al Jazeera Media Network condemned what it called the 'targeted assassination' of Al-Sharif and said he and his colleagues were among the last remaining voices from within Gaza providing the world with 'unfiltered, on-the-ground coverage of the devastating realities endured by its people'. Omar Shakir, from Human Rights Watch, added: 'The brazen targeted killing of Palestinian journalists Anas Al-Sharif & Mohammad Qreiqeh, along with 4 other media workers, highlights the unimaginable peril Palestinian journalists in Gaza face, and the Israeli military's complete disregard for civilian life. 'As Israel continues to impose a ban on journalists entering Gaza, Palestinian journalists play an indispensable role in documenting and reporting Israel's ongoing extermination of Palestinians. 'Rather than killing voices reporting on its atrocities in Gaza, Israel should stop committing them.'
