Air India crash rekindles debate over cockpit video recorders
One of the industry's most influential voices, International Air Transport Association head Willie Walsh, a former airline pilot, said on Wednesday in Singapore there was a strong argument for video cameras to be installed in airliner cockpits to monitor pilot actions to complement voice and flight data recorders already used by accident investigators.
Aviation experts have said a preliminary report from India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) raised questions over whether one of the pilots of Air India flight 171 cut off fuel to the Boeing 787's engines seconds after takeoff, leading to an irrecoverable situation.
The crash in Ahmedabad, India, killed 241 of the 242 people aboard, as well as 19 people on the ground.
As of now, 'based on what little we know now, it's quite possible that a video recording, in addition to the voice recording would significantly assist the investigators in conducting that investigation on the issue of mental health,' Walsh said.
Advocates for cockpit video cameras say the footage could fill in gaps left by the audio and data recorders, while opponents say concerns about privacy and misuse outweigh what they argue are marginal benefits for investigations.
Video footage was 'invaluable' to Australian crash investigators determining what led to Robinson R66 helicopter breaking up in mid-air in 2023, killing the pilot, the only person aboard, according to the Australian Transport Safety Bureau's final report, which was released 18 days after the Air India crash.
The video showed 'the pilot was occupied with non-flying related tasks for much of this time, specifically, mobile phone use and the consumption of food and beverages,' the report said.
The ATSB commended Robinson Helicopters for providing factory-installed cameras and said it encouraged other manufacturers and owners to consider the ongoing safety benefits of similar devices.
In 2000, US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Chairman Jim Hall urged the Federal Aviation Administration to require commercial airliners be equipped with cockpit image recorders.
Hall's recommendation came in the wake of 1999's Egyptair Flight 990 crash, when the first officer intentionally crashed the Boeing 767, according to the NTSB, killing all 217 people on board.
'In the balance between privacy and safety, the scale tips toward safety, unequivocally,' air safety expert and former commercial airline pilot John Nance said. 'Protecting the flying public is a sacred obligation.'
Another aviation safety expert, Anthony Brickhouse, said that as an accident investigator, he is in favor of cockpit video, but acknowledged that commercial pilots have real concerns.
Video on Air India flight 171 'would have answered lots of questions,' he said.
Air India declined to comment. India's AAIB, which is expected to release a final report within a year of the crash under international rules, did not reply to request for comment.
US pilots' unions such as the Air Line Pilots Association (ALPA) and Allied Pilots Association (APA) say the voice and data recorders already provide enough information to determine the cause of a crash and that the cameras would be an invasion of privacy and could be misused.
Calls for cockpit cameras are an understandable reaction to 'the stress of not knowing what happened immediately after an accident,' said APA spokesperson Dennis Tajer, an American Airlines pilot.
'I can understand the initial reaction of the more information, the better,' but investigators already have enough data to adequately determine an accident's cause, leaving no need for cameras, he said.
To make flying safer, current safety systems should be enhanced to record higher-quality data, rather than adding video cameras, an ALPA spokeperson said.
There are also concerns the footage could be used by airlines for disciplinary actions or that video could be leaked to the public after a crash, said John Cox, an aviation safety expert, retired airline pilot and former ALPA executive air safety chairman.
A pilot's death being broadcast on 'the 6 o'clock news is not something that the pilot's family should ever have to go through,' he said.
If confidentiality can be assured around the world, 'I can see an argument' for installing cameras, Cox said.
Cockpit voice recordings are typically kept confidential by investigators in favor of partial or full transcripts being released in final reports.
Despite that, International Federation of Air Line Pilots Associations said it was skeptical that confidentiality could ever be assured for cockpit videos.
'Given the high demand for sensational pictures, IFALPA has absolutely no doubt that the protection of (airborne image recorder) data, which can include identifiable images of flight crewmembers, would not be ensured either,' the organization said in a statement.
Boeing declined to disclose whether customers are able to order cockpit video recorders, while Airbus did not reply to request for comment.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Bloomberg
3 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Ex-Trader Turned Market Cop Halts Jane Street's India Bonanza
Ananth Narayan paced his office in Mumbai as the clock ticked toward a revelation that would shock the global financial industry. The 56-year-old former trader — now market regulator — was racing with his team to upload hundreds of pages of documents detailing an investigation into Jane Street Group LLC, one of the world's most secretive trading firms.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
A Woman's Son Died in the Air India Crash, and Now She Says She Was Given the Wrong Body: 'An Appalling Thing to Have Happened'
'We don't know what poor person is in that casket,' Amanda Donaghey said of the body she believed to be her son's After losing her son in the Air India plane crash, a grieving mother traveled to India to bring his body home. But the coffin she returned with, she claims, contained the remains of a different victim. On June 12, Air India Flight AI171, a London-bound Boeing 787-8 aircraft, crashed just after takeoff in India, resulting in the deaths of 241 people — everyone on board but one. Amanda Donaghey's son, Fiongal Greenlaw-Meek, 39, and his husband Jamie, 45, were on the flight, returning home to the United Kingdom after celebrating their wedding anniversary in India. Donaghey, who lives in France, traveled to the crash site to see where her son had spent his final moments, and to bring his body home — but the remains she brought back to London were not her son's, she claimed in a new The Sunday Times interview published on July 26. Donaghey, 66, first arrived in India five days after the crash, on June 17, and gave blood in order to find a DNA match among the remains of the 241 — 229 passengers and 12 crew members. On June 20, as she began to lose hope, someone informed her a 'match' had been found, she told The Sunday Times. Believing his body would now be able to join the body of his husband, which had already been properly identified and brought home, Donaghey arrived in London Gatwick Airport 'with the assurance that Fiongal was in the casket,' she told The Sunday Times. But she claimed she would soon make a 'heartbreaking' discovery that disrupted the family's plan to have the couple rest together. As Donaghey and her family planned Greenlaw-Meek and Jamie's funerals, police allegedly informed her that a coroner in the U.K. had determined that the remains she had brought home were not her son's. It happened in early July, when family liaison officers set up a meeting with Donaghey, along with Greenlaw-Meek's father, sister and brother, and allegedly told the family, 'We don't have Fiongal. We have carried out the DNA tests and we do not have Fiongal,' according to The Sunday Times. 'I had my doubts, but to be told that was heartbreaking,' the grieving mother recalled to the outlet of the revelation. 'We don't know what poor person is in that casket. This is an appalling thing to have happened,' Donaghey added to The Sunday Times. 'And we would now like the British government to do everything in its power to find out, and bring Fiongal home.' As Donaghey continues her effort to bring her son's body home, she fears, however, it may now be an impossible feat. 'We have spent every day since then on the phone to the Foreign Office, trying to get a response on where Fiongal is,' Donaghey told The Sunday Times. 'All the time, I feel like I'm just standing on the edge of a black hole thinking, 'Has he been disposed of?' ' Greenlaw-Meek's loved ones are not the only ones in this situation. James Healy-Pratt, an aviation lawyer who said he is representing multiple U.K. families in the wake of the crash, previously told CBS News and The Daily Mail that the remains of two British victims had been misidentified. Speaking with CBS News, he described it as 'a double psychological trauma.' In a statement shared on July 23, Indian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Shri Randhir Jaiswal said authorities 'have seen the report' about the mix-up and "have been working closely with the UK side from the moment these concerns and issues were brought to our attention.' "In the wake of the tragic crash, the concerned authorities had carried out identification of victims as per established protocols and technical requirements,' Jaiswal added. 'All mortal remains were handled with utmost professionalism and with due regard for the dignity of the deceased. We are continuing to work with the UK authorities on addressing any concerns related to this issue." In a statement to The Sunday Times, a U.K. government spokesperson said that "formal identification of bodies is a matter for the Indian authorities." 'We understand that this is an extremely distressing time for the families, and our thoughts remain with them," the spokesperson continued, in part. "We continue to liaise with the government of Gujarat and the government of India on behalf of the Inner West London senior coroner to support the coronial process.' Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. An official cause of the Air India Flight AI171 crash has not officially been released, but officials are currently investigating why the fuel to the engines was cut. The Ministry of Civil Aviation previously announced it was establishing a committee to investigate the incident, promising to assess "the root cause of the crash" and "contributing factors, including mechanical failure, human error, weather conditions, regulatory compliances and other reasons.' Read the original article on People

Wall Street Journal
11 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
Watch: Passengers Slide Onto Runway After Plane Catches Fire
The Federal Aviation Administration said it will investigate the incident at Denver International Airport after passengers were evacuated from an American Airlines flight. Photo: @highlymigratoryfishing/Instagram/Reuters