Joe Schmidt should let Wallabies play for their states against the Lions. Here's why
There isn't an apples-to-apples comparison to be made between the British and Irish Lions tour of New Zealand in 2017 and the one in Australia this year, at least in terms of scheduling.
The All Blacks, to the pleasant surprise of many at the time, allowed established Test stars such as Sam Whitelock, Codie Taylor, Owen Franks and Israel Dagg to play for the Crusaders against the Lions just two weeks before the first Test of the series.
Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt has signalled this won't happen this year, and the apparent discrepancy has already been picked up in the northern hemisphere, where fears of the tour being devalued are a quadrennial storyline.
The complexity of this year's schedule is that the Wallabies are playing against Fiji in Newcastle on July 6, one day after the Waratahs host the Lions in Sydney and four days after the Reds welcome them in Brisbane.
It is the addition of that Fiji fixture two weeks before the first Test on July 19 that will weaken the Reds and the Waratahs for the Lions tour games, not Schmidt's desire to shield his players from injury risk, and the question really become one of whether the Wallabies are better served by the Fiji Test or playing in the tour games.
It is self-evident that the tour as a whole would benefit from the Wallabies' top-liners being available for the first three tour games (the Force, the Reds and the Waratahs – the Brumbies game is just 10 days away from the opening Test and a less realistic prospect).
Imagine the frisson in Brisbane if Harry Wilson was permitted to run it off the back fence against the Lions in a Queensland jersey on July 2.
But from a high-performance perspective, the tour games are also surely better preparation for the Test series than the hit-out against Fiji, whose style is completely different to that of the Lions and whose players are largely familiar to the Wallabies thanks to the presence of the Drua in Super Rugby Pacific.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
a day ago
- News.com.au
Brumbies seal Super Rugby semi final berth with win over the Hurricanes
There's still a pulse in Australia's ailing Super Rugby teams. Not for the first time, the ACT Brumbies have saved Australian rugby's blushes with a thrilling 35-28 quarter-final win over the Hurricanes in Canberra on Saturday. They now face the dreaded prospect of having to win twice in New Zealand to take the title but that's a problem for another day because the good news is that at least they're still alive. Australia's other teams all folded like cheap suits and have already crashed out of the tournament, leaving the Brumbies to fly the flag alone against the three remaining Kiwi sides. If it wasn't for an officiating blunder that cost them victory in their final regular season clash with the Crusaders, the Brumbies would be hosting a semi next week but instead they're off to Waikato Stadium in Hamilton to tackle the Chiefs. It's a tough assignment but the Brumbies have always been a side willing to roll up their sleeves and grind out wins through hard work. Twice they found themselves trailing the Hurricanes inside the first quarter of the game but both times they levelled the scores with tries off the back of rolling mauls after spurning the chance of easy points from penalties. It's not pretty but it's a highly effective tactic that the Brumbies have mastered and the Wallabies should consider using in their upcoming series against the British and Irish Lions. Four of the Brumbies' five tries against the Hurricanes were scored by frontrowers, two by hooker Billy Pollard and one each from props James Slipper and captain Allan Alaalatoa, who returned to the side from injury. 'It felt good to earn ourselves another week,' Alaalatoa said. 'We knew it was probably going to take everything we had. Physically, we spoke a lot about our tackle area and our tackle completion from the last time we played them. 'We backed ourselves. We knew that if we were going to beat the Hurricanes, we had to score some tries. 'The last time we played him, we didn't get many A-Zone opportunities, so we wanted to take as many as we could.' Only Tom Wright, who had an impressive game at fullback, chalked one up for the backline after he combined with powerhouse backrower Rob Valentini. If the Brumbies have a weakness it's with their defence. They conceded 50 tries during the normal season and gave up four more against the Hurricanes to keep the visitors in the game right until the final whistle. There was some added pressure before the game when the Auckland Blues scored in the last minute to beat the Chiefs in New Zealand, meaning the Brumbies' match was sudden-death. Had the Chiefs won, both the Brumbies and the Canes would have been assured a place in the semis regardless of the result but it was the Aussies who survived to fight again. 'It's good for us to experience that pressure now, especially heading over to Hamilton now where it is going to be do or die,' Alaalatoa said. 'To have that feeling for the game I think it's gonna be good for us heading into next week.'
The Advertiser
a day ago
- The Advertiser
Lagergren blows hot to lead weather-hit KLM Open
British trio Connor Syme, Richie Ramsay and Andy Sullivan have remained in contention as Sweden's Joakim Lagergren led the KLM Open at the end of a disrupted second day. Winds of over 35mph in Amsterdam led to a two-hour stoppage due to "oscillating balls", extending play deep into the evening for a second successive day after Thursday's storms. Lagergren was already safely round in 68 for an eight-under-par halfway total, which proved too much for the chasing pack to match in tough scoring conditions. Syme followed up his opening 65 with a one-over-par 72 to reach five under, good enough for third place behind first-round leader Ricardo Gouveia. Fellow Scot Ramsay was also one over for his round with one hole to play when darkness descended, sharing fourth place with France's Pierre Pineau on four under. England's Sullivan shot 70 to reach three under alongside Francesco Laporta, who also had one hole to complete, and Oliver Lindell. Another Englishman, Dan Brown, had finished day one in a share of third place after matching Ramsay's 66 but fell off the pace on Friday with three double bogeys, including at the second and third holes. His eventual 79 left him only just inside the cut line at three over. It was not a good day for Australians, Jason Scrivener following his opening-round 68 with a 75 that left him nine off the lead. David Micheluzzi is 10 over after repeating a 76 and Daniel Gale is 16 over following his 75 while Danny List withdrew. British trio Connor Syme, Richie Ramsay and Andy Sullivan have remained in contention as Sweden's Joakim Lagergren led the KLM Open at the end of a disrupted second day. Winds of over 35mph in Amsterdam led to a two-hour stoppage due to "oscillating balls", extending play deep into the evening for a second successive day after Thursday's storms. Lagergren was already safely round in 68 for an eight-under-par halfway total, which proved too much for the chasing pack to match in tough scoring conditions. Syme followed up his opening 65 with a one-over-par 72 to reach five under, good enough for third place behind first-round leader Ricardo Gouveia. Fellow Scot Ramsay was also one over for his round with one hole to play when darkness descended, sharing fourth place with France's Pierre Pineau on four under. England's Sullivan shot 70 to reach three under alongside Francesco Laporta, who also had one hole to complete, and Oliver Lindell. Another Englishman, Dan Brown, had finished day one in a share of third place after matching Ramsay's 66 but fell off the pace on Friday with three double bogeys, including at the second and third holes. His eventual 79 left him only just inside the cut line at three over. It was not a good day for Australians, Jason Scrivener following his opening-round 68 with a 75 that left him nine off the lead. David Micheluzzi is 10 over after repeating a 76 and Daniel Gale is 16 over following his 75 while Danny List withdrew. British trio Connor Syme, Richie Ramsay and Andy Sullivan have remained in contention as Sweden's Joakim Lagergren led the KLM Open at the end of a disrupted second day. Winds of over 35mph in Amsterdam led to a two-hour stoppage due to "oscillating balls", extending play deep into the evening for a second successive day after Thursday's storms. Lagergren was already safely round in 68 for an eight-under-par halfway total, which proved too much for the chasing pack to match in tough scoring conditions. Syme followed up his opening 65 with a one-over-par 72 to reach five under, good enough for third place behind first-round leader Ricardo Gouveia. Fellow Scot Ramsay was also one over for his round with one hole to play when darkness descended, sharing fourth place with France's Pierre Pineau on four under. England's Sullivan shot 70 to reach three under alongside Francesco Laporta, who also had one hole to complete, and Oliver Lindell. Another Englishman, Dan Brown, had finished day one in a share of third place after matching Ramsay's 66 but fell off the pace on Friday with three double bogeys, including at the second and third holes. His eventual 79 left him only just inside the cut line at three over. It was not a good day for Australians, Jason Scrivener following his opening-round 68 with a 75 that left him nine off the lead. David Micheluzzi is 10 over after repeating a 76 and Daniel Gale is 16 over following his 75 while Danny List withdrew. British trio Connor Syme, Richie Ramsay and Andy Sullivan have remained in contention as Sweden's Joakim Lagergren led the KLM Open at the end of a disrupted second day. Winds of over 35mph in Amsterdam led to a two-hour stoppage due to "oscillating balls", extending play deep into the evening for a second successive day after Thursday's storms. Lagergren was already safely round in 68 for an eight-under-par halfway total, which proved too much for the chasing pack to match in tough scoring conditions. Syme followed up his opening 65 with a one-over-par 72 to reach five under, good enough for third place behind first-round leader Ricardo Gouveia. Fellow Scot Ramsay was also one over for his round with one hole to play when darkness descended, sharing fourth place with France's Pierre Pineau on four under. England's Sullivan shot 70 to reach three under alongside Francesco Laporta, who also had one hole to complete, and Oliver Lindell. Another Englishman, Dan Brown, had finished day one in a share of third place after matching Ramsay's 66 but fell off the pace on Friday with three double bogeys, including at the second and third holes. His eventual 79 left him only just inside the cut line at three over. It was not a good day for Australians, Jason Scrivener following his opening-round 68 with a 75 that left him nine off the lead. David Micheluzzi is 10 over after repeating a 76 and Daniel Gale is 16 over following his 75 while Danny List withdrew.
West Australian
2 days ago
- West Australian
Lagergren blows hot to lead weather-hit KLM Open
British trio Connor Syme, Richie Ramsay and Andy Sullivan have remained in contention as Sweden's Joakim Lagergren led the KLM Open at the end of a disrupted second day. Winds of over 35mph in Amsterdam led to a two-hour stoppage due to "oscillating balls", extending play deep into the evening for a second successive day after Thursday's storms. Lagergren was already safely round in 68 for an eight-under-par halfway total, which proved too much for the chasing pack to match in tough scoring conditions. Syme followed up his opening 65 with a one-over-par 72 to reach five under, good enough for third place behind first-round leader Ricardo Gouveia. Fellow Scot Ramsay was also one over for his round with one hole to play when darkness descended, sharing fourth place with France's Pierre Pineau on four under. England's Sullivan shot 70 to reach three under alongside Francesco Laporta, who also had one hole to complete, and Oliver Lindell. Another Englishman, Dan Brown, had finished day one in a share of third place after matching Ramsay's 66 but fell off the pace on Friday with three double bogeys, including at the second and third holes. His eventual 79 left him only just inside the cut line at three over. It was not a good day for Australians, Jason Scrivener following his opening-round 68 with a 75 that left him nine off the lead. David Micheluzzi is 10 over after repeating a 76 and Daniel Gale is 16 over following his 75 while Danny List withdrew.
