Palestine Action can challenge UK ban, court rules
Court documents, disclosed to the BBC, reveal how officials and ministers deliberated for at least eight months over whether to ban Palestine Action under terrorism legislation.The UK's terrorism laws focus on banning groups that use serious violence to further a cause. But the definition also allows ministers to outlaw organisations that cause serious criminal damage. Palestine Action is the first group to be proscribed under that part of the definition.Since the group's launch in July 2020, Palestine Action Group (PAG) has carried out more than 385 direct actions against firms it links to Israel's military, leading to more than 676 arrests.Since last month's ban, police have made at least 200 more arrests of people suspected of taking part in protests in support of the group.The cross-government debate over a ban began in earnest last November after an assessment of the damage that PAG members had been accused of causing during a break-in at Elbit Systems, an Israeli defence firm, in Bristol the previous August.
Eighteen people have been charged in relation to that incident, which includes allegations of assaults on a security guard and two police officers.The individuals have all denied wrongdoing and trials start later this year.Government papers in the legal challenge, brought by Huda Ammori, Palestine Action's co-founder, reveal police chiefs told the Home Office the network's activity was "unaffected" by ordinary criminal investigations."Operationally, existing legislation is seen as insufficient to address high-level offences, which meet the definition of terrorism," officials wrote in March."There is currently no existing legislation to deal with [PAG] holistically, meaning the network can only be dealt with on a case-by-case basis in response to isolated incidents of direct action."From the perspective of regional police forces, it is argued that this fractured case-by-case approach has proven operationally ineffective, considerably limiting preventative and disruptive opportunities."The police argued banning PAG would help prevent crime - but they also warned that it could look like "state repression" and the use of "draconian counter-terrorism legislation".
That fear was partly echoed by the Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) in the advice it sent to Home Office counterparts.Officials there said a ban would be read by some international partners as a stand against antisemitism, but added: "Acting in this way may be interpreted as an overreaction by the UK."Palestine Action's activity is largely viewed by international partners as activism and not extremism or terrorism."They advised that Palestinians themselves and Arab states could regard banning PAG as an attempt to shut down activism - and a Home Office analysis of potential tensions in the UK also highlighted risks."Proscribing PA would almost certainly be perceived as evidence of bias against the British Muslim community in favour of British Jews and Israel more broadly," wrote officials in one of the documents disclosed in the case."[Proscripton] is likely to generate significant discontent and could introduce new social cohesion challenges."By the end of March, papers show that Home Secretary Yvette Cooper was considering banning the group - but had raised a series of questions.The papers indicate she consulted other ministers during May - and finally decided to ban the group after the 20 June break-in to RAF Brize Norton, which the Ministry of Defence estimates caused £7m of damage to two jets.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
25 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Oasis fans at Wembley gig where man died question alcohol use and security
Oasis fans who witnessed a fatal fall at Wembley stadium during a reunion concert on Saturday have questioned the security setup and the amount of alcohol being consumed in the stands. The Metropolitan police said a man in his 40s died after suffering injuries consistent with a fall at the end of the band's performance at about 10.19pm on Saturday night. On Monday, the Met announced that the Health and Safety Executive, the body which investigates accidents, had been informed. Witnesses who were 10 ft (3 metres) from where the man landed said he fell from the upper tier of Wembley's block 511, on to the aisle between block 211 and block 210. Emma, 40, from Liverpool, said the man landed next to a row behind her and her partner, Mike, only five seats away. 'I've been feeling awful ever since – I can't stop thinking about him,' she said. 'It happened directly behind our right shoulders. If he had fallen where someone was sitting, it would have killed both people.' Within seconds of the fall, several staff began trying to perform CPR on the man. Mike said: 'It's quite traumatic, seeing people just doing CPR on someone frantically. I haven't been able to focus on anything else.' Both Emma and Mike, who declined to give their full names, urged Wembley to review safety and alcohol sales at the stadium. Emma said: 'So much beer was being thrown throughout the whole concert. I was surprised they allowed people to bring drinks into the stands. It made the floor really slippy.' She added: 'They should put the security guard at the bottom of all the aisles too, and permanently station them there to stop people falling off.' Mike, who works in health and safety, said: 'Beer was coming from everywhere. I got hit by an empty cup right on the side of the head. If it had been full it would really have hurt. We started getting beer on us from the moment Oasis came on stage.' John, 52, a delivery driver from Oxford who also declined to give his full name, saw many fans leaning over the balcony from block 511. He said: 'There were loads of people who just kept going down to the front and leaning right over. One guy was stopped but after that no security came down. The security was so lax. There's a rail and a small guard but it did make me think someone could quite easily get knocked off there.' John added: 'It seemed unsafe. If they'd have actually posted a security guard at the bottom of those steps, where people were continually going, it would prevented the fall.' He was also surprised by the level of drinking at the gig. 'The amount of alcohol that was sold on the night was quite shocking. I constantly saw people with cardboard cup holders full of pints,' John said. Last week the Times revealed that Oasis fans were consuming an average of 250,000 pints a night during the Wembley gigs. Wembley Stadium has been approached for comment. In a statement on Sunday it said: 'The police have asked anyone who witnessed the incident to contact them.' Saturday's concert was the fourth of seven sold-out reunion gigs at Wembley Stadium. Despite the tragedy on Saturday, the fifth gig on Sunday went ahead as planned. The sixth and seventh gigs will be in September.
Daily Mail
25 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Pictured: Teenager, 19, stabbed to death in 'targeted attack' in town centre car park - as three men are arrested
A 19-year-old teenager stabbed to death in a 'targeted attack' in a town centre has been named and pictured for the first time. Mohammed Afzal, known to his loved ones as Isa, was fatally attacked in Powerleague car park in the heart of Bury, Greater Manchester, just before 9pm on Friday, August 1. He suffered several stab wounds before sadly later dying from his injuries. Greater Manchester Police have confirmed that Mohammed's family are now being assisted by specialist officers during this 'difficult time'. Following the fatal incident, three teenagers were arrested and detained on suspicion of murder. They currently remain in police custody for questioning. The trio are all male and aged 19, with the latest arrested at Manchester Airport at 4.30am on Sunday. The others were detained in Bury and Bolton on Saturday night. Greater Manchester Police's Major Incident Team is leading the ongoing investigation into the shocking murder. On Sunday, Detective Chief Inspector John Charlton said that he believed the attack was 'targeted' and there was therefore no wider threat posed to the public. He described the incident as both 'violent and tragic', adding that it was 'witnessed by a lot of people'. DCI Charlton added: 'Even though we have three people in custody this is still a live investigation and that will continue today and into next week. 'This was a violent and tragic incident that was witnessed by a lot of people. 'This incident will have shocked the community and distressed anyone who witnessed it, but we believe this was a targeted attack with no wider threat. 'Our officers will be in the area today and over the next few days as we try to establish what happened in the lead-up to this awful incident. Greater Manchester Police have encouraged any individuals with information related to the incident have been asked to contact the force quoting log 3354-01/08/25 'We also have specialist officers supporting the family at this difficult time.' Forensic officers were seen gathering evidence from the Powerleague car park and a second scene on Valley Mill Lane, near the Roch Valley Greenway, over the weekend. Powerleague remained closed throughout the weekend, but reopened on Monday morning. Any individuals with information related to the incident have been urged to contact the force quoting log 3354-01/08/25. Information can also be reported by calling 101 or speaking anonymously to independent charity Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111.
BreakingNews.ie
25 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Stella Rimington, first female director general of MI5, dies aged 90
Stella Rimington, the first female director general of MI5, has died aged 90, her family announced. Dubbed the 'housewife superspy' when she came into the role, she is widely credited as the model for Judi Dench's M in the James Bond films. Advertisement She was born on May 13 1935 in South Norwood and died on Sunday night. In a statement, her family said: 'She died surrounded by her beloved family and dogs and determinedly held on to the life she loved until her last breath.' In a statement on its website, MI5 expressed its condolences to Stella's family, friends and former colleagues. Sir Ken McCallum, current director general, said she 'broke through long-standing barriers' as the service's first female head. Advertisement He said: 'Dame Stella was the first publicly avowed director general of MI5. Her leadership ushered in a new era of openness and transparency about the work MI5 does to keep this country safe, a legacy that continues to this day. 'As the first avowed female head of any intelligence agency in the world, Dame Stella broke through long-standing barriers and was a visible example of the importance of diversity in leadership. 'Our thoughts and deepest sympathies are with her husband, two daughters and extended family.' Stella began a career as a novelist after leaving MI5 (John Stillwell/PA) As part of a policy to 'demystify' MI5's work, she began a programme of releasing files to The National Archives, the service said. Advertisement She joined MI5 full time in 1969, having been recruited as a part-time clerk typist by its office in New Delhi's British High Commission after she accompanied her husband on a diplomatic posting there four years earlier. She became director of each of the service's operational branches before she was appointed to deputy director general in 1991 and then director general a year later. During her tenure in the top job, between 1992 and 1996, there were threats from the IRA and Russia, while the Islamist terror threat was also emerging. When a newspaper published a photo of her house, she and her family had to move to a covert location for their own protection. Advertisement After leaving MI5 in 1996, she was appointed Dame Commander of the Order of the Bath that same year and published her autobiography, Open Secret, in 2001, kickstarting her career as a novelist.
