EFT payments and cybercrime: Court says car buyer is liable to ensure money is paid into the correct account
In a case involving cybercrime, the Supreme Court of Appeal ruled that it is the duty of a buyer to ensure that the money is paid into the seller's correct bank account.
Image: File
Cybercrime was once again the topic of a legal wrangle - this time before the Supreme Court of Appeal, which found that payment via electronic transfer (EFT) is only complete when the funds are received by the correct account holder.
This judgment followed legal proceedings between two car sale companies – with the one who bought two bakkies from the other only to discover after delivery of the vehicles that cybercriminals had intercepted the electronic payment made for the vehicles.
None of the parties were prepared to take the financial loss, and the seller initially turned to the regional court in Louis Trichardt to get its R290,000 back – the price at which it sold the two bakkies.
The lower court earlier ruled that Hyundai Louis Trichardt had to pay Northcliff Nissan the R290, 000 for the vehicles. The magistrate reasoned that the two car dealerships had a contract in place and, cybercrime or not, Northcliff Nissan was due payment for the two bakkies.
Aggrieved with this judgment, Hyundai successfully turned to the Limpopo High Court, sitting in Thohoyandou, to appeal the lower court's verdict. But Northcliff Nissan took the matter on appeal to the SCA. The risk of erroneous payment due to the cybercrime was that of the payer in this instance, the SCA found. 'A debtor bears the risk of misdirected EFT payments and must ensure that the payment is made to the correct bank account,' it said.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad Loading
The court added that the onus of proof in contract disputes over payment lies with the payer (debtor). 'Cybercrime risks do not automatically shift liability to the payee, and the courts will not impose an overarching legal duty on creditors to protect debtors from cyber fraud,' the court said.
The court was told that in October 2018, Hyundai purchased two Nissan bakkies from Northcliff Nissan for the sum of R145,000,00 each. Northcliff Nissan emailed the invoices for both vehicles to the buyer. The invoices provided details of the nominated bank account for payment of the purchase price for the bakkies.
On the same day, Hyundai paid for one bakkie and emailed proof of payment to Northcliff Nissan, after which the bakkie was then delivered. A few days later, Hyundai made another payment and took delivery of the second bakkie. At that stage, no one realised that cybercriminals were at work.
Approximately a week later, Northcliff Nissan told Hyundai that payment of the purchase price for the bakkies had not been reflected in its bank account. It then became clear to the parties that the emails had been intercepted and the bank account details on the invoices were altered by a cyber fraudster.
The parties realised that they were victims of business email compromise (BEC), a cybercrime that has become popular in this technological age of electronic communication and payment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Tips for first-time homebuyers to get a foot on the property ladder
Tips for first-time homebuyers to get a foot on the property ladder The Western Cape remains one of South Africa's most sought-after regions for property investment, attracting strong interest from both local and international homebuyers. However, for first-time homebuyers, especially those looking at Cape Town, homeownership is a challenge as the province records the highest average purchase price. Still, data reveals that activity in the entry-level market persists, suggesting that many homebuyers are finding creative ways to get a foot on the property ladder. According to the latest oobarometer data from ooba Home Loans, the Western Cape's average purchase price in Q1 2025 was R2.33m – well above the national average of R1.66m. Yet, the province continues to draw first-time homebuyers, with the demand for property in the region showing no signs of slowing. 'We're seeing many young professionals and investors gravitating towards the Western Cape for its lifestyle, infrastructure and perceived safety, but affordability in the metro remains a challenge, especially for those trying to enter the market for the first time,' explains Grant Smee, CEO of Only Realty Property Group. Who Is Buying in the Western Cape, and Where? Lightstone data shows that 40% of the Western Cape's housing stock is priced under R750,000, and while appearing to be a more accessible price point, most of these properties can be found in smaller towns and rural areas. 'Investment properties are also in high demand, with the Western Cape recording a year-on-year increase of 0.5% to reach 12.9% in the first quarter [ooba Home Loans]. There is a growing trend of first-time homebuyers purchasing in the Boland and Overberg regions in smaller, outlying towns,' says Smee. 'These areas offer a more balanced lifestyle and slightly more accessible pricing, while still benefiting from the broader Western Cape infrastructure.' He says entry-level homebuyers investing in Cape Town's CBD are also increasingly choosing more affordable micro-apartments and sectional title units in high-density, mixed-use developments: 'These offer security and lifestyle perks like on-site retail, communal workspaces and gyms.' Attracting Foreign Investors Meanwhile, the Western Cape remains a top choice for foreign homebuyers, with its global appeal and in-demand lifestyle at comparatively more affordable prices than elsewhere. However, Smee notes they're investing in a higher price bracket. 'According to Lightstone data, the province leads in luxury price bands, with international homebuyers accounting for over 40% of purchases above R10m, around 25% in the R5m to R10m range and approximately 15% in the R3m to R5m bracket.' He adds: 'Compared to global cities, the Western Cape offers strong value. For instance, the average price of a home in one of the region's upmarket suburbs sells for around R10m. To purchase an apartment in London – with considerably less living space – homebuyers will pay upwards of R12m.' The Australian Property Investor also highlighted South Africa's comparatively low housing prices, with South Africans paying around R17,000 per square metre for a median-priced home, compared to Australia's R113,000 for the equivalent. Alternatives for First-Time Buyers Smee notes that while the Western Cape remains a strong performer in the property market, savvy buyers are increasingly exploring outlying regions that offer better value for money than central Cape Town. Areas such as the West Coast, the Garden Route, and the northern and southern suburbs present attractive alternatives. 'The Western Cape's so-called 'Zoom' towns – so-called for their remote working appeal—include Pringle Bay, Betty's Bay, Kleinmond, Malmesbury, Hermanus, and Gansbaai,' he explains. 'These areas provide easier entry points for buyers and remain within comfortable reach of Cape Town.' However, he adds that excellent opportunities exist beyond the Western Cape as well. 'Mpumalanga, for instance, is currently leading the pack when it comes to home loan applications from first-time buyers [ooba Home Loans]. Nelspruit, in particular, is booming with new estate developments that offer a secure, lock-up-and-go lifestyle, community atmosphere, and budget-friendly pricing.' Gauteng also continues to hold strong appeal. 'Popular nodes like Waterfall, Bryanston, and Hyde Park are drawing interest from buyers seeking well-established infrastructure and upscale living,' he says. Meanwhile, KwaZulu-Natal's North Coast – most notably Umhlanga, Ballito and Salt Rock – has become a magnet for investment. 'Over the past decade, this region has experienced massive growth, with estate developments, excellent schools, security, and community-driven living making it an increasingly worthwhile investment,' he adds. The Eastern Cape is quietly gaining momentum, too. Towns like Kenton-on-Sea and Jeffreys Bay are becoming hotspots for short-term rental investors, thanks to their appealing lifestyle offerings and growing popularity. 'These regions combine access to economic centres with strong lifestyle appeal, without the Cape Town price tag,' Smee explains. 'For buyers willing to expand their horizons beyond the Western Cape, there are standout opportunities, many in secure estates or fast-growing nodes. And with many of these areas doubling as holiday destinations, they open the door to 'reinvestment' opportunities, whether for short-term letting or longer-term leasing.' Practical Tips for Accessing the Market 'For homebuyers determined to get a foothold in the Western Cape property market, there are many options available,' he notes. 'This investment is well worth it too as the average growth of property in the province is around 7.4%.' He shares his top tips for those wanting to get a foot on the property ladder as follows: Enter into a joint home loan: Co-buying with a friend, partner or sibling can boost affordability and borrowing power. Co-buying with a friend, partner or sibling can boost affordability and borrowing power. Save smart and plan long-term: Set clear savings goals and budget realistically for transfer and attorney fees. Set clear savings goals and budget realistically for transfer and attorney fees. Start on the outskirts: Neighbourhoods just outside key metro areas often offer more accessible prices and are poised for growth. Neighbourhoods just outside key metro areas often offer more accessible prices and are poised for growth. Buy a fixer-upper: Properties in need of a bit of work can often be negotiated at lower prices and renovated over time. Properties in need of a bit of work can often be negotiated at lower prices and renovated over time. Buy-to-let as a stepping stone: Purchase an investment property in a growing node while renting where you live. 'The Western Cape is a great place to invest, but it could require a bit more creativity and long-term thinking for first-time homebuyers to make it work. Alternatively, if the Western Cape doesn't meet your criteria, regions like the Eastern Cape, KwaZulu-Natal and Mpumalanga have potential. It's not about compromising your goals, but rather being strategic,' says Smee. Issued by Jess Gois
Daily Maverick
8 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Enterprising pupils from Cape Town school turn R1m in virtual capital into real-world win
Armed with R1m in virtual capital, learners worked in teams to build investment portfolios and respond to a series of fictional market scenarios. Each scenario challenged them to apply critical thinking and adapt to local and global economic developments as depicted. What began as a fun challenge at investor events has evolved into a financial literacy exercise introducing school learners to the world of investing in the form of the Coronation Top Investor Challenge: Schools Edition. Reuben Rietoff and Mbali Nhuku, from Parklands College in Cape Town, competing as the Cashflow Co-Pilots, outperformed hundreds of teams to win R25,000 each in Coronation unit trust vouchers, while their school has been awarded a R50,000 cash prize. A total of 292 teams representing 79 schools registered for the competition, with a minimum of two and a maximum of five learners per team. Of those, 191 teams from 58 schools completed the competition (submitted results for all three rounds). Armed with R1-million in virtual capital, learners worked in teams to build investment portfolios and respond to a series of fictional market scenarios. Each scenario challenged them to apply critical thinking and adapt to local and global economic developments as depicted. 'This was the first time many of these learners encountered the world of investing — and they rose to the challenge with remarkable insight and enthusiasm,' said Kirshni Totaram, a senior executive at Coronation. The competitors receive a beginner-friendly guide to investment fundamentals, to help them develop a working understanding of financial markets and portfolio construction. 'This challenge was a brilliant way for learners to apply their classroom theory in a real-world setting. Opportunities like this show them that what they're learning isn't just for exams. It's equipping them to make good decisions in life,' said Totaram. 'When I was told that Parklands College had won, I was surprised but not surprised. The competition is tough, but I know the calibre of our learners,' said Craig Fortuin, subject leader in Economics at Parklands College. The two enterprising scholars on the college's investing team said the competition felt like a great new opportunity to try something different. 'I think what surprised us most was how well gold performed — it ended up being one of our best investments. If I won money like this in real life, I think I'd actually invest it and see how I can grow it over time. It's made me want to keep learning and improve my skills,' said Nhuku. Rietoff said he has always been interested in commerce, and knowing that Nhuku was also keen on commerce, the pair decided, 'This was a great chance to see how our minds could work together. It was tricky at first, especially deciding which sectors to invest in. But, over time, we learned from each other, and that really helped us in the end.' 'We know that talent is everywhere, but opportunity is not,' said Totaram. 'That's why our programmes start as early as high school and extend all the way to the professional level — helping to build a pipeline of skilled, confident young people ready to thrive in the financial sector.' The initiative is not Coronation's first foray into supporting young people. The Coronation Exceptional Student Bursary Programme, launched in 1993, supports academically strong learners from under-resourced communities through their tertiary studies. Many go on to intern at the firm, gaining real-world exposure to the workplace. Post-graduation, Coronation offers the Catapult Programme, a 23-month structured experience developed in partnership with stockbroking firms. The asset manager also backs the Asisa Academy's Fezeka Investment Management Programme, which supports high-potential black female graduates when they enter the industry. DM
Daily Maverick
8 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Business community reels after kidnapping incident: Nelson Mandela Bay's security crisis deepens
On Saturday morning at 6 am, Gqeberha resident Lindsay Knowlden, 65, was kidnapped from the Fresh Produce Market in Markman Industrial Area. While the kidnapping has sent shockwaves through the Nelson Mandela Bay community, frustrated business owners, whose businesses are under threat from protection rackets, have been calling for improved security in that area for more than two years. For the past two years, members of the Markman Business Forum and business owners have been pleading with the Nelson Mandela Bay municipality for improved security infrastructure, more specifically a 300m fence to improve the safety of those who work in the area, spokesperson Graham Taylor said on Sunday. On Saturday, the business community was shocked after Peter and Lindsay Knowlden were attacked in the underground parking at the Fresh Produce Market. Peter Knowlden was assaulted with a firearm and his wife Lindsay was kidnapped. 'We have been battling now for close on two years, and you almost get the feeling that the municipality is trying its best to avoid us,' Taylor said. Taylor said that a meeting had been held earlier this month with acting city manager Ted Pillay and 'some commitments were made'. 'The boundaries of Markman Industria are incredibly porous,' Taylor said. 'Vulnerable' 'We are vulnerable on three sides of the area. We need a 300m fence. That corner where the Fresh Produce Market is has always been a problem,' he said. He said that to the municipality's credit, it had tried to improve the security at the Fresh Produce market and had built a wall around the facility. 'But personally, I have never seen security guards there. The problem is that it remains completely accessible from the back,' Taylor said. He said the area was monitored by private security, but it urgently needed a fence. 'That way we can introduce proper access control.' He said that currently, anybody could enter the area. 'That Addo corridor is a major challenge,' he said, referring to the road that runs from the N2 through Motherwell to Addo. 'We have been having meetings with logistics service providers and industry stakeholders just to address crime,' Taylor said. 'Businesses have the solution, but people need to start listening.' He said that as a result of the deteriorating security situation in the area, the cost of business had shot up. Some businesses now had to pay R300,000 a month for security. 'Protection racket' Taylor said a protection racket was being run in the area, and any vehicle leaving without security would be followed and hijacked, especially those transporting food. 'Demanding protection money has become a trend,' he said. 'People know exactly what is in those vehicles.' Wayne Hart from Atlas Security said they had been called in on Saturday after Lindsay Knowlden was kidnapped, as the couple were clients. 'As you, we are deeply concerned about the kidnapping of Lindsay Knowlden, which took place in the early hours of Saturday morning. Atlas Security was first on the scene, and our team responded immediately after being alerted. 'Our control room and teams have been working closely with the local authorities, using our extensive network of CCTV cameras across Nelson Mandela Bay to assist in the investigation. We can confirm that the vehicle involved was flagged, but in the interest of the ongoing investigation, further details cannot be shared at this time. 'We are aware that the Hawks have received a ransom demand for Lindsay's safe return. The case is now in the hands of the Hawks and SAPS, and Atlas Security will continue to cooperate fully with all roleplayers as the investigation unfolds. 'Our thoughts are with Lindsay's family and loved ones during this incredibly difficult time. We urge anyone with information to contact SAPS,' Atlas said. SAPS spokesperson Captain Andre Beetge confirmed the incident, and that the case had been transferred to the Hawks. The Fresh Produce Market is a Nelson Mandela Bay municipal facility, but by last night, municipal spokesperson Sithembiso Soyaya had not responded to questions about security measures there. Earlier this month, Sanral construction manager Victor Ngcobo was kidnapped from Addo Road, 3km from the latest abduction. He was released unharmed.
