‘Crazy': NSW Premier Chris Minns blames tobacco excise for thriving illegal trade
Chris Minns has again slammed the annual tax increase on cigarettes and blamed it for the rise in black market tobacco across the state.
The NSW Premier spoke to KIIS radio's Kyle and Jackie O days after he called on the federal government to consider lowering the tobacco excise.
He also suggested repurposing police resources from major organised crime networks and domestic violence cases to instead address illegal tobacco sales.
'It's probably not a popular thing for a premier to say because there's been a tax on cigarettes and excise on cigarettes for decades, and I understand that, but they've been radically increased since 2019,' he said on Wednesday.
'So a pack in 2019, 2020, cigarettes had a $16 tax on it. Today it's $28 – a 75 per cent increase.
'This is a crazy thing, that the government used to collect $16bn in revenue and now it's come all the way down to about nine billion.
'It's the only tax in the world, Kyle and Jackie, that they've doubled, and the revenue has declined and all of that money has gone into the black market.'
The tax was first introduced in 2010 as an annual 25 per cent increase to reduce smoking rates, and then in 2023 the federal government announced the excise would grow by 5 per cent annually for three years.
Mr Minns said most of the illegal tobacco came from overseas, with the explosion of black market cigarettes sending huge amounts of money into the hands of organised crime gangs.
The Australian Border Force estimates they control about three-quarters of the trade.
'There's many things I hate about it, but there's two things in particular,' Mr Minns sad.
'Firstly, there's a whole bunch of law-abiding people who go about their lives. They wouldn't break the law in a million years, but they're being dragged into a black market where they go to the store, they can either buy a 17 or $20 packet of illegal cigarettes or a $60 packet of cigarettes.
'It's just a no-brainer for them.'
Mr Minns said Health Minister Ryan Park was likely to raise the issue at an upcoming health ministers meeting.
'Every tax and every tax change starts with an idea,' Mr Minns said.
'Every single one of them, someone's saying, 'Look, I don't think this is working, we need to change and so we might as well get the ball rolling here'.
'We have to make a decision because what's happening with these elite illegal tobacco stores is they're pushing out hot bread shops, small businesses, retail stores, they're pushing out restaurants because it's so lucrative they can just take the rent at a higher price.'
When asked whether purchasing the illegal tobacco was a crime, Mr Minns said the offence was prior to the sale.
'There's an enormous amount of money now circulating in that black economy that's going to create a whole bunch of other problems,' he said.
'I don't want people to smoke by the way … but we have to be honest about it, realistic about what's going to happen.'
Illicit tobacco sales are investigated by NSW Health, with more than 20 compliance officers tasked with managing the tens of thousands of tobacco stores statewide.
Cigarette prices in Australia are considered to be one of the highest in the world, according to the World Health Organisation.
Taxes account for about three-quarters of the price.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
21 minutes ago
- ABC News
Magistrate in Hillcrest jumping castle case to hand down decision
A chapter of the Hillcrest Primary School tragedy may end today, with Magistrate Robert Webster set to hand down his decision in the criminal case, but the story is far from over. It is more than six months since the Devonport Magistrates Court heard evidence in the case against Rosemary Anne Gamble, who is charged with failing in her work health and safety duty over the tragedy on December 16, 2021. Students Zane Mellor, Peter Dodt, Jalailah Jayne-Maree Jones, Addison Stewart, Jye Sheehan, and Chace Harrison died, and three of their classmates were seriously injured when a freak wind tossed a jumping castle across their primary school oval in Devonport in north-west Tasmania. Ms Gamble pleaded not guilty to the charge ahead of a two-week hearing in November. In February, the court heard closing statements from the prosecution and defence lawyers. Some of the victims' family members sat through each day of the hearing, clutching pillows bearing their children's faces and wearing T-shirts printed with their photos. The courtroom was often a scene of tension and heightened emotions as parents' grief, anger and frustration came to the fore. The distressing details and timeline of the tragedy were examined in detail throughout the two-week hearing. The court heard Ms Gamble owned Taz-Zorb, a business that dealt in inflatable amusement devices, and was contracted by the Hillcrest Primary School for its end-of-school-year celebrations on the day of the tragedy. That morning, she and her partner Robert Monte set up their operation on the school's oval, and students began queuing for their turn on the couple's crayon-themed jumping castle. At about 10am, a fierce wind, described by some witnesses as a "mini tornado" and by a weather expert as a "dust devil", swept through the school grounds with devastating effect. It was an otherwise calm and sunny day, and the court heard the couple had used 30cm pegs at four of the castle's eight anchor points to tether it to the ground. The pegs almost immediately failed when the dust devil struck, lifting the castle high into the air. Seven children were inside the castle when it was thrown across the oval, and five of them did not survive their resulting injuries. Another child was waiting in line and died after being struck in the head by the airborne jumping castle blower. The charge alleged Ms Gamble failed to comply with her duty "in a way that exposed the children to a risk of death or serious injury". Crown prosecutor Madeleine Wilson said Ms Gamble failed in several ways to comply with her duty, including by properly failing to anchor the castle to the ground. The Crown also said Ms Gamble had failed to properly train herself or her staff in the proper, safe inflation and operation of the jumping castle. Mr Monte told the court they watched YouTube and taught themselves how to operate the jumping castle after buying it in 2015. "You're f***ing joking," a father said as he stormed out of court during Mr Monte's evidence. Mechanical engineer Roderick McDonald told the court that if star pickets, which were available on the day, had been used at all eight anchor points, the castle would have stayed on the ground. But defence lawyer Chris Dockray SC said it was the defence case that nothing Ms Gamble could have done would have prevented the tragedy on that day, as the dust devil was a freakish and unpredictable weather event. That position was backed in by defence expert witness Professor David Eager from the University of Technology Sydney. "If you hadn't held the event, it wouldn't have happened," he said. During submissions in February, Mr Dockray also targeted Chinese company East Inflatables, the manufacturer of the jumping castle. He said it was East Inflatables' business model to "prey upon people like Ms Gamble" to sell jumping castles. Even if Magistrate Robert Webster does find Ms Gamble guilty, he cannot sentence her to a prison term. The maximum penalty for a category two offence under the Work Health and Safety Act is a $1.5 million fine for a corporation, and a $300,000 fine for an individual conducting a business. If Ms Gamble is found not guilty, she will simply be free to go. But whatever the result, the victims' families will likely soon return to back in court as a coronial inquest is slated to begin once the criminal proceedings conclude. The families also launched a civil class action against the state of Tasmania and Ms Gamble in December last year on the third anniversary of the tragedy. The class action was filed in the Supreme Court of Tasmania by the law firm Maurice Blackburn and alleges the state, as the school's operator, and Taz-Zorb had a duty of care and failed to take reasonable precautions to ensure the children's safety. At the time, principal lawyer Dimi Loannou said the families' grief was a daily experience. "Nothing will erase the suffering or bring back their lost children," she said.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Anthony Albanese faces a novel challenge in Sussan Ley
Anthony Albanese loves a trophy, especially a human one. He prides himself on his various "captain's pick" candidates — good campaigners he has steered into seats. Way back in the Gillard days, he was key in persuading discontented Liberal Peter Slipper to defect. Slipper became an independent and Labor's speaker. The exercise helped the government's numbers, but the bold play didn't end well for Labor or for Slipper. The government was tarnished, and Slipper, relentlessly pursued by the Coalition and mired in controversy, eventually had to quit the speakership. The affair did produce Julia Gillard's famous misogyny speech, however. Now Albanese has another gee-whiz prize — Western Australian Senator Dorinda Cox, who has defected from the Greens. Cox, after being defeated in a bid for Greens deputy leader, approached Labor and the PM drove her course to being accepted into the party. The manoeuvre makes a marginal but insignificant difference to Senate numbers — Labor will still need the Greens to pass legislation opposed by the Coalition. Taking in Cox is a risk, and some in Labor are looking at it askance. The prime minister's embrace of Cox contradicts Labor's argument when its Western Australian senator Fatima Payman defected to become an independent. It said then hers was a Labor seat and she should therefore resign. But this wouldn't be the first time expediency trumped consistency in politics. Cox, who is Indigenous and was spokesperson for First Nations and resources in the last parliament, has been a fierce critic of the extending the North West Shelf gas project, which the government has just announced. Albanese says he is confident she "understands that being a member of the Labor Party means that she will support positions that are made by the Labor Party". She has also faced allegations of treating staff badly. Labor discounts the claims against her, saying they are overblown and a product of Greens factionalism and toxicity. Certainly, she was given a tough time by the hard-left faction represented by deputy leader Mehreen Faruqi. Labor would be wise to ensure Cox feels supported in her new party home. Albanese perhaps calculates that the worst that can happen is there's a blow up and she defects to the crossbench. Labor could shrug and say, she was never really one of us. Snatching a senator from the Greens is particularly satisfying to Albanese because he hates the party so much. Last term, lower house Greens MP Max Chandler-Mather (defeated at the election) really got under his skin. More generally, the Greens held up important legislation, most notably on housing. In the new Senate, Labor will need only the Greens to pass legislation opposed by the Coalition. How new Greens leader Larissa Waters — who replaced Adam Bandt after he lost his seat — handles the party's relationship with the government will be crucial for the more contentious parts of Labor's legislative program. The usually low-key Waters will be under a lot of pressure. The Greens had a bad election, losing three lower house seats. Now they have lost a senator at the start of Waters's watch. Waters conceded on the Serious Danger podcast in late May that Labor had successfully run the narrative of the Greens as blockers. "So, I do think we're going to need to be quite deft in how we handle balance of power in this term, […] People want us to be constructive. They don't just want us to roll over and tick off on any old shit. They want meaningful reforms." Waters will want to pick her fights carefully and also find ways of pursuing the Greens' agenda where the party co-operates. The first deal is likely to be on the government's legislation to increase the tax on those with large superannuation balances, which contains the controversial provision to tax unrealised capital gains. Opposition Leader Sussan Ley and her team will confront some of the same problems as the Greens — when to oppose and when to seek to negotiate with the government. For his part, Albanese will have a novel challenge with Ley — what stance to adopt against the first female opposition leader, especially but not only in parliamentary clashes. After facing two alpha-male Liberal leaders, Scott Morrison and Peter Dutton, a new approach will obviously be necessary. As one Labor man succinctly puts it, "Labor can't monster a woman". There can be no repeat of Albanese, a frontbencher a decade ago in the Shorten opposition, interjecting to urge a female colleague engaged in a stoush with Ley to "smash her". For Ley, trying to deal with the Liberals' multiple difficulties in attracting women voters and candidates must be high on her agenda. Former Liberal federal president Alan Stockdale, one of the three-person group currently running the NSW division of the party, showed himself part of the problem when this week he told the NSW Liberal Women's Council, "The women in this party are so assertive now that we may need some special rules for men to get them pre-selected." Stockdale said later he was being "light-hearted". Tone deaf might be a better term. Ley jumped on him. "There is nothing wrong with being an assertive woman. In fact, I encourage assertive women to join the Liberal Party." The jury is out on whether Ley will be able to make any sort of fist of her near-impossible job. But in the short time she's been leader, she has shown she is willing to be assertive. She emerged from the brief split in the Coalition looking much steadier than Nationals leader David Littleproud, even though she had to persuade her party room to accept the minor party's policy demands. In her frontbench reshuffle, she was willing to wear the inevitable criticism that came with dropping a couple of senior women who had under-performed. As deputy leader, Ley adjusted her style a while before the election, toning down the aggression and sometimes wild attacks, that had characterised her performance earlier in the term. A Liberal source said she found her "line and length". As leader, she will have others, notably deputy Ted O'Brien, to do the head-kicking, giving her room to attempt to develop a positive political persona. Labor leaned into attacking Dutton — never afraid to name him. With Ley, Albanese might adopt the Bob Carr approach of avoiding using his opponent's name. At least until he finds his line and length in dealing with her. Michelle Grattan is a professorial fellow at the University of Canberra and chief political correspondent at The Conversation, where this article first appeared.
ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Landmark trial to enable energy trading between solar homes and those without
Maree Tynan knew that her cottage in Mittagong, in the New South Wales Southern Tablelands 110 kilometres south of Sydney, was the place for her more or less the first time she saw it. It was more than four decades ago and, in time, her and her late partner turned what was a getaway into their permanent home. During that time, Ms Tynan has seen her fair share of changes in Mittagong and in so many other ways besides. Among them has been the extraordinary rise of rooftop solar in Australia, where one in three homes now has the technology. It's long been something she's wanted, too. "We were very keen to be part of it, but we had two major problems," recalls Ms Tynan, whose home was built in the late 1920s. "The first is it's the original roof. That is terracotta. "As you can imagine, after 100 years in a very cold climate, it is very, very fragile. "Apart from the roof, we also have a lot of trees." Faced with those challenges, Ms Tynan feared she may have been locked out of the solar market for good. That was until she came across a project aiming to connect people who don't have solar panels with those who do. "To have had rooftop solar put on, we were going to have to have the whole roof replaced," she explains. "That just seemed crazy because, yes, we'd have solar, but we'd be spending an awful lot of money. "We decided that, while ever the roof was secure and not letting rain in, we'd stick with that and we'd look for alternatives. At its heart, the project aims to enable energy trading between solar households and those without the technology. Known as WinZero, the project is centred around the Wingecarribee Shire Council. Households taking part in the so-called virtual energy network are given a smart meter and hooked up to a scheme allowing them to buy from or sell to other participants in their local area. In order to participate, they must go through small, privately-owned electricity retailer Energy Locals, which uses third party software to handle the trades. Those without panels can buy surplus solar power for a rate lower than a standard tariff over the grid. Similarly, solar householders facing ever lower — or even non-existent — feed-in tariffs can yield higher payments for their exports. Now a new study based on the Wingecarribee model is being led by Deakin University, which is hoping to widen its scope to the entire national electricity market, which spans Australia's eastern seaboard. Of particular interest to researchers are consumers who don't or can't have solar panels themselves. Andrea La Nauze, an associate professor of economics at Deakin, says Australia might lead the world in the take-up of rooftop solar, but most people are still missing out. "We have the highest rate of rooftop solar in the world," Dr La Nauze says. "But there are many of us who are renters or live in apartments or for various reasons can't install solar panels. "First of all, it's expanding access to rooftop solar, which is good for the environment. "It's also hopefully good for the back pocket." As of last year, there were more than 4 million "small-scale" solar installations across the country. Under the definition in Australia, a small-scale installation can be anything up to 100 kilowatts, meaning many businesses with solar are also grouped with the category. However, most installations are on standalone homes and the vast majority of these are owned by their occupants, according to Dr La Nauze. She says virtual energy networks could be a way of bridging what is an inherent divide. By allowing customers with excess generation to sell it to those without panels, she says, both sides of the transaction might just end up winning. "Using the existing poles and wires, people who have excess energy from their rooftop solar can sell it to their neighbour or a local cafe," she says. "They can get more, hopefully, for that energy that they sell than they otherwise would. "And the cafe or the neighbour can buy energy at a lower price than their current retail contract." More broadly, Dr La Nauze says solar trading schemes could help answer a number of thorny questions hanging over Australia's energy transition. While equity in access to clean tech is one of them, she says the over-abundance of solar generation in the middle of the day is another. "We might also relieve some of the congestion that we have on the distribution network," she says. "The poles and wires in many parts of Australia are struggling because we have so much energy coming from rooftop solar in the middle of the day. "If we can encourage households and small businesses to soak up more of that power during the middle of the day, that's beneficial for the network. Michael Dello-Iacovo from Energy Consumers Australia, which is helping to fund the new trial, says the lobby group is keen to see how feasible an expanded network is. Mr Dello-Iacovo acknowledges the idea of trading might be an intimidating idea to some householders but notes the trial would be seeking to overcome this. "It ultimately comes down to the platform itself," Mr Dello-Iacovo says. "And so the platforms that I've seen for virtual energy networks … you can be as engaged as you like and there is an option to be very disengaged. "You can set up very simple trades to either sell electricity from your solar and battery or to buy electricity from someone else with solar or battery. "You can set up more specific trades and trade with an individual you know at a set price, for example. Although such networks are in their infancy, Mr Dello-Iacovo says the notional potential of "peer-to-peer" trading is enormous. He notes there are still millions of people in Australia who do not have access to solar power, making them a huge source of potential demand. "At Energy Consumers Australia, we advocate for all energy consumers," Mr Dello-Iacovo says. "And part of that means making sure everyone who wants to have access to consumer energy resources like solar and battery can have access to it. "So this trial is really exciting for us because there's a lot of potential for bringing those benefits from the energy transition to all households, not just those who are physically able to install solar and batteries." For Mittagong householder Maree Tynan, the scheme seems to be working. She acknowledges her electricity bills are generally modest anyway because she tries to limit how much power she uses. Even still, Ms Tynan says her costs are lower now. To that extent, she reckons buying other people's surplus solar power while cutting her bills is the next best thing to have some panels herself. Asked if she would be happy to keep doing it, she says: "Oh yes, I definitely will keep going while it's available." "I'd dearly love to have solar myself," Ms Tynan says. "But I can't see it happening anytime in the near future for the reasons I've explained." She says that for people in similar circumstances to her, the scheme should hold great appeal, especially if it can help save them money. "I'm very cognisant of what's happening in the world," she says. Along with Deakin University and Energy Consumers Australia, the new trial will be delivered in partnership with QuantumNRG, ReThink Sustainability and WinZero. Anyone interested in taking part in the trial can find out more information at
