Can green card, visa holders fly in the US under new Real ID rules? Here's what to know
As of May 7, all U.S. citizens over 18 must show proof of identification that meets the 2005 Real ID Act's rules. But this change in federal travel requirements is creating some confusion about what it means for noncitizens.
Passed two decades ago by Congress in response to the bipartisan 9/11 Commission's recommendations after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks in New York, Pennsylvania and Washington, D.C., the aim of the program was to raise security standards for domestic travel and federal and nuclear facility access.
But immigration experts say the law's enactment during the second Trump administration has left noncitizens — including some of the 13.5 million people legally in the U.S. on green cards, work and student visas and humanitarian parole — uncertain about what the rule change could mean for their own travel.
President Donald Trump has promised and prioritized mass deportations of criminals and people illegally in the U.S. But in practice, his policies have swept up U.S. citizens and people with a legal immigration status. He has also tried to end legal pathways that allowed people to temporarily live and work in the U.S. Many of these actions are being challenged in court.
Here are some answers to commonly asked questions about Real ID and its effect on citizen versus noncitizen travel.
The Department of Homeland Security says the aim of the Real ID requirements was to bring consistency to the minimum documentation requirements needed for state-issued IDs — driver's license, learner's permits and nondriver IDs.Now, all states issuing Real ID-compliant cards require people applying for those cards to present certain documentation. The exact requirements vary by state, but in most cases the minimum documents needed include:
Proof of identity in the form of a U.S. birth certificate, U.S. passport, or a green card.
Social Security Number in the form of a Social Security card, W-2 form, or a pay stub.
Two proofs of address of principal residence, which may be a utility bill, bank statement or mortgage statement.
Lawful status proof, including a valid employment authorization document, Social Security Number or a valid unexpired visa.
A Real ID card bears a black or gold star or a U.S. flag in its upper right corner. State-issued ID cards that don't have these markers will not be accepted as proof of identity to board domestic flights or enter federal facilities.
No, you can still travel domestically provided you have another form of identification that is Real ID-compliant.
The Transportation Security Administration lists many other forms of acceptable IDs, including options for people who are not U.S. citizens.
Among them:
State-issued enhanced driver's licenses or enhanced IDs, which provide proof of identity when crossing the U.S. borders in a vehicle.
U.S. passports or U.S. passport cards.
Foreign government-issued passports.
Department of Homeland Security trusted traveler cards under programs such as Global Entry, which let U.S. citizens, green card holders and some foreign nationals to go through expedited lanes at airports.
U.S. Department of Defense IDs, including IDs issued to dependents of people in the military.
Lawful permanent resident cards, also known as green cards.
Border crossing cards, a document used by Mexican citizens to enter the U.S.
Acceptable photo IDs issued by federally recognized tribal nations, including enhanced tribal cards.
HSPD-12 PIV cards, which are used by federal contractors to access facilities and systems.
Canadian provincial driver's license or Indian and Northern Affairs Canada cards.
Transportation Worker Identification Credentials (TWIC).
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Employment Authorization Cards.
U.S. Merchant Mariner Credentials, which show evidence of a mariner's qualifications; and
Veteran Health Identification Cards (VHIC).
There's one big caveat: TSA says the list of acceptable IDs is subject to change without notice and advises travelers to check the list before traveling.
Although numerous forms of ID are accepted for noncitizens, the Real ID policy could have a chilling effect on travelers whose documentation differentiates them from citizens, immigration experts told PolitiFact.
As one example, immigration attorney Prerna Lal said that, in any interaction with federal authorities, carrying a foreign passport could lead to scrutiny of that person's identity if they lack legal immigration status.
"Even with valid foreign passports, undocumented individuals and mixed-status families may avoid traveling due to concerns about interactions with TSA or law enforcement, despite passports remaining acceptable documentation," Lal said. "This fear of enforcement, rather than access to IDs, is the primary chilling effect on the immigrant community."
A TSA officer may ask a person to complete an identity verification process. If the identity is confirmed, that person will be allowed to enter the screening checkpoint.
Yes, the Real ID regulations define an individual in a "temporary lawful status" as a person who has a pending application for asylum; has a pending or approved application for temporary protected status; has approved deferred action; or has a pending application for lawful permanent resident or conditional permanent resident status.
The Real ID Act lets states issue temporary, Real ID driver licenses and ID cards to people with temporary status. People with a temporary immigration status are usually granted temporary valid employment authorization and Social Security numbers, which they can use to apply for Real IDs. Their temporary Real ID will remain valid until their lawful status expires. Florida is one exception: The Sunshine State requires almost all immigrants with lawful status to renew their IDs annually. Green card holders in Florida don't have to renew a REAL ID every year; their Real ID is valid until their green card expires. Most green cards are valid for 10 years, but people can apply for a renewal.
Also, people with valid student or work visas can present their unexpired passports, visas and I-94 form, a document that shows a person's authorized period of stay in the U.S., for proof of identity and legal status and get a Real ID.
States that provide non-Real ID compliant ID cards to people without legal immigration status can still do so, according to DHS, but the cards must clearly state that they are not acceptable for Real ID purposes and must have a unique design or color to differentiate them from compliant cards. These non-Real ID compliant ID cards cannot be used as a form of identification for domestic travel.
Lal told PolitiFact that a Real ID alone does not prevent an arrest by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement or confirm a lawful immigration status. Although Real ID-compliant identification requires proof of lawful presence for issuance, it is not proof of current immigration status.
"ICE conducts its own verification, and possessing a Real ID does not grant immunity from enforcement actions," Lal said.
Lal said that people should present to ICE valid, government-issued documentation that shows their current immigration status, such as a green card, employment authorization card or visa.
Phone interview with Ediberto Roman, professor of law & director of Immigration and Citizenship Initiatives at the Florida International University, May 8, 2025
Email interview with Jasleen Singh, counsel in the Brennan Center's voting rights program, May 8, 2025
Email interview with Immigration attorney Prerna Lal, May 8, 2025
USA.gov, How to get a Real ID and use it for travel, updated April 14, 2025
USA.gov, State motor vehicle services, accessed May 8, 2025
DHS, Real ID Frequently Asked Questions, accessed May 8, 2025
TSA, Acceptable Identification at the TSA Checkpoint, accessed May 8, 2025
FindLaw, What Is a Real ID, and Do I Need It to vote?, Feb. 14, 2024
VoteRiders, What is Real ID?, accessed May 8, 2025
NCSL, Voter ID Laws, updated April 16, 2025
News4Jax, Florida enacts stricter driver's license rules for legal immigrants, May 5, 2025
Federal Registry, Indian Entities Recognized by and Eligible To Receive Services From the United States Bureau of Indian Affairs, accessed May 8, 2025
Travel.State.Gov, Get a Passport Card, accessed May 8, 2025
Travel.State.Gov, U.S. Passports and Real ID, accessed May 8, 2025
TSA, Real ID, accessed May 8, 2025
USA.Gov, Who can and cannot vote, accessed May 8, 2025
USCIS, How do I renew or replace my permanent resident card?, accessed May 12, 2025
GSA, Federal credentialing services, accessed May 12, 2025
Maritime Institute, GET MERCHANT MARINER CREDENTIAL (MMC), accessed May 12, 2025
DHS, Enhanced Drivers Licenses: What Are They?, accessed May 12, 2025
Pew Research Center, What the data says about immigrants in the U.S., Sept. 27, 2024
PolitiFact, Can Donald Trump use a 1798 law to carry out mass deportations?, Oct. 18, 2024
PolitiFact, Ask PolitiFact: What evidence does the government need to deport green card, visa holders?, March 26, 2025
The Washington Post, Here are the U.S. citizens caught in Trump's immigration crackdown, updated May 3, 2025
PolitiFact, How spin and falsehoods propelled Trump's immigration crackdown in his first 100 days, April 28, 2025
This article originally appeared on Austin American-Statesman: Can green card, visa holders fly in the US under new Real ID rules?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a minute ago
- Yahoo
Trump Is Hiring ICE Agents to Arrest Immigrants Coast to Coast, Border to Border
Donald Trump is looking to hire 10,000 officers to help carry out his administration's widespread detention and deportation of migrants with tens of billions of dollars in funds from his 'Big Beautiful Bill.' Job postings show that in 25 cities from coast to coast, Immigration and Customs Enforcement is hiring deportation officers who will arrest, detain, and deport migrants, and manage migrants' cases. The listings give insight into where ICE may be ramping up operations. ICE has already been carrying out broad arrests, including at workplaces and courthouses. Agents have been wearing masks and lacking identifying information as they snatch immigrants, sometimes breaking their car windows to drag them out faster. 'Are you ready to defend the homeland?' the job posting reads. 'Launch a dynamic and rewarding career as a Deportation Officer with Enforcement Removal Operations (ERO) at ICE! Join a dedicated team safeguarding U.S. borders and upholding immigration laws, playing a key role in defending our nation.' At a time when the U.S. job market is slowing down and prices remain high, ICE is offering $50,000 signing bonuses and $60,000 in student loan repayment with a salary of about $50,000 to $90,000. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has already issued 1,000 tentative job offers, the Associated Press reported Friday. A spokesperson for DHS said many of the people offered jobs were 'ICE officers who retired under President Biden because they were frustrated that they were not allowed to do their jobs.' These retired officers are being offered $88,000 to $144,000 along with a $50,000 bonus. An image of Uncle Sam, the ultimate recruitment propaganda, appears on the DHS website with the words 'RETURN TO MISSION.' 'Your country is calling you to serve at ICE. In the wake of the Biden administration's failed immigration policies, your country needs dedicated men and women of ICE to get the worst of the worst criminals out of our country,' Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem said earlier this week. 'This is a defining moment in our nation's history. Your skills, your experience, and your courage have never been more essential. Together, we must defend the homeland.' ICE is hiring in Los Angeles, where Trump deployed the National Guard and Marines to lead a militarized crackdown on protests against his immigration raids. Major cities where ICE is hiring include Atlanta, Boston, Chicago, Denver, New York City, Philadelphia, San Francisco, Seattle, and Washington, D.C. The agency is hiring in several large cities with large Latino populations including Dallas, Houston, Miami Beach, Phoenix, San Antonio, and San Diego. ICE is also hiring in Baltimore, New Orleans, Newark, Saint Paul, and Salt Lake City. The agency is hiring in El Paso, a city on the Texas.-Mexico border where detentions are reportedly increasing. They are also looking to hire in Detroit and Buffalo, which are on the U.S.-Canada border. ICE is looking to hire in Harlingen, a Texas border city. The deportation flights taking migrants to an El Salvador torture prison and war-torn South Sudan, both in defiance of judicial orders in cases that went to the Supreme Court, took off from Harlingen. DHS is hiring new criminal investigators, or special agents, at salaries of $63,000 to $102,000 with a bonus $50,000. Returning criminal investigators are being offered $105,000 to $171,000 per year, plus the $50,000 bonus. The department is hiring attorneys all over, at field locations in 90 cities. The jobs are being funded with tens of billions of dollars included in Trump's 'Big Beautiful Bill,' the president's first major agenda legislation. The bill also slashes taxes for the wealthy and will force millions of Americans off Medicaid, the government health insurance program for low-income and disabled people. 'The funding from President Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill will play a key role in fulfilling his promise to the American people to deport criminal illegal aliens,' White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson said in a statement, Politico reported. 'Getting 10,000 [new employees] means basically hiring the people who walk in the door because you're trying to hit your quota,' Josiah Heyman, an anthropology professor who directs the University of Texas at El Paso's Center of Inter-American and Border Studies, told The Los Angeles Times. 'Rapid, mass-hiring lends itself to mistakes and cutting corners.' The Trump administration is also looking at increasing their use of the military in domestic immigration enforcement, The New Republic reported Saturday. A memo from Philip Hegseth, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's younger brother, calls on military leadership to 'feel — for the first time — the urgency of the homeland defense mission' and work together with ICE and Customs and Border Patrol agents. 'The memo is alarming, because it speaks to the intent to use the military within the United States at a level not seen since Japanese internment,' Carrie Lee, senior fellow at the German Marshall Fund, told The New Republic. 'The military is the most powerful, coercive tool our country has. We don't want the military doing law enforcement. It absolutely undermines the rule of law.' More from Rolling Stone Trump's Admin Is Investigating Jack Smith, Who Prosecuted Him Over Jan. 6 'Grow Up': Conservative Senators, Economists Slam Trump for Firing Labor Stats Chief You May Be Asking Yourself How Did Dan Bongino Get Here Best of Rolling Stone The Useful Idiots New Guide to the Most Stoned Moments of the 2020 Presidential Campaign Anatomy of a Fake News Scandal The Radical Crusade of Mike Pence
Yahoo
a minute ago
- Yahoo
‘No sign' Trump tariffs on Scotch whisky will increase, says Ian Murray
The Scottish Secretary of State has said 'there is no sign at the moment' tariffs imposed on Scotch whisky will increase to 25% as he expressed his 'disappointment' in the current US deal arrangement for the sector. Ian Murray also told BBC Radio Scotland's Sunday Show that Donald Trump's admiration of Scotland should be 'exploited' for the sake of the 'national interest'. The US President has so far agreed a 10% tariffs on UK exports and 15% on EU ones. Across the Scotch whisky sector, there are concerns that this deal - which is believed to be costing the industry £4m a week - will lead to significant harm for businesses. READ MORE: Scotch whisky hopes rise after Trump pledges to talk tariffs Trump talks of 'great love' for Scotland during visit 'Scotland must switch whisky exports from America to Canada' The Secretary of State is currently leading a UK Government delegation to Germany this week to 'increase economic ties' with the EU. Mr Murray said it was important to point out that trade deals with the likes of EU and India, the largest growing economy in the world, will provide a 'great opportunity' for Scotch whisky. Yet, earlier on the programme, Scotland's public finance minister Ivan McKee warned that 25% tariffs could be imposed next year as a deal previously reached with America on temporary duty reliefs could be lifted. Between October 2019 and March 2021, the tariff imposed as a result of the Boeing dispute resulted in £600 million in lost Scotch whisky exports. A deal was eventually reached in 2021 to take the 25% tariff off the industry. However, Mr McKee said: 'That was done on a temporary basis and that runs out next year so it's really important that it is taken out of the picture permanently because when that was in place, that was a significant hamper to Scotch whisky exports. 'As the UK Government concludes the deal with the US Government, we would expect it to be 10% tariffs on whisky which is clearly something we wish wasn't there.' Mr McKee said he would hope this was not re-imposed but added: 'There's nothing but unpredictability when it comes to Donald Trump and tariffs so who knows what's happening.' However, Mr Murray insisted it is unlikely this would happen. Asked how likely it would be for 25% tariffs to be re-imposed on Scotch whisky, Mr Murray said: 'There is no sign of that at the moment.' He added: 'It's 10% tariffs on Scottish whisky. Yes, we would rather that was as close to zero as possible but ten percent is as low as anybody else in the world right now." Mr Murray said the Prime Minister Keir Starmer has been able to 'reset international relationships' to do a deal with the US on tariffs. He said: 'Many, including the First Minister, wanted us to walk away from the US president but it was really important in the national interest and in the Scottish national interest for us to have that relationship to do that deal. '10% is the lowest tariff in the world. We did the first trade deal it saved the steel industry, the car industry. 'Yes, 10% tariffs on Scotch whisky is disappointing and we will continue to champion the cause for the really unique position of whisky. "We don't want it to be subject to historic trade wars as it has been in the past. It is a really thriving industry.' Speaking about the US president's visit to Scotland, Mr Murray said it was a 'great privilege' to when he landed in the country last week. He said he was in 'no doubt' of Mr Trump's 'great love of Scotland', adding: 'That is something we should exploit in the national interest.' During his visit to Scotland, President Trump promised to 'take a look' at tariffs on Scotch whisky during his meeting with Starmer as he said he wanted Scotland "to thrive". Since then, however, no changes have been made to the current arrangement. Speaking on the radio today, the Secretary of State also said Mr Trump suggested he should join him at the press conference beside Air Force One when he arrived in the country, however, the Secretary of State declined. Mr Murray said: 'He did tap me on the shoulder and said, 'let's go and do this press conference together' which I declined…because it's not for me to do so. 'I don't think it was for me to speak to the American press pack who is travelling on Air Force One with the President of the United States.'
Yahoo
a minute ago
- Yahoo
Latest Trump tariffs unlikely to budge, top negotiator says
(Reuters) -The tariffs U.S. President Donald Trump imposed last week on scores of countries are likely to stay in place rather than be cut as part of continuing negotiations, Trade Representative Jamieson Greer said on Sunday. Ahead of a Friday deadline, Trump set rates including a 35% duty on many goods from Canada, 50% for Brazil, 25% for India, 20% for Taiwan and 39% for Switzerland, according to a presidential executive order. In trade talks since Trump returned to office, the White House has lowered some rates from levels initially announced, including halving import duties set last week as part of a deal with the European Union. Greer told CBS's Face the Nation on Sunday, however, that this would not be the case on the most recent round of tariffs. "A lot of these are set rates pursuant to deals. Some of these deals are announced, some are not, others depend on the level of the trade deficit or surplus we may have with the country," he said. "These tariff rates are pretty much set." Greer also said recent trade talks with Beijing had been "very positive" and were focused on the supply of rare earth magnets and minerals. "We're focused on making sure that the flow of magnets from China to the United States and the- and the adjacent supply chain can flow as freely as it did before ... and I'd say we're about halfway there."
