Low-traffic neighbourhood scheme ruled unlawful in landmark decision
A High Court judge has ruled in favour of a group of residents and businesses challenging a proposed low-traffic neighbourhood (LTN) scheme in West Dulwich, South London. The West Dulwich Action Group (WDAG) launched legal action against Lambeth Council, successfully halting the experimental scheme.
The residents and businesses argued that the council had disregarded their concerns and unfairly excluded local businesses from the consultation process. Their legal challenge asserted that the council's approach was "so unfair as to be unlawful." The court's decision marks a significant victory for the WDAG, who had voiced strong opposition to the LTN proposal. Further details regarding the judge's ruling and the future of the LTN scheme are expected to be released soon.
At a hearing in February, lawyers for WDAG told the High Court in London that some areas which clearly would be affected were excluded from the scope of targeted consultation.
Lawyers for the council said the claim is 'without foundation' and should be dismissed, telling the court that areas selected had been picked based on the council's assessment of the likely impacted areas, with proposals changing over time.
In a judgment on Friday, Judge Tim Smith, sitting as a deputy High Court judge, ruled in WDAG's favour.
The judge said that the council's consultation process was lawful, though said some elements 'could undoubtedly have been improved upon'.
However, he said that the way the council considered input from engagement with the public was unlawful.
WDAG had delivered a 'detailed' 53-page presentation outlining its concerns about the scheme to a councillor, but Judge Smith said it was not clear whether it was then shared with officers making decisions over the scheme.
He said: 'On the evidence, I am forced to conclude that, despite assurances to the contrary given to the claimant, the 53-page presentation did not form part of the council's considerations in its decision to make the orders.
'It should have done. Its content was highly relevant to the issues being deliberated upon and thus it was a material consideration.
'The failure to have regard to it was a serious failing, rendering the decision to make the orders unlawful.'
At the end of his 34-page judgment, Judge Smith said that written submissions over what should happen next will be considered.
During the hearing earlier this year, the court was told that Lambeth Council workers were offered a wellbeing day after 'hostility and anger' at a meeting over the proposed scheme.
WDAG's lawyers described the meeting at West Norwood Library on April 22 2023 as a 'fiasco' that lasted six hours, after which council workers were only able to record 21 responses because of the difficulties.
In Friday's ruling, Judge Smith said: 'Plainly it was a difficult situation for the council's officers to find themselves in.
'Feelings were evidently running high, and the general sense of hostility together with the volume of people in attendance wanting to express their views meant that the event was not as effective as was intended.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
Tesco sales accelerate despite ‘intensely competitive' grocery market
Tesco has revealed stronger sales over the latest quarter despite an 'intensely competitive' UK grocery market. The UK's largest supermarket chain said it has increased its market share further after investing more in pricing to bring in more customers. The company said group sales grew by 4.6%, on a like-for-like basis, to £16.4 billion for the 13 weeks to May 24. This was buoyed by growing demand for own-brand and premium products, with sales of its Finest range up 18% year-on-year. This was supported by the launch of 350 new own-brand products during the quarter, as shoppers continue to turn more frequently to supermarket own-brands over branded rivals. As a whole, the business saw food sales grow by 5.9%, while non-food sales, excluding toys, rose by 6.2% amid a boost from new ranges and warmer weather. Tesco stressed that growth has come as it maintained its 'strong price positioning' relative to its rivals, continuing to invest in its Aldi Price Match scheme and around 9,000 Clubcard price deals each week on its loyalty scheme. It comes amid continued pressure on pricing from rival supermarkets, with Asda slashing prices this year in a bid to help turn around its fortunes. In April, Tesco said it expects to make as much as £400 million less in profit this financial year due to heightened competition. Ken Murphy, chief executive of Tesco, said: 'We are pleased with our performance across the first quarter. 'Our continued commitment to delivering great value, quality and service for our customers has contributed to like-for-like sales growth across all parts of the group. 'The market remains intensely competitive, and we are committed to ensuring customers get the best value in the market by shopping at Tesco.'
Reuters
33 minutes ago
- Reuters
UK accounting watchdog fines KPMG $1.7 million for Carr's Group audit breaches
June 12 (Reuters) - The British accounting watchdog imposed a penalty of 1.25 million pounds ($1.7 million) on audit firm KPMG LLP on Thursday as a result of an investigation into the financial audit of UK manufacturing firm Carr's Group (CARRC.L), opens new tab. KPMG and audit engagement partner Nick Plumb failed to ensure compliance with applicable independence requirements, the Financial Reporting Council said. "In this case, whilst the quality of the audit work performed by the two firms is not brought into question, the breaches were serious," FRC Deputy Executive Counsel Jamie Symington said in a statement published on its website. ($1 = 0.7374 pounds)
Reuters
33 minutes ago
- Reuters
Tesco's UK sales growth accelerates in first quarter
LONDON, June 12 (Reuters) - Tesco (TSCO.L), opens new tab, Britain's biggest food retailer, reported a pick-up in underlying sales growth in its first quarter and won market share from rivals, saying improvements in value, product quality and service had chimed with consumers. The group, whose share of Britain's grocery market has grown this year to 28%, a level not seen since 2016, said on Thursday its UK like-for-like sales rose 5.1% in the 13 weeks to May 24, having been up 4.3% in the previous quarter. Group sales were 16.4 billion pounds ($22.2 billion), up 4.6% on a like-for-like basis. "Our continued commitment to delivering great value, quality and service for our customers has contributed to like-for-like sales growth across all parts of the Group," CEO Ken Murphy said. But he cautioned that the market "remains intensely competitive". Tesco said it still expected to report adjusted operating profit of between 2.7 billion and 3.0 billion pounds ($3.6 billion-$4.1 billion) in the year ending February 2026, down from the 3.13 billion pounds achieved in 2024/25. The group said in April it expected profit to fall in its 2025/26 year as it set aside cash to deal with a step up in the "competitive intensity" of the UK grocery market - a reference to a pledge of sustained price cuts from Asda, Britain's third biggest supermarket group, which has been losing market share. Most analysts think Tesco's strategy of matching the prices of discounter Aldi on hundreds of key items, together with heavy promotion of its Clubcard loyalty scheme, which provides lower prices for members, is working well. Tesco is also becoming increasingly digital, stepping up personalised engagement with customers and developing growth avenues such as its online Marketplace platform and retail media. Shares in Tesco are up 27% over the last year. Tesco's update bucked wider industry data published on Tuesday showing British consumer spending on non-food items lost momentum in May as households' confidence in their personal finances fell. ($1 = 0.7377 pounds)
