Stray dogs and public safety: A humane reform rooted in progress
But this moment need not spiral into fear-driven policy. Instead, it can be a pivot toward scaling humane, evidence-based solutions already showing results.
The ABC Rules are Humane, Legal, and Working in Pockets: The Animal Birth Control (ABC) Rules, 2023 mandate sterilisation, vaccination, and release of stray dogs back to their territories. This model is not just compassionate—it's scientifically validated and increasingly effective where implemented well.
In Mumbai, over 4.3 lakh dogs have been sterilised. The BMC claims a reduction in stray population from 95,172 to 90,757.
In Bengaluru, a study showed a 10% reduction in stray dog population, with a 20% increase in neutering rates.
In Nagpur, nearly 40,000 dogs were sterilised in just 21 months, averaging 64 procedures per day.
These figures show that ABC works when done right—with trained personnel, infrastructure, and community support.
Why culling is a step backward: calls for culling often arise from frustration, but evidence shows it's counterproductive:
Removing dogs creates a vacuum effect, inviting unvaccinated, unsterilised dogs to migrate in.
Sterilised dogs guard their territory, preventing new entrants and stabilizing populations.
Rabies transmission is reduced when vaccinated dogs remain in their habitat.
India's legal framework already permits euthanasia for terminally ill or dangerous dogs, but expanding this definition risks legal misuse and ethical violations.
Implementation gaps still exist: Despite success stories, challenges remain:
Many municipalities lack trained staff and shelter infrastructure.
Funding for ABC programs has declined since 2021.
In slum areas, sterilisation efforts are often under-addressed, skewing data and outcomes.
But these are fixable problems, not reasons to abandon humane policy.
Global models reinforce India's path: Countries like Thailand, Bhutan, and the Netherlands have shown that neuter-vaccinate-return strategies can eliminate rabies and reduce stray populations—without culling.
Bhutan achieved 100% street dog sterilisation and vaccination in 14 years.
The Netherlands eliminated stray dogs through government-funded CNVR programs, strict anti-abandonment laws, and adoption incentives.
India's ABC rules align with these models—it's time to scale them, not sideline them.
A call for humane acceleration: The Supreme Court's intervention should be a catalyst for reform, not regression. A humane roadmap includes:
Mobile sterilisation units in high-incidence zones
Mandatory dog census and vaccination audits
Public education to reduce fear and promote coexistence
Community adoption and feeding protocols
Reinstated central funding and performance-linked grants
Reframing the Narrative: This isn't a runaway crisis—it's a governance challenge with proven solutions. Let's shift the conversation from fear to fact-based optimism, and from conflict to compassionate reform.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
26 minutes ago
- Time of India
After SC judgment, mental well being no longer charity but constitutional right: Experts
KOLKATA: Mental health activists and experts have welcomed the Supreme Court's explicit recognition of mental health as an integral part of the constitutional Right to Life under Article 21. They say this broadens the interpretation of the right to life to include psychological well-being, not just physical survival. The Supreme Court recognised the right to mental health as an integral component of the right to life under Article 21 while laying down binding guidelines for educational institutions and coaching centres across India. The observation was made in a case related to the death of a 17-year-old student undergoing coaching for the National Eligibility-cum Entrance Test (NEET) examination. The apex court set aside orders of the Andhra Pradesh High Court to allow the transfer of the investigation into the death under suspicious circumstances to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata Mental health activist Ratnaboli Ray, who is the founder of Anjali, a rights-based organisation, said the apex court order moves mental health from the realm of welfare or charity into the domain of legal and constitutional rights. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Health: the best shoes to walk and stand all day Ultra-Comfortable Shoes Undo "This means that the state and institutions are no longer simply encouraged but obligated to ensure mental health protections as part of their duty under the Constitution," said Ray, a psychologist by training. Ray also pointed out that by issuing guidelines for students' welfare in the context of mental health, the court has acknowledged the growing mental health crisis in educational spaces—ranging from anxiety and depression to suicide. This makes schools and universities potentially accountable for creating psychologically safe environments. "The court order represents a cultural shift. When the Supreme Court validates mental health as a constitutional concern, it plays a critical role in destigmatising mental illness, legitimising lived experiences, and encouraging both care-seeking and policy action," she said. Advocate Arush Sengupta pointed out that embedding mental health under Article 21 makes it justiciable. "If someone's right to mental well-being is violated—for example, through institutional neglect, discrimination, or lack of access to care—they can now take legal recourse based on constitutional grounds. This also strengthens the implementation of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, which already defines access to mental health services as a right, but until now lacked the direct constitutional force to ensure consistent and widespread enforcement," he said. Psychiatrist Aniruddha Deb felt the ruling has the potential to transform institutional accountability, public funding, and societal attitudes in India. "This is a landmark judgment. Till now, mental illness was perceived as a disability, a dysfunction and looked down upon. Treatment and care were neglected as were rights. People with mental illness were relegated to second-class citizens. They were even denied the right to vote. Being of unsound mind precluded them from holding any office. All that will change now. The moment you equate the right to mental health with the right to life, the whole observation changes," said Deb. Ray added that the moment demands bold, rights-affirming governance, not piecemeal or tokenistic gestures. "The judiciary has spoken. It is now the executive's responsibility to institutionalize this vision into everyday governance so that mental health is not only constitutionally protected, but meaningfully lived," she added. What SC judgment does * Broadens the interpretation of the right to life to include psychological well-being, not just physical survival * Moves mental health from the realm of welfare or charity into the domain of legal and constitutional rights. State and institutions are no longer simply encouraged but obligated to ensure mental health protections * Schools and universities potentially accountable for creating psychologically safe environments * Embedding mental health under Article 21 makes it justiciable. If someone's right to mental well-being is violated, they can now take legal recourse based on constitutional grounds * Strengthens the implementation of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, * To play a critical role in destigmatizing mental illness, legitimizing lived experiences, and encouraging care-seeking and policy action Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
BMC intensifies drive against diseases after citizen reporters express concern
Bhubaneswar: The Bhubaneswar Municipal Corporation (BMC) has intensified its awareness and prevention drive against water- and vector-borne diseases, following concerns raised by several citizen reporters. Citizen reporters highlighted issues of stagnant water, which creates breeding grounds for mosquitoes, and uncollected garbage, which creates unhygienic conditions in different localities, leading to risk of diseases. The city recently reported diarrhoea cases. Citizen reporter Rudra Narayan Jena pointed out that stagnant water in densely populated areas poses a serious threat of water- and vector-borne diseases, including dengue. "Though there is a steady rise in these diseases in the city recently, no concrete step is being taken by the civic body so far. We urged the administration to look into the matter seriously," Jena wrote on TOI's Citizen Reporter portal, sharing pictures from Bishnupriya Nagar near Infocity. Another citizen reporter, Shanti Lata, wrote how garbage was piling up on the roads of Niladri Vihar for days. "The fear of water-borne diseases in the city escalated due to the bad sanitation practice in different localities," she wrote. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Trade crypto futures confidently in INR CoinDCX Download Undo Sharing a few pictures, she reported that piled-up garbage in Niladri Vihar has created an unhygienic situation. "The rainwater mixed with the garbage provides a perfect breeding ground for mosquitoes. So perfect for a city which ranked 9th in the country in cleanliness," she wrote. Responding to the concerns, city mayor Sulochana Das said that regular awareness drives are being conducted in different localities on good sanitation practices. "Our sanitation workers are also being sensitised on hygiene," she said. Das said that cleanliness is a collective effort, and everyone should contribute. "We are aware about the diseases during monsoon and are prepared accordingly. We have recently intensified our awareness and prevention drives," she said. The city has reported over 200 dengue cases since Jan 1, while the state has reported more than 650 cases. Authorities have identified Patia, Sikharchandi and Prasanti Vihar in the city as high-risk areas. BMC recently floated a tender to select an agency for implementing anti-larval measures aimed at controlling mosquito growth. The tender is in its final stage, sources said. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
GCC to vaccinate 1L dogs against rabies
Chennai: After a five-year pause in citywide vaccination, the GCC is set to launch a 50-day drive from Aug 7 to immunise one lakh stray and pet dogs, in an urgent attempt to address a critical gap in rabies prevention. The civic body aims to vaccinate an average of 3,000 dogs a day across the city. Until now, only sterilized stray dogs were routinely immunised through animal birth control (ABC) centres . With this special drive, GCC plans to widen coverage to include unsterilised stray and pet dogs to break the chain of rabies transmission. "To ensure Chennai is free from rabies, several measures have been taken, including sterilization and vaccination. A recent survey revealed that over 1.8 lakh stray dogs live in the city. So far, only sterilised dogs at ABC centres have been vaccinated. We aim to immunize the remaining stray dogs through this special mass vaccination camp starting Aug 7 (Thursday)," said J Kamal Hussain, veterinary officer, GCC. You Can Also Check: Chennai AQI | Weather in Chennai | Bank Holidays in Chennai | Public Holidays in Chennai The corporation will begin the drive in three zones , eventually expanding to all other zones. Ten trained teams will carry out the vaccinations, with each team expected to vaccinate at least 100 dogs a day. Kamal added, "The rabies vaccination will also include protection against four other major diseases — canine distemper, parvovirus, adenovirus, and leptospirosis. Additionally, Endectoparasiticide will help prevent ticks and other parasite infections in dogs. We expect to vaccinate at least one lakh dogs through this special camp." Notably, the city records an estimated 20,000 to 30,000 dog bite cases annually. During a recent monthly council meeting, ward councillors urged Corporation officials to regularize the administration of anti-rabies vaccines for stray dogs, citing the surge in their population. "Sterilization alone is not enough and does not prevent dog bites. After surgery, dogs are released back into the same areas, posing a threat to the public. Many stray dogs remain unvaccinated. Authorities must ensure strict implementation of these measures," said Fathima Ahamed, councillor of ward 61. Animal lovers have welcomed the move to vaccinate dogs after a long gap. "If the vaccination camp had been conducted earlier, a wider range of dogs could have been covered. Vaccinating both stray and pet dogs will help reduce human-animal conflict," said Arun Prasanna, an animal activist. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
