Unions, advocacy groups decry health-care ‘blame game
In just the past week, Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara's comments in Free Press stories included accusations that the previous Progressive Conservative government 'hid behind numbers they just made up' in an article about hiring new nurses and 'refused to sit down with (nurses)' on health-care concerns.
Manitoba Health Coalition director Noah Schulz said he's grown weary of watching the blame for the province's struggling health-care system being punted back and forth, and wonders how much longer the NDP can claim to be 'picking up the pieces' of a previous government.
'There have been some important investments in health care, but it's just the tip, really, of that iceberg. It's unfortunate that, instead of taking that responsibility… a lot of that focus is on how bad the situation they inherited was, or how badly the PCs bungled things,' said the head of the non-profit group focused on protecting and expanding universal health care.
'We're not expecting everything to be turned around overnight, but it's not overnight, it's (nearly) two years now, and health care needs to be something that all governments prioritize, not a way that they score political points off each other.'
Manitoba Association of Health Care Professionals president Jason Linklater agreed, suggesting partisan politics needed to take a back seat.
MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES
Jason Linklater, Manitoba Association of Health Care Professionals
MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES
Jason Linklater, Manitoba Association of Health Care Professionals
'At many levels of the health-care system, including among some of the key players and decision-makers, the culture hasn't changed. It needs to,' he said in an email.
'If Manitobans don't get lower wait times and better access to care, they're not going to blame the party out of power. Manitobans can see through the political blame game. They want action from the people they elected.'
At the Manitoba Nurses Union, president Darlene Jackson said that a new government promising to prioritize health care with a minister who previously worked as a nurse, had given union members a feeling of optimism that has waned in the time since, in part because of comments from the party in power.
'I can honestly say that I am, and I think nurses are, tired of the blame game of this government continuously blaming a previous government,' she said. 'We're almost two years into their mandate, the election promise was to ensure that they fixed health care — it was all about health care — and we are still waiting.'
Opposition leader Obby Khan said the blame was being unfairly placed on a party with a new leader, with a 'new energy' and a 'new message.'
'You want to talk about a football being thrown back and forth? Well, the football is in (the NDP's) hands now, and they're fumbling it embarrassingly,' he said. 'And they're letting down Manitobans and health-care workers.'
With a provincial byelection in Spruce Woods Aug. 26, Khan said the focus for the PC party is making that clear to voters.
'They solely campaigned on fixing health care, and two years in, health care is worse,' he said.
(newletterPrompt)
Asagwara, a former psychiatric nurse, said the reason for repeated references to the previous government is clear when discussing the current health-care crisis.
'I can certainly appreciate folks don't necessarily like to remember the damaging and the dark days of the PCs… my hope is that in being honest about how we got here, and in committing to not taking the same callous approach as the previous government, we will not only again repair the damage they did, but really make health care stronger for the long term,' Asagwara said.
It is not the first time in Manitoba that health care has been kicked around as a political football.
Depoliticizing health care is impossible, a spokesperson from physicians' advocacy organization Doctors Manitoba suggested.
'Any publicly funded service can never be separated from politics because politicians make funding and policy decisions, and because health care is the most personal and intimate service the government oversees, it is very dependent on political decisions and priorities,' the spokesperson said in an email.
'What matters most to physicians is that all political parties seek advice from doctors and other experts working in the system, invite feedback from the patients and citizens who use the system, and use evidence to guide their decisions.'
University of Manitoba political studies adjunct professor Christopher Adams suggested that the back-and-forth is a natural response to how widespread and all-encompassing health-care failings have become in Manitoba and across Canada.
'I would say it's just natural for it to be a political football, and if the opposition isn't running with this, then they aren't doing their job,' he said.
malak.abas@freepress.mb.ca
Malak AbasReporter
Malak Abas is a city reporter at the Free Press. Born and raised in Winnipeg's North End, she led the campus paper at the University of Manitoba before joining the Free Press in 2020. Read more about Malak.
Every piece of reporting Malak produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
10 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Err on the side of lung health
This summer, Manitobans aren't just sweating under the August sun — we're coughing, wheezing and blinking through a haze so thick you could mistake Portage Avenue for a foggy morning in San Francisco. Recent air-quality readings put Winnipeg at the worst in Canada, with PM2.5 levels soaring well past the 'very unhealthy' threshold. Health experts aren't mincing words: prolonged exposure to this kind of pollution can increase risks of heart attacks, worsen asthma and even impact brain function and mental health. It's not just your lungs feeling the burn, it's your energy, recovery and overall resilience. And while the headlines are everywhere, the lesson isn't: you can't out-train bad air. The basics of health — movement, nutrition, recovery — don't change, but how you approach them needs to adjust when the environment throws you a curveball. Here's how to stay fit despite the forest-fire smoke. 1. Respect the conditions Wildfire smoke isn't something you should ignore. Fine particulate matter (PM2.5) is tiny enough to slip deep into your lungs — and even cross into your bloodstream. That's why experts link it to everything from respiratory distress to cardiovascular strain. One big reason it hits harder during intense outdoor exercise is because you're required to breathe through your mouth when fatigued. Which means you're bypassing your nose, which is your body's best mechanism for filtering out as much of the toxins in the smoke as possible. So if you've ever gone for a jog in thick smoke and felt your chest tighten or your head pound, that's your body waving a red flag. In these conditions, training outside at full-tilt isn't 'toughing it out' — it's digging yourself a recovery hole you may feel for days. Rule of thumb: if the air-quality index (AQI) is above 150, especially in the 'unhealthy' zone, take your workouts inside or dramatically scale back the intensity. 2. Shift focus indoors You don't need a home gym that looks like a pro-hockey training centre to get a solid workout indoors. All you need is a plan — and maybe a little creativity. Try: • Bodyweight circuits: Squats, pushups, lunges, planks. Minimal space, maximum effect. • Dumbbell or resistance band sessions: Strength training is still the best bang-for-buck for metabolism and muscle retention. A pair of weights and maybe a bench will take you far. • Low-impact cardio: A stationary bike, rowing machine, treadmill or walking pad and, yes, even marching in place or pacing the stairs will do the job in a pinch. Here are three smoke-safe routines you can try inside this week: Body-weight burner (No equipment, 15-20 minutes, repeat for 3-4 rounds) • 40 sec. squats, 20 sec. rest • 40 sec. pushups, 20 sec. rest • 40 sec. reverse lunges, 20 sec. rest • 40 sec. plank shoulder taps, 20 sec. rest • 40 sec. glute bridges, 20 sec. rest Dumbbell strength circuit (Pair of moderate weights, 20 minutes, repeat for 3-4 rounds with rest between rounds) • 8-10 goblet squats (or timed sets of 30 seconds) • 8-10 dumbbell bench or floor presses • 8-10 dumbbell rows (each side) • 8-10 Romanian dead lifts Low-Impact cardio & core (No jumping, 15 minutes, repeat 3-4 rounds) • 1 min. march in place • 1 min step-ups (use a sturdy bench or stair) • 1 min. side-to-side steps with light arm swings • 30 sec. plank hold • 30 sec. side plank (each side) 3. Keep recovery in check Wildfire smoke is inflammatory by nature. Even if you don't feel sick, your body is under extra load trying to process and clear pollutants. That means recovery is king. Double down on the basics: • Hydration: Water helps flush out toxins and keeps your mucous membranes moist, which is your first line of defence. • Nutrition: Antioxidant-rich foods (think berries, leafy greens, colourful veggies) help fight oxidative stress. • Sleep: Air purifiers in the bedroom can make a big difference in sleep quality when the AQI is poor. A high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) purifier in your bedroom — look for one with a true HEPA filter rated for at least CADR 250+ for rooms around 300-400 sq. ft. 4. Keep moving It's tempting to use poor air quality as a free pass to skip movement altogether. But long stretches of inactivity can tighten joints, lower mood and increase fatigue caused by poor air quality. Instead, treat these smoky days as a chance to explore: • Mobility flows: Think yoga, dynamic stretching or foam rolling. • Short 'movement snacks' and strength workouts: Three to five minutes of activity every hour — squats, stair climbs, light band work. Then, especially if your outdoor activities are limited, make use of that home gym and hit the weights until it's second nature to do so consistently. • Skill work: Practise form on lifts, balance drills or breathing exercises. 5. Reframe mental game One of the biggest fitness mistakes people make is seeing environmental changes as obstacles instead of opportunities. You can't control the smoke, but you can control how you adapt. You made things work during COVID quarantines, so you can do the same now. For example, if you're used to outdoor walks in the summer (I get it, I know… Debbie Downer), watch a show while you walk indoors, either marching in place or on a treadmill. If your family's cooped up, make it a group activity: set up a living-room 'movement challenge' with the kids. (Trust me — they'll love trying to beat your plank record or obstacle course time.) 6. An 'AQI action plan' Just like you check the weather before heading out, make it a habit to check the AQI (Environment Canada posts regular updates). Create a simple decision chart for yourself: • AQI below 100 (good/moderate): Train as planned. • AQI 101-150 (unhealthy for sensitive groups): Reduce outdoor intensity, keep it shorter. • AQI above 150 (unhealthy): Take it indoors or make it a recovery day. The bottom line In health and fitness, the 'new' news always circles back to the old truths. Movement matters. Nutrition matters. Recovery matters. But the smartest Manitobans are the ones who adapt those basics to fit the season, even if the season smells like a campfire you didn't ask for. So while the smoke may be stealing our summer skies, it doesn't have to pinch your progress. Train smart, recover well and remember: lungs are harder to rebuild than biceps. Mitch Calvert is a Winnipeg-based fitness coach. If you want a free Smoky Day Workout guide you can do at home in under 20 minutes, email him at mitch@ with 'Pulse' in the subject line and he'll send you a go-to routine for days when stepping outdoors is a no-go. Mitch CalvertFitness columnist Mitch Calvert is a Winnipeg-based fitness coach for men and women like his former self. Obese in his 20s, he lost 60 pounds himself and now helps clients find their spark and lose the weight for life. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
19 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Sponsored Content Bracing for excellence
Orthotist Nick Gilmour scans a patient in preparation for the production of a brace. An HSC Foundation grant, funded by donors from throughout Manitoba, is helping Health Sciences Centre deliver better care to patients recovering from spine surgery, or dealing within juries or illnesses affecting the spine. The $200,000+ grant allowed HSC to acquire a suite of equipment to produce thoracic-lumbar-sacral orthoses (TLSOs) in-house. A TLSO is a customized hard plastic body brace that stabilizes a patient's spine. In-house fabrication allows for faster and more accurate production. 'The equipment is a home run, and we are seeing even better results than we expected,' says Nick Gilmour, an orthotist at HSC. Specialized software allows HSC to customize a TLSO brace for a perfect fit in a matter of hours. Prior to the acquisition of the required software, a specialized scanner, an infrared oven, and a 3D carver, the TLSOs had to be produced in Boston while patients waited in a hospital bed at HSC. Production and delivery were expensive, and there were often shipping delays—especially around Christmas and American Thanksgiving. 'Now, thanks to the HSC Foundation and its donors, we can produce a brace in less than a day. We've even produced one in under four hours,' says Gilmour. 'This means a shorter hospital stay and better overall care for the patient.' With the cost savings per unit and the reduced number of hospital days required for most patients, Gilmour notes, the equipment paid for itself quickly. 'My colleagues and I are very grateful,' he says. 'I want Foundation donors to know that this grant helps us provide much better care.' To support the HSC Foundation so that all Manitobans can get the best care possible, please visit or call 204-515-5612 or (toll-free) 1-800-679-8493.
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Protein power
Protein-fortified milk, pasta with added protein, high-protein tortilla chips. Turn down any grocery aisle these days and you'll likely find a wide variety of products bulking up on a certain macronutrient. Interest in protein isn't new (see the popularity of the Atkins and keto diets), but social media has raised the essential nutrient to cure-all superfood status. 'We're bombarded by this idea that we need to eat more protein to have more muscle and look better, and that is changing consumer behaviour,' says Dr. Dylan MacKay, an assistant professor in the department of food and human nutritional sciences and department of internal medicine at the University of Manitoba. PEXELS The rule of thumb for the average person is one gram of protein per kilogram of body weight per day, dietitians say. A 2024 survey of American adults found 71 per cent of respondents were trying to consume more protein, up from 59 per cent in 2022. The same survey determined exposure to food and nutrition content has increased significantly across social media platforms in recent years. Food manufacturers have capitalized on the craze, launching more than 1,500 new high-protein food and drink products into the Canadian market since 2019, according to a report from Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. But not all protein is created equal. While the experts interviewed by the Free Press say eating more protein can be beneficial, they recommend a more holistic approach to nutrition. ● ● ● Carbohydrates, fats and protein are known as macronutrients: food groups that the body needs in larger amounts to function properly. Each 'macro' plays a distinct role in the diet, says Jorie Janzen, a registered dietitian and director of sports nutrition at the Canadian Sports Centre Manitoba. She describes carbohydrates — such as fruits, starchy vegetables and grains — as energizers, while fats are essentials that allow the body to absorb important nutrients found in other foods. PEXELS Seniors, children and pregnant women need higher amounts of the macronutrient. 'And proteins are builders and repairers. That might be plant-based sources or animal sources,' Janzen says. Canada's Food Guide lists meat, fish, eggs, tofu, legumes, nuts and dairy products as good sources of protein. Dietary protein contains amino acids that act as the building blocks for tissue, hormones and enzymes. It's also more satiating than other foods because it's calorically dense and takes longer to digest, making it a helpful tool for blood sugar management, says MacKay, whose research focuses on diabetes. The recommended daily allowance for adults is 0.8 to 1.3 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight — an amount most Canadians achieve with a balanced diet, according to Health Canada. Unless you live with a condition where excess protein can be damaging, such as kidney disease, 'there's no real upper limit on protein,' says MacKay. 'But it can be more expensive and there can be side effects of high protein intake, like gastrointestinal discomfort and gas.' Certain lifestyles and life stages may require more protein. 'Seniors need much more protein because they can't process it as efficiently as a younger person, so it's super important to boost protein to maintain their bones, their muscles, their cognitive health,' says Nadja Abada, a registered dietitian and nutritionist providing virtual counselling services Manitoba. PEXELS Protein is more satiating than other foods. Health Canada also recommends higher amounts of protein for infants, children and teens, as well as during pregnancy and lactation. Janzen typically advises clients to aim for 25 grams of protein four times a day via meals and snacks. For athletes or those engaging in high-intensity exercise, she may bump it up to 50 grams to aid in recovery and the development of lean muscle mass. But the conversation doesn't stop at protein. 'It's a balance of all the macronutrients,' Janzen says. 'It's a balance of your hydration. It's getting the proper sleep in, making sure you're mentally well. Protein is part of it, it's not all of it.' The dietitians also steer clients towards whole foods and away from relying too heavily on the convenience of protein powders, bars and pre-packaged foods advertising added protein. 'Protein powder should be in moderation — an addition to, not a replacement for your nutrition plan,' Janzen says, citing a lack of vitamins and minerals found in other protein sources. Every Second Friday The latest on food and drink in Winnipeg and beyond from arts writers Ben Sigurdson and Eva Wasney. 'I'm not a fan. It doesn't matter if it's animal or plant-based, it requires so much processing to be shelf stable,' Abada says. 'You need your veggies and certain integral grains, which have perks like fibre.' PEXELS Tofu is a good source of dietary protein. Before piling on the protein, Mac- Kay recommends taking stock of your social media diet and advises against following nutrition information promoted by online influencers with a vested interest in views. 'Social media is very bad for what we perceive as a normal body shape or a normal diet,' he says. 'One gram of protein per kilogram of body weight is probably more than enough for most individuals.' Eva WasneyReporter Eva Wasney has been a reporter with the Free Press Arts & Life department since 2019. Read more about Eva. Every piece of reporting Eva produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
