‘Four days of 10 vs 11 isn't right,' ‘India should be allowed a sub': Vaughan calls for change in substitution rule after Rishabh Pant's injury
'I don't like the fact that we've got four days left in the game, four days of action in what has been an incredible series where we are going to have 10 versus 11,' Vaughan said to BBC Sports.
'I prefer that you'd have a sub. You know, once they brought in concussion subs, I was crying out, saying, 'Well, just have substitutions then in the first innings of a game.' That would be my stepping point. If it happens in the second innings, I feel that team might kind of break the rules or indulge in a bit of skullduggery. But if it's clear and obvious when someone breaks a hand or a foot or ruptures a calf it's so evident that someone is in real pain and can't carry on. I think it's very clear to me: you should be allowed a sub,' said Vaughan.
A post shared by BBC Cricket (@bbccricket)
On Wednesday, Pant had to be helped off the field. The incident happened in the 68th over when Pant tried to reverse sweep a Chris Woakes delivery and was hit flush on his ankle. The player immediately went down and the physios came on the field to check on him.
His foot was swollen and the wicketkeeper-batter had to be taken off the field by a small vehicle as he couldn't even walk out on his own accord. Ravindra Jadeja replaced him for the time being in the middle. Pant was batting on 37 when he went off retired hurt.
England veteran Alastair Cook seemed to disagree with Vaughan's ask for a rule change.
'What if it's just a bruise?' said Cook.
'I'm not sure I agree. I'm not even sure what I think at the moment. But say we've just seen Pant walk off — he looks in all kinds of pain. And then it turns out it's not broken. So there's nothing on the X-ray; it's just a bruise. Does he have to play on then?' questioned Cook.
'If he has broken his foot, then that's a different thing. But there will be cases where someone gets hit on the arm. 'I can't move my hand, I'm bruised.' But it's only a bruise. So do you get replaced because of discomfort and the fact that you can't hold the bat as well as you'd like even though it's just a bruise?' he added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
United News of India
23 minutes ago
- United News of India
Gambhir snaps at England draw drama
Manchester, July 27 (UNI) India head coach Gautam Gambhir weighed in on England's visible frustration after Indian batsmen chose to continue batting despite a handshake being offered by Ben Stokes late on Day 5 of the drawn Old Trafford Test. Responding to the controversy, Gambhir said, 'If someone is batting on 90 and the other on 85, don't they deserve a hundred? Would England have walked off if one of their own was on 90? If someone has the opportunity to get their first Test century, you must allow him to take it. It's unfortunate they felt that way- I have nothing more to say. Both guys deserved their tons and thankfully, they got them.' This firm stance by the Indian camp underlines the grit and individual milestones that defined India's late resistance. When asked about changes in the XI, including Karun Nair missing out and Anshul Kamboj debuting, Gambhir clarified, 'We don't drop anyone. We pick the XI we feel can do the job. We felt a left-hander at No. 3 would help against this attack, and Sai Sudarshan did his job. Anshul was picked because his bowling suits overcast conditions, and he can bowl long spells.' In a broader comment on the game, Gambhir supported the idea of allowing substitutes in cases of clear, visible external injuries. 'Absolutely. If the umpires and match referee agree it's serious, there should be a rule for it. Especially in a tightly fought series like this — imagine playing with just 10. That would be unfair,' he said. On the decision to promote Washington Sundar to No. 5, Gambhir said, 'He was in good form. With Rishabh unavailable, it was an opportunity to slot him in at five. We always knew what form he was in. There's not even an inch of surprise about what he did today — and I believe this is just the start for him.' When asked about the No. 3 conundrum after Karun and Sai's rotation, Gambhir stressed that it's not about individual scores. 'We look at partnerships. If No. 3 contributes to a stand, he's done his job. Sai is a phenomenal talent. You can't judge players game by game. He's 23, on his first tour of England, and still managed a brilliant 50 and 60. We have to be patient — these boys are the future of Indian cricket,' he said. Gambhir reaffirmed his belief in results over narratives. 'You're asking someone who only believes in results. We're still 2-1 down in the series, but I believe we can level it 2-2. That would be a great achievement,' he stated. Speaking about captain Shubman Gill's rise, Gambhir said the dressing room never doubted his talent. 'Those who doubted him only talk about cricket, they don't understand it. Even if he hadn't performed, we knew the kind of quality he has,' he said. 'He's living up to his talent and expectation. And this narrative around captaincy pressure? You can't see any of that when he bats. He walks in as a batter, not a captain.' UNI BDN RKM
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
IND vs ENG 4th Test: Triple Sunday! Shubman Gill, Ravindra Jadeja script Sundar escape
Shubman Gill (Getty Images) MANCHESTER: At Lord's a fortnight ago, when Mohammed Siraj was unfortunately bowled out in the last hour of the Test, Ravindra Jadeja remained unbeaten but was defeated by Ben Stokes and England's relentlessness. On Sunday at Old Trafford, he looked them in the eye and walked back to the dressing room triumphant, unbeaten, and a proud centurion, having secured a draw to stay alive in the series. At the other end was Washington Sundar , India's next-gen spin-bowling allrounder, getting his maiden century as the duo dragged India out of a hole to finish at the score of 425/4. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! Jadeja and Washington Sundar, by scoring an unbeaten 107 off 185 and 101 off 206 respectively, batted out 55.2 overs for 203 runs on a pitch with distinct variable bounce and some sharp turn to follow up captain Shubman Gill 's exceptionally gritty 103 and KL Rahul's fighting 90. In doing so, they extracted every ounce of Stokes and England's energy to take the series into the last Test at the Oval next week with the scoreline reading 2-1. Stokes, who literally bowled with his bowling arm hanging from his right shoulder to rock India in the first 80 minutes of the day, went up to shake hands with Jadeja and Washington, having made peace with a draw with an hour left to play. Jadeja and Washington turned down the offer to comically complete their centuries with resigned Harry Brook and Joe Root tossing harmless deliveries to be hit to the boundaries. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Up to 70% off | Shop Sale Libas Undo This generation of Indian cricketers' identity is their stomach for a fight, which was headlined by the draw they stole against Australia in Sydney 2021. This bunch of Indian cricketers, raised largely on the riches of T20 cricket, declared their appetite for success in Test cricket. It couldn't have been better for Indian cricket than their 25-year-old captain Gill, on his first assignment, leading the way with a hundred that will define him as a force in Test cricket. India stay alive, England frustrated after draw; handshake drama at Old Trafford and more The only false shot in the innings cost him his wicket when he poked at a wide delivery off Jofra Archer minutes before lunch. Jadeja's only blemish of the day came off the next ball, flashing at another wide delivery only for Joe Root to drop the catch at first slip. Jadeja has played many come-frombehind knocks for India before. Seldom did the results of those matches favour India. This Old Trafford innings will give him that new feeling of satisfaction. Washington has just put a stamp on his quiet effectiveness in crunch situations. There have been no Indian centurions at Old Trafford since Sachin Tendulkar's maiden Test century in 1990. India added three names to the honours board on Sunday. The 112th over of the innings, minutes before tea, was the defining moment for India, and a shift in momentum happened. Jadeja and Washington brought up their fifties in the same over off Stokes, dispatching him to opposite sides of the boundary. It also wiped out the 311-run deficit. An animated Stokes got engaged in verbal volleys. Gautam Gambhir fiery press conference: Slams critics, big update on Jasprit Bumrah, Karun vs Sai The pitch and English attack both went flat. The two left-handers responded after tea by swatting away the English attack with consummate ease. Left-arm spinner Liam Dawson, Stokes' go-to man for the day, bowled 47 overs of mostly harmless left-arm spin for 0/95. England though started off well. Stokes, who didn't bowl on the fourth evening of the Test, swung into action immediately early on the fifth morning. Half an hour into the day, he got one to stay low and caught Rahul in front of the stumps. Every time he delivered the ball, he grunted like a tennis player playing the last game of the fifth set of a Grand Slam final. He was deservedly named player of the match for his efforts. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
R Ashwin rips into Ben Stokes: 'Your frustration, not our problem!' — Defends Ravindra Jadeja, Washington Sundar century push
Ben Stokes speaking with Ravindra Jadeja during fourth Test in Manchester. (Getty Images) NEW DELHI: Drama and emotion collided in Manchester on Day 5 of the fourth Test as Ravichandran Ashwin came out strongly in support of Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar for choosing to bat on — and complete their centuries — after England skipper Ben Stokes offered to call it a draw with an hour to go. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! With India well and truly having saved the game after being 0/2 in the second innings, Jadeja (89*) and Sundar (80*) stood firm. But when Stokes approached the umpires and offered a handshake to end the match, the Indian pair refused — and stood their ground, quite literally. Poll Do you agree with Ashwin's defense of Jadeja and Sundar's decision to bat on? Yes, they earned their runs. No, they should have walked off. This irked the England captain, who sarcastically questioned whether they wanted to score hundreds against part-time bowler Harry Brook . Jadeja responded with his bat, dispatching Brook for a six to bring up his century. Gautam Gambhir fiery press conference: Slams critics, big update on Jasprit Bumrah, Karun vs Sai Later, Ashwin — speaking on his YouTube channel — tore into the criticism directed at the Indian batters. "Have you heard the term double standards? They played your bowlers all day, batted you out, and suddenly when they're nearing hundreds, you want to walk off? Why should they?!" Ashwin fumed. "You ask, 'You want to make a hundred against Harry?' Not Brook, brother. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo He has to make a hundred. Bring any bowler — they didn't object. It was your call to bring Brook, not ours!" he added, defending the pair's right to play on. Ashwin also laid bare what he believed was the motive behind the early handshake offer: "There were two reasons — one, you didn't want to tire your bowlers. Fine. Second, you were frustrated, and thought 'If I'm not happy, you shouldn't be either.' That's not how cricket works." Ben Stokes press conference: On handshake controversy, India fightback, his own fitness Ashwin argued that if he were captain, he would've played the full quota of overs. "These are Test runs. A century is earned, not gifted. Washington deserved it. Jadeja deserved it. Period." India and England eventually shook hands after both batters got their milestones, with the series poised 2-1, in the hosts' favour, heading into the Oval finale. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
