ActionSA proposes constitutional amendments to stem SA's immigration problems
Among these are changes to the Bill of Rights on provisions related to housing, healthcare and education.
The party's Athol Trollip says that for too long, the country's hospitality and limited resources have been exploited.
The deadline for submissions to Parliament's constitutional review committee closed on Saturday, with it having already received more than 200 submissions by late last month.
ALSO READ: Motsoaledi tables new Immigration Amendment Bill
ActionSA says amendments to the Constitution should start with the preamble, which has been used to extend constitutional protections even to those residing in the country illegally.
The party says this deliberate misreading has placed undue pressure on limited public resources.
Parliamentary leader Athol Trollip says amendments should also be made to Chapter 2 of the Bill of Rights in respect of Sections 26 and 27, related to housing and healthcare, respectively.
"This is an area of exploitation that has a massive impact on our economy, and our municipality's ability to deliver the services required by people living in this country."
Trollip says more than 70% of patient files at Johannesburg clinics belong to foreign nationals, while there's also pressure on schools to find placements for learners, prompting a recommendation to also amend Section 29 on education.
"To provide only citizens, legal immigrants, and legally recognised residents, rather than all people living in South Africa, because this is where the illegal immigration crisis impacts our country so dramatically."
It will now be up to the parliamentary committee to hold oral hearings and to debate whether to propose amendments to the house, which will require a two-thirds majority to pass.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
5 hours ago
- The Citizen
Jobs crisis: Political parties demand accountability for rising unemployment
Stats SA revealed that 140 000 jobs were lost between April and June. ActionSA is blaming the government of national unity (GNU) for thousands of jobs lost in the second quarter of 2025. This comes after Stats SA on Tuesday revealed that 140 000 jobs were lost between April and June. 'This brings the total increase to almost 350 000 unemployed individuals so far in 2025 under the government of national unity (GNU), according to the Quarterly Labour Force Survey (QLFS) for Q2 2025 released by Statistics South Africa today,' said ActionSA MP Alan Beesley. He said the ANC and its partners in the GNU have been too busy focusing on their own internal squabbles, leaving ordinary South Africans to contend with harsh economic conditions. 'With the GNU consumed by infighting, the economy is left rudderless. At their press conference yesterday, the DA openly admitted to being at odds with their coalition partner, the ANC, on virtually every element of their supposed plan to'save' South Africa's economy. 'Instead of working for the people, the GNU's coalition partners are working against each other,' said Beesley. Unemployment The official unemployment rate increased by 0.3 percentage points from 32.9% in Q1 2025 to 33.2% in Q2 2025. 'This means that one in every three active jobseekers cannot find work. While the expanded unemployment rate declined slightly from 43.1% in Q1 2025 to 42.9% in Q2 2025, this was driven by growth in the labour force rather than genuine job creation,' he said. ALSO READ: Unemployment increases again as economy sheds 140 000 jobs Why are there not enough jobs? Beesley blamed years of economic mismanagement for the inability of the economy to create sustainable jobs. He said government should be held accountable. 'President Ramaphosa's recent claim that the economy is in a 'state of emergency' is a belated and inadequate acknowledgement of what South Africans have known for years. 'The emergency was created by years of slow, ineffectual governance, and now those responsible claim they want to solve it,' he said. Beesley said South Africa has not achieved economic growth of 3% or more in over a decade. 'Under the GNU, growth has yet to exceed 1%, and unemployment continues to rise. 'Each day, thousands of South Africans lose their livelihoods while Cabinet grows and executive perks multiply. 'This additional loss of jobs comes before the anticipated imposition of new US tariffs, meaning that this hapless inertia is likely to have even more devastating consequences for South Africa's already fragile economy,' he said. Unemployment problem in Gauteng DA shadow MEC for Economic Development Mike Moriarty on Tuesday said the unemployment problem is being felt in Gauteng. 'Currently, there are 2 645 000 unemployed residents in Gauteng and 595 000 discouraged job seekers. 'Furthermore, 10.3 million young people are not in employment, education or training,' said Moriarty. He said the province's Nasi iSpani jobs initiative has failed many young people. 'Our residents deserve permanent job opportunities, not short-term employment.' He said the provincial government must remove all corrupt officials and replace them with competent individuals who deserve the jobs. 'The DA Gauteng demands that the premier, along with the MEC for economic development, Lebogang Maile, clean up the GPG and take immediate steps to remove officials implicated in corruption, not reshuffling them to other departments,' he said.
The Citizen
7 hours ago
- The Citizen
Judgment reserved on Ngwathe application
During a virtual sitting on Tuesday, the court reserved judgment on the Ngwathe Local Municipality's application for leave to appeal against an earlier Free State High Court ruling ordering urgent provincial intervention in the municipality. This means that Judge J.P. Daffue's earlier ruling on June 20, in which he ordered, among other things, that the municipality be placed under administration and that the municipal council be dissolved — still cannot be implemented until the court decides whether another court might reach a different conclusion. If not, Judge Daffue's order, previously granted in favour of the civil rights organisation AfriForum, will stand. Should the appeal application succeed, however, the court order will remain suspended until the case is heard by the Supreme Court of Appeal. Judge Daffue previously found that the Ngwathe Municipality no longer meets its constitutional, legal, and administrative obligations toward its residents. The court therefore ordered the dissolution of the municipal council and instructed the Free State provincial government to intervene immediately. The ruling follows years of neglect, incompetence, and decline, during which residents of Parys, Heilbron, Koppies, Edenville and Vredefort, were left without reliable service delivery. According to the landmark judgment, the Free State Executive Council must, within the framework of Section 139(5)(a) of the Constitution, draw up a recovery plan to restore services and meet debt obligations, dissolve the Ngwathe Municipal Council, and appoint an administrator. Progress reports, under oath, must be submitted to the court every three months. The Ngwathe Municipality, along with eight other respondents in the matter — including the Free State Premier — was also ordered to pay AfriForum's legal costs.
Mail & Guardian
7 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Nobuhle Mthembu: Joburg ActionSA councillors only stay for salaries, have applied for DA posts
Former Johannesburg council speaker Nobuhle Mthembu. (@cllr_mthembu/X) Former Johannesburg council speaker She accused them of looking for greener pastures in the Democratic Alliance ( 'What I know right now is that ActionSA councillors are there for the salary they get in council and that's why they are still there,' Mthembu told the Mail & Guardian on Monday after her resignation from the party last Friday. 'Should an opportunity arise for them to cross the floor to another political party, I can tell you now, they will leave. Even when we were in council, there was the opportunity where the Democratic Alliance had opened the programme where, if you want to be their councillor, you need to apply. DA councillors were telling us that our councillors had applied.' Mthembu said it would be interesting to see how many ActionSA councillors stayed in the party after the council was dissolved for the Mthembu resigned from ActionSA, citing internal dynamics. In a letter to the ActionaSA regional secretary dated 8 August and seen by the M&G, Mthembu wrote that she believed the party must foster open discussions, transparency and democracy, adding that despite efforts towards addressing these concerns, meaningful change had not been forthcoming. 'I wrote to the region about my resignation, but if you check the national, it was the one responding to it in a statement. Where is the region, where in the provincial leadership it is going straight to the national?' she said. Mthembu said even at her time as caucus leader, the party did not allow her to make decisions about the caucus, with national officials doing that instead. 'There has also been a bit of bullying, when you are a leader and you start challenging certain things, so it also speaks that you must know your place. These are the internal dynamics we were talking about,' she said. Mthembu's suggestion that some ActionSA councillors would readily join the DA comes after the party announced in February that it had opened opportunities for all South Africans who aspired to represent the party in Gauteng metros to apply for positions. This was not only limited to DA members but to all citizens including those in other political parties. The DA said candidates would be subjected to screening, interviews and written tests to see if they fit the party's goals. On Monday, DA Johannesburg caucus leader Belinda Kaizer-Ozukwechuku told the M&G that those who had applied for positions, including herself, were not privy to the process and had no way of knowing who the other applicants were. Last month, Baloyi said the party had advised the councillors to publicly announce their intentions to join without making any demands for positions and not to use the MK party to try to extend their political lifespan. But both ActionSA and the DA denied that their councillors were looking at the option to join Jacob Zuma's party. ActionSA had been expected to hold its first elective conference this year with party president But given that elective conferences tend to give rise to people lobbying against each other, some in the party fear the process could divide it and create a platform for internal purges. In addition to Mashaba, the party is being run by its deputy president, 'There was a process to restart the whole membership from scratch after the elections, meaning all membership ceased to exist after the elections and we had to start all over with the membership system,' Mthembu said. She added that the party was not moving fast to register members, resulting in a delay in holding the elective conference. 'We are questioning ourselves to say, 'will this conference ever happen', because the party is four years old now. Surely we need to have an opportunity to go and elect our own leaders,' she said. 'We were supposed to sit for a regional conference in June and we are in August, and we were supposed to have the provincial conference in November, but at this point in time there's no more discussions about that.' She said although the MK party had also been bashed for not having internal democratic processes, and being run according to the whims of its leader 'The MK makes sense because it's a new party, but ours has been long and people are tired of the fact that there are people at the top who sit there, meaning there is no democracy and only those few will control the direction of the party,' Mthembu said. She said as things stood, Mashaba had the power to remove people from the party without any reason, something which could be prevented by going to an elective conference. 'If they appoint you, tomorrow they can come and tell you to let go of this position,' she said. In the Mthembu warned that the party's support in the metro would probably decline next year, citing what she called neglect of the region by the ActionSA leadership compared with the energy dedicated to Tshwane. She said with the emergence of the MK party, Floyd Shivambu's 'They neglect Johannesburg and I don't know how they are going to win it back. The decisions they have made in Johannesburg have made a lot of people turn their backs on us,' she said. '[Mayor) Nasiphi Moya [of ActionSA] is doing a wonderful job in Tshwane; this is the support all of us as leaders need. I felt that in Johannesburg, the support was not there for me. 'In Tshwane, it's more governance, and in Johannesburg, it's more grassroots. The residents of Johannesburg will say, 'You said let's vote for you, and we voted for you, but what did you do for us?' That is where the problem will arise. In Tshwane, they will have a good story to tell.'
